7 ms·
A conversation about how public transport really works
- neonate 9y agohttp://archive.is/zIs6Z http://archive.is/zIs6Z
- p0la 9y agothx !
- srsly_ft_wtf 9y agoha ha.. thanks, i guess i don't need that FT subscription after all :D
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago>And so this is why it’s tricky and this is why in your example of a bridge, if you widened the bridge but lots of people want to cross it, you’ll end up with a wider bridge that’s exactly as congested as it is now. Widening the bridge does increase throughput; people who used to be unable to use the bridge are now doing so. There's a benefit there, it's just siphoned off from "reducing congestion" to "people are no longer forced to stay home rather than deal with congestion".
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIt might be a benefit economically but I'm not sure having more people sat in congestion is a good thing.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoFacilitating more trips absolutely should be the goal of any transit system. Getting yourself from point A to point B provides you value - else why would you go? "More people sitting in congestion" just means that the facilitated trips are limited by capacity and density rather than geometric distance.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoYet having more people sat in congestion is going to have a negative affect on societies overall wellbeing. The problem is we look at it from the perspective of the immediate economic benefit and ignore the costs of poorer health outcomes and increased environmental degredation.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoOn further thought overnight, I agree with you more. There's a combined goal between zoning and transit to meet human needs, and obviating the need to make a trip on the zoning end is just as good as facilitating a trip on the transit end. The overall systems approach is better in total, too - there are tons of broad cross-cutting concerns here, and transit is one piece of a larger and more complex system.
- deng 9y agoHis point is that if you make going by car more attractive by simply widening the bridge for everyone, people will switch from public transport to private cars. So his solution would be more "make a separate bus line on the bridge, so that they are more attractive to use than a private car".
- ant6n 9y agoInducing demand is not just from mode-shift (towards cars in this case), but also from development. Take the example of a big city on a big island (e.g. Montreal), a larger bridge may encourage sprawl off-island rather than infill development on-island. A choke-point like a bridge isn't just a sort of barrier (geographic, social economic...), but also an opportunity to manage travel patterns and thus development.
- asteli 9y agoPeople don't generally give up and stay home, they find ways to go about their lives. Driving to downtown San Francisco is awful and congested, so people simply take the train (because it exists in a useful capacity). Widening that bridge has an opportunity cost. LA ramped up road infrastructure at the expense of useful public transit and urban densification, and it's a stressful and sickening experience to get around there.
- ghaff 9y agoI expect a lot of people do just stay home. If it’s a total PITA to go into a city after work people find other activities.
- asteli 9y agoleisure trips account for a small fraction of the kind of trip we're talking about they APTA's study shows something like 15% of public transit trips are social or shopping/dining related[1]. i suspect the proportion would be similar (or lower) wrt road traffic. [1] American Public Transportation Association: http://www.apta.com/resources/statistics/Documents/transit_passenger_characteristics_text_5_29_2007.pdf http://www.apta.com/resources/statistics/Documents/transit_p...
- djsumdog 9y agoWenover productions does a great video on how increasing traffic lanes makes traffic worse in every city. People who normally wouldn't drive, will now drive thinking they'll be less congestion. Atlanta had some major closures recently and the city migrated around the problem, people took different paths to work and more people decided to get on public transport. The fact is car lanes can never reach a fraction of the capacity of a train running at regular intervals. Even if you had nothing but self driving cars running bumper to bumper at 120kph and all filled to a capacity of 4.2 people, on a four lane road, you wouldn't even approach 8% of the capacity of a single rail line running at 2 minute intervals! Singapore's trains are automated. They're already self driving and run at <1.5min intervals during peak hours.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mseebach 9y agoThere’s something wrong with your numbers. 120kph for two minutes is 1km, or 250 4-meter cars, bumper to bumper. Four lanes, 4.2 occupants, that’s 16,800 passengers per two minutes, which is a full order of magnitude more than a 12-carriage train packed with standing passengers[1] - and the people in the cars are all sitting down. 1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Rail_Class_700 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Rail_Class_700
- djsumdog 9y agohttp://www.oregon.gov/ODOT/RPTD/RPTD%20Document%20Library/maximum-theoretical-person-capacity-24-hour-period.pdf http://www.oregon.gov/ODOT/RPTD/RPTD%20Document%20Library/ma...
- schiffern 9y agoAhh, that explains it. The paper assumes a sane minimum of 1.6 seconds/car (aka 2250 pcphpl), but 4 m spacing at 120 kph would be 0.12 seconds/car.
- rahulnair23 9y agoReally wonderful interview. One point that doesn't come up os that serious operational inefficiencies and "friction" exist in how current fixed route services are delivered in most cities. Some due to political challenges (see WMATA funding woes). Some are due to older technologies that lead to lower capacities (see MTA signals), or sluggish transit agencies that have networks that have not kept up with changes to the city (see Dublin Bus). Public transport needs to work better for the public too.
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago>political challenges (see WMATA funding woes) See also: why BART doesn't go further south than Millbrae (hint: NIMBYs and thinly-veiled racist worries that it'd bring in "undesirable" folks)
- StudentStuff 9y agoAh, Vantucky just north of Portland, OR has the same BS "concerns". Ditto for the rich part of Bellevue, they've blocked Eastlink Light Rail from using any of the existing rail that is already government owned, cause "oh dear it'll bring the baddies!". They're still pissed off by the rails to trails project though...
- kapauldo 9y agoAnyone have a non login version of the article?
- cameldrv 9y agoI like Jarrett Walker. He does come at the problem from a certain perspective though -- he wants to solve problems with mass transit. Just like he talks about there being immutable laws of geometry, there are some immutable laws of transit. Mass transit fundamentally depends on having a lot of people who want to get from point A to point B, all at the same time. Since this is never true, you have to relax the requirements. You can make people wait until there are enough of them, you can make them walk to or from a stop, you can make them detour, slow down, stop and then speed up to let others get on and off, and you can make them switch vehicles. Fundamentally those are your options given some set of vehicles, whether they're planes, trains, or automobiles. All forms of transit exist on the tradeoff surface between these possibilities. As population density goes up, it's easier to find lots of trips that are close enough in the five dimensional space of origin, destination, time. Where I perhaps differ from Jarrett is that I see no problem in having transit options that have one or two people per vehicle. The 2-5 person capacity mass transit vehicle has been a very underexplored space because someone has to own it and someone has to drive it. Services like Uberpool and Lyft Line are exploring this because smartphones make it possible, and this will only increase when you don't have to pay someone who isn't riding to operate the vehicle.
- imgabe 9y ago> Mass transit fundamentally depends on having a lot of people who want to get from point A to point B, all at the same time. Since this is never true, you have to relax the requirements. There is also induced demand. If you make it very easy to get from point a to point b. Lots of people will want to live at a and work at b or vice versa. Right now we focus most of our energy and resources on making it as easy as possible for everyone to drive their car, so that's what they do.
- Arnt 9y agoJarrett doesn't have a problem with small-vehicle options either. He just says: In a dense big city that has to be a sideshow and therefore discussing it is a harmful distraction. (I've seen small-capacity "mass" transit, btw. Never two-person-max. But I've seen ten-person microbuses in several cities. Where I live there are a few that feed minor outlying hubs.)
- djsumdog 9y agoI wrote about this a while back. Self driving cars are not a solution, at least in America where they won't solve the last leg problem from trains to home (because we have so few trains or even express buses). http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-solve-the-transportation-problem/ http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-sol... Self driving vehicles on dedicated road ways can't even expect to match a tiny percentage of what trains or even express buses can deliver. Singapore already has autonomous fully automated trains. The same tech has been sold to Kuala Lumpar. London has several driver-less trains with more of their underground being switched over to semi/full-autonomous as well. We've already had two articles on HN about NYC's crumbling rail infrastructure (both the subway and Penn Station). Chicago hasn't expanded their lines in decades. Our two biggest European style rail cities are not expanding, and are actively falling apart. There is hope though. Seattle is expanding with ST3 and Florida's high speed line just went operational, with additional stops opening over the next few years which will eventually connect Miami with Orlando. Now if California doesn't fuck things up, we might finally have two real high speed lines in this country (and no, I'm not counting the Acela).
- mratzloff 9y agoSeattle's light rail isn't bad, but it's expanding slowly and has a long way to go before it even comes close to matching NYC's breadth of transit service, let alone someplace like Tokyo. Investment in the NYC lines is continuous, and although much more could be done to upgrade switching infrastructure and renovate some aging stations and train cars, it's still a remarkable achievement.
- StudentStuff 9y agoSeattle's light rail should just about triple over the next 6 years, adding 42 miles of new track, from Northgate to Kent to Bellevue and Redmond. We also maintain our rail, unlike NYC. Chronic underfunding of rail maintenance (in favor of unneeded station upgrades) is tanking reliability on light rail lines in NYC and DC currently, and its only going to get worse so long as critical maintenance is delayed.
- srsly_ft_wtf 9y agoHmmm... i have an FT subscription but i STILL need to turn off ad blocking.. sub cancelled. This is a real shame as the FT is a good paper.. damn they need to modernise!