6 ms·
Notable: "And these prices do not represent just a few one-off, left field offers. All told, there were more than 100 bids combining wind and solar, or both, wi
by rossdavidh 9y ago
Notable:
"And these prices do not represent just a few one-off, left field offers. All told, there were more than 100 bids combining wind and solar, or both, with battery storage, and 20 gigawatts of such capacity.
The “median” means that half the bids were cheaper than the median price cited above."
I realize most readers of HN know what a median is, but the fact that this was not just the lowest bid in each group was worth highlighting.
- murph-almighty 9y agoThanks for the pointer, I would not have caught that
- ghostcluster 9y agoDoes this include wear and tear and replacement costs on the battery storage cells?
- diafygi 9y agoYes. These bids are usually for a "power purchase agreement", which is a bid to deliver X amount of power over some period of time. All of the maintenance, fuel, wear/replacement costs are included with the bid since it's just a raw end power delivery contract. The interesting thing that's new about this is that these bids are for "dispatchable" renewables. Up until this point, most renewables were not dispatchable since they didn't have cost competitive storage. This means that renewables now can bid for much higher levels of grid penetration in capacity markets.
- wlesieutre 9y agoNote that coal is also not a dispatchable power source. Mostly they're base load plants [1], best case they're load following power plants [2]. No way for them to respond quickly to demand changes like natural gas, hydroelectric, or batteries can. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Load_following_power_plant#Coal_based_power_plants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Load_following_power_plant#Coa...
- wlesieutre 9y agoOne last reference, these are in contrast to peaker power plants [3] which can quickly start up and shut down as needed to cover high demand periods. Gas, hydro, and grid tied batteries fit into this category. At least in the US, the grid runs as a market where as demand rises, plants bid their price to meet the demand. The energy price that they charge for these peaks is substantially higher than the base load price because you have to build enough power plants to meet the highest demand (else you get brownouts) and the peaker plants are only going to run for a small fraction of the time. The price they charge for that small time still has to cover all of the infrastructure cost. Since the peak energy price is so high, that makes a good opportunity for batteries to jump in. Tesla's recent Australian battery project is a great showcase of that. [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant
- test6554 9y agoThis appears to have come before the recent 30% Solar panel import tariff. Can anybody else confirm that the bids that include solar would not be possible today?
- epistasis 9y agoThese bids are for projects that go into service by 2023. It's extremely unlikely that this tariff will last even two years. Similarly enacted section 201 tariffs get squashed the next time the WTO considers them. If, by some implausible and disastrous series of events we are taken into a trade war and the current tariffs stand, they decrease by 5% each year, to 10%. So its safe to say that they will have as little impact on the bids 5 years from now as they do on increasing US manufacturing.
- hughes 9y agoAlso worth noting that even a 30% tariff on panels just makes them cost about what they did in 2015. It does nothing to the other significant costs of solar tech - inverters, supporting structures, land, installation labor. At worst it will delay solar adoption by a couple of years.
- phil248 9y agoAnd prices continue to drop precipitously. Given the tariff phase out, the market will probably return to 2017 equivalent in short order, and then continue to get cheaper in spite of the tariffs.
- sitkack 9y agoI am no economist, but the tariff could end up accelerating the decrease in prices as the foreign producers have a steeper gradient to overcome. If they are indeed dumping at below cost, they could also respond by lowering prices by the tariff amount. If the tariff is applied to foreign assembled units, they could onshore the final assembly. Or start bundling non-tariffed systems so they are still cheaper in the end. I could envision a cargo container with the panels and strandbeest-accordian support structure, plant on end in the ground and it would automatically unfurl (high school bleachers but with an alternating Z pattern) as the container moves along. Even with a lower pack density, deployment in hours would save the overall system cost. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theo_Jansen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theo_Jansen