5 ms·
>That's actually a pretty strong compliment. One could reverse it and ask, why in America and Europe people are easy swayed by lies in "a catchy headline or a p
by mrtksn 9y ago
>That's actually a pretty strong compliment. One could reverse it and ask, why in America and Europe people are easy swayed by lies in "a catchy headline or a pretty image", instead of demanding actual information about the product?
Maybe because the information is useless when it's too complicated or out of context?
For example, if you look at the spec sheet of an iPhone you might think that it's less capable than a cheap Android phone unless you have very deep understanding of the technology.
In west, companies try to communicate the utility or the feeling that this product will give you and most of the technical information is seen as distraction and only the cheapest, lowest quality companies will bombard the users with that information in a bid to convince you that they offer the same thing for cheaper.
Apple famously doesn't advertise RAM or processor clock speed on iPhones.
- crankylinuxuser 9y ago> Apple famously doesn't advertise RAM or processor clock speed on iPhones. As long as I can remember, they've always under-specced their hardware and then jacked the prices up for the cost of "experience". And my memory goes back to the mid 80's. Same old game then as it is now.
- mrtksn 9y agoWhat does under-specced even mean? How do you provide better experience by "under-spec" a product?
- phil248 9y agoIt means you provide the minimum hardware necessary to provide a quality experience now, without regard to (and in anticipation of) near-future developments that render that hardware under-powered.
- mrtksn 9y agoI didn't knew that Apple is doing it. iPhones are used for very long time, holding 2nd hand value the most of any other smartphone. The same goes for Macs, people tend to use these things for many years. In fact, Apple is still selling Macbook Airs like hot cakes despite the device not being significantly updated for almost a half decade now and people are happy with that product. The claim sounds like induced anxiety of a user who just couldn't swallow the premium paid over the same Ghz laptop or same Megapixel smartphone :)
- hesarenu 9y agoMaybe they are happy with Air because its the cheapest Apple. I know since i got one recently for development purpose. I would have liked a better spec'd once, but others were costly.
- mrtksn 9y agoI also have an 2015 Air, it performs as advertised. I can't say that the performance degraded over time, contrary to the claim.
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoI'm also going as far back as their first 20 MB SCSI drive that they charged $550 for when IBM compats were charging $400. They did something goofy, unsurprisingly to the hardware to prevent users from using the cheaper SCSI drives. And this was back in the '80 s. Its not surprising they still play their stupid games. People in tech have such short term memories - much here is on a day by day basis, or weekly. Yet, its the same actors in the Apple administration (well, minus Jobs).
- fpig 9y agoI used my iPhone 4 for 6 years. I was very happy with it and it was virtually indestructible. The battery was also pretty decent even after 6 years. The iPhone 4 felt like a device that "lasts forever", like some pre-smartphone devices used to be. However, it did get slower over time more so than I would expect from a phone and became almost unusable near the end. Not sure whether it was OS updates, application updates, or what, but it was very noticeable. So I would agree with the grandparent comment in that respect. If I used my phone a lot, I would have probably bought a new phone MUCH earlier due to how slow the 4 became.
- matte_black 9y agoThey do not "under-spec" their phones. They spec them to exactly what they need. Over-speccing a phone is useless and a waste of battery life. Remember: YAGNI.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoYAGNI is bullshit for infrastructure (including platforms). In fact, the opposite is true - the more you give, the more interesting uses follow. Every extra sensor, every screen resolution increase could be dismissed on the basis of YAGNI. Hell, that 64K quote comes to mind. Also, battery life and Apple phones - that's rich too, given that Apple was found to make iPhones reduce their computing power over time to preserve battery life, instead of educating their customers that batteries are not magic pixie dust, and they degrade over time.
- freehunter 9y agoWith that mindset, I demand Apple make an iPhone with a serial port and a built-in fax machine given how often I need a serial port and the ability to fax a piece of paper. I find myself morally outraged that they did not consider my very common use case when building their smartphone.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoNot sure about the iPhone, but on Android phones you should be able to do both of those with appropriate USB-to-$whatever connector and an app. And this is possible precisely because people didn't go all YAGNI about a proper micro USB port and ability of apps to use it.
- matte_black 9y agoBwahaa, is this not the same Apple we're talking about? The one that eliminates headphone jacks and Flash and usb ports and cd drives and anything else people hold dear all in the name of YAGNI? If they could eliminate even less, I'm sure they would. The fact is, we need exactly what we have now, nothing more and nothing less.
- crooked-v 9y agoActually, the latest iPhones are the fastest thing on the market. https://www.tomsguide.com/us/iphone-8-benchmarks-fastest-phone,review-4676.html https://www.tomsguide.com/us/iphone-8-benchmarks-fastest-pho...
- coldtea 9y ago>And my memory goes back to the mid 80's Your memory is faulty. They usually beat competing flagship models by a long margin, ever since the first model: E.g. https://www.gsmarena.com/a11_in_iphone_x_crushes_top_android_competition_in_geekbench-news-27302.php https://www.gsmarena.com/a11_in_iphone_x_crushes_top_android... Or: Until now, Samsung's flagship smartphones have always been king of the Android phones – but Google's latest offering has finally knocked it off its perch. Another shock is just how badly the new Sony XZ performed. It finished in last place, some two minutes slower than the iPhone 7. This isn’t the first time the Apple iPhone has won Gold in a speed test. Earlier this year, the team at PhoneBuff pitted the iPhone 7 against the now-discontinued Samsung Galaxy Note 7. The iPhone managed to open and close the chosen apps in a total time of 1 minute 40 seconds, while it took the Galaxy Note 7 a whole 3 minutes and 14 seconds to complete the same task. https://www.express.co.uk/life-style/science-technology/739606/iPhone-7-Google-Pixel-Samsung-Galaxy-S7-Speed-Test https://www.express.co.uk/life-style/science-technology/7396...
- TeMPOraL 9y agoInteresting. Does that mean I'm in the minority, because for me, the more a company tries to "communicate the utility or the feeling that this product will give you" instead of factual information, the more I perceive them as crappy and/or dishonest? I'm an adult, I know my needs, I can read the specs (or learn to read, or ask someone more knowledgeable) and make the purchasing decision myself. Maybe I should move to Japan.
- mrtksn 9y agoI'm curious, how do you know that you need 1) 3500mah battery or 2) 2.1Ghz processor or 3) 4GB Ram on a smartphone? These things are meaningless without 1) detailed energy consumption analysis. 2) SoC Architecture details 3) OS Architecture details Even if you are knowledgeable enough to understand all these, that information is useful only if you are going to do something different than the original design purpose. If you are going to use the product for the purpose that it's designed for, all you need is the average use time between charging. Maybe you are an expert in the area but what about washing machines or tables? How likely is that the engineering specs of these products will also be in your domain?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoFor a random, unique electronic device alone, the specs like you gave are difficult to make use of; but in reality, consumer electronics is not random - most competing devices are in the same ballpark of functionality and internal implementation, so battery capacity, processor speed and amount of RAM can be easily used to compare between models and against expected use cases. E.g. if last year's model with 1GB RAM choked on its own stock operating system, I can be sure that this year's model with 1GB RAM will be choking even more, and it's probably a safe bet to go for the 4GB one. I do not expect consumers to have expert knowledge in every possible domain. But some things can be estimated pretty easily if companies are providing relevant data. Which they go out of their way to avoid, to muddy the waters, so that people don't ballpark things. You said washing machines or tables - two areas which are as far away from my expertise as one can be; I still believe I'd be able to do a good job shopping if I had the following data: For washing machines - peak/average power/water/detergent use on "typical" and "highest cleaning" (worst efficiency) program. Also peak and average generated noise (in dB) for those programs. For tables - size, weight and supported weight (I'm flabbergasted by companies which don't provide the last; do people buying desks/tables not care about the safety of secondary use cases like "sitting on a desk" or "standing on a desk to change the lightbulb in the ceiling light"?).
- goatlover 9y ago> In west, companies try to communicate the utility or the feeling that this product will give you and most of the technical information is seen as distraction So you mean typical manipulative advertising that distracts you from informed decision making to get at your feelings so you'll want their product.
- herbst 9y ago> In west, companies try to communicate the utility or the feeling that this product will give you and most of the technical information is seen as distraction and only the cheapest, lowest quality companies will bombard the users with that information in a bid to convince you that they offer the same thing for cheaper. Could be just me. But maybe west here means the U.S.? I don't think I have seen even iPhone ads without a little spec sheet.
- kruczek 9y ago> if you look at the spec sheet of an iPhone > Apple famously doesn't advertise RAM or processor clock speed on iPhones. There is a lot of space between these two extremes. While I do not expect full spec sheet for a tool (because, as you said, I couldn't understand it anyway), I do expect to be able to find out some basics; for me RAM or CPU certainly are a part of these basics.