25 ms·
UK mass digital surveillance regime ruled unlawful
- ben_w 9y agoWell that was predictable. Shame the government didn’t listen to people like me who literally told them that while it was still a Bill not an Act.
- dm319 9y agoCan anyone point to countries which are not going down this same route? In my head Europe is doing better with protecting privacy, but maybe that's just an impression. Canada? Not Australia. Japan?
- skrause 9y agoHere is a good overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_surveillance_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_and_survei...
- etiam 9y agoIn principle that's a nice start. I call male bovine excrement on the assessment of Sweden though. Full take collection, installed by and heavily integrated with FVEY, is the gist of it. Describing it as "Little or none" seems like a cynical joke.
- Nition 9y agoIt says there was no collection as of 2009. Has it started since then? The page probably just needs someone to update it.
- ninkendo 9y agoI took one look at that article and the fact that the U.S. is literally painted the same color as China as having an equal amount of internet censorship would be hilarious if it weren’t so egregiously misleading. There’s internet censorship and there’s China. Nobody else is in the same league. The only explanation I can think of is if censorship and surveillance are just being casually lumped together, but people understand that they’re not synonyms, right? Right?
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThey are closely related though. Mass surveillance, and/or the loss of privacy online, has a chilling effect - effectively censorship. Either your government blocks / censors your er, controversial statements, or you're afraid to post your controversial statements because the government is watching you. Same effect.
- ninkendo 9y agoStop creating a false equivalency. China blocks access to anything on the internet that disagrees with their ruling party. They block any VPN or SSH. Like, not just for avoiding filters, just at all. They degrade any encrypted traffic by just doing compression analysis and dropping packets if your traffic looks encrypted. This is not the same thing as the NSA’s dragnet surveillance or anything the UK is doing. China is already at the endgame you are hypothesizing, and you’re creating a false equivalency through a slippery slope. A slope where the bottom is where China is today.
- Sean1708 9y ago> The only explanation I can think of is if censorship and surveillance are just being casually lumped together The chart is literally titled "Internet censorship and surveillance by country (2014)" with categories that don't differentiate between censorship and surveillance, so I'm relatively certain that the two have been lumped together.
- ninkendo 9y agoSure, but that doesn’t imply that there’s an equivalency between the two, or that the grading scale should be course-grained enough to show no difference between the U.S. and China. If I made an article called “human rights violations and numbers of reality tv shows by country” and painted Saudi Arabia and Germany the same color, it should rightly raise some eyebrows.
- Sean1708 9y agoAll I was saying was that you didn't need to speculate, not that it was the right way to present the data.
- mrtksn 9y agoIf I remember correctly, Europe relies on US to spy on it's people so technically they are not spying on their own people. Personally, I find it unrealistic to expect that such huge opportunity(almost by the second log of citizens activities and opinions as well as precise control of who sees and hears what) will arise and the people in power will not exploit it. China is taking a more direct route but in general it looks like the political elite's dreams are about to come true on global scale. edit: HN really hated that idea :) I could not find the source of the claim but it makes sense to me.
- olavk 9y ago> Europe relies on US to spy on it's people so technically they are not spying on their own people. Where on earth did you get this idea? Are you suggesting European countries does not have police or intelligence agencies performing surveillance?
- mrtksn 9y agoI'm not suggesting that. The idea is that if a country can't do mass surveillance on it's own people due to political reasons, still can just let an ally do it and get that information from that ally as a part of information sharing agreement.
- simias 9y agoI can believe that it happens in some cases but I doubt it would make a lot of sense to do it for the mass surveillance of the population, if only because it would also make it extremely easy to do large scale industrial espionage. I'm pretty sure Germany wouldn't want the USA to have access to all of its trade and industrial secrets for instance. At least I would require a better source than "if I remember correctly" in order to be convinced.
- mrtksn 9y agoIt doesn't have to be binary. Sure they wouldn't want to let USA complete access, so they can spend their time keeping the US espionage on the desired domain and everyone happy and politicians elected.
- tonylemesmer 9y agoThe article makes it sound a little like rights are respected if the controls are to be put in place. However, bulk collection is still going to carry on is it not?
- mabbo 9y agoI know of very few British MPs, being a Canadian who watches occasionally British panel shows, but I do hear about Tom Watson fairly frequently and almost always for things I am in favor of. Now here he is championing the fight against mass surveillance as well. British folks: is this guy eventually going to replace Corbyn? He seems likeable enough to. And he has a sense of humor- the first time I heard of him was when he was doing comedy bits with Five Second Films[0]. [0]https://youtu.be/Z4oNjTuTz-8 https://youtu.be/Z4oNjTuTz-8
- stuaxo 9y agoHe was handily at Glastonbury during one of the biggest anti-Corbyn plots, that many say he had a hand in.
- crdoconnor 9y agoNo. He aligns with the deeply unpopular Blairite wing of the party and has spent an awful lot of time and effort trying to undermine Corbyn. This is good though. He should stick to doing stuff like this.
- beaconstudios 9y agoyou say that like undermining Corbyn is an objectively bad thing. He's an extremely divisive element of the current Labour party and the primary reason why I (and I consider myself a liberal first and foremost) cannot support the current Labour leadership. Labour's always been a mix of liberals and socialists but in my opinion Corbyn is too far to the latter to ever unify the party behind his ideas.
- crdoconnor 9y agoHe's divisive among a lot of the MPs especially the ones who came in under Blair because of his policies. By historical standards they're soft-left but they're to the left of the overton window so he's "extreme". The members, most of whom are disgusted with establishment politics and neoliberal dogma are about 90% behind him though. Enough new members were inspired to join by him that they now have the largest membership of any party in Europe. Anti-establishmentarianisn is only natural given the failure of the status quo to deliver egalitarian growth and freedom. You can have it from mild liberals like him or the far right. Either way the days of the dominant neoliberal era are numbered.
- Quarrelsome 9y agoBiggest problem IMO with this is that they left the data collection and storage to each ISP individually without any support. This results in a large surface area for security failure and the inevitable leak of this data into the public domain. I wrote my MP with these concerns but they wanted it on the cheap and forced it through. I don't like that they're storing the data in general as even if they centralised it and secured it properly it'd still probably leak but they've more or less chosen the worst approach on top of recording information that they shouldn't be recording in the first place. Also its linked to billing account which is a lossy way to deriving who is actually looking at what and begs the question: "do you actually know what websites your children are visiting?". Because now those sites come up as places YOU (the bill payer) are going to. I'm looking forward to the "scandal" when MPs are "found" to visiting dubious sites when its really someone else in their household. and everyone going anywhere vaguely dark with half-decent tech knowledge just switches to VPN undermining the whole premise. My MP was _very_ interested in that bit without realising that even if you close that loop hole we just invent another.
- nickjackson 9y agoYep. TalkTalk can't even keep their customers key details secure, and now they are expected to keep browser history as well? It's a joke. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/talktalk-fine-data-breach-theft-customers-information-stolen-record-penalty-a7346316.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/talktalk-fin...
- matt4077 9y agoThe judges invoked EU privacy laws, so I guess this one of those cases of „the yoke of Brüssel imperialism“ that the UK may soon(ish) be liberated from.
- benevol 9y agoWhat we have learned thanks to Snowden is this: You can never trust your government. Mass surveillance was conducted illegally before and continues to this day. Does anyone really think some "law" will change this?
- iamben 9y agoI agree. But that doesn't mean we should make it legal, and, as per the snooper's charter, relax who has access to it. I'm glad we still have people fighting for us.
- benevol 9y ago> I'm glad we still have people fighting for us. Absolutely. We should just not forget that it is not a law or any other promise from government officials that will protect us from mass surveillance.
- gnocchi 9y agoGood point, but if we can't rely on the law to help us what will be left? I wonder if one can make a request for information (Freedom of Information Act) about data personally held from the government?
- Beltiras 9y agoThere were cases in the States where a defendant tried to subpoena records from the meta-data collection saying it would exonerate him from the accusation. I can't find how the motion was ruled on with some light Googling. Anyone remember?
- krapp 9y ago> Good point, but if we can't rely on the law to help us what will be left? The only options remaining, when you can't trust the laws or the systems that create the laws, are attrition (pervasive encryption and decentralizing of networks to deny governments access to information coupled with aggressive leaking and whistleblowing to limit their effectiveness), violence (which serves the interests of authoritarians and extremists) or acceptance of the status quo.
- listentojohan 9y agoI'm not exactly convinced this will change anything. It's the same for Denmark, and even though it was also ruled unlawful, it just continues. They are even planning on expanding it, and sharing data across public inst. without approval.
- nkkollaw 9y agoWhat is the real reason behind surveillance? The government(s)'s excuse is terrorism, but terrorism in Europe doesn't kill a big enough amount of people to justify these drastic measures. I would argue also that no one has proven that it's efficient at preventing terrorist attacks. There must be a reason, I don't get it. Is it just because governments can, so they do it? It is to create the basis for some initiative that is planned for the future when technology improves..?
- 7952 9y agoIt is possible that surveillance really is useful in preventing terrorism. And it would seem cheaper and easier to do than human intelligence.
- atom_enger 9y agoSo if you disagree with them they can deal with you one way or another? I've always thought that was the real reason: to dissuade dissidence.
- nkkollaw 9y agoBut is it true, though..?
- turc1656 9y agoI've always thought this as well. They can more effectively control the population and also get "dirt" on anyone they want. There's pretty much no one on this planet who hasn't said or done something they aren't proud of, don't want public, don't want their spouse to know, is mildly illegal (but which could then be vigorously prosecuted once they are a target), etc. etc. I think it's for the Donald Trump scenario - if an "outsider" tries to enter the political arena to gain power they can crush that person using all the available tools in their arsenal. Regardless of how you feel about Trump, he was able to combat that because he was already rich and famous. No regular human being could rise to power without the approval of the existing political elite. Mass surveillance is just one tool they use to maintain that power.
- turc1656 9y ago"Yet again a UK court has ruled the government’s extreme mass surveillance regime unlawful. This judgement tells ministers in crystal clear terms that they are breaching the public’s human rights." So the question then remains...where are the handcuffs?! I ask this question constantly when it comes to government wrongdoing and there is almost never anyone charged with anything. If the government has been acting in a manner that has been found in a court of law to violate human rights, then multiple people should be going to jail. Before you drop the "well now we know for sure - we shouldn't be punitive and punish people who thought they were doing their job properly" crap, think about this. Whenever the government applies a law in a new and untested way against a civilian the case is watched very closely and if that civilian is found guilty they never get the benefit of the "well it's been settled and now we know" argument and get let off lightly. So I argue the same should apply here. The government has grossly violated the rights of citizens on a mass scale and everyone at the top of the food chain involved in these programs should be rotting in a jail cell.
- rocqua 9y agoBecause those who wrote the law have cover from parliament passing the law. Who would we be cuffing? Those who drafted the law? Or maybe those who whipped party members into line to vote for the law? In my opinion, people drafting illegal laws is to be expected. It is the responsibility of parliament and the house of lords to keep illegal laws from being enacted. So if we were to cuff anyone, it seems to me it ought to be parliament. For parliament we have a different measure than the courts though. That would be elections! It seems less that wise for the public prosecutor to be able to target members of parliament for how they voted. The solution should be sought in a better democracy. An underlying issue here might be that a majority of voter would actually like to see the constitutional basis for this ruling changed. The Brexit vote could be seen as supporting this. If indeed the electorate wants to get rid of this, there is very little to be done. And that is how a democracy is kind of supposed to work. Sometimes, this makes democracies suck. But like Churchill said, democracy is the worst form of government except for all the other forms we've tried.
- shaki-dora 9y agoNot all trials are criminal. In fact, the vast majority are civil. To expose elected politicians to criminal liability would completely stymie them: laws are routinely struck down for all sorts of reasons, and it would be almost impossible for a single parliamentarian (who usually has a staff of two or three, max) to foresee all challenges. I know this "Snooper's Charter" evokes strong feelings, which makes it a bad example. The courts also have enough power already to make their judgements stick. Roe v. Wade made abortion legal in the US, and it didn't take any jail sentences to make that right a reality, even though roughly 40% of the population are vehemently opposed. To see a particularly crass example that comes close to your fantasy, see Joe Arpaio, one of the very few politicians to actually defy a court long enough to be convicted of criminal charges.
- ahamedirshad123 9y agoAadhaar in India, hopefully!
- goombastic 9y agoAadhaar in India is far worse. 99% of the data has leaked multiple times already. It also seems to sport all the classic signs of an amateur project. Post facto design changes, unauthenticated mails, unprofessional mobile apps, leaky access to all of the data irrespective of your need, terrible code (same hard coded passwords for everyone), cludgy design increments making the problems worse while not acknowledging existing issues, logical errors (like beign unable to reset passwords if you have lost mobile device) and the deaths of people unable to access hospitals and food in some areas, Police cases against people reporting on vulnerabilities, ... ... It's a kafkaesque nightmare and I am surprised no one mentions it on HN much. Probably because it's a slow motion train wreck. I am not sure how the Indian courts are even going to justify continuing with the system anymore given the absolutely callous handling of the data thus far by their Aadhaar agency. In the end, India's aadhaar is actually not a government project, it is a private project run by a bunch of companies run by some ex infosys top shots who have time and again proven to only look after their own interests.
- ahamedirshad123 9y agoFunny thing is NRIs, who don't have to enroll, are writing opinions to defend this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- evilmoo 9y agoOh no, now the government won't have access to my browsing history. Apart from GCHQ as part of TEMPORA & NSA as part of UPSTREAM.
- TorKlingberg 9y ago> The three judges said Dripa was “inconsistent with EU law” because of this lack of safeguards, including the absence of “prior review by a court or independent administrative authority”. I imagine the government knows exactly how to take care of the pesky little problem of EU law giving people rights.
- mtgx 9y ago> The court of appeal ruling on Tuesday said the powers in the Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act 2014, which paved the way for the snooper’s charter legislation, did not restrict the accessing of confidential personal phone and web browsing records to investigations of serious crime, and allowed police and other public bodies to authorise their own access without adequate oversight. This was such a massive power grab by the authoritarians like Theresa May and David Cameron and they were so transparent about it. Of course such powers should never be allowed in any democrat. But they thought they'd get away with it anyway, because "people don't care about privacy". But this is going to end up badly for UK citizens if they're allowed to operate mass surveillance at a policeman's or taxman's level.
- 23443463454 9y agoThis is going to be interesting. I am sure this will not be popular here, but reality and the truth far more often are so than not. The "elite", power brokers, wealthy ... however you want to refer to those who actuate the levers of power ... have been working diligently to shatter and fracture democracy by importing and imposing foreigners upon their populations that are inherently incompatible and introduce conflict and disassembly of unified identity and common interest. The idea was to substitute community and common interest that have presented a clear opposition to the elite through the middle class that it produced, and substituting state, i.e., elite ruled instruments of power and state control, as the common glue in a shift away from self-motivated cohesion towards state imposed cohesion. The whole plan is and was heavily reliant on a massive surveillance state, the very same kind you have heard of in all the past and current authoritarian and totalitarian regimes, e.g., Mugabe, Saddam, Gaddafi, China, Indonesia, Sauds, etc. When you have shattered the self-motivated and self-interested bond that keeps a people organized and cohesive, you then introduce a poison pill that will and is inherently shattering democracy as intended, which will then require heavy handed control by an elite that will invariably become ever more authoritarian and eventually totalitarian.
- codeisawesome 9y agoThis does not explain homogenous societies ruled by autocracies of various descriptions.
- 23443463454 9y agoActually, when you realize that the end goal is full control of society the same way that the very autocracies you mention have retained, it very much explains it. What I described is a method and/or technique for shattering and fracturing the current state where the middle class holds exceptional control over the elite that, let's be honest, has been an anomaly in human history at this point. What you are describing is a state that those very "homogenous societies ruled by autocracies of various description" you are referring to have no need to enact or reestablished. As you point out, they already have control of such a condition. What I was describing is a means to an end, not the end itself. The elite don't care today any more about whether the population they desire to lord over is diverse or not, any more than they did in the past, when, e.g., Europe was little more than an extremely high stakes game of Survivor or business gamesmanship. The autocratic regimes already have autocratic control over their societies in a way that the globalist elite desire more than anything. They have no need to enact creative strategies in order to fragment and shatter the impediment to their reinstatement of their desired end state of elite control again. Reality is that the elite see an opportunity to arrest control from that dastardly middle class that has kept them from their desired state of full control akin to those very elite all throughout the rest of the world. They are at a point where they will have none of it anymore ... especially as they see the elite of those very autocratic regimes blow past them in wealth and power and control, while they have to scrape their wealth together by earning it from the middle class. For thousands of years, the elite of all societies have ruled with impunity and only the American Revolution imposed a stunning blow that set off a cycle and state of decline of that condition, which has persisted to this point to some degree. The state of modern democracy for the last ~250 years and only in a few countries, is merely a blip in the overall history of human society that has overwhelmingly been not democratic at all for thousands of years. If you look closely, past the propaganda and into the pragmatics and practical issues, you will start realizing that what things like "immigration" and "diversity" really are, is an invalidation and fracturing and deconstruction of democracy itself, the control of the government by the governed to enact self-determination and liberty and control over their own lives. If the citizens of a country are not able to even be prioritized over those who are not citizens, let alone enact principles of democracy under self-governance, then what is it, because it is not democracy and not even a legitimate government on those terms. We are being led into an era that is arresting control from the vast majority of humanity. I dread the anguish that will come when a generation in the near future starts realizing what this generation did as they were being led around by the nose to their own detriment. It's quite lamentable, even more so when you realize that the governed are acting against democracy out of an unawareness that they are being lured and conned with promises of socialist/communist/free candy for all, head long into elite/powerful control. Unfortunately for humanity, once you have given away control over your life, it will only be regained through extreme suffering and sacrifice, if at all. The conditions leading up to and surrounding the American Revolution make it a rather unique set of circumstances. It seems unlikely that such conditions could ever be recreated again unless it were on some other planet and under conditions that weaken the otherwise overwhelming power long enough for a democracy to sufficiently strengthen itself.
- tastythrowaway 9y agoCan we get some of this for the US? Asking for a friend.
- therealmarv 9y agoBrexit, problem solved, everything legal for the UK government.