9 ms·
Rent Control Needs Retirement, Not a Comeback
- jacobsheehy 9y agoThe author thinks low-income people's incomes are rising and that is false. The rest of the article is fallacious because of this.
- tylerhou 9y agohttps://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Fallacy_fallacy https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Fallacy_fallacy
- andyjohnson0 9y agoThe "Falacy falacy" strictly applies to logical falacy. Its pretty clear that the grandparent is using "fallacious" in the informal sense of "mistaken belief".
- tylerhou 9y agoEven if you (loosely) interpret the usage of "fallacious" in the parent comment as "mistaken belief", he's still claiming that the rest of the article exhibits the "mistaken belief" that rent control is bad. His argument for why the article exhibits a mistaken belief is because the article has a wrong statement near the beginning (incomes are rising for low income people). This is still an example of the fallacy fallacy. > The "Falacy falacy" strictly applies to logical falacy. Are you claiming that the parent comment is not logical or not making a logical argument? What type of other acceptable argument is there?
- Finnucane 9y agoIncomes are, on average, rising a little. Which is partly why the stock market is freaking out; Wall Street hates it when income goes up, because they view it as money coming out of their pocket. Cities like New York and Boston and SF are expensive because there's a lot of money going through them; this creates high demand and high incomes for some. But companies like Facebook and Google and Apple could certainly afford to pay everyone who works for them in any capacity enough so that no one would have to live in a car. But the investor class would have a shit if that happened.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ChrisLomont 9y agoLowest incomes, even inflation adjusted, certainly have been rising. Here's historical Census Data [1], Table H-1. Income Limits for Each Fifth and Top 5 Percent. Maybe you have some large scale data you'd like to share? [1] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-poverty/historical-income-households.html https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-p...
- Retric 9y agoFrom the data you linked: lowest 5th 2001: 24,361 2016: 24,002 that's a net loss over the last 15 years. The numbers rise and fall but: 1979: 21,594 2014: 21,728 Is not what i would call meaningful progress.
- ChrisLomont 9y agoYes, if you cherry pick all time highs (2001) then you can claim they've lost since then. Picking a second case (1979) and oddly comparing it to 2014 instead of 2016 is equally misleading. Instead of cherry-picking dates to suit a narrative, looking at all data, the 2016 income was higher than any year back to 1966 except the 3 years 1999,2000,2001. So of the 50ish years in the data, 2016 ranks in the top 4, and is 96% of the all time high. The trend since the recession is increasing, and if not for the recession, would probably be at all time highs. I would not be surprised if once 2017 or 2018 numbers were in all time values will be reached. So yes, wages are increasing. One reason low end stays mostly flat is it includes all people just starting careers, who have no skills, so it's not unreasonable that the inflation adjusted value they provide is not tremendously increased. Looking at values over this time frame also needs demographics figured in for this reason, and as the workforce becomes younger, wages are expected to become lower, while each individual person at point X in a career still has higher wages. Census reports cover this. Remember avg wages are static snapshots of a moving cohort.
- Retric 9y agoThe problem with your argument is the last 40+ years is +/- 10% of ~22,000. Yes there are highs and lows, but that's not progress that's just how well the economy is that year. Basically take 22,000 * a function of unemployment rate and the data is flat over time. PS: Looking at the highest income for a quintile also says very little about it as everyonone is making less than that. You really want the median of the quintile or the average of everyone within that range.
- pmarreck 9y agoThis comment and its replies are what happens when you refute an assertion without evidence
- saosebastiao 9y agoThere are various perspectives to take on income in which two people looking at the same data can come to two different conclusions. It goes much further than Simpsons paradox. Simply choosing your windows for comparison differently can cause this: one person chooses to compare 2014 with 2016, and the other chooses to compare 2001 with 2009. One perspective that is almost universally true going back as far as we have data, is that incomes rise over the lifetime of the individual. Because the bottom 20% today are a completely different set of people as the bottom 20% of tomorrow. And because people strongly to earn more as they get older, the premises of the article hold up.
- MarkMc 9y ago> The author thinks low-income people's incomes are rising and that is false. The author doesn't specifically mention low-income people - she just says that 'incomes rise': But then incomes rise, and rents don’t. People with higher incomes have more resources to pursue access to artificially cheap real estate: friends who work for management companies, “key fees” or simply incomes that promise landlords they won’t have to worry about collecting the rent. Your observation that poor people's incomes are stagnant actually strengthens the authors point above, because a growing income gap gives rich people 'more resources to pursue access to artificially cheap real estate'. > The rest of the article is fallacious because of this. There are some points in the article that are not dependant on rising incomes. For example, Meanwhile, price ceilings reduce the supply because they decrease the incentive to build, and can make it downright imperative to remove rental housing from the market and turn it to some other use -- condos, warehouses, anything that won’t trigger the rent controls.
- diogenescynic 9y agoBuild more houses first—reduce the ridiculous zoning laws and permitting processes, especially in California. Then we can talk.
- notyourday 9y agoTrue, rent control needs retirement, but only with the retirement of restrictions on building of housing.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>Serial experimentation with this policy has repeatedly shown the same result. New York's two largest building booms took place during times of very strict rent controls - the 1920s and between 1947 and 1965. >rent control looks like a victory for the poor over the landlord class. But the stifling of price signals leads to problems. Except when it actually happened the price signals sent by the strictest rent controls still weren't enough to end the city's biggest housing booms. Seriously, Megan McArdle telling you that price controls are "just going to hurt the poor" is a bit like Trump telling you that demolishing Mar a Lago will only hurt the immigrants. Rent control is a dirty hack, for sure, but it's a dirty hack that shouldn't be removed until a proper fix is put in place - i.e. a land value tax. I won't hold my breath for Megan McArdle to advocate for that. Bloomberg should have her fired. She does absolutely no credit to their publication.
- DangerousPie 9y agoBoth of those building booms were shortly after world war one and world war two. Can you really make any fair comparisons based on that? The entire US economy was booming after the war. So numbers from that period don't tell you much about what things would have been like in peace time.
- crdoconnor 9y agoExcept I'm not claiming that the rent controls stimulated the boom. Just that the correlation posited by Megan McArdle absent any supporting data is imagined.
- RyanZAG 9y ago> Bloomberg should have her fired. She does absolutely no credit to their publication. I don't think calling for everyone you disagree with to be fired is the right way forward.
- grasshopperpurp 9y ago>I don't think calling for everyone you disagree with to be fired is the right way forward. I don't think conflating a specific person with everyone is a fair reading of the OP's statement.
- adrianN 9y agoRecently I was in SF for the first time. I was pretty shocked to see the endless rows of tiny one story + garage houses separated by impossibly wide streets. No wonder housing is so expensive. The city could easily double its density by building more apartment buildings.
- codingdave 9y agoTrue, but not everyone wants their city to be packed full or large brick cubes that block the views of everything else.
- Retric 9y agoI am not sure why those people should have much say about what's going on. Most of the US already looks like you're describing.
- Thriptic 9y agoThat's a perfectly fair stance to take, but then people will simply have to accept that rents will be sky high in cities like SF in perpetuity. The high prices are fundamentally a supply issue; build enough housing and prices will inevitably fall.
- Retric 9y agoThat's also likely real opposition, people with inflated assets want them to stay inflated.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>So the promise of economic justice erodes over time, as lucky insiders come to dominate rent-controlled apartments, especially because having gotten their hands on an absurdly cheap apartment, said elites are loathe to move and free up space for others. So Megan's response is just not to pursue economic justice at all? It doesn't make any sense, of course the powerful will try to erode justice for the powerless, that's just society, that doesn't mean we stop pursuing justice. It means we become even more vigilant about it.
- paulgb 9y ago> Megan's response is just not to pursue economic justice at all? I think the argument here is more "not pursue short-term economic justice at the expense of long-term economic justice"
- AstralStorm 9y agoAnd she tested that the long term justice materialized ever how? Any reference group at least?
- dkarl 9y agoI don't agree with the article, but I think your reasoning is dangerous. If a means is introduced to serve a noble purpose, but it does not serve that purpose, then the nobility of the purpose is not a defense of the means. Right now there's an article on the front page about the consequences of applying that reasoning to dubious forensic sciences that were introduced with the noble intention of ensuring justice but in fact undermine it. If a means doesn't serve an end, then continuing to pursue it despite the perverse consequences doesn't prove your commitment to the to the desired result.
- closeparen 9y agoThis statement right here is the entire philosophical disagreement between (liberal) YIMBYs and affordable housing activists: given that price controls (esp. affordability requirements for new construction) are well intentioned but don’t produce housing at a large enough scale to help, do we double down on them or back off? One side is hammering on the noble purpose, saying that if price controls don’t work, we must take housing entirely out of the hands of the market. The other is hammering on the practicality and implementation detail of particular regulatory regimes, and we talk past each other for years.
- vr46 9y agoLondon housing still has a fair number of long-settled subsidized tenants who no longer need subsidized housing, but "council-homes-for-life" is in place and confers huge advantages to incumbents, which hardly seems fair. Basing access on need, this is not. I have lived in various parts of Central London in mixed social housing, always as a market rate tenant (I am fortunate enough to afford it as a software engineer) and sympathize with the laments of poorer tenants who are occasionally booted out of their homes due to some housing development or other, complaining about the breakups of their communities and their families. But what about people who HAVE to leave their communities and families in order to make the most of opportunities when they arise? Is there an easy answer?
- bradleyjg 9y agoWe have a standardized bundle of rights that shields the person that possesses that bundle from many (but not all) price increases in a living space. It's called ownership. If a city thinks that certain people should be protected in that way, it should buy the proprieties and give them to those favored people. Trying to unbundle ownership and tenancy to mix and match them, at a city level with only acquiescence as opposed to enthusiastic collaboration from state and federal governments, as well as quasi-governmental institutions, is not going to work well.
- irascible 9y agoFound the libertarian...
- amorphid 9y agoI live in a San Francisco rent-controlled apartment. I only moved to San Francisco because of rent control. Otherwise I would not have been able to afford a place at all. New apartments in cities without rent control always seem to be expensive, and I couldn't afford those either. Rents on old apartments seem to be skyrocketing, too. I, for one, welcome rent control.
- swsieber 9y agoIt's not that rent control doesn't help some people - it's just the wrong solution. The real solution is building more housing. (I think)
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoThat's not the only solution I think we should be implementing, though. We could subsidize housing for people that can't afford it in other ways - giving people money to pay for their apartment through social programs after considering their income, rent, and expenses to get a grip on their actual ability to pay for available housing. All without having a hard-line income cutoff for this stuff (which doesn't help when the numbers are out of balance with the local situation). Building housing will hopefully help folks so long as there is a shortage, but it isn't a cure-all either.
- xamuel 9y agoSounds like a recipe for really, really wealthy landlords.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoFolks aren't generally getting rich from HUD: In Indiana, at least, lots won't accept HUD due to regulations and not paying on time. The last bit should be fixed, the first bit should just be standard for rentals. Landlords wouldn't necessarily know if they just let it be shown as regular income. Besides, this does hinge on there being enough housing - including a few empty places. It is better to generally have empty units available just like you want a little unemployment to have a pool of employees to choose from.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wheaties 9y agoJust so people understand where I'm coming from with what I'm about to say, my family has worked and existed in the construction business for a long time. Houses to rent out were considered the safest income producing retirement asset to invest money. Then rent control was introduced. Fast forward 20yrs later and rent had stayed the same but taxes and municipal fees had increased to the point where they dwarfed the legally allowable income. Add to this new mandates which stipulated how electricity and water could be billed to tenants requiring installation of new equipment in the buildings every few years. Then throw in rising insurance rates coupled with rising maintenance expenses. So, we took at look at the figures and decided the best course of action was to either bulldoze a set of perfectly livable buildings, let the lots sit for the required minimum time, then rebuild a non-rent controlled property --OR-- sell to someone who could afford to do the same. There was no legal way to earn a profit otherwise. Turning into slum lords was not something we wanted to do. Welcome to being a landlord with rent controlled property.
- hindsightbias 9y ago> rent had stayed the same SF allows rent increases, CPI adjusted, usually 1.5-2.5% a year. SF county use taxes have been ~8% for a couple of decades. Prop 13 has been in effect since the 70s. 4 out of 6 units in my building have flipped in 5 years, allowing rent increases. Resulting in at least $70-80K additional income for the landlord (at Prop 13 tax rates). This is more the norm than an outlier - many of the new techies aren't mad at grandma stealing their freedom fries, they're mad at techies who beat them here in 2012. I'm all for giving up rent control when landlords give up Prop 13.
- skybrian 9y agoA compromise that would please nobody: how about mild rent control, say a limit of a 5% increase a year, doubling in 15 years?
- purplezooey 9y ago"Rent control is one of the most effective ways to destroy a city’s housing stock." The concept of 'housing stock' is generally a foreign one to the bay area. Residents mostly care about their own home value, rather than how having ample supply regionally benefits everyone.
- PeterMikhailov 9y agoPlease stop taking Megan McCardle seriously https://theoutline.com/post/2303/megan-mcardle-has-a-lot-of-bad-ideas https://theoutline.com/post/2303/megan-mcardle-has-a-lot-of-... http://exiledonline.com/megan-mcardles-hypocrisy-exposed-portrait-of-a-libertarian-as-a-taxpayer-subsidized-brat/ http://exiledonline.com/megan-mcardles-hypocrisy-exposed-por... https://twitter.com/asymmetricinfo/status/960546413582192641 https://twitter.com/asymmetricinfo/status/960546413582192641 https://www.splicetoday.com/politics-and-media/megan-mcardle-pushes-meritocracy https://www.splicetoday.com/politics-and-media/megan-mcardle... https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/view/articles/2018-01-30/megan-mcardle-s-12-rules-for-life https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/view/articles/2018-01-30/megan... https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-10-23/we-libertarians-were-really-wrong-about-school-vouchers https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-10-23/we-libert... https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-06-16/beware-of-blaming-government-for-london-tower-fire https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-06-16/beware-of... https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/view/articles/2017-09-18/we-didn-t-normalize-trump-we-normalized-the-left-s-violence https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/view/articles/2017-09-18/we-di... http://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2017/06/why_not_try_medicare_for_all_g.html http://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2017/06/why_not_... https://twitter.com/asymmetricinfo/status/859101074501890048 https://twitter.com/asymmetricinfo/status/859101074501890048 http://web.archive.org/web/20120314140221/http://www.janegalt.net/blog/archives/004056.html http://web.archive.org/web/20120314140221/http://www.janegal... https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2007/10/defending-vegetarian-honor/2054/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2007/10/defendi... http://prospect.org/article/atlantics-mcardle-problem http://prospect.org/article/atlantics-mcardle-problem http://firemeganmcardle.blogspot.com/2008/03/everybody-has-to-die-of-something.html http://firemeganmcardle.blogspot.com/2008/03/everybody-has-t... http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2012/12/newsweek-wins-worst-newtown-reaction-award.html http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2012/12/newsweek-wins-w...