3 ms·
I really wish that the author would have, when complaining about "Drexler's Book", been clear about which one he was talking about. Also, "Mechanical objects o
by Symmetry 16y ago
I really wish that the author would have, when complaining about "Drexler's Book", been clear about which one he was talking about.
Also, "Mechanical objects on microscales do not exist" is gratuitously false, we even have really simple mechanical objects (like cantilevers) on the 100nm scale now.
- zeteo 16y ago"we even have really simple mechanical objects (like cantilevers) on the 100nm scale now." Interesting. Do you have a link or paper name for that?
- krschultz 16y agoMost of this stuff comes out of Sandia, I just googles for some quick MEMS pictures and found this link. http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~database/MEMS/sma_mems/mems.html http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~database/MEMS/sma_mems/mems.h...
- jimbokun 16y agoThese are labeled micro-machines, and seem to be the same things that the author calls "millitech" (both cite tiny accelerometers as an example). So it seems there are some terminology differences to sort out.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's actually huge problem around the whole 'nanotech' sphere. Everybody seems to have a different definition for everything, usually the definitions tend to absurdity depending on whether the person is a skeptic or a 'true believer'. It's very boring because in the end the terminology should be secondary to the goals and how we go about achieving them.
- shabble 16y agoJust skimming through those pictures, but most of the fairly complex mechanical parts, at least the ones which have scales, seem to be of the order of 10-100um. Not sure what would actually constitute nanotech there, but certainly the minimum feature size (spacing of teeth on a gear, etc) is probably <1um, which would count in my book.
- pedrocr 16y ago"This is an honest summary of Drexler’s Ph.D. thesis/book"
- spot 16y agowhy summarize and criticize a book published in 1986?
- jacquesm 16y agoNot that I necessarily agree with this particular summary in everything, but the point of summarizing something it to make it easier to digest the core of the argument before criticizing it. For that to work you have to have a really good understanding of the subject matter though, and I think he does Drexler great disservice when he says "He seems to lack the imagination, and of course, the physics to figure out what a real nanosized doodad might look like.". That to me is the hallmark of someone with an ax to grind rather than an objective reviewing of a book written quite a while ago. Of course Drexler didn't have the physics to figure out what a real nanobot might look like, nobody did, and nobody does. Drexler could not have easily foreseen some of the obstacles a direct translation of mechanical concepts would encounter, but there are more ways to skin a cat, and biology seems to have found at least one of them. Now it's up to us to find either another path or to harness biology to produce those structures that we can not produce by direct means and to build up a library of tested components to do our 'nano engineering' with. I see Drexler more as a visionary than as a 'hard applicable science' guy and that's the way to approach his book. If you're looking for a 'ready to build' nano bot or a hard treatise on nano engineering you're not going to find it, if we had had that at that time then we wouldn't be where we are today. Incidentally, I think that the 'proponents' of nano tech have done a very bad job at raising expectations (Drexler among them), I do believe that long term nano technology will become a reality and will become a mainstay of our technological arsenal. Just like electronics, which were practically non-existent one hundred years ago are today.
- spot 16y agoi understand what summary is for. what i don't "understand" is why he chose as the target a book that's 24 years old in a fast moving field. actually i do understand: it was a strawman! i agree with your assessment.