4 ms·
It's fascinating to watch the British tolerate this bizarre puritanical fascist shift. The forced surveillance laws are not unexpected, that's going on in most
by adventured 9y ago
It's fascinating to watch the British tolerate this bizarre puritanical fascist shift. The forced surveillance laws are not unexpected, that's going on in most of the developed world these days to one degree or another. The laws around porn are the part that I never would have expected. It seems like something the more extreme conservatives in the US would have cooked up.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It seems like something the more extreme conservatives in the US would have cooked up. It sounds more like something the US did cook up back in the 90s; the Communications Decency Act in 1996 and then after the relevant part of that was struck down the Child Online Protection Act in 1998; similar age verification was widely adopted by adult sites in the US to avoid liability under these acts, in the brief time they were in force. Usually, credit card verification was used.
- nkkollaw 9y ago> Usually, credit card verification was used How convenient. That doesn't prove age at all. In fact, as a kid I'd steal my parent's credit card, but now that I'm an adult I don't own one. Go figure.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> How convenient. That doesn't prove age at all. That criticism was noted in a number of media outlets at the time; it probably would have eventually become a legal issue had the laws not been struck down, rendering it moot.
- adventured 9y agoAnd yet here we are. Hundreds of large porn sites in the US, requiring zero real verification. Age verification was never adopted by most of the major US porn sites. I was a teenager at the time, I never once had to age verify or provide a CC to use any of the large sites. The only thing most of those sites have ever required - if anything at all - going back to the 1990s, is a click or equivalent indicating you're over 18. Beyond that there were dozens of large US porn forums back then, facilitating downloading, none of which required age verification at any point either.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> And yet here we are. Hundreds of large porn sites in the US, requiring zero real verification. Because the relevant parts of the CDA and COPA were struck down by the courts. Doesn't change that the US did concoct laws of this type and try to enforce them.
- adventured 9y agoI certainly agree, that is factually spot on. The more puritanical types in the US almost persistently attempt to do things like that, it has been a never-ending battle, only varying in seriousness, since the mid 1990s. They've rarely gotten very far with it though, mostly thanks to the extraordinary protections on speech & expression that the US has. That group's censorship efforts appear to be almost entirely stagnant or dead at present.
- masonic 9y agoCIPA[0], however, was signed into law by Clinton and upheld by SCOTUS. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Internet_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Internet_Protecti...
- dragonwriter 9y agoCIPA was much weaker than the others on its face, and interpreted to be even weaker than it seemed on its face when it was found to be constitutional at all, it's not great, but it's a far cry from what the earlier attempts tried to do.
- keypress 9y agoFrom the same government that initially talked about removing Internet end to end encryption.
- Torgo 9y agoIt wasn't that long ago that they had a censorship office that prevented import of pornography based on various criteria.
- adventured 9y agoI've never heard of that one. I'm curious, when was that roughly?
- Torgo 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_in_the_United_King... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/a-long-list-of-sex-acts-just-got-banned-in-uk-porn-9897174.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/a-long-list-of-sex-act...
- ravenstine 9y agoA society that actually believes it needs these measures is in serious trouble. None of this crap is going to work. And why would it? Pretty much all boys got their hands on porn when I was a kid, and it seemed to have no bearing on how we grew up. There's porn addiction and all that, but there's a lot that goes into what defines an addiction(and alcohol is legal, so...), and some of the boys I knew who watched the most porn grew up to earn six figures or more in prestigious fields. A child who is viewing porn online is almost definitely seeking it out, and if that's true, they will circumvent almost any of these truly laughable attempts to shield children on the internet. At best, you might be able to instantiate laws around porn in advertisements. But good luck preventing kids from watching porn. If anything, age walls will make porn more exciting to watch because it makes it forbidden. The stupidity of adults never fails to astound me. COPPA made me laugh when I was a kid, and still does. I don't know why you're being downvoted. It's true that GB accepts far more invasive policies, including mass surveillance that exceeds the United States.
- adventured 9y agoBeyond your excellent points, porn is a tremendous means for a person to discover all sorts of aspects of sexuality, both their own and the broader concept. There are so many valuable things to be exposed to sexually, and plenty of it can be difficult to explore safely or emotionally comfortably otherwise. Some will reasonably argue the obvious value to real experiences with other people, I'm not detracting value from that at all, rather I think porn is a critical compliment to sexual discovery. I was a semi geeky teenager. My introduction to sexuality was in part courtesy of the Web. Playboy was pretty lame by comparison, even then it seemed decades out of fit culturally. The Web was a safe, comfortable way to explore what my preferences were.
- joshumax 9y agoAdditionally, it is a tremendous help to reduce sexual assault and accidental pregnancy. A fair portion of teenage guys are frightening enough, but the last thing that we need is a bunch of confused horny teens with no safe outlet to explore sexuality. Sure, there is some strange and downright awful stuff out there, but I can only imagine the increase in assaults and pregnancies this form of online control can cause. Additionally, it reinforces the idea that bodies are inherently sexual in nature and seeing consenting, nude adults should be viewed as "taboo" or "extraordinary."
- lucozade 9y agoI believe the accepted term is "swivel-eyed loons" and we have plenty of them here in the UK. There's been a fairly strong streak of puritanism in the UK for generations. It wouldn't surprise me if we invented it (we used to be good at that sort of thing). As to tolerating it. I have no evidence but I'd hazard a guess that only a tiny fraction of people even know. And of those that do, there aren't many groups that would vocally defend our inalienable right to watch porn. TBH I'd expect that most Brits, if they thought about it, wouldn't expect the Government to be sufficiently competent to actually make this work. It's not a good reason to tolerate it but it wouldn't surprise me if it is one.