4 ms·
Seems awfully unfair to blame Google for what other members of the Open Handset Alliance are doing with Google's GPL code. You either have open code and deal w
by eli 16y ago
Seems awfully unfair to blame Google for what other members of the Open Handset Alliance are doing with Google's GPL code.
You either have open code and deal with people forking it, or you have closed code. It's tough have it both ways.
- alxp 16y agoThat's why I'm mostly fine with iOS being proprietary to Apple. Anyone reselling it would just make it worse by changing it.
- krschultz 16y agoGoogle's code is not GPL. A lot of the problems associated with Android are because it is not GPL and the manufacturers do not have to open up their changes to Android. However, if it was GPL a lot of handset makers would not have adopted Android for exactly that reason. Pick your poison.
- joezydeco 16y agoHaving worked for an OHA company, I can confirm that the alliance was really a 1-way deal. Google got the hordes of subcontractors needed to get the platform going, and in return the companies got to say they were allied with Google and not much else. OHA companies were never in the loop on major design/development issues with Rubin and his team. I can't fault some of the member companies for trying to recapture some of the effort now, HTC being the biggest one of them.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoWhat's strange is the most of the article is begging Google to act like a benevolent dictator and tell the carriers and hardware manufacturers to take a hike if they disagree, then he quotes an article in which someone claims that Google is telling their OHA partners that it's their way or the highway and yet spins this as somehow even worse.