13 ms·
How Apple Built a Chip Powerhouse to Threaten Qualcomm and Intel
- masklinn 9y agoThe SoC timeline is not uninteresting but it's lacking at least one of the major events: Apple switching from ARM-licensed to internally designed cores with the A6. It should also outline the A7 more, that wasn't just Apple's first 64b SoC, it was an industry-wide-first of shipping 64b cores in a product, that took the industry very much by surprise (64b products were planned for 12~24 months down the line before that IIRC). These are the events which genuinely placed Apple on a serious footing as a chip designer, the A4 was Apple-branded but only a preparatory step. The essay also lacks other silicon acquisition of Apple, like Intrinsity, whose work actually showed up as early as the A4 (before it was acquired). It's also oddly padding the timeline with X-variants.
- dave84 9y agoThe opening paragraph also glosses over the fact that some of Apple's chips are also vulnerable to Meltdown and Spectre.
- nialljudedev 9y agoYeah, it's vague at best on the detail.
- masklinn 9y agoI'd missed that, but you're perfectly correct. It's also stating that Apple could topple Qualcomm… despite Apple not selling to third parties, the only way that'd happen is if they obtained a complete monopoly on the smartphone market. I don't see either happen.
- zimpenfish 9y agoTheoretically, if the premium brand smartphone dropped Qualcomm and managed to make a go of it, that does put a lot of pressure on them and, perhaps, encourages others to do the same (Samsung, for example.)
- rwmj 9y agoIf Qualcomm sits around and does nothing. However Qualcomm are competing for the nascent ARM server market with the (incredible IMO) Amberwing, and Qualcomm would still have 50%+ of the mobile market for selling their modems and Snapdragons to fund development.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- simonh 9y agoThe BBC News breaking article on Meltdown and Spectre was hilarious. The title was something along the lines of "Apple phones have bug", then in a paragraph down near the end it noted that oh, by the way, almost all chips used everywhere by everyone are also affected.
- servitor 9y agoApple were one of the last of the major companies to come out with a statement regarding Meltdown and Spectre. The BBC articles for Intel and the rest were written a day or so earlier.
- digi_owl 9y agoWell media production orgs have a massive myopia for Apple tech, so it would not surprise me...
- servitor 9y agoI think the A7 being the first 6-wide core in the mobile space was far more important than the fact it was 64 bit. That gave it unprecedented single threaded performance and competitors are struggling to keep pace on that front to this day, despite them also being 64 bit for several generations now.
- cedivad 9y agoWhats a 6-wide core?
- masklinn 9y agoFetched & decoded instructions per cycle. Parent is wrong though, the A7 has 3-wide cores (and dual-core like previous chips)
- servitor 9y agoThe Cyclone core has 6 decoders. It can decode, rename and retire up to 6 instructions per cycle[1]. [1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/7910/apples-cyclone-microarchitecture-detailed https://www.anandtech.com/show/7910/apples-cyclone-microarch...
- ethbro 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superscalar_processor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superscalar_processor
- simonh 9y agoIt's true that 64-bit wasn't as big a difference in terms of performance or user facing features, but it was an utter humiliation for the rest of the industry. Nobody could pretend that Apple was not way ahead of everyone else in terms of chip design capability and design sophistication. Right up to that point Samsung and Qualcom had been telling everyone they had all the experience and Apple was a newbie at this chip design stuff that didn't know what it was doing. All of a sudden they were faced with the reality. If they could do 64 bit a year before anyone else, they could do anything a year before anyone else. They could ship working products that other teams barely had on the drawing board, which means nobody could reasonably predict anything they could do next. How can you design a flagship phone for next year to compete with them, when you have no clue what features are even possible for them to have? That's what it brought to the table.
- tooltalk 9y agoAll Apple A series chips were branded as theirs although it was fairly clear that prior to the A6, all A series chips were designed and manufactured by Samsung. The A4 chip was also designed by Samsung (and Intrinsity in collaboration) to compete with Qualcomm and go beyond the 1Ghz clock speed barrier. Bloomberg also seems to think that the A4 was Apple's first processor designed in-house, when Intrinsity was not part of Apple. So I'd like to know how much of Apple's own engineering went into the design of the A4, that wasn't Samsung or Intrinsity.
- TokyoKid 9y ago"But Apple is just good at marketing"
- dang 9y agoWe've banned this account for posting too many unsubstantive comments. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gchadwick 9y agoI have only skimmed the article but two things jump out: > Recently the company got a fresh incentive to go all-in on silicon: revelations that microprocessors with components designed by Intel Corp., Arm Holdings Plc and Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. are vulnerable to hacking. Apple isn't immune: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208394 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208394 (indeed seems iOS devices suffer from Meltdown where AMD devices do not). > The result: a chip powerhouse that could one day threaten the dominance of Qualcomm Inc. and even, eventually, Intel. Surely to threaten dominance Apple needs to start selling it's chips to other people? Whilst it's possible it would run counter to the way Apple likes to do things, namely get as much in house a possible to get maximum control and seamless vertical integration, they've never shown any interest in selling bits of their technology to others (well recently anyway).
- m_mueller 9y agoWould IMO totally make sense in markets where they cannot loose anything, like servers, workstations and PCs. Question is whether Apple has what it takes to disrupt completely new markets (with their current management).
- rahoulb 9y agoI would suggest Apple has absolutely no interest in those markets. Even when Steve Jobs had been fired, Apple was focussed on products for the end-user, not components for others to assemble from.
- PopePompous 9y agoThey might have trouble selling their chips. They optimize far more towards performance over price than Qualcomm does. Apple can afford to do that, because of its high profit margins. Potential buyers probably couldn't afford that tradeoff.
- jagger27 9y agoThe only market I can think of where higher prices wouldn't be as much of an issue is the server market. Imagine that. High density, Apple designed, ARM SOCs for servers. Or maybe they'll bring back Xserve.
- Shivetya 9y agoI am not worried but instead welcome the integration of their chips to protect the integrity of my machine's data from hackers or even government agencies. That I fully support and expect to see. I do seriously doubt they will move away from an Intel compatible platform, at most if they did then perhaps AMD chips. If Apple took their Macs away from Intel compatibility I doubt I would buy a new one and it would put into question the ability to maintain what software library that exists for the platform.
- technofiend 9y ago>If Apple took their Macs away from Intel compatibility I doubt I would buy a new one and it would put into question the ability to maintain what software library that exists for the platform. I'm not sure there's much reason to be that tied to the chip anymore... When you load up MariaDB on your Fedora box the commands to install it and run your software are identical whether it's Intel or ARM. Apple of all people just like (for example) the Linux community are perfectly capable of writing device drivers for each processor architecture and once that work is done really what else makes a MacOS machine on ARM vs Intel any different than a Linux distribution found on multiple architectures? Particularly since Apple focus so heavily on positive customer experience I can't help but feel they'll make it as painless as possible. Most likely it's not a concern at all.
- slantyyz 9y ago>> I'm not sure there's much reason to be that tied to the chip anymore... How about virtualization? Desktop virtual machine software seems to be a pretty healthy industry on Mac.
- jsjohnst 9y agoApple already provides a hypervisor framework (and has previous experience with Rosetta), it’s not beyond reason that they could solve that issue themselves.
- Anarch157a 9y ago
- antr 9y agoI can only hope for Apple to revive the Mac Mini, or the " Bring Your Own Display, Keyboard and Mouse" concept. I think there is a (small) market for Apple, but it is also a way bring new users into the Mac ecosystem (although the iPhone/iPad do this). I want a small, but affordable Mac to have as a backup and toy around... and as a Mac user, the Mac Mini was perfect. I'll cross my fingers.
- georgespencer 9y agoiPad is converging on this space IMO.
- alsetmusic 9y agoTim Cook supposedly confirmed that a new Mac mini is in the works by way of email: > I'm glad you love the Mac mini. We love it too. Our customers have found so many creative and interesting uses for the Mac mini. While it is not time to share any details, we do plan for Mac mini to be an important part of our product line going forward. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/10/the-mac-mini-isnt-dead-yet-says-tim-cook/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/10/the-mac-mini-isnt-de...
- whywhywhywhy 9y agoMaybe it's just the mishmash of corporate speak but that statement says the exact opposite to me.
- freehunter 9y agoMaybe I'm just more used to corporate speak, but "we can't share details yet but this product will be important to us in the future" couldn't be more clear in indicating that a redesign is in progress and they're not dropping the line.
- whywhywhywhy 9y agoThink my point is more what would Tim Cook say if he didn't care about the Mac Mini at all going forward? I feel it would be similar to that statement. It hasn't been updated in 3 years and the phrasing he used didn't mention "future" just "an important part of our product line going forward." which is pretty non-committal IMHO
- ENOTTY 9y ago> Apple has wisely focused on designing its silicon (for its system on a chips, Apple uses reference designs from Arm Holdings Plc). I was under the impression that the current A cores are not reference designs from ARM... That it was a purely Apple-designed core implementing the ARM ISA. Am I mistaken or is the article mistaken?
- JoachimS 9y agoApple is one of very few companies that has an ISA license. This allows them to implement the ARM ISAs using their own microarchitecture and physical implementation. Digital was afaik the first ISA licensee, which allowed them to design the StrongARM. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StrongARM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/StrongARM StrongARM ended up at Intel when they bought Digital. The design team for StrongARM split up into two companies: SiByte and Alchemy. The design work i in SV on StrongARM was lead by Daniel W. Dobberpuhl. Daniel was cofounder of SiByte and (more relevant) founder of PA-Semi. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_W._Dobberpuhl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_W._Dobberpuhl https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P.A._Semi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P.A._Semi PA-Semi was a fabless company that designed really powerful and power efficient CPU cores based on the Power (PA) architecture. PA-Semi was really good at both architecture, but also physical design for low power. PA-Semi was acquired by Apple in 2008 (as mentioned in the article. Boutique chip maker is an interesting phrase btw). PA-Semi basically became the processor design team at Apple. Looking at the timeline, the first A-series CPU (A4) was released in 2010 which would be possible for the PA-Semi team to have developed. (If my understanding of the history is correct.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dfox 9y agoSmall correction: Intel didn't buy Digital, but got StrongARM with it's design team (and IIRC some tangentially related products like 21152) as part of settlement of some kind of patent dispute. Also of note is that Success of HTC is to some extent also coming from DEC and it's StrongARM reference platforms (mainly Itsy) which Compaq then commercialized as iPaq which was manufactured by HTC (with pressumably HTC-designed "HTC ASIC" which contained most of the various PDA-specific glue required for StrongARM).
- currysausage 9y agoI'm surprised they don't mention Jim Keller, the engineer who designed the A4/A5 chips, as well as the AMD Zen and K8 (Athlon 64) microarchitectures: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Keller_(engineer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Keller_(engineer)
- walterbell 9y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-30/google-is-designing-more-in-house-phone-chips-to-take-on-apple https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-01-30/google-is... "Google officially closed its $1.1 billion deal with HTC Corp., adding more than 2,000 smartphone specialists in Taiwan to help the search giant chase Apple Inc. in the cut-throat premium handset market. The deal will help Google design more of its own consumer hardware and could set it up to wade deeper into special-purpose chips -- like Apple. Google’s most recent Pixel model came with a new image processor to improve the device’s camera. More of this "custom silicon" will come in the future, Google’s hardware chief Rick Osterloh said in an interview."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- beaker52 9y agoI feel like this article is just an advert for Apple - in the wake of the recent processor flaws we've collectively suffered.
- nickpsecurity 9y agoI wonder if this all started with Apple buying the company behind this PowerPC processor: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PWRficient https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PWRficient I rarely see that company mentioned when people talk about Apple getting into hardware. What I dont know if it's because they were uninvolved in ARM-related stuff done later or just not well known.