5 ms·
> the tires were designed to handle a sustained temperature of 194 degrees Fahrenheit when traveling at highway speeds between 65-75 mph. In excess of 200 degre
by kevin_thibedeau 9y ago
> the tires were designed to handle a sustained temperature of 194 degrees Fahrenheit when traveling at highway speeds between 65-75 mph. In excess of 200 degrees, the tire ran the risk of tread separations.
Doesn't seem like there was much margin in the design. How was this even allowed to be sold?
- wccrawford 9y agoBecause tires don't usually get that hot? https://www.caranddriver.com/columns/a-look-behind-the-tire-hysteria https://www.caranddriver.com/columns/a-look-behind-the-tire-... >How hot does the tire get? Typical tires experience a temperature increase of roughly 50 degrees after running on the highway for a half-hour. If it's a 70-degree day, this suggests a tire temperature of about 120 degrees. So even at 120 degree weather, you'd only expect the tires to reach 170 degrees. That's still far below the 194 that they're rated for.
- briffle 9y agoThat is for passenger car/ light truck tires. These were much higher load ratings, heavier, and much, much larger. Most are inflated to 75-110 PSI, and each Tire can carry around 3600lbs (at least in the G670 that replaced it)
- cavanasm 9y agoGoodyear had test results indicating the tire would get to 225 degrees or higher when operating at 65-75 mph.
- themacks 9y agoIn 100 degree weather, fairly common in the south, the road surface temperature would be significantly higher, upwards of 150 to 175.
- ChrisLomont 9y agoI cannot find anywhere listing road temperatures nearing 175 F. Do you have a source? Most I find are like this [1], which would allow a max road surface temp at 100F air temp at the equator with the sun directly overhead on a perfectly clear day to reach around 148F. (see equation 17 in the paper). The rest of the literature I have found is similar. I doubt roads in the US south reach 175, and likely not even 150. [1] http://www.ijirae.com/volumes/Vol2/iss8/01.AUAE10083.pdf http://www.ijirae.com/volumes/Vol2/iss8/01.AUAE10083.pdf
- merpnderp 9y agoOn hot days I like to take my laser temp gun and shoot roads and other things, and I've never seen anything over 140F.
- ChrisLomont 9y agoOut of curiosity, what is the hottest background temps you think you've checked in? Any around 100 F ambient?
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoNot parent: >Dr Howard Robinson, chief executive of the Road Surface Treatments Association, says most roads in the UK that experience a reasonable amount of traffic will start softening at 50C. >[...] >And dark road material can absorb a lot of heat. The typical summer ground temperature is higher than air temperature. Robinson says roads "regularly" reach a temperature of 50C and above. (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23315384 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-23315384) // 50 deg C is 122F; but this is UK with air temps of ~30 deg C
- ChrisLomont 9y agoYeah, I read that too. 30C is 86 F. The OP above mentioned a 100 degree day, 14 degrees warmer, and the formula and paper I referenced above would put the surface temp of the road would also only rise 14 degrees, to 136 F on a 100 degree day. The OP claimed 150-175 is common on a 100 degree day. No research I can find (except one single author) is anywhere near that amount.
- venomsnake 9y agoIsn't speed limit 55mph? And doesn't this gives some wiggle room for goodyear - after all the tire was operated outside of the conditions.
- WalterBright 9y agoI just can't see driving an RV at 65-75. It's not a sports car.
- fotbr 9y agoTake I-70 across Kansas. Or I-80 across Nebraska. If you're not doing 75, you'll be run off the road by traffic (including RVs) going much faster. You don't need sports-car maneuverability on big, fairly light-traffic interstates.
- WalterBright 9y agoTake a look at the tires on a sports car, and the tires on an RV. They're very different. It's isn't just the handling, it's their ability to withstand the centrifugal forces and heat from high speed.
- jhayward 9y agoI take it you've never driven in the American west. From San Antonio to El Paso interstate 10 is 550 miles of extremely smooth, well designed divided highway with speed limits of 80 mph for much of the way. There is almost nothing of interest between those two points, esp. if your trip objective is somewhere west. You'd be insane to not run at the maximum safe speed of your vehicle. Many RV trailer tires are only rated to 65 mph, although there are some 80 mph rated ones becoming common because people are so tempted to gain back those extra hours of travel time slowing to 65 involves.
- cryptonector 9y agoWell, you don't want to drive "at the maximum safe speed of your vehicle" all the time. You should want some margin for error. But many many cars sold in the U.S. have maximum safe speeds well in excess of 120mph. As for an RV... driving an RV faster than 70mph seems a bit scary to me, but then, I've never driven one.
- jhayward 9y ago
- cryptonector 9y ago"Because you shouldn't speed!" Of course, that's silly (but you know there will be moralizers ready to say that, often the sort who wouldn't yield the passing lane to speeders). First, we have highways with higher speed limits anyways (up to 85mph in the U.S.). Second, people speed -- our highways and cars are generally designed to tolerate much higher speeds. I have seen caravans of cars drive up the NJ turnpike at speeds in excess of 130mph.