3 ms·
I'd argue the old stuff is better, not simply "good enough" vs. Electron etc. What have we gotten in exchange for the crap performance and extra RAM usage? Pr
by kelnos 9y ago
I'd argue the old stuff is better, not simply "good enough" vs. Electron etc. What have we gotten in exchange for the crap performance and extra RAM usage? Pretty animations? I don't need those; in fact they're distracting and annoying. You absolutely can make "pretty", complex UIs in native/cross-platform toolkits, and personally I find them much nicer to work with than the horror show that is HTML/JS/CSS.
I get that Electron brings benefits: it's dirt-easy to build something that'll run on Windows, MacOS, and Linux, without having to know a bunch of platform-specific details, and if you already have a webapp, you can leverage a lot of that work, but in the end it just feels to me like people cutting corners. You get a sub-standard app, but you don't have to pay developers to build for each platform plus the web. Which I think is a perfectly reasonable business trade off to make; I'm just not happy with the result as a user.
- solarkraft 9y agoI'm glad you understand one part of Electron adoption, but the other part is user experience. Apart from being resource hogs Electron apps are usually delightful. And usability (for non programmers!) is what for a large part decides the value of your app. You want users to use your program, right? What they see is the UI. Making it easy to develop good UIs is important for a GUI tool (obviously!).
- jakelazaroff 9y ago> Pretty animations? I don't need those; in fact they're distracting and annoying. Animations are an important tool for showing transitions between states. Pasquale D'Silva has a bunch of good blog posts explaining how they can help an interface: - https://medium.com/@pasql/transitional-interfaces-926eb80d64e3 https://medium.com/@pasql/transitional-interfaces-926eb80d64... - https://medium.com/elepath-exports/spatial-interfaces-886bccc5d1e9 https://medium.com/elepath-exports/spatial-interfaces-886bcc...
- SZJX 9y agoWe can totally accept old-fashioned UI as developers. Hell, we even work in our terminals all day or use i3wm instead of any desktop environment. However, most apps target normal end users, not developers. Show your cousin whether she likes a flashy "modern" UI more or a succinct UI more, the answer is a no-brainer. And then try to explain to her what RAM usage actually means... The same as asking her whether she prefers using i3 or Windows, Vim or Word etc.