3 ms·
Where do you see the profit? I would think precious metals get a lot less precious if they start falling out of the sky and I am pretty skeptical about other E
by maxerickson 9y ago
Where do you see the profit?
I would think precious metals get a lot less precious if they start falling out of the sky and I am pretty skeptical about other Earthside uses being profitable at all.
People that go try to live in space are going to have a hard time of it so I wouldn't expect profit from supplying space industry either (the longer missions cosmonauts and astronauts have completed have had grave physical consequences, we aren't adapted to low g environments).
- encrystation 9y agoThere's probably lots of neat uses for gold at the moment that aren't financially viable due to the cost of the raw material.
- mmjaa 9y agoNot to mention that the idea of things just falling out of the sky when we need them sounds great to me. Seriously, not kidding. Lets push 3D printing so hard all we need to do is send a few drones worth "up there", and oila .. free everything for everyone, forever.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIt's less fun when you realize that being able to drop any meaningful amount of material from space is equivalent to having a weapon of mass destruction. (This is actually a constant thing in spaceflight, that comes up because of the scales involved. Similarly to that, any engine able to cut down interplanetary travel to reasonable lengths (days, weeks) will have energy output of a WMD, and could be used as such.)
- Neutrion 9y agoAlso the disruption brought by let huge objects falling through the sky will be devastating to atomsphere.
- mmjaa 9y agoClearly we'll work out how to deliver through the atmosphere.
- maxerickson 9y agoRight, but if you make the price of gold fall by 5 or 10 times you are, uh, undermining your own profitability.
- sitkack 9y agoMoney is a proxy. When one has a star trek replicator, money doesn't matter anymore.
- PeterisP 9y agoWhy would the cost decrease? It'd still be more cost-efficient to e.g. mine for gold under the ocean or in the Antarctic rather than send gear up to space to do that. If we had a huge solid gold asteroid (how would that occur?) floating in a very close, very convenient orbit then maybe it would be cost-effective to send a ship to connect, re-orbit and land it without vaporizing; but anything realistic simply wouldn't be worth the launch effort&cost.
- yaniqt 9y agoThe value of the resources is not in having them on Earth. It is in not having to get them into space from Earth at ~$10,000 / lb.
- maxerickson 9y agoYeah, I expressed a couple of thoughts about that. There's not billions of dollars of demand for bulk materials in space.
- yaniqt 9y agoPerhaps because there is currently no supply.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoExactly. This is a chicken-and-egg problem, and to break out of it, you need to address supply and demand simultaneously. Asteroid mining isn't happening in a vacuum (well, it is in a physical one, but not metaphorical). Fortunately, there are people working on using the mined material to manufacture things in space too; missions plans are being sketched around those capabilities.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoThat's entirely because of the cost of lifting to orbit. If resources were available at reasonable cost, demand would soar. It would be the largest expansion of commerce since the discovery of the new world. It cannot be underestimated the impact this would have on human development.
- maxerickson 9y agoWhat's the end market driving all this commerce? Current space industry is dominated by intensively manufactured goods (satellites) that provide enormous value to ground based users. Having literal tons of steel available isn't going to help with the intensively manufactured part. I can see space hotels or whatever, but that is not a huge market, even with Musky launch prices.