5 ms·
While it would be nice if the legal system clarified the issue, I would lean towards that copyright can not be expanded to cover self recording. Record of that
by belorn 9y ago
While it would be nice if the legal system clarified the issue, I would lean towards that copyright can not be expanded to cover self recording. Record of that kind will naturally include the environment, and as such, the legal system need to ask what the intention is and what conflict of interests may exist rather than a black or white view. If someone record themselves eating at a restaurant then the music in the background and the painting on the walls should not dictate the legal status of the recording. Same should hold true for any recording where the intent is not to record the works of others but rather the person doing the recording.
There is a similar legal uncertainty revolving cosplay, and the details are very similar. The content of movies and games is the inspiration of the costumes, but the intent is not to compete on the same market that the games and movies operate on and there really should not exist any reasonable claim of conflict between creators.
- herbst 9y ago> Same should hold true for any recording where the intent is not to record the works of others but rather the person doing the recording. From what I can tell most streams depend fully on third party graphics like games for their visual content. I like your argument. But i totally see why this would be different. Edit:// adding to that fair use allows snippets to be used. While let's plays more or less show uncut content from start to end. Imagine that with a movie.
- dogma1138 9y agoIt really depends on what the material essence of the stream is the streamer or the game. You can go on YouTube and have multi hour long recordings of single player games that turn the game into a movie for story focused games I can definitely understand why some publishers would like to put an end to this as I have watched a few of those instead of buying the game and I know quite a few other people that would. In other cases the streamer is the focus of the video either as an “athlete” or a “skilled professional” and you watch how they play or as an an entertainer where the game in the background doesn’t serve any purpose other than a filler or a tie in. As for cosplay the legality while not formalized is pretty well established if you commercialize by for example selling kits, molds etc. without licensing you’ll get sued if you just cosplay at conventions no one would care. “Professional Cosplayers” are currently the problem because they blur the line between the comercial and amateur/ hobbyists as many of them well the really pretty ones are paid to attend events and do promotions basically as boothbabes in costumes this the biggest thorn as those events are often not sancationed by the owners of the IP or and could go counter to their principles or at least the public face they try to maintain. Yes there are outliers like Nintendo and in some cases companies that didn’t like what was portrayed on stream but the former is getting better and the latter doesn’t just apply to games you can still be sued in civil court for damages caused even if the content was under fair use.
- mstade 9y agoYou can go on YouTube and have multi hour long recordings of single player games that turn the game into a movie for story focused games I can definitely understand why some publishers would like to put an end to this as I have watched a few of those instead of buying the game and I know quite a few other people that would. I've done this, both for games I own and don't. Last I did it was for the new Wolfenstein game. I thought it looked cool, so when the demo came around I downloaded and tried it. At that point though, the suspense of what was going to come next was gone, and instead I just focused on controls and other things that bothered me. I didn't buy the game in the end. Streaming has increasingly informed my purchasing decisions over the past year or so. Sometimes it's made my buy things I never thought I'd look twice at (e.g. Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice) and other times as mentioned it's dissuaded me entirely. It's a double edged sword, for sure. EDIT: To add to this, I feel that demos filled this niche for me before, but these days you rarely get anything but a super polished ad video that barely has any relation with the game. Back in the shareware days, demos were common place, and they definitely made me buy games more than once. Sometimes the rest of the game were a dud, most of the time it wasn't. A current game that does this to great effect is Tomb Raider – it gets you in the game proper, teaches you the controls, and drops you off right as the story is about to begin for real. If you purchase the game, you can then pick up right where you left off (which you can't from watching a video, or playing in a store.) It's a great example of demo design.
- YeOakAye 9y agoYears ago System Shock 2 had a demo which was basically just the introduction to the story, and the new Prey recently was similar. Both lead to me purchasing the full game almost instantly after completing the demo. Also, in addition to streamers and youtube, I find the 2 hour playtime window for which Steam will refund unquestioningly, helps alleviate the stress of making a bad purchase. Provided the game is available on Steam, of course!
- mstade 9y agoThat's exactly how the Tomb Raider demo is, and just like you it led me to purchase the game afterwards – I wanted to see the rest! Almost certainly I wouldn't if I had watched the thing streamed though. The two hour window is nice, but when does it start? I'll buy games sometimes because they are a good deal, during a sale or something, but not play them until long after. Regardless, I only ever play on my PS4, so I buy games through their store. Not sure what the return policy there is.