8 ms·
Fertility rates decrease as rents increase
- ohiovr 9y agoGoing rate for a baby delivery in the hospital was around ten thousand dollars last time I checked. I bet medicaid would absorb it but if you fall between dirt poor and middle class it sounds cripling.
- api 9y agoThat's a one time expense and is not that high for most people. Real estate is much worse.
- devereaux 9y agoI am surprised more families are not planning a trip abroad around the delivery date, to benefit from cheaper healthcare of a comparable quality + free extra citizenship for their kid. The market exists in other countries: https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-island-where-chinese-mothers-deliver-american-babies-1513852203 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-island-where-chinese-mother... I am surprised american parents don't hedge their bets by getting a EU citizenship for their kid. If anything, the kid may benefit from free healthcare if they get something bad as an adult!
- smnrchrds 9y agoFew countries have unrestricted jus soli (birthright citizenship). Among those, only US and Canada are desirable countries of citizenship. EU countries who have any sort of jus soli have severely restricted it. See some examples: Germany: Children born on or after 1 January 2000 to non-German parents acquire German citizenship at birth, if at least one parent has a permanent residence permit (and had this status for at least three years) and the parent was residing in Germany for at least eight years. France: Children born in France (including overseas territories) to at least one foreign parent who is also born in France automatically acquire French citizenship at birth. Portugal: A child born in Portuguese territory to who does not possess another nationality is a Portuguese citizen. Also, a person born to foreign parents who were not serving their respective States at the time of birth is a Portuguese citizen if the person declares that they want to be Portuguese and provided that one of the parents has legally resided in Portugal for at least five years at the time of birth. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli
- devereaux 9y agoSo Portugal would work.
- ebalit 9y agoYou miss the second part for France: "Children born to foreign parents may request citizenship depending on their age and length of residence." The rule is as complex as the French law can be... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_nationality_law#French_citizenship_by_birth_in_France_or_its_overseas_territories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_nationality_law#French_... But basically, children born to foreign parents become French at their majority if they lived most of their childhood in France.
- virmundi 9y agoWhich European countries do this? This is more a new world thing as far as I know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jus_soli
- r00fus 9y agoTraveling in the third trimester isn't comfortable or recommended. Premature mile high birth sounds like something people are wary of.
- zxcmx 9y agoMost airlines won't let you fly without a medical certificate if you look "quite" pregnant (>28 weeks you need documentation). If you are very close to term, they won't let you fly at all. Example policies: http://www.etihad.com/en-au/experience-etihad/special-assistance/expectant-mothers/ http://www.etihad.com/en-au/experience-etihad/special-assist... http://www.jetstar.com/au/en/help/articles/pregnancy-and-air-travel http://www.jetstar.com/au/en/help/articles/pregnancy-and-air...
- surfmike 9y agoIf you could afford a trip like that, you probably already have health insurance in the US.
- stevenwoo 9y agoIn the USA it's averaging 30,000/50,000 depending upon if it's natural delivery or Caesarian, if you trust the numbers from a childbirth advocacy group. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jan/16/why-does-it-cost-32093-just-to-give-birth-in-america https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jan/16/why-does-it-...
- nshelly 9y agoChild care is $20,000 to $30,000 per year in NYC and SF and many cities, the cost of the child's health care insurance is around $300-400 for a low deductible plan, and the extra rent, is around $1,200 for an additional bedroom, so the fixed costs are at least $40,000 per year, or one partner needs to drop out of the workforce which has its own costs. The birth itself is equivalent to the cost of only a few months of the child's life. You have to really want children to pull it off in American cities today. I think the only viable option here if we want children (and their parents) in cities -- which would require buy-in from the older generation -- is to raise property / land taxes and use this to afford better schools and pre-K (so you're only on the hook for the first few years of the child's life), and to build more housing of course. https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=United+States&country2=United+States&city1=New+York%2C+NY&city2=San+Francisco%2C+CA https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou...
- xupybd 9y agoI think there is more at play here. Some of the highest birth rates are still in the lowest economic groups. While high rents are a problem and a no doubt causing economic hardships preventing young families from having children I think this is an over simplification of a larger problem.
- hackits 9y agoIt is cheaper for us to down-size to a 2 bedroom unit and have one partner working full time than it is to pay for day care for the little one. Even with all the reduced childcare here in Australia the difference at the end of the week comes to $20. Granted I'm all-ways amazed that in the West on one hand the news proclaim and medical professionals to have children when the women are in there 20's. Although the support and service's such as cheap day-care and family centered activities are completely lacking to support that mind-set. The message most young people receive is `It is healthy to have children when you're younger`. The reality is `Yes you can, but I hope you like living in a studio apartment counting your monies well all your colleges/friends are having fun`. That and in today modern world having a child in your 20's is more or less considered social suicide. The only to maintain a life-style and support structure for young women would be to find a partner who can support them and their child well at the same time maintaining their quality of life. Something such partners are very small so there is a lot of competition for this type of partner.
- xupybd 9y agoYes that's a real challenge for double income families. That it's self is a big change that's not that old. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying women shouldn't work. I'm saying society is still adjusting to that change is all. For me I chose to get my education and start a career before even thinking about starting a family. Now I'm in my mid 30's I'm really starting to think I may not have played this very smart. I'd have been better off spending more time looking for a partner in my 20's. I'm a man, I hate to think what this looks like for a women who has a more limited fertility time span than I do.
- 9y ago
- dennisgorelik 9y agoPeople do not like have kids in a high population density environment. Humans have a trigger that suppresses fertility when there are too many people around.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago[citation needed]
- dennisgorelik 9y agoCities have much lower fertility rates than suburban and rural areal. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12288643 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12288643
- Domenic_S 9y agoThat’s a leap. Cities have lower both rates, so humans must have a trigger that turns down fertility?
- lukealization 9y agoThe OP nor the study made no indication that the two were related — merely that they correlate.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoOP very explicitly claimed there's a trigger: > Humans have a trigger that suppresses fertility when there are too many people around
- in_cahoots 9y agoThere are vast differences between rural and urban populations, especially in China. The fact that urban households have fewer children in no way implies that density leads to reduced fertility.
- 9y ago
- dogma1138 9y agoI think way too many people rather enjoy the DINK life style rather than have economic issues. If anything birth rates are higher in the lower end of the socioeconomic scale than in the middle and higher end currently.
- surfmike 9y agoPart of that is the upper middle class expectation of owning a house and investing heavily in your child's education. People wait until they are established to have kids, and higher housing prices push that date back.
- dogma1138 9y agoSpeaking for my self, my partner and all our late 20s to mid 30s friends it’s not the money. We rather rent an apartment across the street from Hyde Park have 2-3 big vacations each year and do a weekend in Europe every other weekend or so than have kids. And this is not even that much of a conscious decision kids were just never discussed other than the odd “vasectomy commercial” remark when an air raid siren in a trolley passes by. There is just something different about this generation and it’s not just the socioeconomic issues that some millennial mostly those who were born in the mid-late 90s onwards are having (80s “millennials” are in a pretty good spot IMO). Whether it’s selfishness or infantilism or something less I don’t know but this isn’t about money. Poor people never had problems having kids, heck they never had problems more kids than the average. Educated people also didn’t had a problem having kids my mother was pregnant during Uni with my older brother gave birth and was back after 2 weeks, when she had me she was teaching and basically had birth came back and we’re going home to breast feed me between classes, I don’t know of anyone who would do this today not saying they don’t exist but all my relationships never were with someone that would be willing to sacrifice or work as hard to have a kid as my mother did.
- richardknop 9y agoBut surely if you live across the street from Hyde park, go on 2-3 big splashy vacations per year and travel to Europe for getaways every couple weeks, you must be in top 1% of earners. And all your friends are likely rich too. So drawing conclusions from that is meaningless as vast majority of millennials are financially struggling to even think about that.
- internetman55 9y agoI think computer programmers won't understand this problem since i made enough to raise a middle class family at my first job out of college
- surfmike 9y agoThat's not the case in Silicon Valley anymore.
- focusgroup0 9y agoWhere did you live?
- internetman55 9y agoCentral NJ
- norikki 9y agowhen did you graduate?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoYour "middle" would likely be "lower" to most people around here.
- internetman55 9y agoThat could be the case
- crazygringo 9y ago> And a team of economists have now crunched the data proving that zoning and restrictive land-use regulations–forces that contribute to making housing so expensive in cities like San Francisco and New York–are actually driving fertility rates downward. Are they actually preventing couples from having children, or are couples simply moving away from those areas in order to have their children elsewhere? And on top of that, are the kind of people who move to NYC or SF already the kind of people planning not to have a kid over the next 5-10 years, or ever? Taking a quick look at the original paper, the authors don't appear to address these potential factors at all.
- philip1209 9y agoAlso, it doesn't "prove" anything . . . no statistician would ever make that kind of assertion. Correlation is not causation. The conclusion has an error margin.
- VHRanger 9y agoDepends on the statistical method used. Some quasi-experimental methods like instrument variables or difference-in-differences can plausibly tease causal effect sizes from messy economic data That said, this paper seems to be mostly simple descriptive statistics
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> And on top of that, are the kind of people who move to NYC or SF already the kind of people planning not to have a kid over the next 5-10 years, or ever? For what it is worth, NYC as a whole is quite child friendly. Take a stroll around Park Slope and you're tripping over gaggles of children. Now San Francisco? I'm amazed when I see someone under 18.
- nikanj 9y agoLet's say that huge gaggle of kids is is 850 children. New York has some 8 500 000 people living in it. That's an adult-to-kid ratio of one to ten thousand. It's really hard to estimate birth rates by observing people, as our brains just aren't equipped to handle the numbers present. We see the hundreds of children, and flat out refuse to believe there's a decline in births.
- epx 9y agoThe perspective of losing everything in a divorce when kids are involve would be a factor as well.
- hackits 9y agoThey have a nickname for that divorce rape. Though why is divorce so much? Because its worth it! Legally alimony, child support can see you living out of a back seat of a vehicle. Depending on your partner it can go easy or it can be a nightmare.
- Domenic_S 9y agoI think people aren’t having babies because there’s too much interesting stuff to do, and the world has never been as accessible as it is today. Technology has made nearly every corner of the globe accessible for prices that would seem magical a generation ago. As far as our ancestors are concerned, we may as well have invented teleportation. Then entertainment, wow, the entertainment that’s available at the push of a button. Every song, every tv show, every movie, right in your own apartment! Massively multiplayer games, message boards, Wikipedia; the sum of human knowledge in your pocket. And you can create stuff, and share it with millions of people without even leaving your chair. Code, music, art, whatever — make it this morning, 100k views by lunch. There is SO MUCH to do, to make, to share, to learn — our world has gotten so so big just in the last generation that I think I’d be surprised if the birth rate didnt go down. There are just too many other things vying for our finite attention.
- Noumenon72 9y agoI absolutely agree with you and still think it is totally irrational to have kids and cut into your fun -- however, you may be interested in [this comment thread](slatestarcodex.com/2018/01/16/bundles-of-joy/) where many of these crazy kid-having people explain their point of view. It's worth noting that whatever unsatisfactory explanations they manage to convince themselves of, have greater genetic fitness than the ones that convince us. It's very frustrating that even though wrong, they are guaranteed to prevail through natural selection.
- piaste 9y ago> It's very frustrating that even though wrong, they are guaranteed to prevail through natural selection. I think you're contradicting yourself here. If you believe it matters whose lineage wins at natural selection, then those parents are in fact right and you are wrong. If you believe that it doesn't matter, or that it matters less than having your childless fun, then you shouldn't find it frustrating that their genes will win an unimportant game.
- paultopia 9y agoSkimming over the paper that the article references, it doesn't look like the authors have a real way of disaggregating two possible causal pathways from housing costs to delaying/avoiding children: 1. housing costs --> economizing on housing --> not having room for children 2. housing (and other) costs --> higher earning --> longer working hours for both (prospective) parents --> not having time for children. It would be interesting to know whether people are not producing kids because they can't afford more space or because they can't afford to sacrifice income for childrearing.
- mattnewton 9y agoOr, as other people have mentioned in the thread, Housing costs -> moving elsewhere to have kids With the people moving to the city being ones that don’t plan on children anyways
- eadmund 9y agoI think that there's a massive correlation/causation problem here. Yes, it certainly appears that restrictive zoning laws are inversely correlated with fertility — but is it possible that the sorts of people who are likely to have fewer children are drawn towards the sorts of cities which restrict construction?
- lkrubner 9y agoHere on Hacker News there was some discussion of the article from the Economist, six weeks ago, titled "The link between polygamy and war". This was in response to that essay: "This suggests that political stability depends on young men being able to pursue their romantic dreams. This would apply in any country, not just African countries. In nations in the West, an important limiting factor is the ability to get one’s own apartment. That is, the ratio of average male wage to average rent. In the USA, the happiest year for this ratio was 1958, when people were spending 22% of their income on rent, on average. Not by coincidence, this was the peak year of the Baby Boom. In some sense, it was the best year in history to be a young white male in the USA. It was the year when it was easiest for an 18 year old male to get out of high school, get their own apartment, marry their high school sweetheart, and start a family. And of course, young people did this in huge numbers, which is why 1958 remains the peak year for teenage pregnancy in the USA." http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/do-men-become-warlike-if-they-do-not-have-women http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/do-men-become-warlike...
- Powerofmene 9y agoThere are so many factors that come into play when deciding to have a child w cost of living being just one of the many. In areas where people are delaying having a family only after establishing their career, people consider: reduction to one income or cost of daycare; what needs of children will do to career and the hours required for career; commute time if having to move out a bit for more affordable housing; concerns with schools (quality of education and violence in the school systems); higher incidents of disabilities based on the age of mother; and rising costs of everything. Autism is steadily increasing and this shows no signs of changing. Discrimination is rampant against pregnant women or mothers in the workplace, and general societal ills all make people question if they want to have children. It would be very difficult to pinpoint with any accuracy why people are delaying or forgoing parenthood. Some reasons may be very personal or may be viewed as insensitive and may keep someone from stating the real reason why they choose not to have children. They may also may not be able to have children and give a reason because they do not want to share what they may see as something very private. Maybe this article would be better titled “Is high rent contributing to the decline ..... in high density areas?”
- matheweis 9y agoThis paper is a vast oversimplification of a confluence of many issues, of which rent is only one - and I’d seriously question the causative effect suggested here as well. Aside, the US fertility rate has taken a steep dive since the Great Recession - during, and for a while after which, the rents were (at least in absolute terms) quite a bit lower. I have four kids myself, so I’d like to think I understand at least some of the issues fairly well.
- kaffee 9y agoIs there no indignity that the boomers will not inflict on their progeny?
- norikki 9y ago> Doesn't mention immigration > Doesn't mention outsourcing/trade deficit > Doesn't mention how section 8 housing vouchers and violent crime stop gentrification > Doesn't mention foreign real estate investment This article is worthless. It links to an article called "Capitalism Is The Real Problem" with this gem of a quote in it: > People want the fruits of production and the yields of our generous planet to benefit everyone, rather than being siphoned up by the super-rich, so we can change tax laws and introduce potentially transformative measures like a universal basic income. To translate out of Communist-speak, the author wants to raise taxes on the middle and professional class, (the people living in NYC & SF) to give it to all the unproductive, low-skill immigrants the super-rich corporate CEOs brought in for cheap labor over the past 30 years. Great. Here's a better idea. If you need government assistance to survive, you forfeit your right to reproduce. Snip snip. No kids. In 2 generations the problem is solved, and then people who are productive can afford to have productive kids. America isn't a giant factory for making more people who need welfare. We need to stop running it that way. > Cities, Shoag says, could do more to support fertility rates, population growth, and opportunities for lower-income people to move there and thrive by building more and affordable housing. No. I do not want my tax dollars paying the rent for a foreign-born cleaning lady who is employed by someone richer than me, so that rich person can pay her less than what she actually needs to afford her rent.
- PeterStuer 9y agoI have to call BS on this. even the article itself contain 'While it is impossible to definitively trace a causal link between land use restriction and fertility, the results here suggest that the two are strongly related in the data.' A correlation is shown, but no causation. If I needed to speculate, even without resorting to hidden variable impacts, I'd say the market for 'exclusive' housing in less child friendly environments would tend to be dominated by singles and couples with large disposable incomes, potentially resulting from being more career than family focused. 'We can't financially afford having another baby, so we wont' does not seem to hold at all as a rule for primary driver in both present and historic worldwide reproduction data. If anything, it's the reverse.
- gt_ 9y agoThe HN post title ’Fertility rates decrease as rents increase’ to the article’s ’People Aren’t Having Babies Because The Rent’s Too Damn High’ reflects this well. Thanks HN.