6 ms·
They added another $6.7 billion in long-term debt in the quarter, bringing the total up to $103.9 billion. With the tax changes now taken care of, I'd like to
by adventured 9y ago
They added another $6.7 billion in long-term debt in the quarter, bringing the total up to $103.9 billion.
With the tax changes now taken care of, I'd like to see them begin reducing that immense pile of debt. You do it while times are good and you're pulling in $50b in net income, rather than getting caught in a very bad position later (which is overwhelmingly what most companies do).
In a very short amount of time, several of the leading tech companies have gone from being among the least indebted companies, to among the most indebted. Microsoft as another example, is carrying $76 billion in long-term debt, up from $27 billion in 2015. Their cash exceeds their debt, I consider that a very low bar to be setting though. Instead of bribing shareholders with buybacks (an indicator of lackluster growth opportunities in the business, when it comes to capital deployment opportunities), and artificially boosting EPS growth, that capital should all be going into paying down debt.
- fancyfacebook 9y agoWhen you're a company like apple debt is not a problem, in fact you can even sometimes get paid to issue debt if you're very very profitable. This is nothing like your monthly credit card payment, it's more of an accounting convenience.
- reubenmorais 9y agoCan you (or someone) expand on this? It's not the first time I hear someone say that big $$$ views debt differently, but I don't understand how.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoCan you explain what the benefit of this would be? While I disagree with the parent (if you're sitting on a mountain of cash, debt is not a problem), what would the benefit be of having debt when you also have a mountain of cash? Certainly made sense before when Apple had cash overseas that they couldn't touch, but what would the benefit of it be now?
- jlmorton 9y agoThere have been major tax advantages. The impact is lessened by the recent tax reform, but consider Apple has hundreds of billions of dollars in wholly-owned offshore subsidiaries. Up until recently, if they repatriated that cash, they had to pay 35% in taxes. Much better then for an Aa1-rated company like Apple to take out debt at a very low interest rate.
- pawelk 9y agoAs I understand it, it would be similar to the situation when my savings account gives me 2% annually and I was able to take a loan at 1% annually. I wouldn't use my savings to pay off the debt, but the other way around.
- adventured 9y agoYou're talking about the present. I'm talking about paying down debt now, because the really good times never last. You tightly constrain - or ideally eliminate - the debt now so that when the challenging times inevitably arrive, you have far more flexibility. See: GE, Sears, US Steel, Alcoa, GM, Xerox, Eastman Kodak, Kmart, IBM. All former giants that were laid low. The only guarantee Apple has, is they'll face a critical point like those companies did. Having $200 billion in cash with zero debt, will sure beat having $50 billion in net cash, when that time comes. Apple should know this better than anybody. They nearly went bankrupt 20 years ago, due to their fortunes turning south.
- samfisher83 9y agoTheir borrowing rates are super low. They can simple just invest the cash they have in an asset that is safe but has a better return and can make money on the difference. Even if the difference is like .5% that is billions of dollars.
- adventured 9y agoEverybody else is talking about today. I'm talking about tomorrow. Here, I'll give you the obvious scenario. Apple wilts. There are no exceptions, all the top corporations from each generation falter to one degree or another. The very few that are lucky or good enough, revive after taking a big hit. Profits fall to $12 billion, or $25 billion. I'm not even modeling a loss scenario here, I'm being generous. Shareholders are used to being bribed with fat buybacks, financial engineering. They also like the solid dividend, which then has to be slashed as the situation worsens. Simultaneously Apple has immense capital outlay requirements to maintain their margins. They're also bloated on labor, as they massively bulked up on employees and operational costs (the new HQ, and HQ2 et al.) during the extremely fat years, that means mass firings. The market cap crumbles, 15 pe * $25 billion = $375 billion. Now shareholders are really ticked off. $200 billion in debt. $200 billion in cash. Hey, debt is cheap after all, so why not. Today their net income is more like $50 billion against ~$104 billion in long-term debt; a two to one ratio. Now make that ~$20 billion in net income against $200 billion in long-term debt; a ten to one ratio. That $200 billion debt level will be reached in just four or five years at this point, if they don't stop accumulating at the rate they are. Interest costs rise considerably as the market has a lot less confidence in Apple's prospects. How does just 5% sound on $200 billion, $10 billion in interest costs, while yielding $20 billion in net income. That becomes a debt hell, that is nearly impossible to get out of. This is not a reach, this is almost guaranteed to happen at some point if they keep pushing the debt up (unless one assumes the utopia outcome, where Apple is the sole exception in US history, and they just soar forever). That's the medium outcome scenario. Feel free to model the bad scenario where the iPhone loses its place in the market. In that scenario, Apple goes bankrupt again circa 2030. It could never happen, that the present Apple glory falters, everyone will say. My refutation: it has never not happened in US industrial history, that the top tier giants don't tumble (typically in a big way). Apple is far more exposed to that outcome than the very few corporate giants that have done it best over long periods of time, such as Exxon (even they just saw their profits contract toward zero when oil crashed). And that's why you get rid of the debt. Just ask GE how they feel about their present balance sheet (negative $32 billion in net tangible assets). GE was on top of the world not very long ago. They're not the same situations, skeptics will declare; of course not, they don't have to be, Apple will follow its own unique scenario of faltering, as all companies do.
- runT1ME 9y agoThe biggest risk to Apple is the overall economy tanking, and if that happens, the Fed will lower rates. This causes inflation which eats away at the debt by making the amount 'owed' less (relative to the old value of the dollar).