5 ms·
One consequence of defeating aging I haven't heard discussed is the tendency of society to become very conservative. Even if someone's mind regains the flexibi
by joe_the_user 9y ago
One consequence of defeating aging I haven't heard discussed is the tendency of society to become very conservative.
Even if someone's mind regains the flexibility of a 20 year old, it's hard to see how the lessons of a lifetime wouldn't lead to some fairly fixed beliefs. If you can a population with only a trickle of actually young people, it seems like the rate of change could become very slow.
- darod 9y agoagreed. "A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it." -Max Planck
- joe_the_user 9y agoOne approach that universities could use would be force a given professor to retire and leave their field after, say, 50 years, sending them to perhaps join a different field where they could have fresh insights.
- darod 9y agoThis concept isn't applicable just to science. It's applicable to policy, politics, social opinion, etc. Young blood and new ideas are a constant threat to the status quo.
- theothermkn 9y agoThis is a very common trope, but it fails to address what might be the cause, rather than the mere correlation, of age-driven conservatism: imminent mortality. If you're 50 years in to an 80 year lifespan, it's more difficult to imagine starting over, with reduced vigor, to revamp your thinking and lifestyle. If there is essentially no increased risk of next-year mortality with age, and if we all have the stamina and energy of 20-year-olds, then there truly are no old dogs. Also, I'd really like to hear this "tendency of society to become very conservative" fleshed out. I think you meant "as average age goes up," but I'm not sure why "society" gets brought into it. Aren't we pointing to a tendency of individuals to become more conservative as they age?
- forkerenok 9y agoThat's a very interesting perspective! Any particular reads inspired it? Though I think "imminent mortality" is not the only thing at the foundation of age-driven conservatism. I think there is also tendency to follow paths of least resistance (energy conservatism): learning/discovering new ways of doing things comes with more friction (if one does not enjoy the learning/wandering process). EDIT: I just realized that the two points are really intertwined. Time conservatism is closely related to energy conservatism and cannot be regarded in isolation. (forgive the awkward terms)
- theothermkn 9y agoIf anything, I formulated it–I'm sure it's not original–as a reaction against Kuhn's Structure of Scientific Revolutions and its nearly universal adoption by the worst kind of smug, vocal startuppity Silicon Valley types, who apply it to every objection to their newest pet projects. It just seems obvious to me how the fear and resentment of an imminent decline and demise transfers into one of the few places in an older person's life where they still have power, the dinner table and the voting booth. Aging is degrading and humiliating, and you're supposed to wear it with grace and dignity. And then the "news" guy on the conservative channel tells you about all the mistakes that kids and immigrants are making... Presto! Instant "conservative" harking back to an invented Golden Age. > ...if one does not enjoy the learning/wandering process... Or, if one does not perceive that the investment has time to pay off.
- marchenko 9y agoThe Book Algorithms to Live By describes some research which found that it is not chronological age, but rather one's position on the explore/exploit curve that drives the apparent conservatism of old age. So a 70 year old who expects to live 50 more years might be considerably more novelty-seeking than a 70 year old who expects to live 20 more years, because the first has a longer interval within which to exploit the benefits of any useful finds.
- 9y ago
- Retric 9y agoThis may be a better thing than you might assume. Study history and you find regulations tend to be repealed as soon as their cause is forgotten. US fiscal policy for example was far more rational when people who remembered the great depression where still in control. I expect air quality standards to start to slip in about 20 years etc etc in an endless cycle.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- richardjdare 9y agoI always thought anti-aging tech should come with a mandatory course of ayahuasca to shake the belief system up a little.
- narrator 9y agoLearning new ideas becomes harder as we age due to atrophy in the mechanisms of long term potentiation. If learning were easier in old age there would be a lot less conservatism and nostalgia among the elderly.
- toyg 9y agoWould it? As I get older, I can tell you that my feelings and thoughts are not really influenced by that; I learn as I’ve always done, by trying out stuff; and if it takes a bit longer, who cares. Imho, a much more powerful force is the loss of innocence. You know X is bad for you because you experienced it before; so you don’t do X. And Y. And K. And slowly, you don’t do very much at all, except very safe boring stuff. You would really like to go back being a fearless child, but you can’t: even if your body could heal like it did before, your mind won’t forget all the stuff you went through.
- jjeaff 9y agoDo we have any evidence that a more conservative society would be a negative thing?
- yks 9y agohistory? arguably, since Enlightenment we've been gradually giving up on conservatism and an average person benefits from that.
- BurningFrog 9y agoThat's theoretical speculation. Empirically, as the average age of the population has increased the last 1-2 centuries, the rate of change in society has kept increasing.
- draugadrotten 9y ago> ... it's hard to see how the lessons of a lifetime wouldn't lead to some fairly fixed beliefs. As someone who has spent some time talking to several 80+ olds, my impression is quite the opposite. People are much more open-minded at 80+ than they are 30-60. With age comes wisdom and the ability to see what really matters.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI see that in my parents. They used to be very narrow minded but now in their end-80s they have a much broader perspective and openly regret things they did when they were younger.
- ginko 9y agoAnother consequence would be that dictators like Mugabe could rule indefinitely
- decorator 9y agoBecause being a dictator is such a safe job?
- gaius 9y agoit seems like the rate of change could become very slow No, the opposite would occur, because of the compounding value of experience. Imagine what engineers would be like with 10x the experience to bring to bear on any problem. Imagine the megascale engineering we could do. But you don’t have to because we have actual evidence: life expectancy 1000 years ago vs now. Which society changed faster?
- nezzle 9y agoI, too, used to think conservative values were an old people thing, but it turns out that's not always the case. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/04/07/white-millennials-are-just-about-as-racist-as-their-parents/?utm_term=.0d01a469febb https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/04/07/white... I think you maybe be on a bit of a red herring here. Yes, values vary by age group but I'm unconvinced that cohorts change predictably over their lifetimes especially if we consider a more international view. However, values aside I think there is an impact from neuroplasticity in terms of how younger people adapt more readily to new technology, etc.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoI see where you're coming from, but on the other hand its almost a contradiction to say that a mind regains its flexibility yet remains stuck on fixed beliefs. If rigid beliefs are the product of a rigid mind, then a youthful mind would not suffer from the same problem.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoOne consequence of defeating aging I haven't heard discussed is the tendency of society to become very conservative. Your most conservative groups are families with dependent children. Old people vote more consistently not because they are conservative, but because they have the time. They aren't working full time while raising kids, etc. I see no reason to assume old people would be inherently conservative. Older people who are not risk averse may not look real wild because they know how to hedge their bets and how to explore what they want without calling so much attention to it. That isn't conservative. It's competent.