5 ms·
If narcissism is something that has penetrated the popular consciousness as being an "epidemic", then perhaps surveys are showing less narcissism because people
by perl4ever 9y ago
If narcissism is something that has penetrated the popular consciousness as being an "epidemic", then perhaps surveys are showing less narcissism because people have been trained to answer the survey in a way that minimizes the recognized markers.
Certain younger people I know seem to be obsessed with the concept of narcissists being the root of all evil, and defending millennials as a generation from charges of various faults. It seems weird to me because nobody I knew talked in this way about Generation X or mental disorders when I was at a similar age. I suspect the internet and optimized clickbait of reaching some sort of critical mass that may be interfering with the mental functioning of people who would otherwise be reasonably sanguine about the world.
The more people worry about narcissism, the more I would expect them to conceal anything indicative on a survey.
A screed I read on the internet many years ago about narcissism was written by a guy who self-identified as such, and the overriding impression I got was that his issue was vast and malignant self-hatred, to the point where I didn't really believe he was as horrible as he claimed. I was unable to tell whether he resembled the "canonical" narcissist, whatever that might be. It made me wonder if a narcissist can be self aware or not, by definition.
I think the use of surveys to define and monitor mental disorders is a morass of confusion and misunderstandings.
- hoopladler 9y agoAs a fairly young guy, I think a lot of the fallout over narcissism is really a kind of sublimated culture shift. Before about 1975, unemployment was typically under 5%, and underemployment or precarious employment was far more rare. Social safety nets (for white people, at least) existed and were strong. University wasn't terribly expensive, and the chances of getting a job that delivered an acceptable standard of life was really quite high. This meant that, with their basic needs essentially met, generations born before a certain point tended to concern themselves with ideas like self-growth, fulfillment, and personal goals. Between 1975 and 2008, those concerns became increasingly displaced by survival-level thinking, as unemployment ticked steadilly up, and jobs generally grew more time-consuming, and less well paid, while commodities and rents of all kinds increased. I think for a lot of young people, there's a kind of fallacious misidentification between the concerns of older generations, and narcissism. To obsess over abstract personal concerns to the point that basic needs are not met is narcissitic - and if somebody of a generation that went into the workplace following 2008 obsessed over personal concerns to the degree that the older generations do, it would absolutely impact their abillity to cater to their basic needs. However, because older generations are typically in a good financial situation, having profited both from the pre-80's social contract, and often, from its disassembly - it's not at all narcissitic to care about personal concerns! It's absolutely rational - they aren't going to become homeless if they decide to go on a buddhist retreat, or engage in a messy divorce, or start a new career. Narcissism gets picked out as a culprit since it's a way to both categorically assert that a different way of life is wrong, and equally, to lay the blame for the current situation at the feat of our proximate frustrators - the boss, the mentor, the parent.
- rdiddly 9y agoI dunno if I buy the separation of "survival concerns" and "personal concerns." There are narcissistic ways of responding to survival concerns. In fact some responses are more advantageous in meeting those concerns than the less-narcissistic responses.
- Bucephalus355 9y agoI really appreciated your post. There is a trend I notice where current generations use the strategy of the last generation in order to live their lives. In a sense, they’re using strategies / ways of thinking that are often 30 years out of date. Since narcissism is such a well known issue now, I wonder if in the future there will be a “crisis of conformity” like there was in the 50’s? Maybe going to Law School will be considered a sound investment, or the mid-west will once again be the place to live. It makes you wonder if it’s all an endless cycle of old trend, new trend, countertrend, and so on.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoYes, art works this way, too. Everything is a reaction to a reaction. We're constantly trying to find balance - rarely achieving it on an individual level, likely never achieving it on a societal level. *perfect balance
- gt_ 9y agoI agree. I just feel like elaborating on my understanding of this. And, as in art, success requires a mix of past combined with strategic changes to what is understood of the current contextual state, which is dependent on individual conscience for accuracy, or enlightenment. Societies do not have a conscience beyond the sum of individuals who influence it’s character. Once they become influential, they establish behaviors that resemble ‘lack of conscience’ as a norm. Although individuals acknowledge the narcissistic norms, gaining influence requires conformity with them. It takes a keen and educated bunch to break the trend, hence an Enlightenment.
- c8d3f7b49897918 9y ago
- lwhi 9y agoI agree .. A narcissist is obviously going to be very aware of the way they're being perceived, and will put a lot of effort in to positively affect that perception. If they admitted to narcissistic traits .. they'd be failing. Maybe the aurvey needs to assume narcissist aren't going to self-identify?