7 ms·
Interesting that for such an inexpensive but specialized hardware device it still has a "phone home on boot" feature. Given what this device does compared to a
by zdw 9y ago
Interesting that for such an inexpensive but specialized hardware device it still has a "phone home on boot" feature.
Given what this device does compared to a 3d printer (xyz axis movement, suction head, part reel incrementer, webcam + identification software), it seems like a sufficiently motivated hobbyist could come up with something passably similar in the same price ballpark.
- manicdee 9y agoHow many of them have turned it into a viable product with after market support and a commitment to ongoing development?
- vvanders 9y ago> it seems like a sufficiently motivated hobbyist could come up with something passably similar in the same price ballpark. This is one of those things that sounds trivial but has tons of hidden gotcha's. EEVBlog usually breaks it down pretty well but I can't find any of the recent ones he's reviewed.
- princeb 9y ago> This is one of those things that sounds trivial but has tons of hidden gotcha's. to support your point, from 2 weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255
- gh02t 9y agoPnP doesn't make sense for a hobbyist though, that's the problem. A PnP is a tool for someone making a hundred or more of the exact same design, not something you usually do unless you're selling something. It's not worth the considerable time required to set up feed reels and all the other stuff required for a PnP if you're only making a few boards. There are open source PnP designs though: https://hackaday.io/project/9319-diy-pick-and-place https://hackaday.io/project/9319-diy-pick-and-place it's really just that not many hobbyists need or even want one.
- hoopladler 9y agoAs a hobbyist, I'd like one. You could do projects using hundreds or thousands of devices that are -at the moment- out of reach not for reasons of price, but rather because it would take too long to assemble the devices in question. For instance, tagging and tracking wild animals, or getting really granular local climate data. Electronics just gets more interesting the more it moves away from the monolithic device approach, for me.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoHundreds or thousands of something is typically not a hobbyist venture. Also remember that placing parts is only one step of the process. If you're going to automate assembly by purchasing a P&P, you should also be ready to do high-volume stenciling and have a fast oven. In any case, the time spent aligning the machine and setting up reels can be a significant fraction of the time to just place parts manually. In some cases, you could have placed parts for your entire run by hand before you finished setting up the machine! Depending on how complex your board is, building, say, 100 units by hand isn't time consuming. I've soldered literally thousands of through-hole boards and SMT is much faster and easier to do by hand.
- marshray 9y ago> Hundreds or thousands of something is typically not a hobbyist venture. But isn't this just begging the question? If hobbyists can make use of it, then by definition it's a hobbyist venture. Bringing down size, cost, and complexity is exactly the path by which so much has become available to hobbyists these days. Wasn't that long ago that a laser cutter, heaven forbid a 3d printer, was for pro shops only.
- gh02t 9y agoYeah but I think there is a fundamental difference here. A 3D printer enables you to do things you can't do otherwise (fabricate custom mechanical parts). A pick-and-place enables you to do stuff you can already do with tweezers except in the most extreme cases. And likely do it faster than with a pick-and-place, because they require quite a lot of work to configure. Edit: a good analogy is a homebrewer putting caps on beer bottles. You can do it by hand with a simple tool pretty easily - even capping 100 bottles at once is no sweat, really. It just doesn't make sense to have an automated bottle capping machine even if it was cheap, because it takes up space and ends up taking more effort to set up for a small run than it saves you. Pardon the pun, but the bottleneck lies elsewhere.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoYes, but if you can buy it for the same price it would cost to build, why bother building? Time has its own costs too.
- jstanley 9y agoBecause you don't want it to phone home on every boot.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoI can't thing of any (realistic) reason for a P&P machine to be connected to the internet.
- jstanley 9y agoExactly. OP said: > Interesting that for such an inexpensive but specialized hardware device it still has a "phone home on boot" feature.
- vonnieda 9y agoI'm the founder/author of OpenPnP, which exists to do exactly this. I've been working on the project for about 6 years now and I'm happy to say that lots of hobbyists, small companies, maker spaces, etc. have built and are running OpenPnP based pick and place machines. It's a harder problem than it seems, as I've found out over the past 6 years. While the basics are quite similar to a 3D printer, PnP has some unique challenges. 3D printing can be relatively inaccurate but still produce a good output since you are working with a pretty "oozy" substance to begin with. PnP has to be pretty accurate across it's entire work surface, though. If the machine is 0.1mm off at any point in it's travel that creates a likelihood that a part will be placed incorrectly. Feeders are also, mechanically, a lot more difficult to get right than it seems like they would be. In any case, we're having good luck and a lot of success, so if you are interested in DIY / Open Source / Hobby pick and place, please come check it out! http://openpnp.org http://openpnp.org
- eggsome 9y agoFor those interested, here is a video/demo of OpenPnP from LCA2016: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9BGVYnaOs8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9BGVYnaOs8 (great project by the way!)
- stryk 9y agoNo way is that the same Aussie chap from SuperHouse? (he used to [?] do excellent video guides on DIY hacking those cheap Sonoff wi-fi enabled electrical relays)
- jacquesm 9y agoThat's a super project and I'm really surprised this is the first time I hear about it if you've been working on this for 6 years.
- jcoffland 9y agoOpenPnP is awesome! I enjoyed seeing you guys at the Bay Area Maker Faire last summer. We were about four booths down.
- 9y ago
- leggomylibro 9y agoMaybe that "feature" is because of the 'inexpensive + specialized' thing. PnP seems like a hard problem. I thought the same thing as you awhile ago, looked at some efforts that others were putting together, and was surprised at how many opted for complex things like computer vision to verify part positioning. And it did not take long for me to decide that, like most problems I take a cursory look at, there was no flippin' way I'd be able to make anything workable on my own in a reasonable cost/time-box. If I had an affordable plug-and-play design, I might take steps to protect it. Personally I'd think twice about a 'phone home' solution because I hate that shit as a consumer - or just open source it outright - but I can understand the stance.