11 ms·
Scientists find massive reserves of mercury in permafrost
- joantune 9y agoTL;DR: another way how global warming is going to kill civilization as we know it. Or as Republicans - the selective amish of today's political scenario - call it: 'fake [might I add scientific] news' - they kinda believe in some of the science, the one that sprouted the technology they have, but not the one that they are paid not to believe in
- anonytrary 9y agoTo a politician is science just about spending money to know more information? Is this bad? Or is it just bad that people have confirmation bias?
- ElmntOfSurprise 9y agoQuality threads in HN: "But [outgroup] would disagree!"
- h2g3yhogw8 9y ago"maybe mercury's good for us, who knows ?"
- randomdrake 9y agoStudy: Permafrost Stores a Globally Significant Amount of Mercury Citation: Schuster, Paul F.; Schaefer, Kevin M.; Aiken, George R.; Antweiler, Ronald C.; Dewild, John F.; Gryziec, Joshua D.; Gusmeroli, Alessio; Hugelius, Gustaf; Jafarov, Elchin; Krabbenhoft, David P.; Liu, Lin; Herman-Mercer, Nicole; Mu, Cuicui; Roth, David A.; Schaefer, Tim; Striegl, Robert G.; Wickland, Kimberly P.; Zhang, Tingjun. Geophysical Research Letters, 45. Link: https://doi.org/10.1002/2017GL075571 https://doi.org/10.1002/2017GL075571 DOI: 10.1002/2017GL075571 Abstract: Changing climate in northern regions is causing permafrost to thaw with major implications for the global mercury (Hg) cycle. We estimated Hg in permafrost regions based on in situ measurements of sediment total mercury (STHg), soil organic carbon (SOC), and the Hg to carbon ratio (RHgC) combined with maps of soil carbon. We measured a median STHg of 43 ± 30 ng Hg g soil−1 and a median RHgC of 1.6 ± 0.9 μg Hg g C−1, consistent with published results of STHg for tundra soils and 11,000 measurements from 4,926 temperate, nonpermafrost sites in North America and Eurasia. We estimate that the Northern Hemisphere permafrost regions contain 1,656 ± 962 Gg Hg, of which 793 ± 461 Gg Hg is frozen in permafrost. Permafrost soils store nearly twice as much Hg as all other soils, the ocean, and the atmosphere combined, and this Hg is vulnerable to release as permafrost thaws over the next century. Existing estimates greatly underestimate Hg in permafrost soils, indicating a need to reevaluate the role of the Arctic regions in the global Hg cycle.
- dang 9y agoIt's fine to post links to the relevant paper, but could you please stop pasting bibliographic boilerplate into HN threads? I'm sure your intention is good, but the purpose of HN threads is thoughtful conversation, and this is not that.
- solutron 9y agoBibliographic info along with an abstract are an excellent way to help contextualize a thoughtful conversation, and does so without diverting attention away from the main thread.
- dang 9y agoI'm afraid I don't agree, for the same reason that no one would read all that stuff out loud in a normal conversation. This information is easy to get for anyone who wants it, particularly if someone has posted a link to it. There's no need to inline the content.
- Chris2048 9y agoHow does a full citation list help with context?
- randomdrake 9y agoSure. Thoughtful conversation and adding to it is definitely part of the intention; not trying to be a bother. Happy to adjust and try to keep contributing if you could be so kind as to let me know what would be preferred instead of a citation like this.
- dizzystar 9y agoI think the poster was irritated with the long citation list and other extraneous items. Just share a link and a part of the abstract, or do a summary.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yesenadam 9y ago>"The study found approximately 793 gigagrams, or more than 15 million gallons, of mercury is frozen in northern permafrost soil. That is roughly 10 times the amount of all human-caused mercury emissions over the last 30 years, based on emissions estimates from 2016. >The study also found all frozen and unfrozen soil in northern permafrost regions contains a combined 1,656 gigagrams of mercury, making it the largest known reservoir of mercury on the planet. This pool houses nearly twice as much mercury as soils outside of the northern permafrost region, the ocean and the atmosphere combined. Gigagram? Never heard that one before.. uh a billion (US) grams? So.. a million kilos..a thousand tonnes..a kilotonne. or 1,656 gigagrams = 1.656 million tonnes, I think. (Weird that the imperial unit is gallons, a measure of volume I thought) This doesn't sound good. Also I'm surprised that human mercury emissions in the last 30 years were so high. Since the late 80s..sheesh.
- userbinator 9y ago(Weird that the imperial unit is gallons, a measure of volume I thought) It is volume. The density of mercury is 13.69 g/cm3 and thus 793E9 grams is 5.8E7 litres, or 1.5E7 gallons. "more than 15 million gallons" is correct.
- infogulch 9y agoYou're recalling correctly, gallon is a measure of volume. I would assume they used density conversions just to make it into a "relatable" measure for US readers. But there is no US-gram. The SI unit for mass is the kilogram, (for which "kilo" is shorthand), where kilo- and giga- are standard SI prefixes. Units and prefixes are designed to be mixed and matched, so gigagram is just as valid as kilogram, even if it's more rare. Edit: thank you userbinator for the base unit correction. I've edited above to not be blatantly wrong.
- userbinator 9y agoThe SI unit for mass is the gram, (not "kilo" which is just shorthand for kilogram, which is just commonly used because it's relatable) The SI base unit for mass is actually the kilogram. It is memorable and notable for being the only base unit that already has a prefix.
- EarthIsHome 9y agoScary stuff: > The study reveals northern permafrost soils are the largest reservoir of mercury on the planet, storing nearly twice as much mercury as all other soils, the ocean and the atmosphere combined. And the permafrost is thawing thanks to climate change. > “There’s a significant social and human health aspect to this study,” Sebestyen said. “The consequences of this mercury being released into the environment are potentially huge because mercury has health effects on organisms and can travel up the food chain, adversely affecting native and other communities.”
- thrownaway6392 9y ago> Scary stuff: So is this: http://www.unz.com/isteve/fear-of-a-black-planet-un-boosts-its-2017-population-forecast-for-africa-in-2100-to-4468000000/ http://www.unz.com/isteve/fear-of-a-black-planet-un-boosts-i... https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2014/08/13/340091377/unicef-report-africas-population-could-hit-4-billion-by-2100 https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2014/08/13/3400913... The difference being that you can at least publicly discuss the potential hazards attending to climate change. By contrast, just mentioning the fact that Africa's population seems poised to swell to four and a half billion by 2100--even without reference to any of the obvious negative consequences--is enough to earn a harsh rebuke (or a shadowban on HN), as happened to French President Emanuel Macron when he recommended that women in Niger stop having so many children (7.5 per woman): https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jul/11/slur-africans-macron-radical-pretence-over https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jul/11/slur-a...
- selimthegrim 9y agoWhat relevance does this have to the topic at hand?
- thrownaway6392 9y agoThey're both (arguably) existential threats. It's just that only one of them can be (and is--constantly) publicly acknowledged, while the other, apparently, can't be. Quoting John Derbyshire on the graph from the first link: > That graph—the world’s most important graph—looms over the 21st century like a monstrous great crow. Yet we can’t talk about it. Or rather, I can, and Mark can; but no-one with much more of a profile than us, can. > Why not? Do you need to ask? That line shooting up on the graph represents Africa—black people (mostly), and a high proportion of them Muslims. The other line, the one plodding along horizontally, represents Europe—white people (mostly), and a very high proportion not Muslims. > In the state ideologies of the Western world, black people are sacred objects to whom whites must defer, Muslims only slightly less so. Nothing negative may be said about these peoples, nor even hinted.
- darfo 9y agoHow did it get there? I was disappointed that wasn't mentioned.
- freeone3000 9y agoWhen a mommy sun and a daddy cloud of interstellar gas condense into higher-order matter...
- jannes 9y agoIt wouldn't be trapped in ice if it had been there for that long... I think he meant: how did it get trapped in permafrost? The only hint the article gave was this: > Mercury accumulates in aquatic and terrestrial food chains [...] and: > [...] trapped in permafrost [...] since the last Ice Age.
- matt4077 9y agoJust speculating: maybe atmospheric dust (pollen, etc.), and/or migrating animals contain it and it gets deposited wherever the dust comes down, or the animal dies. But in permafrost, it is quickly fixed by humidity and ice, and it isn't returned to the oceans by a constant flow of water?
- IIIIIIIIIIIIIII 9y agoI read before (this study) that mercury accumulates at the poles more than anywhere else. Context was affect on wildlife there, some birds turning gay [0][1] (that effect is location independent, but I read it first in a northern location context). A possible reason for it to "go north" is mentioned here: [2]. > Environmental scientists at Harvard have discovered that the Arctic accumulation of mercury ... is caused by both atmospheric forces and the flow of circumpolar rivers that carry the element north into the Arctic Ocean. [1] also is a pretty good article on the effects of mercury on wildlife. There also is mentioning of possible pathways to the north here: [3] - unlike [2] they claim it's mostly through the atmosphere though. > From our observation site north of Alaska’s Brooks Range, we determined that gaseous elemental mercury in the atmosphere is the dominant source of Arctic mercury. We calculated that it accounted for 70 percent of the mercury that finds its way into tundra soil. [0] https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/12/101203-homosexual-birds-mercury-science/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/12/101203-homo... [1] http://e360.yale.edu/features/mercurys_silent_toll_on_the_worlds_wildlife http://e360.yale.edu/features/mercurys_silent_toll_on_the_wo... [2] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/arctic-rivers-toxic-mercury/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/arctic-rive... [3] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/mercury-from-industrialized-nations-is-polluting-the-arctic/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/mercury-from-indu...
- rfujikawa 9y agoSounds like a job for Cody of Codyslab. I see "Recovering Mercury From Permafrost" videos in our future...
- ageofwant 9y agoCody extracts mercury by roasting cinnabar which is a mineral rich in HgS - or maybe HgS is called cinnabar - I forget. I'm assuming this mercury is also bounded, and not lying around in pools of Hg. Hg is less toxic than Pb, and yet the government is OK with people shooting thousands of kilograms of the stuff over swamps and waterways and food crop fields.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoyou can thank the nra and that idiot ryan zinke for that. i just talked to a scientist today who is publishing a study on how hunting with lead shot, then eating what you hunt, can... wait for it... result in huge amounts of lead in your body, if you do it habitually over time. yet the nra is actively saying there is no science to back up the claim that hunting with lead bullets is a health hazard, and zinke rescinded obamas EO that you cant hunt with lead on federal lands (which was put in place as an attempt to stop poisoning animals who would eat the shot animals). so, alot of people are going to die, and a lot of children are going to be developmentally disabled because of this. its really unconscionable.
- carlmr 9y agoI just buy my Cinnabons at the Cinnabar.
- madaxe_again 9y agoIt's going to be biological mercury - from bioaccumulation in top predator tissue which ends up frozen and inert in the permafrost when the top predators die. The thing that makes this really nasty is that biological mercury is most commonly methylmercury - which makes free mercury look like delicious gravy. It's very readily absorbed by tissues, and doesn't leave. God help us if it's acquired a second methyl group through tens of thousands of years of incredibly slow decomposition - dimethylmercury is pretty much the most toxic thing we know of.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoLets make this maximal catastrophic, lets mine the mercury using the methane escaping from the permafrost with drones. We can then use the mercury to destroy djungle mining for gold. This species deserves to be nuked so much...
- Someone 9y ago”mercury is frozen in northern permafrost soil” Is it? From a quick scan, I couldn’t find any reference to mercury compounds in the paper, and pure Mercury has a freezing point of -38,83 °C. Seems you could crush the frozen ground, and the Mercury would drop out. Also, if that’s the case, how much of it would simply drop deeper into the ground when the permafrost thaws?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- singularity2001 9y agofrozen as in 'surrounded by ice' <> frozen as in 'surrounded by police'
- MattHeard 9y agoEven if the mercury remains a liquid, it could still pose a risk if it is currently trapped within ice but flows into waterways when released from the thawed ice.
- aardvark291 9y agoIt's almost certainly not in the form of elemental mercury (which would be a liquid), but a solid mercury compound.
- Camillo 9y agoAfter all the scaremongering about "peak mercury", finally some good news! Scientists have discovered massive new reserves of the precious resource - enough to provide every child with life-saving vaccines for the next million years.
- arca_vorago 9y agoI could make good use of it in the snake temple and in my tomb that won't be unearthed for thousands of years.
- jwfxpr 9y agoWell, climate scientists have been predicting it for years, but the evidence is finally in: the mercury is definitely rising.
- GEBBL 9y agoTo be honest, at this stage, it's just another thing to add to the ever growing list of things that could potentially kill us.
- joantune 9y agothis one is avoidable though
- azeotropic 9y ago793 gigagrams in how many grams of permafrost? From the paper's estimate of the concentration in soil (43ng mercury per gram of soil) this mercury is dispersed in 18 exagrams of soil. For scale, the concentration of mercury in permafrost is about an order of magnitude less than what is found in tuna, and about the same as what is found in haddock or mackerel. (At least according to Wikipedia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury_in_fish https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercury_in_fish)
- jebeng 9y agoDo Tuna and other forms of life effectively act as a sort of biological filter collecting mercury over time though? Like we would too if we ate too much Tuna getting mercury poisoning. Could an order of magnitude less actually be a lot if you look at it that way? Since the permafrost would just be passively accumulating, as opposed to actively in a way which only something living can do.
- semi-extrinsic 9y ago> Do Tuna and other forms of life effectively act as a sort of biological filter collecting mercury over time though? Yes. This is called biomagnification. Basically, animals absorb heavy metals that are in the food they eat, but don't have an efficient way of excreting it again. Mainly since these metals are bound so they're fat soluble, not water soluble. The higher up in the food chain, the worse it gets. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomagnification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomagnification
- woopwoop 9y agoI don't understand why the concentration is relevant. The issue is the amount. Once the permafrost melts, the mercury locked in it will enter the mercury cycle. I don't have a model of how this will change the amount of mercury in our diet, for example, but it seems a good first order estimate would be that it is proportional to the total increase of mercury in the mercury cycle. The concentration of mercury in fish may be higher than in soil, but is the total amount of mercury in fish greater than than the total amount in soil?
- johnalamos 9y agoJust change it to Gold. $_$ https://www.wikihow.com/Make-Gold-from-Mercury https://www.wikihow.com/Make-Gold-from-Mercury
- blubb-fish 9y agousing gallons as a unit - that's ri-di-cu-lous
- xq3000 9y agoDoes it mean that as the global warming progresses all that mercury will mobilize and Earth will poison itself...?