9 ms·
> The foundation owns itself, so no Kamprad family members hold shares. Late stage capitalism... Anyway, I don't really get why the article claims he didn't c
by viraptor 9y ago
> The foundation owns itself, so no Kamprad family members hold shares.
Late stage capitalism...
Anyway, I don't really get why the article claims he didn't care about money. It's known for a while that IKEA avoids taxes in many dodgy ways. If he really didn't care, the connected companies could pay a reasonable amount.
- dagw 9y agoHe didn't really care about money personally, or at least not the material things money can buy. At least that's the image he worked very hard to portray by driving an old Volvo, living in a modest house and wearing clothes bought in a second hand store etc. He obviously cared a lot about his companies making as much money as possible. Although if you asked him he'd probably say that all that tax avoidance was just him being frugal.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoOk. But when why not donate the tax savings to an org that can use it? I just can't see "I don't care" resulting in hoarding (so much money). Maybe "Money doesn't motivate me" would be more accurate?
- dagw 9y agoOk. But when why not donate the tax savings to an org that can use it Technically the IKEA Foundation (www.ikeafoundation.org) is that charitable organisation. And technically they do donate a bunch of money each year to various causes. Of course they're not the most transparent of organizations so it's hard to really judge their philanthropic efforts. Maybe "Money doesn't motivate me" would be more accurate? At the risk of trying to psychoanalyses a man know very little about,I'd say that "personal wealth doesn't motivate me" is probably the most correct statement. He obviously cared very much about his businesses and making them as successful as possible, and as such probably cared deeply about money to the extent that they're the 'points' used to judge who's winning that game.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoSaid better. Thanks. Words matters.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- f4rker 9y agoOk why not start donating 30% of your money every paycheck? We are very generous with other peoples money Not so much with our own
- pikzel 9y agoThat was part of his public appearance because it has been extremely valuable, and it has been debated wether it was authentic or not.
- manigandham 9y agoWhen you are worth billions, those are unnecessary games.
- ryanlol 9y ago"It was not exactly so, as reporters found. His home was a villa overlooking Lake Geneva, and he had an estate in Sweden and vineyards in Provence. He drove a Porsche as well as the Volvo. His cut-rate flights, hotels and meals were taken in part as an exemplar to his executives, who were expected to follow suit, to regard employment by Ikea as a life’s commitment — and to write on both sides of a piece of paper." https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/28/obituaries/ingvar-kamprad-dies.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/28/obituaries/ingvar-kamprad...
- jessriedel 9y agoPorches are still modest for a mega-billionaire...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thisacctforreal 9y agoPrevious discussion when he died; https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252104 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252104
- kolla 9y agoHe owned several luxury houses and most certanly never bought 2nd hand clothes even if he wore simple clothes. So it was a carefully crafted image, not what he actually did.
- dagw 9y agoIt was obviously a well crafted image, but hardly one invented out of whole cloth. For example non of the three homes he owned[0] would classify as luxury by any reasonable rich person standard. His 'luxury' house in Switzerland was probably not even among 10 most expensive houses in town and was significantly smaller than most billionaires garages. His house in Sweden is in the middle of nowhere, the sort of place where 'no one' wants to live and you can pick up large swaths of land for very little money. edit: here is a picture of "luxury villa" in Switzerland: https://w.cdn-expressen.se/images/7d/e2/7de2bbfb59044fe6bfc39c15918b00cf/16x9/680.jpg https://w.cdn-expressen.se/images/7d/e2/7de2bbfb59044fe6bfc3... Don't get me wrong it's a nice place and something for a reasonably successful doctor or lawyer to aspire to, but hardly screams "one of the 20 richest people in the world". [0] The vineyard was technically owned the Ikea Foundation and not by him personally, and since the wine they produced there was sold at the restaurants at his stores the whole thing was probably considered a business expense for tax purposes. Because that was how he rolled
- noetic_techy 9y agoLooks like an average upper middle class house in the US. Hardly swanky.
- swombat 9y agoI’m Geneva that costs a few million dollars. Not much by billionaire standards but not cheap either.
- ribosometronome 9y agoAll depends on the location. That'd cost a few million in NY or SF but 200k near a lot of US metro areas.
- walkingolof 9y agoThat was his image, he and his family owns a company in the tax haven that is the Netherland Antilles, which on a yearly basis receives 3% of the total turnover of IKEA in a brand name licensing deal.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf he didn't care about money personally, why did he move to Switzerland from Sweden to avoid paying taxes? There is also that weird non-profit cooperative that IKEA masquerades as to avoid paying corporate taxes as well. Whatever can be said about the founder of IKEA, he really knew how to avoid taxes!
- charlesdm 9y agoBecause there is no point in being frugal if you have to pay significant corporate tax. And it helped expand "the empire" he was building, because he could reinvest everything. He most likely hated wasting money, whether that was on excessive expenses or taxes -- it makes no difference. The money is gone either way. I have a friend whose grandfather built quite a large retail business (in the billions). He said his grandfather was the same, including the tax avoidance. Grew up poor, made it, and hated wasting money.
- mulmen 9y agoIf you're paying significant corporate tax isn't being frugal even more important?
- charlesdm 9y agoFlip the situation: a) I can be frugal and pay corporate tax; or b) I can be frugal and pay no corporate tax. He picked option b.. which is fine. You don't start a business from the notion of funding the state.
- mulmen 9y agoBut you said there's no point in being frugal if you are paying significant corporate tax. If you have a heavy tax burden surely it is important to allocate your remaining resources frugally? I'm saying option a is better than option c) spend wastefully because you pay high taxes. Your comment seemed to advocate for this third option. I now understand your meaning to be "paying high taxes is not frugal" which I disagree with for other reasons. Specifically paying unnecessary taxes would not be frugal but a company can still be frugal and pay high tax rates. To put it another way I do not believe tax avoidance is a frugal necessity.
- erispoe 9y agoHe didn't care for the lifestyle that money can bring. He was living in a nondescript suburban house near Lausanne and kept his old car for 20 years. Much like Warren Buffet, he was one of these self-made fortunes for whom money is a way to keep tally.
- galfarragem 9y ago"It's not about the money, it's about the game." -- Gordon Gekko
- icantdrive55 9y agoNo, the fictional character cared about money: 'I bought that building for 800 grand, and sold it for a few year later for --------. I thought that was all the money in them world. Now it's a day's pay.' 'Enough money to have a girl like Darien?" 'Enough money to not waste time.' He was a greedy bastard---like every guy whom I saw make it big financially. He didn't have an enabling rich father though? He was a community college boy. I graduated college, and went into graduate school. I had a lot of stress, and not much support, nor a life outside of school. I used to do homework with Wall Street, and Platoon playing in the background. I liked those movies because they portrayed the duality of life perfectly, or so I thought back then. I ended up having a nervous breakdown, and rarely watch either movie, but really identified with Sheen's characters in both movies.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- oblio 9y agoI'll see if I can find the sources but I saw some comments recently that it was a sham, mostly. He did have high expenses. Edit: Wikipedia says: > Kamprad owned a villa in Switzerland, a large country estate in Sweden and a vineyard in Provence, France. I can't guarantee the prices, but those things should be in the multi-million Euro range. Not quite rapper expenses, but definitely not middle class either.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bsbechtel 9y agoNot caring about money doesn't necessarily mean you are willing to pay more taxes than you are legally required to, especially a subjective amount that others deem 'reasonable'.
- galfarragem 9y agoAnd overpaying taxes will be always considered bad management. I don't think he and IKEA top management would ever want that.
- rtpg 9y agothis is such a weasely way to phrase agressive tax minimization. It's the "I spent all day eating Sam's Club food samples" of business. You didn't need to do it, you're helping no one but yourself, and you look bad afterwards.
- gaius 9y agowilling to pay more taxes than you are legally required to There is a material difference between that and actively seeking loopholes that are not available to ordinary people. Ikea is only possible because of the physical and legal infrastructure paid for by those ordinary people after all. Not that they will do anything of course, the Viking spirit is long dead.
- dx034 9y agoNot really. Corporate taxes and personal taxes are two very different things. Ikea didn't commit tax fraud (at least from what I heard), they just used structures to minimise taxes. Those weren't loopholes, they were made by countries for companies like Ikea. Companies utilising those structures aren't the problem. It's governments creating the opportunities. Same as with tax incentives for investments. You can't blame a company using tax incentives but you can blame the state/city/region that they created them.
- sooheon 9y agoCompanies own the governments that create those opportunities.
- Arnt 9y agoWhat is the reasonable amount for a company that pays its "owner" no dividend and apparently never will? This isn't empty rhetoric. Most countries extract tax as x% of turnover plus y% of dividend plus many smaller taxes. Kamprad structured his company to pay its "owner" nothing, which leaves VAT and the smaller taxes, and apparently the structure prevented his heirs from ever getting any financial benefit from Ikea. Forgoing an income foregoes income tax. I'm asking you whether that's fair. Can someone like Kamprad decide that neither he nor the state should get any financial benefit from Ikea?
- Scarblac 9y agoThe money is now in a foundation, that can re-invest in Ikea or use it for philantropical purposes. It's a nonprofit according to Dutch rules, and they have decided not to tax those. Eventually the money is spent on something, and will be taxed then.
- elmar 9y ago>"If he really didn't care, the connected companies could pay a reasonable amount" He probably thought that the money would be better spent for the good of society by private institutions than by the government.
- patall 9y agoSure, thats why he let some of his products be produced by political prisoners in states like the GDR. Please excuse, my sarcasm but this man was not the good guy, even if he wanted to make everyone believe that.
- saosebastiao 9y agoNot everybody feels the same that you do about government. Hell, I feel differently about different layers of government. I would probably not seeking to minimize my city or state taxes any more than is convenient, but I'll never give the federal government any more than it takes to keep my head.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI'd be willing to pay more city and state taxes if I could pay them to cities or states of my choosing.
- vanderZwan 9y agoYou cannot make sense of Ingvar Kamprad and IKEA without taking a moment to look at how Scandinavian culture is very different from American culture. First, we should talk about the infamous "Jantelagen": > The Law of Jante is the description of a pattern of group behaviour towards individuals within Nordic countries that negatively portrays and criticises individual success and achievement as unworthy and inappropriate. (...) Used generally in colloquial speech in the Nordic countries as a sociological term to describe a condescending attitude towards individuality and success, the term refers to a mentality that diminishes individual effort and places all emphasis on the collective, while simultaneously denigrating those who try to stand out as individual achievers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante (It should be noted that these days, Jantelagen as petty as described here does not really apply so much to urban Scandinavian culture, but rural areas can still be very much like this) Kamprad grew up on a farm in a small village in the 1930s, so we can be fairly certain that this attitude was part of the social values that he grew up with. That is enough to explain why Kamprad did not show off wealth: it would be considered offensive back home. It is also easy to imagine how one can consider cheapness a positive character trait with this mindset. So I am inclined to believe that Kamprad sincerely did not care about money despite his billions, at least not in the "American" sense. Jantelagen may also be part of why back in the seventies, Scandinavia was one of the earliest places to embrace principles of Participatory Design: design done together with the people being designed for[0]. Interestingly, in that same period Kamprad wrote "The Testament of a Furniture Dealer"[1]. It does a lot to explain how from the Kamprad/IKEA perspective, being a force of good in the world for the have-nots is not at odds with making tons of money. It reads like political manifesto, except written by someone who can only see the world from the point of view of furniture business. I suppose it kind of is. Just look at the opening paragraphs: > To create a better everyday life for the many people by offering a wide range of well-designed, functional home furnishing products at prices so low that as many people as possible will be able to afford them. We have decided once and for all to side with the many. What is good for our customers is also, in the long run, good for us. This is an objective that carries obligations. > All nations and societies in both the East and West spend a disproportionate amount of their resources on satisfying a minority of the population. In our line of business, for example, far too many of the fine designs and new ideas are reserved for a small circle of the affluent. That situation has influenced the formulation of our objectives. > After only a couple of decades, we have achieved good results. A well-known Swedish industrialist-politician has said that IKEA has meant more for the process of democratisation than many political measures put together. We believe, too, that our actions have inspired many of our colleagues to work along the same lines. > But we have great ambitions. We know that we can be a beneficial influence on practically all markets. We know that in the future we will be able to make a valuable contribution to the process of democratisation outside our own homeland too. We know that larger production runs give us new advantages on our home ground, as well as more markets to spread our risks over. That is why it is our duty to expand. So how did Kamprad reconcile being successful and making tons of money on the one hand, with social values "that diminish individual effort and places all emphasis on the collective" on the other? Beyond his own frugality, he oriented his ambitions towards producing for the collective. Note that this is not a self-evident business model! Plenty of businesses maximise the perceived value of their products through the idea of exclusivity (supercars and wrist-watches come to mind). When is the last time you saw that attitude applied to an IKEA product? Nobody brags about having a Lack table at home. You know what does fit the IKEA ethos? The Lack Rack, and IKEA hackers[2][3]. As far as I can tell, the internal culture of IKEA reflects this as well. I am originally from the Netherlands, but studied a master in Interaction Design in Malmö University, and have been living in Sweden for five years in total. A number of the people that I studied with ended up working for IKEA. Through them I get the impression that they truly believe in "the cause" of making affordable designs for everyone. You can also see it in IKEA's approach to sustainability[4]. Anyway, the point is that for Kamprad, maximising profits for a successful business, and this business working for the benefit of everyone was not at odds. Keep that in mind and a lot of things about IKEA start making a lot more sense. As for the IKEA foundation, yeah, it's pretty shady. It would be interesting to look beyond the tax-evasion construction and see how guilty IKEA is of other dubious business practices like externalising costs - that is, whether or not these other practices were as easy to reconcile with a frugal mindset. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_design#History_in_Scandinavia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_design#History_i... [1] http://www.ikea.com/ms/en_US/pdf/reports-downloads/the-testament-of-a-furniture-dealer.pdf http://www.ikea.com/ms/en_US/pdf/reports-downloads/the-testa... [2] https://wiki.eth0.nl/index.php/LackRack https://wiki.eth0.nl/index.php/LackRack [3] https://www.ikeahackers.net/ https://www.ikeahackers.net/ [4] https://www.greenbiz.com/article/ikea-argues-businesses-go-all-sustainability https://www.greenbiz.com/article/ikea-argues-businesses-go-a...
- etskinner 9y agoIf he believed that his foundation was better suited to appropriate that money than the government, then avoiding taxes is a rational thing to do, and doesn't necessarily mean that their claim about his not caring about the money is false.
- runeks 9y agoAlso, if the consumer picks the cheapest item on the store shelf, then companies can’t afford to be philanthropic, as the company most skilled in avoiding taxes will be able to offer the same products cheaper.
- msla 9y ago"Late stage" capitalism? This is pre-capitalism, feudalism. Besides, "late-stage capitalism" is a meaningless buzzword.
- amag 9y agoHe cared about being frugal because that was the Sweden he grew up in. I think this video, where he's buying lunch at an Ikea store in Poland, says a lot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbUE3O03h_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbUE3O03h_s (For those who cannot/will not view it, he gets a bit upset when the cashier tries to charge him for the coffee, despite that it should be included in the lunch.)