4 ms·
The disconnect is that a lot of people do not find the Singularity an appealing concept. Of his list Yudkowsky seems the only sane one to me. "Primarily conc
by jimbokun 16y ago
The disconnect is that a lot of people do not find the Singularity an appealing concept. Of his list Yudkowsky seems the only sane one to me.
"Primarily concerned with the Singularity as a potential human-extinction event, Yudkowsky has dedicated his work to advocacy and developing strategies towards creating survivable Singularities."
My pure speculation is that many people feel a very understandable sense of unease, but it gets expressed as doubting the possibility of the singularity future. As opposed to accepting it as possible but advocating that we try to avoid it, or at the very least approach it with extreme caution.
Kurzweil, on the other hand, comes across to me as very Pollyana-ish. He seems to spend very little time considering what could go wrong with a Singularity, and much more time eagerly anticipating our impending god-like future.
- Jkeg 16y agoThe majority of people, who when told of the singularity, automatically dismiss it offhand only because it has that Hollywood "scifi ridiculous" sound to it, seem a lot less sane to me than anyone on that list.
- astine 16y agoThat seems like a poor measure of 'sanity' to me. Dismissing the possibility of something because it sounds ridiculous doesn't make you crazy, just intellectually lazy at worst. Actively campaigning for a future where humans lose their humanity without the least thought as to the potential dangers? Imprudent at best, crazy at worst.
- Jkeg 16y agoIt's definitely intellectually lazy. But dismissing something because it was also made into a bunch of films? Utterly failing to think for yourself and just reacting via knee-jerk because it's past an arbitrary mental line of what's 'acceptable' to consider? Certainly falls under 'crazy' (i.e. high irrationality), just not what most people think of when they hear 'crazy'. And I certainly wouldn't characterize singularitarians as advocating a human-less future without considering potential dangers. Anyone associated with the Singularity Institute for one will at least claim to consider potential dangers.
- Avshalom 16y agoMost people have spent their lifetime watching people completely fail at predicting even the immediate future. Dismissing predictions of the singularity as scifi bullshit isn't a lack of sanity, it's basic extrapolation.
- Jkeg 16y agoSo these people think they are better predictors of the future than all the people who failed, even though they probably never made a serious prediction themselves? They believe something is never going to happen just because it hasn't happened yet? Sounds highly irrational to me.
- Avshalom 16y agoThere is a MASSIVE difference between "you're wrong" and "I'm right". Calling the singularity bullshit in a casual conversation is an example of the prior.
- blasdel 16y agoI agree with your sentiments, except that I'd invert your sanity bitmap. I'd place John von Neumann as having been extraordinarily sane, and one of the most productive minds in history. I'd put Eliezer as far crazier and more potentially destructive than Kurzweil — there's not much distance between "creating survivable Singularities" and Butlerian Jihad. At least Kurzweil did productive things before he decided to live forever and tell us all about his magnificent future. Yudkowsky's brother died, and then he decided that nobody should have to die again.