10 ms·
Concerns that social media causes childhood depression
- juicyfroot 9y agoAlways blaming the proximate cause and not the ultimate. Ask yourself: What causes someone to go on social media? What causes that cause? No. Here it is: "Depression" is an unscientific word, with no falsifiable or predictive power. Lame and lazy procrastinators will be lame and lazy. Don't blame their behaviour on "muh depression" or "social media". If you do that, then people will NOT change/improve fpr you have now disassociated them.
- sjg007 9y agoChildhood and adult.
- jxub 9y agoI think Girard got it right. Social media, as a whole, is a really big net negative to one's psyche, as we get to know what others have or desire, and become infected with their passions, fears and desires in this memetic process. It makes us uniform, bland, predictable neural networks, cogs involved in unifying the capitalistic market, and losing values far more important than money. Thankfully, there is still some resistance to that mental girardian unification, southern Europe seems to be harder to unify and bend to the global monoculture of anglo-capitalistic gollumization (I think Venkat at ribbonfarm.com wrote somethink about it) And I also still think we have a chance to suceed in this gollumized society as a species, we'll just be less happier in our endless pursuit of darwinian fitness.
- unclebucknasty 9y ago>It makes us uniform, bland, predictable neural networks, cogs involved in unifying the capitalistic market This. We have become mindless uber-consumers, copying vs creating, regurgitating vs thinking. Reposting an animated gif meme is valued more than original thought. As a consequence, we are easily infected (perfect word) with ideas. Worse, we believe these ideas to be the product of our own creation. Beyond that, all we seem to be able to muster is endless streams of desparate duck-lipped photos, begging for validation. This is what we've been reduced to and convinced is normal. It's a form of collective mental illness, encouraged by mind-hackers who profit from it.
- foobarian 9y agoI blame secularization. Human beings are genetically very good conduits for transfer of ideas. This is why in the past religions had such success in becoming popular and "infecting" people's brains. But once modern society decided that religion is bad, they created a memetic vacuum, a population of brains with empty slots ready to attach to whatever big idea came next. And that happened to be social networks with their strong feedback loops and financial incentives to be as addictive as possible. I wish there was a church option again that was a bit less loony. Something focused on community and shared values, less on the mystical. Honestly I think Unitarians come close but I don't know why their numbers are record low; maybe there needs to be more of a social network backlash to get some new members through the door.
- IntronExon 9y agoThe vast majority of people are part of a religion. What are you talking about? Religion has less ability to control people in some parts of the world, and people in some parts of the world are becoming less religious. Most of the world is still quite religiou though, often to their detriment. India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iran, Israel, huge swaths of the US, South and Central America, and so on are all very religious. So again, what are you really talking about?
- foobarian 9y agoI'm talking about modern western society. Sorry I don't have scientific references, and this is all anecdata/personal observation but I don't know a single person in my large US city that is religious or attends church, and yet I know many that spend a lot of time on social networks and yet are lonely. Mostly combination of family/friends/work.
- IntronExon 9y agohttp://news.gallup.com/poll/200186/five-key-findings-religion.aspx http://news.gallup.com/poll/200186/five-key-findings-religio... http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/ http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/ https://www.prri.org/research/american-religious-landscape-christian-religiously-unaffiliated/ https://www.prri.org/research/american-religious-landscape-c... Atheists and agnostics account for a minority of all religiously unaffiliated. Most are secular. Atheists and agnostics account for only about one-quarter (27%) of all religiously unaffiliated Americans. Nearly six in ten (58%) religiously unaffiliated Americans identify as secular, someone who is not religious; 16% of religiously unaffiliated Americans nonetheless report that they identify as a “religious person.” Note that religiously unaffiliated represent ~21% only. Less dominant and slowly declining, but far from what you previously described as But once modern society decided that religion is bad.
- mbrumlow 9y agoSocial media in my opinion is a scourge on our society. It is a place that fosters narcissism and sociopathic natures. The little good it does bring is heavily outweighed by the bad. Some will say it brings families and lost friends together across the world. This is true, but could be had without the endless streams of gloating, selfies, and photos of what you have eaten. Recently I have had a child. And I have already decided that the only social interaction he will have will be real-time or near real time. This means face to face, live video, real time chat (sms Hangouts is okay). This shows real interest and attention to the other party in real time and allows true connections to be formed. No endless scrolling through people's lives you meet once. I should also mention photo albums of actual events will be allowed too. I know that this will be hard and I will likely fail. But I am going to do my best to help my son learn how to truly interact with people and feel fulfilled with the relationships he has. Never do I want him to feel the loneliness of endlessly peering into others life's from a small window on phone.
- agumonkey 9y agosocnets are optimized interactions: you have more people that follow your interests but you may never get to know them in ways that physical proximity do to your mind. also it's too easy to end up in cycles of small interaction hormone boosts (dopamine hits apparently) that makes it exciting but not in the right way.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pmoriarty 9y ago"I have had a child. And I have already decided that the only social interaction he will have will be real-time or near real time. This means face to face, live video, real time chat (sms Hangouts is okay). This shows real interest and attention to the other party in real time and allows true connections to be formed." Remember how physical letter-writing used to be hugely important? We lost something there that wasn't real-time.
- cdancette 9y ago
- DanBC 9y agoHN readers might not be aware of "Skoville", a social media site for children under 13. https://www.skooville.com/ https://www.skooville.com/ It has some superficial "educational" Flash games (about being safe online, or about getting a job and paying your bills. But it also has some of the negative features of social media. https://www.skooville.com/ https://www.skooville.com/
- kartan 9y agoA better society will help us to be less depressed. I have had some experiences with ill-behaving companies. Where bosses think that employees need to be in fear so they are more productive. Where people is told to "never make a mistake" or they will be fired. You get the picture. People is depressed. You see people actually crying at their job. I have also worked for functioning companies. People is valued and get positive feedback on their job. Mistakes are investigated to get an understanding and improve the processes to help people but personal blaming is forbidden. Where the manager´s job is to help employees to achieve their potential and support them. In the first situation people is depressed and unhappy. People is paranoic and don´t trust each other. A blaming culture rewards lying about the status of projects and their results. In the second situation people is more happy at work. Meetings are constructive and ways of improving the company are found. People find themselves realized at work. Social media is just a mirror of society. It magnifies its uglyness or its greatness. I love to get into social media and see nature pictures from one friend. Another one composes music and shares it on-line. Most people will react joining into a good joke and answering with some one has a practical question. I love to be on social media, but I can understand how different that experience will be for others. Like the two companies I described, the same personal circunstances can be seen as gloomy or fantastic by the influence of your environment. Social media can, and maybe should be regulated, but the only solution to the problem is better education that values the indivual while encourage to work for the better of all society. And then society is going to be able to look at the mirror and like the image that is sees.
- tzahola 9y ago* people are
- thom 9y agoYup, nobody seems to be addressing the issue that we appear to have raised and enabled a generation of bullies using these technologies. Seems a vastly bigger issue than the medium itself, or the vague implication that it's the victim's fault for using social media in the first place.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago
- petra 9y agoIt's probably not just social media, but the internet(and tv) itself. We know how human beings are supposed to live to be happy: small communities of stable relationships, with a lot of face to face time, ideally spending some of it outside doing some sort of physical activity. And being focused is better , more enjoying than being distracted, and better for mind according to the meditative traditions . Some people are introverts though, so for them this recipe is somewhat different , less social contact. But the social contact they have shouldn't be emotionally empty. And even their alone time is focused, like in book reading. Alas, the internet is the excat opposite.
- matthewbauer 9y agoYes, definitely agree. I wonder if there are more introverts now than there were many years ago? It seems to me that has been a trend but I don't have any data to back it up.
- dazc 9y agoCertainly less willingness to engage in conversation or, often, a failure to even acknowledge the presence of other human beings.
- kleer001 9y agoAll I see is a new evolutionary pressure rising.
- IntronExon 9y agoOnly if this impacts reproductive fitness.
- wutbrodo 9y agoI would imagine that it's not implausible that being poorly socialized impacts reproductive success, particularly for men.
- saas_co_de 9y agoOne issue that I have never seen recognized is the affect of isolation on people. People who use computers a lot tend to be physically isolated. Social media provides a simulation of social engagement that works on some levels of the brain but is incomplete and missing physical touch, smell, and other aspects of presence. It is my suspicion that some of the negative effects of attributed to social media/gaming/etc are actually caused by the isolation that compulsive computer use results in and that people are essentially putting themselves in solitary confinement without realizing it and experiencing similar psychological outcomes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TaylorGood 9y agoA side effect is that I've found myself having a harder time to pick up the phone. In person I am no different than when I was using less screen time, but the habit of calling has deteriorated and now I have to be obedient. Every day there is a set period of time where I make calls.
- dazc 9y agoI found the same thing, conversations over the phone can feel awkward and unnatural. It takes a lot of constant use to get over this feeling, for me at least. Therefore, after a period of communicating purely via text I start to feel the awkwardness again. And this, sometimes, means I actually put off making calls, which only makes things worse.
- kowdermeister 9y agoI've gotten so far, that I didn't have a phone. Then I got a dumb phone. Now I'm using a Nexus, but I still dislike making calls. Mostly taxi or other inevitable situations :)
- Cococabanana 9y agoThis reminds me of growing up as an active member of the original BBS scene in the 90's. Parents/Adults are clueless as usual. Let the kids have their fun!
- Trav5 9y agoI find the comments that rant against social media on hacker news amusing. Hacker news is a social media website. "Hacker News is a social news website focusing on computer science and entrepreneurship." [0] It's the same as a group on any other system, just different formatting. It even has karma which can suck you in... I do not disagree with the sentiment though, managing the amount of time one gives to social media is tough. Picking good social circles and getting out of bad ones is tough. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hacker_News https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hacker_News
- andrepd 9y agoI think Hacker News (and traditional topical discussion forums in general) is to Facebook as playing boardgames with your friends is to a Casino.
- darkerside 9y agoIt's more like playing poker at the casino instead of roulette
- nicklaf 9y agoIf Hacker News is just as much 'social media' as less literary platforms like Twitter or Facebook, then I don't think that social media is the problem per se. Y-combinator has its own profit motive, but it doesn't take its readers for fools to be manipulated. (Well, maybe this happens a little bit, with people voting up trendy stories.) Yes, Hacker News has a 'share button'. I think what sets it apart from sites like Facebook is that it's not sufficient for the shared item to garner lots of attention; rather, it will be subject to written criticism, potentially leading to downvotes and flagging. Finally, Hacker News is moderated by very thoughtful people, ruling out a big chunk of the content that makes unmoderated social media little better than a tabloid magazine.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThat sounds rather like "we can use this media because we're talking about clever stuff but people talking about trivial stuff clearly shouldn't use it".
- larodi 9y agoevery 'media' producing interrupts may be considered harmful for one's mind, as it blows the thought process into smithereens. psychologists, psychiatrists and spiritual teachers from all around the globe are crying warnings in our face since before the dawn of Internet, but only few listen... the concept of conscious living/being and (as one other commentator noted) the essence of meditative practices is completely incompatible with social or any other media based on push updates and preprogrammed streams (tv/social/etc). add to this the tricks for retention and the fact that we develop reflexes to ask the network, and not our own memory, and you get a totally unconscious living, one that slowly diminishes concentration and intelligence irrelevant. the WHO needs to immediately come forward and warn Earth's population of the forthcoming collapse of free will/thought, as this is already happening and we can only guess where it gets to. it's concerning that there are many signs we're about to witness social-media-related-insanity 'en masse' in the very near future.
- taurath 9y agoMaybe lack of actual community existing causes childhood depression? The way so much of our society is set up to allow for individualism and solitude it doesn’t surprise me that the kids are not alright.
- John_KZ 9y agoI think the article mixes up and confuses two different concepts. One is that social media might amplify "normal" social conditions, such as bullying, to an unprecedented degree. The other one is the misuse/abuse of social media as socialization substitutes by children, leading to isolation. Social media can bring a lot of benefit to everyone, even children, if they are used to augment and improve our real-life, face-to-face interactions. But they cannot and should not substitute them. Some argue it's just about how you use them. That's not true. Companies like facebook use psychometrics, sociologist and psychologists to optimize their software for something, and that something probably never is your well-being. We can use regulation to enforce this. You can be the most active and social person there is, but a properly designed piece of software that filters and controls all your social interaction can destroy your social life and mental health. Especially if you're 9 years old and most of your life experiences come from a screen.
- joejerryronnie 9y agoRemember when rock music was going to lead us down the path of evil? And then violent video games were creating an entire generation of lawless degenerates? Now social media is causing depression. I can only imagine the societal ills that AR/VR will wreak on us all!
- zappo2938 9y agoI went to three different high schools in as many states before the time of the internet and cell phones. Each time I became disconnected from my hard earned friendships was depressing. I wish I had better communication at the time.
- lerie82 9y agoI would gladly defend social media against people who say it's bad for anyone. It all boils down to the person using the social medium. Exactly the same way someone uses a public forum for speaking. I think people who bad-mouth social media are just looking for someone to blame something on. For example, if their child is misbehaving, if their wife/husband/gf/bf is doing something differtent, it must be social media right? My child was using "insert social medium here" and now they are doing "insert whatever you want here", so it's obviously the fault of "insert the social medium here"... I think the people who blame social media just don't want to admit that there are bad people in the world, they need something to blame besides people, so they blame something else, and hey, social media is the bad thing these days. Remember when television was said to have negative affects on children? It's the same freaking problem, just a new thing to blame it on. I wonder what it will be next? AI? Let's start blaming AI now, so we can just avoid that in the future. I bet the same people who hate social media not only use social media daily but also hate donald trump. Maybe the social media haters are the sheep of society, maybe this is a good way to identify them. It's also pretty hard to say someone is being bullied online when all you have to do is not be their friend or look at their timeline or read their messages. It just seems like poor parenting to me.
- enord 9y agoSocial media is yet another aspect of the atomization of the individual. We are engaged in a great un-meaningfying of human interaction driven by a philosophication of empirically established human propensities. We are what we do, and the value of what we do is eatablished by market forces. You are your friends and likes. You are your upvotes and replies. You are your retweets and followers. These are truths when you are too young to establish your own moral footing. And we pulled the rug out from under them; religion is out, atheism is uncool (they can tell), spiritual self discovery is illegal(usually involves drugs) and The Internet, well, thats where they get depressed, innit? We are ill equipped for the marketisation of identity.
- ukulele 9y agoOne of the best things about the internet is the potential for searchable comments like these 20+ years from now. I look forward to seeing how the same things get repeated over and over and over at the onset of each new technology.
- enord 9y agoHahaha, I remember claiming that expensive phones with crappy cameras was a stupid fad that would blow over. If you dont't make a bold claims you don't get the benefits of hindsight i guess! I would like to add that I was trying to make a point about morality and nihilism in our culture with developing technology as the backdrop, not the cause as such.
- stratigos 9y agoIve been saying this since 2007 when all my friends complained that I dont have a facebook account ;)
- evantahler 9y agoHere’s my philosophy: happiness comes from creation. We are hackers, we know this. But “creating memories” and “creating experiences” counts too! Browsing Social media is not an act of creation, but one of consumption.
- kangxitenant 9y agoNice article. Being pedantic, Id just like to point out that all photos are digitally manipulated tho.
- Gatsky 9y agoSocial media is indistinguishable from smoking, except we are all smoking the same damn pipe. (tobacco smoking, to be precise)
- clubm8 9y agoThen what caused my childhood depression? Does AIM count as social media? ;)
- conmarap 9y agoThis doesn't surprise me at all. Unfortunately, social media is not social at all. It's not just the medium everyone uses to talk about and prize themselves, but also the medium that people use to silently ostracize others, who in turn use the completely fake and narcissistic posts of whoever they deem popular, or "cool," as a metric of how good their own lives are and, ultimately, fall into depression whilst failing to understand the fakeness of what they see.
- creep 9y agoI'd be depressed too if my news feed was filled with the social dynamics of pubescent-aged children. It's much easier to understand what's truly going on in the social world when one is physically present in that world, and it's also much easier to remove onself from a toxic group of people. Every school-aged relative I have has a Facebook with nearly every kid from school added as a friend. But every friend's feed is presented by default as if you are directly involved with their shit. It's hard to remove oneself from that, especially because having more Facebook friends to a kid is very socially laudable.