7 ms·
MPEG: A crisis, the causes and a solution
- clouddrover 9y ago> AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies I don't think is correct. The driver for innovation in video compression technologies will continue to be the practical problems of encoding and distributing video. The quest for smaller video file sizes while maintaining quality is what has driven the development of VP8 to VP9 and now to AV1. Smaller video file sizes directly help reduce the costs of companies like Google, Amazon, Netflix, Hulu, Apple, etc. and I don't see that changing any time soon. There will be an AV2 eventually.
- gok 9y agoSure a company might want to fund development of a proprietary way to reduce their costs but why would they want to make that available to their competitors in a global standard for free?
- Jonnax 9y agoSo they can get adoption in the market? For example you need hardware acceleration for it to be a feasible alternative on mobile.
- clouddrover 9y agoBecause they need their video to play on other company's devices. Netflix and Google want to use AV1. To make the best use of it they want it supported on as many phones, TVs, computers, tablets, etc. as possible. This "coopetition" is good for everyone.
- sigstoat 9y agothey need good decoders, and acceptable encoders to be free, to spur adoption. they can try to keep an advantage by not releasing their most cutting edge encoder.
- trothamel 9y agoAren't the browser vendors the gatekeepers here? As long as there are browsers that are given away for free, the decoders would be have to be made also. And if the browsers refuse to add a decoder unless encoding is also patent-free, then we have free codecs.
- gsnedders 9y ago> As long as there are browsers that are given away for free, the decoders would be have to be made also. Or have major platforms (realistically, Windows, macOS, iOS, and Android) ship decoders at the platform level, and have them ubiquitous enough. This is, ultimately, how we got H.264 decoders commonplace in browsers. That said, Firefox held out for a long time with H.264, and only once it was clear it was costing them users did they give in and add H.264 to the whitelisted platform codecs exposed.
- lawl 9y ago> That said, Firefox held out for a long time with H.264, and only once it was clear it was costing them users did they give in and add H.264 to the whitelisted platform codecs exposed. But even then MPEG (LA) didn't really make any money out of that because IIRC they pulled a hack where Cisco is providing a decoder binary, which they distribute. But the license fee has a cap which cisco was already almost at anyways, so that didn't cost cisco much. Then they have (had planned?) reproducible compilation. So the decoder is open source, but you're not allowed to ship a binary that hasn't been compiled by cisco, but you can always verify the binary cisco provides matches the source code, as the resulting binary will be exactly the same if your compile it yourself. Cisco essentially sponsored an open-source royalty-free decoder here. So yeah, they gave in, but MPEG got nothing from them. Good. Fuck MPEG LA.
- clouddrover 9y ago> IIRC they pulled a hack where Cisco is providing a decoder binary OpenH264 is only used for WebRTC and, importantly, there's no AAC support (which doesn't matter for WebRTC because you can just use Opus). Firefox uses the OS platform's H.264 decoder for video element playback. > which cisco was already almost at anyways, so that didn't cost cisco much It apparently cost Cisco quite a lot more in licensing fees but they considered it worth it for the sake of integration with their video conferencing hardware. See the comments to this blog post from Monty Montgomery for some discussion on it: https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html?thread=439550#cmt439550 https://xiphmont.dreamwidth.org/61694.html?thread=439550#cmt...
- nitwit005 9y agoBecause a lot of companies pay costs on products they don't control. A company like Netflix generally has to store their movie files in multiple different formats to support all the various different devices that are out there. If they want to improve the format, they need everyone else on board.
- guelo 9y agoYes. This is the lie of software patents. That somehow without thousands of lawyers and corrupt business contracts engineers will stop innovating. We don't need them.
- ryandrake 9y agoIt's the lie of intellectual property in general: Without a way to own ideas and inventions, and control how others use them, nobody will invent or create new ideas.
- Ace17 9y agoThe actual lie of "intellectual property" is that such a thing exists at all.
- rayiner 9y agoIn many areas, engineers need to get paid to innovate. Dating back to at least the standardization of CD-ROM, that was mediated through the use of patents. Note that until recently, there was almost no open source development of media codecs. Today, there is an advertising and entertainment industry generating huge surpluses that can also bankroll engineers to develop codecs. I’m not convinced that this is a better model.
- vetinari 9y ago> Note that until recently, there was almost no open source development of media codecs. Vorbis was released in 2002. That's 16 years ago. That's hardly 'until recently'.
- icebraining 9y agoAlso FLAC and Musepack, which I think are even older. Plus for video, Theora's initial release was in 2004.
- 9y ago
- genericpseudo 9y agoThis means that codec development makes no sense for anyone who doesn't own either a large distribution platform or a large playback platform. (Much of the research has been done by middleware companies attempting to tax the two; their business goes from royalties to work-for-hire, at best, which is way less attractive for them). This is fine – in a macroeconomic sense – but of course it sucks if you're one of the companies being disrupted.
- didibus 9y agoWouldn't academic research still persist? Or has that also moved to a can't patent or profit from it, no interest in furthering research mindset?
- wahern 9y agoBy that logic Free Software wouldn't exist, not to mention codecs like Vorbis. The logic of software patents systematically underestimates the existing incentive structures. That's because of the simplifications economists usually make. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assume_a_can_opener https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assume_a_can_opener) The assumptions underlying patents become less justifiable as 1) the pace of innovation in an industry increases, compounding first-mover advantage; 2) complexity increases, because integration of an invention into a viable product becomes much more difficult--often such that copyright and other IP protections alone are more than sufficient to provide a moat; 3) as financing becomes cheaper and potential markets larger the time horizon for and amount of ROI demanded by investors diminishes; Those are especially applicable to many modern high-technology industries, software (Silicon Valley) and industrial (SpaceX). Other industries have proven to be able to thrive without strong patent protections or even copyright protections for myriad other reasons. The fashion industry has thrived without strong patent or copyright protections, largely based on trademark and marketing. Likewise for the beverage industry and consumer foodstuffs more generally. Major automakers had poor copyright protections, and while they had stronger patent protections, as safety regulations increased they shifted to a market segmentation model such that the big auto manufacturers often freely license patents among each other long before the patent expires. Economists, especially conservative economists, often argue against anti-trust, reasoning that as markets become larger (finance markets, consumer markets, etc), the typical lifetime of a monopoly become shorter--often shorter than the typical lifetime of anti-trust litigation. I would argue that as markets grow larger and more fluid they're far more capable of discovering and leveraging sufficient incentives to support innovation in the absence of government-imposed monopolies. Especially in the realm of software, the circumstances where there's a legitimate market failure requiring patents are so uncommon that there's no reason to even entertain the notion of a software patent system. In the absence of _manifest_, _systemic_ market failures, patent advocates make the same mistake Communists make--an inability to imagine how a market can support an endeavor is not evidence that a market is incapable of supporting that endeavor; it's merely evidence of one's own lack of information and imagination. And the surest way to introduce market failure is by dangling the prospect of government-imposed monopoly rents, artificially increasing the opportunity costs of discovering and leveraging all the non-obvious incentives that naturally exist or could evolve.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI agree it isn't correct, the implication is that the only "value" that generate new codecs is 'money for royalties.' There are many reasons for developing better codecs, whether they perform better on hardware, they allow for more channels in a pipe with fixed bandwidth, or optimize the viewing experience for particular types of signals. When I read the reference post I heard the echos of rationalizations that have been used for years and years to justify applying rents against someone else's labor. I can only hope that the author is correct in that this rent seeking behavior has become unsustainable. That would be a good thing indeed.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nightcracker 9y ago> AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies. And nothing of value was lost.
- chrisseaton 9y agoRight - it's patently false. If there was no incentive to develop new video compression, then why would anyone pay someone else to develop new video compression (buying licenses) either?
- merb 9y ago> Here are a few, out of close to 180 standards: MP3 for digital music (1992), MPEG-2 for digital television (1994), MPEG-4 Visual for video on internet (1998), MP4 file format for mobile handsets (2001), well mp3 was mostly frauenhofer, not mpeg (yes they created the standard, etc. but the most patentable work was done by the frauenhofer) also the date... on 1992 it was not (yet) called mp3. it's silly to actually name it in the mpeg sense... Edit: not a fan of mpeg, but if I would be them I would try to form a non profit and actually try to collect money like that instead of being a super duper not obvious big licensing company. I mean H.265 was released in 2013 and it's still not as widely used as it could be and better fully open source alternatives emerge quicklier than ever.
- djsumdog 9y agoIt was called MPEG2 Layer III, right? And the licensing around mp3 is why many Linux distributions didn't offer mp3 in the default install, without adding "non-free" repositories. We also saw open standards emerge, like Ogg Vorbis and FLAC (although neither were widely adopted by hardware vendors compared to Apple's AAC/ALAC)
- auxym 9y agoAccording to wikipedia, the compression algorithm was originally called MUSICAM. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MP3#Development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MP3#Development
- LeoPanthera 9y agoYou are misreading it. MUSICAM is an older codec technically very similar to MP2, as used in digital radio in Europe.
- lorrit 9y agoIt is not "Apple's AAC". Apple did not have any part in the development of AAC. It was actually developed by Fraunhofer as a successor to their MP3 encoding.
- 9y ago
- pjc50 9y agoIf you read between the lines, this is an admission that patent licensing is now simply too complicated to make proprietary codecs viable. Especially when enabling an extra compression "profile" requires extra licenses. Also, that the indirect value of having an open-licensed codec to the big players in AOM is far more than the possible license revenue.
- Animats 9y agoThis is from the chairman of the Moving Pictures Experts Group. That's different from MPEG-LA, the patent pool company.
- ttoinou 9y agoStandard MPEG-1 MPEG-2 MPEG-4 Visual MPEG-4 AVC MPEG-H HEVC Bitrate vs previous 25% less 25% less 30% less 60% less The table at the end is hiding one factor : the computation cost of each new codecs. Have we really found new better ways to compress videos, or is it just Moore's law in action ?
- wmf 9y agoYes, the computation per pixel has increased ~2x per codec generation so codecs are taking advantage of (a fraction of) the gains provided by Moore's Law.
- krylon 9y agoI remember that time when I tried to play a 4k video (x264 or x265, I am not certain) on my Mac Mini. I was pleasantly surprised that it actually ran smoothly, but the poor thing nearly melted.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoIt depends what you mean by "better". More advanced video codecs have higher visual quality at lower bitrates, but are more computationally expensive. All of these video codecs use the same underlying ideas of 2d transforms, intra- and inter-frame compression, motion compensation, entropy coding etc., but using more complex techniques to preserve video quality. I wouldn't say it's a simple as "Moore's law in action".
- ttoinou 9y agoBetter is increasing filesize/( (video quality)(computation cost) )
- ecesena 9y agoI think it's because the major cost is bandwidth, so everyone is incentivized to optimized on size primarily, maybe at the cost of being more cpu/memory intensive on enc/dec.
- leeoniya 9y ago> Companies will slash their investments in video compression technologies. Thousands of jobs will go and millions of USD of funding to universities will be cut. that's quite a lot of FUD. hosting providers have very aligned incentives to invest in better - and not necessarily proprietary - compression technologies, as do ISPs who have to carry the packets.
- revelation 9y agoYou can buy a $50 SBC today with 4k HEVC decode HW blocks, enabled out of the box. For me, that puts the technology deep into the established box, and last I checked, whoever is making the IP core for it neither the many manufacturers shipping it are the least bit concerned. This post sounds like scaremongering.
- clouddrover 9y agoHEVC and VP9 were released at around the same time, but today VP9 has twice the installed base of HEVC: https://ngcodec.com/news/2017/10/21/why-we-are-supporting-vp9-and-av1 https://ngcodec.com/news/2017/10/21/why-we-are-supporting-vp... The simplicity of VP9's licensing versus the complexity HEVC's licensing probably has a lot to do with that.
- revelation 9y agoEhh, this is counting 1.7 billion mobile users for VP9 but not HEVC because of mobile Chrome installs. It's hard to take this serious when it's counting software decoding on mobile (if Chrome will even decode it on a lot of those phones, they know its pointless in SW.) Meanwhile, nothing iOS supports VP9 HW decode. Until they come around, people could give a fuck about installed base. Then there is the stuff this article doesn't very well measure. Like DVB-T2 in Germany using 1080p50 10 bit HEVC. That is expected to be around for a decade or more. That is a whole lot of TV settop boxes.
- vetinari 9y agoVP9 support is mandatory in Android. If you want to ship Play Store, that is. So it is not due to mobile Chrome installs. The amount of Android devices dwarfs iOS devices and Apple knows that it is not viable position in long term. That's why they joined AV1. People in near future would not give a fuck about the Apple, if they couldn't play their Youtube or Netflix videos in 4K on them.
- TD-Linux 9y agoUnfortunately that's not where the licensing ends - HEVC pools also charge for content distribution. Hence why you see companies like Netflix in AOM, despite them not having to pay fees for the hardware itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Efficiency_Video_Coding#Patent_license_terms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Efficiency_Video_Coding#P...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 9y agoThe crisis is simple, MPEG rarely cared to make royalty free standards, except may be in the case of DASH. So this is now haunting MPEG tech in a big way, since free codecs are replacing patent encumbered ones for various technical and financial reasons. DASH counter example itself demonstrates it, since it's adopted by big users just fine. > The situation can be described as tragic. I'd call the situation liberating. Tragic for parasitic patent aggressors, but great for actual technology progress. Choose what you prefer. > AOM will certainly give much needed stability to the video codec market but this will come at the cost of reduced if not entirely halted technical progress. There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies knowing that it assets will be thankfully – and nothing more – accepted by AOM for use in its video codec. That's false, because instead of patent trolling, proper company would be adding resources to the common pool, benefiting in result from it. I guess the author finds the concept of collaboration to be foreign, but it actually pushes progress much faster than patent driven pocket lining. > Can something be done? MPEG can fix it going forward, and push for royalty free / patent unencumbered technology only.
- clouddrover 9y ago> MPEG rarely cared to make royalty free standards, except may be in the case of DASH DASH is not royalty-free: http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/DASH/Pages/Intro.aspx http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/DASH/Pages/Intro.aspx
- shmerl 9y ago> DASH is not royalty-free It is, the above is just a list that trolls are assembling to intimidate others. They have it on many thigns, including established royalty free codecs. If they sue someone with it and prove in court they actually own patents on DASH - then it will be another story. Until then - intimidation doesn't equal ownership. In this industry, such intimidating tactics (very protection racket and mafia like) are commonplace. Check the story how Qualcomm and some others tried to intimidate Opus project.
- clouddrover 9y ago
- ohazi 9y agoThe idea that private companies were responsible for the majority of the innovation that led to these video compression standards is a complete fabrication. The majority of the work was done by the grad students of the professors who are on the standards committee. Private companies then race to patent or buy up anything that's tangentially related during the draft period, so that they can sign on and receive royalties after standardization. Many of these companies are owned by or have board members who are standards committee members. The whole thing is a giant racket. Licensees were getting tired of this, so they started to do the same thing, and now you have multiple patent pools, no clear guidance on which ones are legit, and even fewer people who are willing to play along.
- ecesena 9y agoAnd so what do you think is the solution? Do you think that "Only by becoming a Technical Committee can MPEG [...] stay competitive in the market." is true, or what could be a valuable alternative?
- jchw 9y agoIt seems like there's an answer: the market actually wants free standards because they're realizing it's more beneficial to them than any other outcome. So money and effort is being pumped into developing free video encoding standards. It seems there is an incentive for the foreseeable future to continue to improve video codecs simply because it saves on bandwidth and disk space costs, and improves user experience. Though obviously, everything's too good to be true. Just like MPEG seems to be hitting the end, some day the AOM will hit the end, too. The world changes. Something else will emerge and impact the business model. It may be worse, or maybe it'll be a return to norms. Could just be another one of those things that cycles every so often. With audio codecs, it doesn't look like we ever really needed much in the way of commercial entities, since Vorbis and Opus have been outperforming the competition for a long time now.
- CharlesW 9y ago> …Vorbis and Opus have been outperforming the competition for a long time now. Sorry to be pedantic about one bit of an otherwise-fine post, but AAC is comparable to Opus at any given bitrate[1]. Plus, even the most esoteric flavor of AAC has the enormous advantage of 7+ years of ubiquity[2]. [1] See the multiple charts at http://opus-codec.org/comparison/ http://opus-codec.org/comparison/, for one presumably-unbiased source. [2] All versions of Android support HE-AACv2 playback, iOS introduced support for HE-AACv2 playback in iOS 4 (released 2010), macOS introduced support for HE-AACv2 playback with iTunes 9.2 (released 2010), Adobe Flash Player introduced support for HE-AACv2 in 2007, All versions of Windows Phone support HE-AACv2 playback, all open source players support HE-AACv2 playback via FAAD2
- binarymax 9y agoDoes anyone know what happened to Daala? It seemed like it was going great but has been quiet for several years now. https://xiph.org/daala/ https://xiph.org/daala/
- ckocagil 9y agoThey joined AV1 and contributed with some of their novel compression techniques.
- mbebenita 9y agoMozilla is an AOM member. A lot of the technology in Daala has been integrated into AV1, along with Cisco's Thor.
- ksec 9y agoSome of the technology*. Not all. As a matter of fact only a few were made in AV1 because the two codec were so different.
- shmerl 9y agoI think it is still independently developed, but parts of it are included in AV1. Thea idea of lapped transforms in video is really interesting and AV1 isn't using it as far as I know. So hopefully Daala will continue on its own. UPDATE: Looking at the mailing list archive, there isn't any activity there: http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/daala/ http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/daala/ The code repo is also pretty quiet: https://git.xiph.org/?p=daala.git;a=shortlog https://git.xiph.org/?p=daala.git;a=shortlog
- phkahler 9y agoI agree with you on the whole lapped transforms concept. It looked quite promising, but they ran into issue. IIRC it was problems with the overlap between differing block sizes. My instinct tells me there is a way to overcome those issues but it may be a while before anyone finds it.
- sfink 9y agoWait... someone at MPEG actually believed their own bullshit? That a massive campaign of extortion, intentionally complex legal maneuvering, and outright intimidation is actually beneficial to technological progress in some way? (Sure, it's beneficial to some of the companies involved in the licensing extortion scheme; I don't think anyone disagrees with that.) Or is this guy just an incredibly skilled troll with 30 years of experience in pulling the wool over people's eyes? I don't think so, though. He really seems to think that imposing massive amounts of friction on a system somehow makes it work better. Wow. Just wow. I mean, I'm not unsympathetic to the argument that patents can promote advancements by funneling money to inventors, however weak it starts sounding when you look at actual events in certain spheres. But the claim seems to be that nobody is going to bother to research improvements in an interesting, impactful technical area because they'll no longer be able to (1) invent something, (2) hire an army of lawyers, then (3) profit. Er, okay. Let the people who will only work with that sort of path go do their ICOs instead.
- jcranmer 9y agoWhen people first started discussing which codecs to use on the web a decade ago, the argument made for the MPEG-LA stuff was that a) we're better, b) we're reasonably priced, c) we're already everywhere in hardware, and d) you don't have to worry about the patents because we've got you covered. Ultimately, they won on that basis. However, when HEVC rolled around, that argument was destroyed by the multiple patent pools, and the consumer groups for the patents were pissed off enough to make competitive alternatives. I suspect that he believes that the perpetual funding stream of ever-better patents is needed to fund the research for ever-better codecs (which, as you say, is disputable but not unreasonable). I also suspect that he would argue that some of the problems of the protection racket amounts to a necessary evil (a protection racket does give you a viable means to combat submarine patents). However, the AV1/HEVC situation undermines these arguments, and this is someone who realizes the gravy train is running out of rails and is desperate to keep it from derailing instead of bailing while he still can.
- djsumdog 9y agoSo how does this work out fee/patentwise in the OSS world? I know ffmpeg/libav can play HEVC/x265 streams (or at least mpv can). Can it not encode to HEVC? Or do the fees start to apply when you start distributing content? Or is it like mp3 where fees are only attached to hardware encoders/decoders (which gets all iffy because where do you draw the line between hardware sold for encoding/decoding that has software codecs on it vs general purpose OSes with the same codecs?) And doesn't Firefox have some special deal with Cisco to use their x264 decoder on the web?
- kuschku 9y agoOne big issue is that research is getting privatized. In the past it was common that researchers would go to research institutes such as the Fraunhofer institutes, and do research there. The research would be published, patented, and licensed. From the fees, the Fraunhofer institutes fund themselves. Now this is being replaced by companies doing the research in-house, where it's often kept as trade secret, or, if it's patented, never licensed to competitors. This limits innovation. I'm not sure how we can protect the German research societies, but it'd be a shame to see this continue. Research done by companies is inherently unfair, and gives them a competitive advantage. In this case, of course, Google opened their codecs, but for example with Waymo's self-driving technology, that won't happen. Ideally, every carmaker could license the best selfdriving technology as soon as it exists. This is relevant to this discussion because the Fraunhofer group has previously created mp3 and AAC, and those patents have funded hundreds of further openly available research projects
- snvzz 9y agoThe article completely glosses over the existence of the Alliance for Open Media[1]. They mention it and go straight into "Can something be done?". To me, the real question: Why should we care about MPEG anymore? It is indeed true that the MPEG approach is dead. Once AV1[2] is out, the open, royalty-free codecs will be the better performing codecs for both audio (Opus[3]) and video. So yes, if MPEG is dead, its components are free to join AOMedia, as long as they leave their silly RAND ideas behind. [1] http://aomedia.org/ http://aomedia.org/. [2] https://aomediacodec.github.io/av1-spec/ https://aomediacodec.github.io/av1-spec/ [3] https://opus-codec.org/ https://opus-codec.org/
- theandrewbailey 9y agoThe article mentions AOM (and vaguely what it is) about 5 times, and even dedicates a paragraph to AOM: > Alliance for Open Media (AOM) has occupied the space left free by MPEG: outdated video compression standard (AVC), no competitive Options 1 standard (IVC) and no usable modern standard (HEVC). AOM’s AV1 codec, due to be released soon, is claimed to perform better than HEVC and will be offered royalty free.
- thinkloop 9y agoDoes VLC pay for a licence for all of them?
- ST2084 9y agoNo
- thinkloop 9y agoDo you know why/how?
- nandhp 9y agoSoftware patents are not recognized in Europe, where the VideoLAN organization is based. http://www.videolan.org/legal.html http://www.videolan.org/legal.html
- thinkloop 9y agoThis must be an old topic for hn'ers, new to me, but this is incredible, we keep complaining about how stifling software patents are, why hasn't there been an explosion of innovation in Europe simply by having this benefit (has there been?)? Are there studies and comparisons of what has come of this policy?
- djsumdog 9y agoSoftware patents are also banned in New Zealand.
- haasn 9y agoWell, one question we could ask is why basically every single popular open source multimedia project (FFmpeg, x264, MPC-HC/madVR, mpv, avisynth/VapourSynth, MVtools/SVP, heck even LAME, .....) is made mostly by european authors? Some projects are almost 100% european, some are partially european with some russian and other non-american countries thrown in. The only projects I can actually think of that are based in the US and made by american authors are those by xiph.org, and they only get away with it because their entire business model is developing royalty free alternatives to MPEG codecs. Even if multimedia patents might not affect big corporations much, they definitely seem to strongly affect the open source community. I imagine if we had similar dystopian laws here in the EU, our best and most beloved multimedia software would plain not exist.
- ninjakeyboard 9y agoAssuming author will see, year of approval for mpeg2 is listed as 1004 at the end of the article. I worked in video for a several years - sorry to hear about your issues.
- themihai 9y agoOhh so they take credit for dash already!:)))
- themihai 9y ago>> Companies will slash their investments in video compression technologies. Thousands of jobs will go and millions of USD of funding to universities will be cut. I believe this is total BS. There are great open technologies(i.e http/http2) and they didn't need a extortion cartel to police anyone who dares to use them without to buy a license(if they could buy it in the first place). Codecs should be open and they can be developed/sponsored by people who benefit most(i.e. Media companies, internet companies, hardware companies etc)
- sfink 9y agoThis isn't just about being able to decompress video on your smartphone so you can watch youtube without draining your battery, by the way. All compression algorithms, whatever domain they operate in, are about understanding the entropy stored in a stream of data and using that understanding to extract just the useful information. (Lossy compression incorporates understanding of our perceptual systems to only transmit what is necessary to transmit relevant entropy from the source to our brains.) The primary use is to display media streams with reduced network, CPU, and battery usage. But it's a much more general field, replete with all kinds of fascinating insight about the nature of visual/aural manifestations and human perception. Anything you can remove yet still recover the relevant parts of the original signal is an opportunity to understand how our brains, and the world in general with its physical laws, work. There's a ton of interesting and useful research that could be done -- but would you really want to look into how texture is encoded, processed, and reacted to in our neurons when you have to worry about various mafia-like patent licensing consortiums? The whole licensing setup has a chilling effect on many different area of inquiry, even apart from its impact on classic compression algorithms. (Though that is harmed too -- if you come up with an incremental improvement that works really well for some type of input, and you'd like other people to build on your work, what do you do?)
- danbmil99 9y agoI think it's worth noting that Google's initiative is an open source project, with its roots back in the days of the Theora (ogg, xiph, vorbis) open source codecs, with which av1 shares a common ancestry. To argue there will be no innovation in this field without patents is similar to saying there could be no innovation in Linux or Apache without restrictive, object code only proprietary licensing.
- emilfihlman 9y agoWhat am I reading? Someone whining because an outdated and antique idea of having to pay for _standards_ is finally going away?
- arca_vorago 9y agoDoes anyone know the state of Daala, which to me seems to be the proper foss competitor to h.265?
- kibwen 9y agoDaala was contributed by Xiph/Mozilla (who are in the AOM) towards AV1.
- jokoon 9y agoAnecdote : some video gif on Reddit seems to display incorrectly... It's twisted with some green cream all over. Video decoding is weird because while the software might be sound, I have no idea how the hardware supports it. I don't know if the hardware has to be specifically built to handle a family of codecs, or if it is a kernel matter or else...
- tzahola 9y ago“At long last everybody realises that the old MPEG business model is broke, all the investments (collectively hundreds of millions USD) made by the industry for the new video codec will go up in smoke and AOM’s royalty free model will spread to other business segments as well.” Good. “Can something be done?” Yep. Search for a new job!
- hannob 9y agotl;dr We were able to exploit the development of tech with patents for decades and now we won't any more. I'm only happy about this. And I seriously doubt this conclusion: "There will simply be no incentive for a company to develop new video compression technologies". It seems the author of this text thinks the only way to have an incentive to develop new technology is patent fees. This is outright ridiculous. Companies like Google or Netflix obviously have an incentive to further improve media codecs, because transmitted gigabytes translates into costs for them.
- szczepano 9y agoI feel complete opposite to the author. I believe that open soruce patent free codecs will drive innovation and produce better solutions in no time, more then MPEG does over those years.
- ksec 9y agoThis is writing as someone who flavours HEVC, but still support the AOM initiative, hopefully AV2. 1. AOM was formed in 2015, and the idea of collaborating between Mozilla and Google and others were very well known within the industry before the formation of AOM. But let's just call it 2015, so three years later in 2018, the head of MPEG, just a year ago ( 2017 ) has seen this a threat coming. May I ask What was he doing between 2015 and 2017? 2. >all the investments (collectively hundreds of millions USD) made by the industry for the new video codec will go up in smoke and AOM’s royalty free model will spread to other business segments as well. Collectively Hundreds of millions? If there were only 10 companies paying the max cap of 25M per year, that is $250M per year from HEVC and to MPEG LA alone, excluding the other two groups and NPEs. And that is devices maker, excluding content producers. Assuming a video codec has a life time of 10 years, that is a total of $2.5 Billion minimum. Do you not think wasting hundreds of millions to save a few billion for the industry is a very good deal? I do not known how the US and Canadian University works, but at least what the article said is true in terms of Universities funding in EU, Cooperate Sponsor etc for the work. Well at least it was true in my era of studying. And I do not have a solution to this problem. And I guess I cant really blame MPEG, what was originally an outrageous amount $25M now seems fair and reasonable compared to what others were asking. It is likely the greed that every company has for their IP portfolio wanted more.
- MindTooth 9y ago> Companies will slash their investments in video compression technologies. Thousands of jobs will go and millions of USD of funding to universities will be cut. https://www.ted.com/talks/rob_reid_the_8_billion_ipod https://www.ted.com/talks/rob_reid_the_8_billion_ipod
- tinus_hn 9y agoThe solution is to either abandon or severely limit software patents.