4 ms·
Humans presumably are seen as sentient yet [the majority of us?] are being exploited in one way or another: Capitalism has no inbuilt concept of respect. If yo
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
Humans presumably are seen as sentient yet [the majority of us?] are being exploited in one way or another: Capitalism has no inbuilt concept of respect.
If you meant not exploited for food, that is obviously different. I'm not aware of any humans that do that anymore.
Now tell me how you judge sentience?
- ImSkeptical 9y agoWhy can't we respect human dignity like those communists who murdered and starved tens of millions of people, ruined economies, and consigned countless people to oppression and deprivation?
- joemi 9y agoCommunism as you're referring to it is not what many supporters of communism (and/or opponents of capitalism) are advocating for.
- announcerman 9y agoAs a citizen of an ex Eastern Bloc country I'd rather not have any other humans co-opt me into another helping of true communism™
- coldtea 9y agoWell, other members of ex Eastern Bloc countries disagree, so?
- announcerman 9y agoWe'll decide in a democratic and respectful manner to not fall for the red plague again. If that was your point.
- coldtea 9y agoHow is a response about what communists did relevant to a critique of capitalism? Except if one can't think of any other alternative or starting point from which to criticize capitalism but communism (and even more so, how some specific regimes practiced it).
- ImSkeptical 9y agoCommunism is the typical alternative to capitalism.
- macintux 9y agoNice but irrelevant. It's like saying "But Hillary!" every time someone offers a critique of Trump.
- ben-schaaf 9y agoBut what about... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- coldtea 9y agoThere are tons of alternatives to capitalism. From anarcho-syndicalism and social democracy, to more obscure religious, environmental and so on approaches.
- MisterBastahrd 9y agoYes, human dignity like those capitalists who drilled giant oil wells in Nigeria, poisoned the land and the people, hired hit squads terrorize the native populace, then fled the country overnight when the regime changed.
- pdx 9y agoI think you're talking about Shell Oil in the 1990's, and their requesting the Nigerian military to help them deal with violent protesters, and allegedly peaceful protesters as well. Yep, that sounds like a problem that needed addressed. That pales compared to the atrocities that have been done in the name of communism. It's frightening that young people have forgotten those lessons, even the oldest of which is less than 100 years ago. The ideal of sacrificing the individual to benefit the group is where communism always ends up, and from there, it's never a long slide to the disappearings, the executions and the starvation. The American ideal of protecting the individual, even at the expense of the group is much more inline with the world I want to live in. Happily, you still end up with a strong group, since it's composed of motivated individuals that feel safe.
- dang 9y agoIdeological boilerplate is not welcome here. Please don't post any more of it. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: this account has been using HN primarily for ideological battle. As the site guidelines say, we ban accounts that do that, so I'm banning this one. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.
- labster 9y agoUgh not this Marxist BS again. This is completely unrelated to the topic at hand. Let's talk about improving animal welfare in this thread and not go into yet another tangent about human political systems.
- freeflight 9y agoIt's really sad how any kind of critique of capitalism, no matter how minor, instantly triggers, the very same and very predictable, knee-jerk responses along the lines of "Communism killed billions!". Like the wonders of capitalism don't kill anybody or like there are only those two choices between capitalism and some Soviet-style centrally planned communism. Which begs the question: Do these people really think we've reached the end of the line in terms of economic systems? I'm asking this question in all seriousness because I'm utterly confused by this lack of imagination/curiosity behind such a mindset.
- nerfhammer 9y agoOptimal allocation of finite time and resources on a society scale is a hard problem. Supposed alternatives to capitalism tend to ignore that. Bad economics of all stripes tends to assume some form betrayal theory as the only issue.
- freeflight 9y ago> Optimal allocation of finite time and resources on a society scale is a hard problem. Agreed > Supposed alternatives to capitalism tend to ignore that. Disagreed, capitalism ignores the finite nature of resources, while treating some of them, which are actually infinite, as finite (time). Also, I'd argue that nothing about the resource allocation, the way capitalism does it, is in any way optimal, at least in regards to our actual finite resources. Most of it boils down to hoarding "money", which isn't a finite resource (can be printed at will) nor is it an actually useful resource on its own (can't do much with it except burn it if it's paper). It's supposed to be a tool, but at this point, it feels like the tool has been declared the goal: Just hoard more of the money and you've "won" the game like it's the ultimate solution to all problems. This dynamic also influences the allocation of resources to most "profitable" of individual entities, it's a dynamic that rewards hostile competition over friendly cooperation. Which is a dangerous reward system considering we are all stuck on the same piece of rock, drifting through infinity, sharing the very same finite resources. Wasting so much energy, and resources on how to "screw each other" over for those finite resources, and increasingly bigger "profits", seems quite wasteful and ultimately a very petty way to go about our existence. I'm not saying I know the ultimate fool-proof solution, I just want to point out the flaws with what we've currently got going and imho these flaws are massive and will come bite us in the back-end sooner or later [0]. [0] https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995 https://www.newyorker.com/cartoon/a16995