20 ms·
How a Medical Catastrophe Can Bankrupt a Life
- juandazapata 9y ago*(in America)
- soperj 9y ago*in the USA.
- puppetmaster40 9y agoUnless you have insurance, provided by most employers.
- alexibm 9y ago*Only in the USA
- blocked_again 9y agoLiving the American dream
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoGo to Canada for that.
- tw1010 9y agoPlease don't make HN into Reddit.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here. It makes crappy subthreads, as below. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- matthoiland 9y agoWelcome to the USA. Uninsured appendectomy in California – now I owe $45k. #freedom
- clumsysmurf 9y agoThats it? ;) Antivenin for rattlesnake bite costs over $153,000. Watch your step and don't tread on it. http://www.wideopencountry.com/actual-cost-rattlesnake-bite-u-s/ http://www.wideopencountry.com/actual-cost-rattlesnake-bite-...
- tptacek 9y agoTo a first approximation nobody gets bit by rattlesnakes, while one in twenty Americans will eventually need an appendectomy.
- sdfasdasf 9y agoLots of people get bit! 7000 to 8000 a year [1], more than handgun deaths. Death from the bites is rare thanks to, among other things, antivenom! [1] https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/snakes/ https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/snakes/
- tptacek 9y agoThat's 2-3 orders of magnitude fewer than appendectomies, and an order of magnitude fewer than handgun injuries. 7000 rattlesnake bites is 0.002% of the population.
- sdfasdasf 9y agoSure and appendectomies are very expensive. But why do you dismiss the OPs concern for the outrageous cost of anti-venom? Perhaps because the cost of something as rare, expensive to produce and perishable as anti-venom is sort of justified, whereas a relatively routine operation like and appendectomy is not? Ok, that's fine. But it still stands that snake bites cost 150K and that's a lot of money!
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI saw this critique a while back on reddit: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BiCvPKWCUAA7Rtl.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BiCvPKWCUAA7Rtl.jpg:large The long story short, Breaking Bad, wouldn't be a TV show. That's because of socialized medicine didn't try to profit on the sick. So he wouldn't have started making methamphetamine. ------------------ Edit: Sigh, at -4. I thought this added a valid discussion, that the idea of lack of any sort of medical program across the US is a definite detriment to all. Not only that, but saying he had insurance through the employer only reaffirms: 1. You're trapped at your employer if you're sick 2. You're bound by the quality of care the employer offers via agreements you can't have access to (chosen insurer) 3. Lack of choice by mandated "care plans" and coverage agreements that exclude you from treatment due to insurance not covering it I really don't get HN some days.. :/
- howToLearnSpark 9y agolol
- dang 9y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? Please see this explanation, which I just posted in a similar situation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16300163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16300163.
- zingermc 9y agoBreaking Bad would still be a show! Walter White was a chemistry teacher, which implies he had health insurance that would cover chemotherapy. He also has a son with cerebral palsy, who almost certainly has needed medical treatment before. The thing is, he only wanted to go to the "best" doctors, which his insurance didn't cover. He also refused to let his friends pay his bills. You could still make this kind of choice with socialized medicine -- "I don't want the in-network doctors, I only want the best!"
- SilasX 9y agoRight. For example, the UK has free education, but there's a British show [1] whose plot involves a man who does shady, illegal things so he can pay for a prestigious boarding school for his son. [1] forget the name -- the one with the grandma constable
- jsnk 9y agoI have some questions about American health care system. If patients are being charged this much for anything, the money must be going to someone? Who's making all the money? Drug companies? Hospitals? Health insurance? Doctors or nurses? Why don't people honestly follow where the money end up and actually solve the problem once and for all. Increase the supply of X or many other bottlenecks by deregulation and result in decreased price?
- md2be 9y agoIt’s a very labor intensive, capital intensive business. It’s why you can get open heart surgery at 3AM 365 days a year.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 9y agoWho's making all the money? Drug companies? Hospitals? Health insurance? Doctors or nurses? Yes.
- cratermoon 9y agoNot the nurses. Definitely not the nurses.
- maxerickson 9y agohttps://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes292061.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes292061.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes291141.htm https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes291141.htm The majority of nurses are RNs and make well above median wages. LPNs still make better than average money. They aren't getting incredibly wealthy, sure, but they aren't working for peanuts either.
- cratermoon 9y agoWhy is a nurse's services worth less than a computer programmer's?
- joe5150 9y agoI recommend reading the linked article by Molly Osberg as well https://splinternews.com/how-to-not-die-in-america-1822555151 https://splinternews.com/how-to-not-die-in-america-182255515...
- Firebrand 9y agoMedical care is a commodity, and aren’t we all often faced with commodities we cannot afford? People who cannot afford medical care have no right to demand it from anyone. Maybe someone will be empathetic enough to offer charity; friends and family may choose to band together and fund a sick person’s medical care. But even a poor person’s necessity does not change the fact that healthcare is a service and a good provided by a third party. No matter how much some starving kid needs food, he doesn’t have a right to steal someone’s wallet or hold up the local convenience store to obtain it. If I were in that position, maybe I’d end up choosing to steal since it’s the least immoral choice under the circumstances, but that does not make it a moral choice, or suggest that I have not violated someone‘s rights in pursuing my own needs.
- warent 9y agoSetting aside the fact that you're conflating voluntary theft with involuntary medical catastrophe, we're only as good as our weakest link. To your point, when people in society suffer, society as a whole suffers.
- wlesieutre 9y agoYou can make that argument about other services the government provides. It's like saying "Security is a commodity. People who can't afford security guards and private investigators have no right to demand protection from criminals or investigations into their house being burglarized. A poor person's necessity does not change the fact that policing is a service and a good provided by a third party." We are aware that the current healthcare system treats it as a commodity for those who can afford it. The argument being made is that this is a problem and that we would do better to treat it a public service provided for those who need it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fao_ 9y ago> Medical care is a commodity No, it's a right. > No matter how much some starving kid needs food, he doesn’t have a right to steal someone’s wallet or hold up the local convenience store to obtain it. Everyone has the right to life. I cannot imagine how callous one must be to willingly deprive fellow human beings of that right, purely because it is not how the economic system works. If we have the resources to provide healthcare to everyone, then we should. No matter what the cost. Repeat after me: Property is worth less than people. ""This means that nobody - including the government - can try to end your life. It also means the government should take appropriate measures to safeguard life by making laws to protect you and, in some circumstances, by taking steps to protect you if your life is at risk. Public authorities should also consider your right to life when making decisions that might put you in danger or that affect your life expectancy."" In the UK, Sweden, Norway, and many other civilized countries, everyone pays into a public pot that is used to provide medical care. Because of this, our workers are much more healthy, and much more able to work without the stress of "what if I get injured during work". They do not have to die of preventable diseases like septicemia, from something silly like duct taping their glass cut because they cannot afford to be treated.
- rwx------ 9y agoAt least in US you get the medical treatment first and then they hand you a large bill to pay. In poor countries the hospitals will turn you away until you pay a significant sum in advance (not exaggerating it has happened to me).
- chimeracoder 9y ago> At least in US you get the medical treatment first and then they hand you a large bill to pay. A large bill which, if you're uninsured, you can almost always negotiate down to 10% or less of the original. Of course, most people don't know this, but those large bills aren't what the hospitals expect uninsured patients to pay. They just legally have to present them the same initial bill that they present private insurers.
- chromanoid 9y agoThis is a good way to sort out the ones who can't negotiate. They have no place in a capitalist society anyway. /s
- nothrabannosir 9y agoI think you make a good point, downvotes notwithstanding. A "market society" inherently rewards people who are good at "the game." Which is fine for most things: worst case scenario you pay too much for a shit car. But having to play that damn game when you life is on the line is inhumane. There's no time out zone.
- chromanoid 9y agoYeah, it's wonderful how you can make it in such a system. Just imagine - a self-employed blue-collar worker slips with his car on a wet road. He loses his wife, his unborn child and his leg. He sells his house to pay the bills of the hospital and the mortician. His parents also pay some bills because he still had not enough. And then after a year or so on the street somebody tells him how negotiable these bills were. The American dream...
- radoslawc 9y agoI've heard multiple times that medical care in USA is pretty expansive if you don't have insurance. But I had no idea to what extent, until someone posted comments section form amazon's page for fish antibiotics. People are buying those for them self (well, still it's amoxycycline), just check any comment, most of them have something like: my 'fish' is better, $300 saved. That's just inhumane.
- Firebrand 9y agoThere’s only three parts of the economy where prices have consistently outpaced inflation: education, health care (including prescription drugs) and real estate over long periods of time. These are all sectors in which public policy subsidizes demand and restricts supply.
- samsonradu 9y agoThese are also the most impactful on the quality of life I might add.
- jayd16 9y agoWhat about food stamps? FDA regulates food. But really, those are huge sectors of the economy. It's weird to say that they can't keep pace with inflation when its the majority of a lot of pay checks. Wouldn't it be better to say wages have stagnated while the price of other goods have dropped?
- cjalmeida 9y agoAbout food, thanks Ricardo for making a case in 19th century that free trade of food makes for a more efficient economy. I wonder what would be the effect if regulations where such that one could easily import and distribute medical drugs. Or the AMA would allows foreign physicians to operate within borders.
- viraptor 9y agoIt is country-specific though. In Europe, there are a few countries with (for example) free education from primary too university level. It hasn't changed in years.
- cratermoon 9y agoOnly in the United States. Are we Great yet?
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI understand the narrative, its the 'tiger outside the village'or the 'wolf in the forest' sort of tale that there is this "bad thing" that will randomly attack/kill/impoverish people that collectively we could eliminate if we just had the will, as a community, to do so. And I don't disagree, we could overcome the badness if we had the will. Where I part company with the narrative is over looking how we have structurally made the 'collective' so large as to prevent such a decision to be taken. I expect that if you were to poll San Francisco you would find overwhelming support for a single payer, 'state' (and by that I'm using the notion of the collective government not the state of California) administered health care system for residents. No doubt it would be paid for by taxing some of the wealthiest residents or as part of some sort of rent/property taxation plan. You might even be able to get this passed (agreed to) for the entire state of California. However, country wide consensus on the issue is elusive and often divisive. The saying goes that "all politics are local" and to a large extent that is true. But I wonder why it is that the state of California was progressive enough to legalize marijuana but can't get something like this done? The current punch line is "This isn't a problem in North America if you are Canadian."[1] so why is that the case in California? We've got the largest state economy in the US, we've got the largest population base, and we're bigger than France[2]. So what is the hangup with just showing the rest of the country how things 'should' be done rather than complain about how things are being done 'wrong' ? [1] And yes I know there are plenty of complaints about the system there as well, it is still better than what you get south of the border. [2] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/07/american-state-bigger-economy-than-india/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/07/american-state-bigger...
- danans 9y ago> But I wonder why it is that the state of California was progressive enough to legalize marijuana but can't get something like this done? The current punch line is "This isn't a problem in North America if you are Canadian."[1] so why is that the case in California? We'll see. Ironically, and optimistically, the attack on the ACA at the federal level might push California voters towards supporting universal health coverage. But marijuana is a different issue than healthcare, because in order to legalize it, you don't need to tax the haves more. It's only opposed by social conservatives, who are not a huge contingent in CA. Universal coverage in CA, however, would need to involve some form of redistribution downwards (just like the ACA did), and many Californians aren't as progressive when it comes to that. You see this same phenomenon in NIMBY anti-development housing policies, and in the underinvestment in public education. The demographics of this tendency are strange, too. The older generation has a strong skew against progressive social policies, but sometimes young, well-to-do, and childless people are also opposed to more downward redistribution, because the things that some of the progressive policies affect (healthcare, education, etc), are a non issue for them (at least so far).
- trs80 9y agoThe scary truth about doctors is they frequently misdiagnose. When I was healthy each diagnosis was pretty accurate "you're fine". Then I had a real catastrophe and was mistreated by the medical community. Till this day I suffer and I'm still not content with their diagnosis. Don't put too much faith in them to save you.
- conanbatt 9y agoHealthcare produces a mental model on patients that is not how medicine is practiced. Doing tests is not only economically costly, its also costly in terms of health, so ordering unnecessary tests is in detriment to health. There are also false positives. So tests without symptoms should not be performed. But that also means you dont find things pre-emptively. For example, you are worried that your fatigue is due to a brain tumor (google surely told you that), so you ask your doctor to do an MRI to rule it out. MRI comes in negative. But the MRI radiation gave you cancer, because it does (in a very small amount of people), as well as gave you very expensive bill for it, because MRI are expensive everywhere, not only in the US.
- philipkglass 9y agoFor example, you are worried that your fatigue is due to a brain tumor (google surely told you that), so you ask your doctor to do an MRI to rule it out. MRI comes in negative. But the MRI radiation gave you cancer, because it does (in a very small amount of people), as well as gave you very expensive bill for it, because MRI are expensive everywhere, not only in the US. Good example, except you're thinking of a CT scan, not MRI. CT scan uses x-rays. MRI uses no ionizing radiation.
- conanbatt 9y agoSorry! Thanks for the correction.
- viraptor 9y ago> So tests without symptoms should not be performed. But that also means you dont find things pre-emptively. That's not entirely true. It's accepted you get periodic screening for many issues. (breast cancer, pap smear are probably the most common) Then there are tests you can easily request without any symptoms. (STI and allergy tests for example) > But the MRI radiation gave you cancer There's no MRI radiation. That's not how it works.
- ypeterholmes 9y agoInsurance companies are the problem. Single payer + Universal Healthcare is the answer because it will eliminate insurance companies from the equation and get us back towards actual cost and remove this threat that hangs over all of us.
- refurb 9y agoYou realize that countries like Switzerland and Singapore have private insurance companies, universal coverage and reasonable costs? That would suggest insurance companies are not the problem.
- dv_dt 9y agoSwitzerland does however have government set drug and procedure prices even if private insurance companies manage the billing. They are also one of the more expensive of the developed universal healthcare nations - though still significantly more efficient than the US system.
- ohples 9y agoThey are also very small countries compared to the US
- cgmg 9y agoWhy do you think that's relevant? In any case, the same point would apply in the other direction.
- doomjunky 9y agoI see a problem in the US system, the insurance companies have two options to make profit, (1) drain the insured people and (2) negotiale the the medical providers. This puts insurance companies in a very privileged position. This is why the insurance companies are the problem. Germany for example has a national "public" health insurance system and a private insurance system. The national health insurance system is based on an tax-based insurance font. For the public insurance sector this font is the only one (!) allowed source of income for the insurance companies. This means the companies can not drain the insured persons, they have to negotiate prices with the medical providers.
- dawhizkid 9y agoHaving worked in a tech startup adjacent to healthcare insurance one of the biggest reasons healthcare costs are out of control is largely a result of how healthcare is billed. Most consumers (i.e. those insured under an employer-offered plan) are very far removed from the actual price of a service because, assuming a medically necessary service or drug is covered, you are paying up to some deductible, coinsurance, or copay but usually never anything that closely resembles the retail price. Most insurance companies operate off a "network model" where they go out and negotiate contracts with different providers/hospitals to get discounted rates that are usually pegged to Medicare prices (which is as low as the prices go). Large employers can negotiate good rates through insurance companies as well to drive prices down to control their own healthcare costs. The opaqueness with which care is paid means that consumers receiving care have little incentive to shop around for prices, quality, value, etc., which means providers can basically charge whatever they think the gov't (through medicare/medicaid) will pay and a percentage above medicare/medicaid for everyone else. Of course, if you are uninsured or go out of network (i.e. your insurance company has no contract with the provider you saw), then you're going to be asked to pay ridiculous retail prices that very few people actually ever pay. If you look at the difference between price trends for elective vs non-elective care (i.e. cosmetic surgery, LASIK, cosmetic dermatology), prices for non-elective care outpaces elective care by a long shot with the main difference being consumers pay out of pocket for elective care and actually put pressure on prices whereas consumers do not for insurance-covered non-elective. The reality is that if you are ever in this situation you should ALWAYS negotiate. There's a reason medical debt is bought for pennies on the dollar because 1) difficulty actually collecting "patient responsibility" in the first place and 2) everyone know these retail prices are completely BS.
- tomkarlo 9y agoIt's definitely a problem that pricing is opaque and disconnected, but have you considered that maybe healthcare isn't a good candidate for a market solution? Even without this problem, customers have relatively little ability to choose providers or price shop, and they often don't really understand what they're being asked to buy. By extension, it seems like the key difference between "elective" and "non-elective" care is that one of them is elective... it's going to be a very different market when a consumer can choose to buy something or not buy it at all, vs. when they have to buy something and may not even understand what or why they're buying it. It's not necessarily that consumers are shopping prices more or being stronger negotiators, it's partially just that demand naturally falls if prices start to rise too much.
- knorker 9y agotl;dr: Life In The USA, the worst country in the world to have medical issues in, that also refuses to change to what everyone in the world knows works, for some reason.
- refurb 9y agoI would say the US is the best country in the world to have medical issues in if you have good insurance. That's why you see Canadians making the trek down for treatment when they can't get it (or at least the quality they want) in Canada.
- jasonlotito 9y ago> That's why you see Canadians making the trek down for treatment when they can't get it (or at least the quality they want) in Canada. We did that for our children's autism. It was faster, better, and cheaper than anything Canada offered, which is monstrously bad.
- refurb 9y agoHere is a recent example in the Canadian news.[1] Two friends, one in Canada, one is the US. The one in the US got the latest cancer treatment and is in remission. The one in Canada is stuck with old drugs because the gov't hasn't decided whether to pay for the new drug. "It's crazy that I live in Canada, but now I'm looking at having to sell my house for coverage of my medication." People act like a single payer system is a panacea for all the US's problems, but there are also trade offs involved. [1]http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/a-tale-of-2-friends-with-breast-cancer-1-has-coverage-for-costly-drug-the-other-forced-to-pay-1.4495123 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/a-tale-of-2-f...
- baby 9y agoI met someone in Chicago who fell from a roof, had a bunch of surgery that costed more than a million dollars, he ran away and went back to Spain instead of paying for them. I'm not sure what will happen next for him.
- booleandilemma 9y agoI have a naive question: Why can’t healthcare be like going to the mechanic to get your car fixed? You go to the shop, they tell you the problem and give you an estimate, and you go from there. Why is healthcare so much more complicated?
- tathougies 9y agoHave you ever had an undiagnosable condition? A car is a human invention, so fixing it is easy. Moreover, if it can't be fixed, the solution of buying another car is an option. The same is not true with your body.
- Balgair 9y agoWhen a car dies, it's a money problem. When a human dies, it is more than a money problem. Also, cars aren't subjective. Flat tires are flat tires. With humans, coughs aren't just coughs and broken bones aren't just broken bones. The level of complexity is vastly larger. Even a simple yeast cell is essentially a black box still.