8 ms·
Demographic Consequences of Defeating Aging
- thriftwy 9y agoThat's not defeating of aging until you found a way to prolong youth and not just the old age as this research seem to assume.
- thriftwy 9y ago...Aaaaand if you prolong youth, people will eventually have more kids. One at 30, one at 45 and one at 60. And then maybe one at 75.
- ghostcluster 9y agosoace colonies (as long as we're just making up future scientific advances)
- thriftwy 9y agoThat was the idea. But why would want to move there? In 60-s, people imagined how population would line up for space colonies to build a farm there. And a big house. Now, people want not just live on Earth. They would prefer to live in, let's say, the EU. And not even all of the EU; how about a Paris arrondisement? That's the place we find desirable. A few people would like to be the first to space colonies. I fail to see how a few billion people would like to move there, to become some sort of worker drones. Plus, this tend to not end well. Compare how well do people in Spain live, and compare it to how people who went abroad to South America live.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Compare how well do people in Spain live, and compare it to how people who went abroad to South America live. The fate of South America is not due to the failures of the local population... more "thanks" to decades of racist and/or anti-"communist" US foreign policy.
- cgmg 9y agoSouth American (Venezuelan) here. This is not true. Blaming US foreign policy for all or even most of South America's failures is silly and a common tactic of demagogues, with no basis in reality, to deflect from bad domestic policy. Admittedly, I did not fully understand the point the GP was trying to make with the Spain comparison.
- thriftwy 9y agoWe may argue why South America has lower life quality than Spain, but the fact that it has. This will be the case with space colonies too, I'm afraid. While it will be debatable why colonies perform worse than Earth, it will be apparent that the best course was to stay.
- ghostcluster 9y agoSo you're going to ignore the United States, Hong Kong, Australia, etc?
- thriftwy 9y agoThey're very special cases, and still, I'm not sure that Australia (and even US) fares much better than e.g. source England and Norway.
- nathanasmith 9y ago> I'm not sure that Australia (and even US) fares much better than e.g. source England and Norway. I don't know many fellow Americans that are of Norwegian descent but the US fairs better than the UK on lists of human development, happiness, and productivity. That has to mean something.
- theothermkn 9y agoApparently, every opportunity that women are given to delay pregnancy and childbirth is taken. Education advances, health advances, birth control, and wealth have each caused a delay and decrease in reproduction. It's a bit of a cliche fear that is popular because of its simplicity, not its correctness, IMO.
- kimdcmason 9y agoI’m not convinced. It does that for a high percentage of the population. However, after a period, the smaller percentage of the population that don’t reduce their birth rate will become increasingly dominant. Current examples are the rapid growth of Orthodox Jews as a percentage of Israel’s population, and evangelical birth rates in the US. My bet is that given technology to allow massive extension of fertility into older age, the fertility differences between religious groups that believe in a religious duty to procreate, and everyone else, will increase even more.
- carapace 9y agoYeah, it's weird to me that people in general don't see this. I like to joke that the Amish are obviously the one true religion because eventually they'll cover the earth: They live long and peaceful lives, have scores of children, and are among the best farmers on Earth. As long as the rest of us don't do something horrible the end state is inevitable.
- watwut 9y agoThat has a lot to do with consequences of having child. If you are young for long, giving some years to one more child might be less of sacrifice. If you know that having one more child is game over for everything else, you wont get a chance to restart the rest of your life.
- theothermkn 9y ago> That's not defeating of aging until you found a way to prolong youth and not just the old age as this research seem to assume. The article considers four separate cases: 1) negligible senescence, 2) slowed aging, 3) continuous rejuvenation, and 4) one-time rejuvenation. It seems that at least 1 and 3 are what you want. Have I misunderstood your comment? EDIT: thriftwy is correct, here. The authors leave the crucial detail of when, in their model, life extension begins, until deep in the article. It's around age 60, in their model. This is in no way what is conventionally meant by these terms as I have ever seen them used when reading about "negligible senescence," "anti-aging," "SENS," & etc.
- thriftwy 9y agoNegligible senescence after 60 (or 40) years is not actually youth. It's past reproduction age for most people.
- theothermkn 9y ago"Negligible senescence" means that you don't get appreciable deterioration with age. You're 240, but you feel 29. EDIT: Ah. They explain that later in the article. That's an unfortunate use of the term, given its history of use in the field.
- darod 9y ago"Moreover, if some members of society reject to use new anti-aging technologies for some religious or any other reasons (inconvenience, non-compliance, fear of side effects, costs, etc.), then the total population size may even decrease over time." I don't understand how this would decrease the population. Also why would they even bring this point up in the abstract. I thought this study was supposed to analyze the worst case scenario. Additionally an increase of 22% is not a trivial number when the population of the world is 7 billion.
- joe_the_user 9y agoOne consequence of defeating aging I haven't heard discussed is the tendency of society to become very conservative. Even if someone's mind regains the flexibility of a 20 year old, it's hard to see how the lessons of a lifetime wouldn't lead to some fairly fixed beliefs. If you can a population with only a trickle of actually young people, it seems like the rate of change could become very slow.
- darod 9y agoagreed. "A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it." -Max Planck
- joe_the_user 9y agoOne approach that universities could use would be force a given professor to retire and leave their field after, say, 50 years, sending them to perhaps join a different field where they could have fresh insights.
- darod 9y agoThis concept isn't applicable just to science. It's applicable to policy, politics, social opinion, etc. Young blood and new ideas are a constant threat to the status quo.
- theothermkn 9y agoThis is a very common trope, but it fails to address what might be the cause, rather than the mere correlation, of age-driven conservatism: imminent mortality. If you're 50 years in to an 80 year lifespan, it's more difficult to imagine starting over, with reduced vigor, to revamp your thinking and lifestyle. If there is essentially no increased risk of next-year mortality with age, and if we all have the stamina and energy of 20-year-olds, then there truly are no old dogs. Also, I'd really like to hear this "tendency of society to become very conservative" fleshed out. I think you meant "as average age goes up," but I'm not sure why "society" gets brought into it. Aren't we pointing to a tendency of individuals to become more conservative as they age?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- staunch 9y agoIt doesn't make sense to worry about what happens if humanity become immortal and nothing else changes. Technology is going to change everything about the world, and immortality may be the least of it. There's every reason to think humanity will develop super intelligent life, or augment itself into super intelligent life, within 100 years. Which means that there will never be billions of ape-like humans living to be hundreds or thousands of years old. When super intelligent life emerges, it will probably be immortal, but none of the concerns we have about immortal humans will apply. There's only one part of our future we can be sure of, and that's giving birth to Superhumanity. It almost doesn't matter what we do before this, and we will have no control over what happens afterwards.
- grondilu 9y agoAgreed. People already live quite long, so immortality would take a very long time to make a difference with how things already are. If the first person to live 150 years is twenty years old today, he will reach that age in 130 years, that is in 2148. I believe that in 2148, the world will be vastly different than it currently is, and to a degree we can't even imagine. So to me the desire to be still alive then sounds naive, even futile. I understand that from a subjective point of view, and especially to people who fear death, immortality is of prime importance, but in the grand scheme of things, it's just a detail : paradoxically it does not matter in the long term because its effects take too long a time to manifest.
- KasianFranks 9y agoDefeating aging or extending human life to some extent say 150 years, gives us time to extend life to 300 and so on. It solves for true deep space travel and colonization of habitable planets.
- grondilu 9y agoDo you really think a reasonable solution for deep space travel is to spend centuries in a spaceship? Don't you think some kind of suspended animation would be preferable?
- KasianFranks 9y agoYes, suspended animation would be great if we did not age during the process.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoIf we had viable suspended animation technology today, that'd be far more valuable than interstellar travel.
- carapace 9y agoTraveling close to lightspeed to take advantage of time dilation would be preferable, eh?
- grondilu 9y ago> with the most radical life extension scenario (assuming no aging at all after age 60) That does not sound like the most radical life extension one can imagine. IMHO the most radical one is : no more aging after the age of say 30. In that case, one crucial question is : would women remain fertile? If so, what would be their reproductive behavior?
- nezzle 9y agoFurther delay in advanced countries. The biological clock puts an upper limit on how long women can delay childbirth now. Groups that breed without control will continue to do so.
- antisthenes 9y agoHonestly if we're in sci-fi territory, then I feel like we can create an artificial uterus/womb as well.
- prepend 9y agoIt seems like the smartest way to prep for these demographic shifts is to buy renewable natural resources- timber, real estate, etc. Just get lots of money that keeps getting bigger and outrace demographics. This has worked for family wealth for thousands of years.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoThe biggest consequence of defeating aging is how people will work and will other people have jobs . We already see this happening now. If you have a set of very experienced people that can perform their tasks why do you need to replace or fire them? Consider the job market with professors in math. Due to tenure you have a bunch of math professors that do extraordinary work. People who would have replaced them instead get non tenure track positions or go into other fields . This is not to blame math professors that have jobs right now. Or the situation that grad students have in becoming professors. It also has a weird effect where the social dogma stays for longer than would be if medical science wasn’t so good. I don’t know what the long term changes that will do. To be honest if there wasn’t so much emphasis on people learning calculus math would have become like getting a Philosophy degree.
- esturk 9y agoInteresting to see this article today with the release of the show Altered Carbon this weekend. I haven't gone far in the show but the implications there is that society will bifurcate into the affluent class called the Meths that can afford to resleeve into new bodies whenever and wherever they want vs the grounded class that can't afford to. People are too hung up on the Utopia vision that comes with curing aging but the probable outcome is that the Rich won't die and will get to accumulate more and more wealth until they don't have to answer to anyone. And then society as a whole becomes stagnant because it has reached an optimal point because the Rich wants to keep it that way. That's unlike today where the Rich do sway politics and hold considerable power, but they will eventually die off and then change may come of it. I recommend folks who like these kinds of sci-fi shows to check Altered Carbon out.