6 ms·
The Navy’s Second Stealth Zumwalt-Class Destroyer Is Almost Ready for Action
- jandrese 9y agoGiven the recent problems with collisions on Navy ships I might be a little nervous serving aboard one that is designed to defeat naval radar. It would be pretty embarrassing to sink the newest destroyer because some big cargo ship couldn't see it in the dark and ran over it.
- gaius 9y agoThat would be 100% the decision of the Captain who chose to sit in a busy shipping lane showing no lights. The civilians captains going about their legitimate business, in a shipping lane, showing running lights, and restricted in ability to manoeuvre, have been blameless in all collisions to date.
- jandrese 9y agoWhich could definitely be an issue since the Zumwalts are tiny and low prestige so they might not get the top shelf Skippers.
- pablobaz 9y agoAt over $4 Billion each, I'd hope they still get top class skippers. Whatever the training, recruitment, retention etc. costs the Navy it would be worth it.
- jandrese 9y agoYeah, but it's a ship with a crew of 140 with no realistic path towards a combat deployment. It's the naval version of a dead end job.
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoIf you look at pictures of the Zumwalts putting around, you'll see they have standard naval radars mounted atop the deckhouse. Also, with stealth aircraft it's common practice to attach reflectors when not on a mission to go blow someone up. I imagine it's the same for the ships.
- scrumper 9y agoSeems that in a sense the Zumwalt is the first casualty of China’s new anti-ship ballistic missile system.
- adventured 9y agoNo. That'd be like saying the US should stop making carriers because of the new India/Russia BrahMos cruise missile. Or the so called DF21 carrier killer from China. These systems are primarily for fighting nations not named Russia and China. If China decides to sink a carrier or a Zumwalt, it's WW3, millions will die.
- gizmo385 9y ago> These systems are primarily for fighting nations not named Russia and China. But are those "nations not named Russia and China" realistically going to be able to do anything to a destroyer like this? Could they have realistically done anything to the previous generation of destroyers? It seems (to my uninformed eye) that these upgraded destroyers are almost comical in how far ahead of the technology that any adversary has (once again, those not named China and Russia).
- qubex 9y agoDidn’t the attack on the USS Cole (a dinghy loaded with explosives driven by suicidal fanatics) demonstrated that being “comically far ahead” in therms of technology sometimes amounts for precious little?
- gandhium 9y agoAt least Russia now is ready to flung their new technologies to anyone who can pay for them (selling S-400 to Turkey for example). So that _nations_ can have access to pretty advanced technologies.
- scrumper 9y agoOkay I understand that, makes sense. So this isn't so much about stealth not being worth pursuing as the Zumwalt having served its purpose as a technology demonstrator and experience/requirements gathering exercise, albeit one that cost more than intended? (We carry on with a new block of the Arleigh Burke class for the time being.)
- protomyth 9y agoDid the Navy ever figure out what the solution to the 155-millimeter Advanced Gun Systems ammo problem?
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoYeah. They're adapting the projectile developed by the railgun project to conventional powder guns. It'll end up being a much more affordable and practical approach. As far as whether they'll end up on the Zumwalts? Who knows. The lack of a missile defense system on the Zumwalts has more or less made them pointless beyond research/development testbeds. We're just going to build more Burkes and upgrade existing ones instead, which is more cost effective on the whole.
- jandrese 9y agoI'm guessing the whole "you can't get a radar lock on me to shoot in the first place" didn't work out for ballistic missile defense?
- dingaling 9y agoMost BMD scenarios centre around protecting other assets, not the launch platform.
- jasonwatkinspdx 9y agoIt's not a binary thing. But the main limit of the Zumwalts in missile defense is lacking the right radars and the combat management software. There's a kinda long history to all this, and it's a little muddled. My understanding of roughly what happened is originally a larger stealth cruiser design was going to handle missile defense, while the Zumwalts would handle strike. Then the cruiser project got canceled, so they started talking about adding the capabilities to the Zumwalts. That fell through when the development contract for the needed radar went to Raytheon (I don't fully understand why this killed it, seems to be something political?). What no one in the navy wants to say clearly and openly is: the Zumwalts, as well as the 2 LCS designs, are pretty much useless as built. They won't be used for more than training, development testing, and perhaps mine sweeping duties. Out of all 3 of those classes, the only fully capable ship anyone is talking about is a new, stretched version of the Freedom class LCS that tries to be a mini-frigate. And that's only getting talked about because foreign customers are interested. It's an incredible waste of taxpayers money.
- ghostcluster 9y agoIt has a very striking design: http://nationalinterest.org/files/styles/main_image_on_posts/public/main_images/zumwalttnibaby.jpg http://nationalinterest.org/files/styles/main_image_on_posts... but: > Given the sheer expense of the DDG-1000 class and its lack of certain ballistic missile defense capabilities—not to mention a number of outmoded technologies onboard—the Navy opted not to continue building the Zumwalt class. The three-ship class has cost the Navy $23 billion, with each ship coming in at roughly $4.25 billion per vessel when research and development is not factored in. > In the medium term, the future of the Navy’s surface fleet lies with the new Flight III Arleigh Burke (DDG-51) class destroyer—which BIW will start building starting with DDG-126 and DDG-127. Flight III Arleigh Burke (DDG-51) class destroyer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arleigh_Burke-class_destroyer#/media/File:130920-N-NX070-025_-_USS_Arleigh_Burke_(DDG-51).jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arleigh_Burke-class_destroyer#... Naval shipbuilding needs a SpaceX.
- fhood 9y ago> Naval shipbuilding needs a SpaceX. Not just Naval shipbuilding. I can think of a few contractors that could stand to get shaken up. Problem is you probably need an obscene amount of money and connections to get into that space.
- imglorp 9y agoOr at least an honest procurement process that doesn't include congressional influence. Look at the the M1A1 thing with Ohio.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI wonder how all these super expensive and complex weapons systems will do if there ever is an all-out war against an enemy who has access to advanced technology. It seems you should be able to bring down a 4 billion ship with a swarm of thousand drones for maybe 1 million each for the total cost of 1 billion. Same for aircraft carriers. From what I have read about the maintenance needs of systems like the F-22 and B-2 someone who has simpler, easier to maintain airplanes should also have an advantage once things get busy.
- 9y ago
- theBuess 9y agoWhats the advantage to these over the Arleigh Burke III's other than that these look cooler? It seems like you could have 2 or 3 of the Burke class for every one of these.
- smacktoward 9y agoThere's the stealth aspect, of course (which is a big difference from conventional ships like the Arleigh Burkes all by itself), and beyond that the Zumwalt class was supposed to incorporate a bunch of other next-generation features too: cutting-edge guns and missile-launch systems, an advanced permanent-magnet powerplant that could generate ten times the electrical power of conventional ones (which in turn would allow mounting things like beam weapons, when they became practical), new automated systems that allowed a crew half the size of a Burke's to operate the ship, and so forth. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zumwalt-class_destroyer#Design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zumwalt-class_destroyer#Design for a good overview.) Trying to roll so many technical leaps forward into a single ship proved to be a big mistake, though, as many of those advances were never able to be practically realized and some of those that were ended up costing much more to develop than originally anticipated. So the Zumwalts have become kind of a white elephant; the cost overruns caused the Navy to eventually cut its order for the ships from 32 to just three, and those that will be delivered are unlikely to ever be as capable as they were originally planned to be.
- drdeadringer 9y agoBecause of a recent "Software Engineering Daily" episode about modern warfare, I just finished reading "Ghost Fleet", a fictional book from a few years ago which features this Zumwalt-class destroyer in a war between the US and a joint China-Russia alliance. It was a fun read.
- phyller 9y agoI wonder what would have happened if they took all that development money, didn't worry at all about stealth, and just tried to make it as unsinkable as possible.