7 ms·
Where the wall once stood
- skrause 9y agoSeems like the wall of concrete has been replaced by a wall of parked cars.
- dalbasal 9y agoIt was more than concrete.
- azernik 9y agoFor a very good reason - if you look at the old pictures, you'll often see the pre-1961 sidewalk embedded in the street. The Wall was often build in the middle of streets that had been used as demarcation lines between Soviet and other zones. When the wall came back down, those streets were rebuilt, and so car parking went down exactly along the route of the wall. You can see this by looking at the ground; modern Berlin marks the route of the wall with a line of bricks in the middle of the pavement. In many of the current pictures, that line runs just between the traffic lanes and the parked cars.
- f_allwein 9y agomissing the most famous view of the wall, next to Brandenburg Gate: https://www.awesomestories.com/asset/view/Wall-at-the-Brandenburg-Gate/1 https://www.awesomestories.com/asset/view/Wall-at-the-Brande... Background: today is the day the Berlin wall has been down for as long as it has been up - http://nationalpost.com/news/the-berlin-wall-has-almost-been-down-as-long-as-it-was-up http://nationalpost.com/news/the-berlin-wall-has-almost-been...
- salmonfamine 9y agoI think I stood in almost that exact spot a few months ago during a trip to Europe. Crazy to think that there used to be a border there.
- barking 9y agoTo me it didn't look like they tried too hard to take the picture from the same angle etc. I remember a person from the old West Germany saying to me that they'd like that wall back twice as high and the same depth underground because of all reunification cost and the entitled attitude of 'osties'
- Narretz 9y agoYou'll also find old Eastern Germany people say they want the wall back because they had it better in the DDR. Or at least they think they did.
- FabHK 9y agoKnown in German as "Ostalgie" ((Ost = east) + (Nostalgie = nostalgia))
- executesorder66 9y agoThey did have it better. Which is why that want to go back. Edit: or should I rather put it this way: They have lived in the GDR, and have years of firsthand life experience of what it was like. And they also live in the reunited Germany. And they also have years of firsthand life experience of what that is like. Why would they prefer the worse option? (hint, they won't) And why would they think the worse option was better, if they have personally experienced both in detail? Who are you to say that what they think is wrong?
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoBecause "the good old days" maybe? Seems to be a common sentiment among older generations everywhere.
- executesorder66 9y agoThe term "Ostalgie" was coined in 1992. German reunification was in 1990. It took 2 years to coin a term that described a feeling people had already felt. Not 2 decades. So I don't agree with your theory at all.
- fergie 9y agoIts amazing how much nicer most European cities have become since the '80s. The wall was one thing, but the general crime, grime and sense of decay was almost as bad.
- mseebach 9y agoNew York went through the same transformation. It's a "general" culture shift, suburbs went out of fashion for generation X. No sure what the exact underlying dynamic driving it was, but it's happened, as you note, more or less in tandem across Europe and US during the 90s and into the 00s.
- woodpanel 9y agoMaybe the 1980s Bronx was comparable in terms of deterioration but the "general cultural shift" definitely didn't affect any inner city of Western Europe in the ways which can be seen in the aforementioned videos there. Quite the opposite: Yes, suburbs flourished, but the appalling differences between East and West prove it has nothing to do with suburbanization. And the pictures of East German inner cities prove something else: That class differences still existed. Like only government-loyal members of society get to live in Pyongyang, all the Eastern German "white trash" would be found in those inner cities. People with connections had an easier time getting into new High-Rises being built at the city outskirts.
- hellofunk 9y agoA lot more than the Bronx. Most of NYC, including many parts of downtown Manhattan, the East and West villages, huge swaths of Brooklyn, all have gone through extraordinary changes since their grim, gritty days of the 1980s.
- ghaff 9y agoIt’s not so much that suburbs went out of fashion. There’s been plenty of growth in suburbs surrounding affluent and growing cities. It’s more that some cities became cool again, many of which were shrinking as late as the 1990s. This is true even of cities like Boston.
- woodpanel 9y agoI've seen so many pictures of the wall in my life, yet I can't remember seeing even one taken from the eastern side. Probably because it would have landed you in jail?
- FabHK 9y agoSo, two things: 1. The wall was all around West Berlin, separating it from East Berlin and the rest of East Germany. 2. There was a whole wide border defence strip, known as the death strip. The wall was just the inner most ("western") part of it. From West Berlin you could walk right up to it (though sometimes there was a thin strip of East Berlin strictly speaking), but on the outer ("eastern") side there was the considerable "defence in depth" and guards and fences etc. Basically, if you ever stood in front of the wall on the "eastern" side, you were either a border guard or about to be shot. See pictures here: https://allymalinenko.files.wordpress.com/2015/05/wall001.jpg https://allymalinenko.files.wordpress.com/2015/05/wall001.jp... https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Bundesarchiv_Bild_B_145_Bild-P061246.jpg https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datei:Bundesarchiv_Bild_B_145_... http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/berliner-mauer-der-geharkte-todesstreifen/1627392.html http://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/berliner-mauer-der-geharkt... EDIT to add: 3. Similarly, there was a 1400 km border between East and West Germany, which was also heavily guarded. It also had a border defence strip on the eastern side, up to 5 km (3 miles) wide, which incidentally turned it into a habitat for endangered species. While this "innerdeutsche Grenze" is less unusual and thus less famous than the Berlin Wall, more people died trying to cross it than at the Wall. 4. The crossings at that border were the stuff of spy movies: East Germany actually installed secret gamma-ray guns to detect people concealed inside vehicles. If someone arose suspicion and tried to flee with their car, there were 6 ton barriers, "Kraftfahrzeugschnellsperren", that could be catapulted across the road using hydraulic rams.
- azag0 9y ago> though sometimes there was a thin strip of East Berlin strictly speaking There were also secret doors in the wall, and on several occasion people from the western part who ended up on this thin strip adjacent to the wall were "kidnapped" by the stasi to the east and later usually traded for eastern agents captured in the west.
- kvgr 9y agoOn some photos, you can see pavement blocks in the asphalt, where the wall has been. Not sure if it is in all of the length, but it sure is in some places.
- f_allwein 9y agoYes, I believe it is most of the length. Very helpful actually, because otherwise it would be hard to figure out where the wall has been as Berlin is changing so much.
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoAre there no intact bits remaining? Last time I was in Berlin (maybe 10-15 years ago) there were a few places around the city where small sections still stood.
- SettembreNero 9y agoEast Side Gallery, Bernauer Straße, a couple of pieces in Postdamer Platz and maybe some other little pieces all around.
- hjkm 9y agoYes, in some parts of the city the wall is still there. In other parts, like where I live, iron beams stick out from the floor to show where the wall used to be. And in other parts, you can't see anything (though you usually don't have to walk far to see some wall-related artwork painted on a wall or something like that)
- theandrewbailey 9y agoThe Topography of Terror has a good portion of original wall on the street in front of it. http://www.topographie.de/en/the-historic-site/berlin-wall-monument/ http://www.topographie.de/en/the-historic-site/berlin-wall-m...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoFYI: The photos are not "side by side." They scroll over to see before and after views. I didn't immediately realize it. My German is lousy. Etc.
- majewsky 9y agoSame for me, although I speak (and am) German. I just thought, "it would be nice if you could move this... oh look, you actually can".
- _Microft 9y agoFormer canadian astronaut Chris Hadfield took a famous picture from the Internation Space Station that shows how it is still possible to see where the wall separated the city! Check this: https://www.theguardian.com/world/shortcuts/2013/apr/21/astronaut-chris-hadfield-berlin-divide https://www.theguardian.com/world/shortcuts/2013/apr/21/astr... Pretty awesome, in my opinion :)
- peterjmag 9y agoBerliner Morgenpost published a cool little interactive thing last week where you draw where you think the wall used to be and it tells you how close you were: https://interaktiv.morgenpost.de/berliner-mauer/ https://interaktiv.morgenpost.de/berliner-mauer/ (German only, but the headline basically just means "do you know where where the wall divided Berlin?") I've lived here for a few years, but I found it really challenging myself!
- binarray2000 9y agoIt is ironic that a country, which reunited after tearing a wall between its people in 1989, had a major role in breaking an almost neighboring country apart, taking part in its destruction and (subsequently) raising walls between people. I am talking about the former Yugoslavia. A quote from a book "The Beast Reawakens: Fascism's Resurgence from Hitler's Spymasters to Today's Neo-Nazi Groups and Right-Wing Extremists" (published in 1999) by Martin A. Lee: (Chapter eight "Shadow over the East", Page 299) Whereas the United States and the rest of the European Community tried to prevent the breakup of Yugoslavia, Bonn unilaterally recognized Croatia as an independent nation at the end of 1991 and twisted arms to get other countries to comply with its wishes. American officials subsequently charged that Bonn was responsible for provoking the crisis in Yugoslavia, which had existed as a single country since 1919, except for the gruesome interlude when Hitler created a Croatian client state. Reunified Germany’s preemptive diplomatic maneuver led to a major escalation of the civil war in the Balkans, which took hundreds of thousands of lives and displaced more than a million people. Bonn exacerbated the conflict by supplying Croatia with large quantities of weapons. Between 1992 and 1994, Germany exported $320 million of military hardware — including MiG fighter jets, surface-to-air missiles, and late-model tanks — to Croatia, despite a United Nations arms embargo forbidding such commerce. Convoys of up to fifteen hundred military vehicles from former East Germany were discovered en route to the Balkan farrago. Germany also trained Croatian pilots and provided intelligence reports in an effort to vanquish their mutual enemy. Heleno Sano, an expert on German defense issues, commented on the psychological underpinnings of this policy: “In their ‘historic unconscious,’ the Germans have resented the Serbs since World War II, because despite the fact that Hitler sent in thirty divisions, he was unable to defeat the antifascist guerrillas led by Tito.” Under the auspices of NATO, German warplanes saw action for the first time since 1945, carrying out aerial patrols to prevent Serbian fighter jets from flying over Bosnian territory. And when the tide turned in Croatia’s favor in the summer of 1995, Bonn agreed to contribute up to four thousand military personnel to enforce a tenuous peace accord. German intervention was widely depicted in humanitarian terms, but General Klaus Naumann had something else in mind when he lobbied behind the scenes for a wider military role. While some German officials expressed a genuine reluctance to interfere in a place that had been devastated by Hitler, Naumann saw a chance for his men to test their mettle in a combat setting.
- 9y ago
- coroxout 9y agoImpressive how many of the buildings are still there and recognisable. Nice to see most of the 30+ year old apartment blocks still standing and well looked after. Must have been so weird to look out from a high-up apartment on one side of the wall all the way over no-man's-land towards the windows of another block on the other side.
- liotier 9y ago> Impressive how many of the buildings are still there and recognisable. Nice to see most of the 30+ year old apartment blocks still standing and well looked after. Have you seen many cities where buildings that are merely 30 years old do not exist anymore ?
- cannam 9y agoThe situation with older buildings in central Berlin is quite interesting though, because so many quite grand buildings on the eastern side went untouched for 50 years after the war. Then in the late 90s large areas of east-central Berlin were restored at some speed, from bullet-holed crumbling blackened stone to smart painted render in what I assume was something like the original style. I once wrote a rather personal ramble that touches on this, here https://thebreakfastpost.com/2014/09/23/alte-schonhauser-strase/ https://thebreakfastpost.com/2014/09/23/alte-schonhauser-str... with some pictures taken in 1993 of the area around Hackescher Markt. If you click through on one of the photos, there are a few more on the Flickr set that don't appear in the article.
- et-al 9y agoThanks for sharing those photos. It's crazy how long Tacheles was in ruins. I was just there in January and there's actually construction breaking ground. When's the last time you were back in Berlin? Have you seen how Neue Schönhauser Str. has developed?
- dehef 9y agoAnd now the world want exactly the same for Jerusalem. I find it's crazy.
- everyone 9y agoLooks like feckin' road engineers had their way with all the land freed up by the removal of the wall. Great!
- kbutler 9y agoI met some East Germans in the US in July 1989. I asked them if the wall would come down. They said the prime minister said, "Not in the next 100 years." 100 years vs. 5 months. Pretty close...