4 ms·
Yes, let's compare a natural system using low energy and fuelled by food with a hungry silicon system fuelled by electricity. It's going to be a great compariso
by visarga 9y ago
Yes, let's compare a natural system using low energy and fuelled by food with a hungry silicon system fuelled by electricity. It's going to be a great comparison. Only problem is that biological brains don't just compute, they also construct themselves, unlike the silicon chips. But we can ignore that as an insignificant detail. Let's also ignore that the brain has no clock or clearly separated layers. Doesn't matter that brain can't do backprop and we have no idea how it works, either. We can just compare neuronal speeds as if it's apples to apples. /s
- samplatt 9y agoFoolish, puny human. You think your neuroplasticity is a good substitute for offsite backups and automated-nanobot onsite parts replacement? Once your programmers figure out how to make threading actually easy to do, it'll be all over, my friend. Until then, we wait.
- sitkack 9y agoThe human brain uses about 20W, for everything.
- taneq 9y ago> The synapses can fire up to one billion times per second — several orders of magnitude faster than human neurons — and use one ten-thousandth of the amount of energy used by a biological synapse. So if this is true, and these chips function as expected, we should be able to simulate a human brain orders of magnitude faster than realtime using with less than 2mW.
- AstralStorm 9y agoThat requires about 200W of liquid hydrogen cooling right now. Brain, some 20-40W of above room temperature water cooling. (Also evaporative.) Total efficiency equation is not yet favourable.
- dang 9y agoCan you please not post snarky dismissals like this? It isn't that you're wrong, it's that the point is a shallow one. No one here likes linkbait titles, but ranting in response to them doesn't make for curious discussion either. (We've edited the title above to use a better phrase from the article itself.) The following site guideline, applied at the article level, covers this situation: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- spartanatreyu 9y agoThe "/s" at the end means it was sarcastic but I usually only see that used on reddit
- deepnotderp 9y agoThere are processors without clocks, just saying :)
- ppod 9y agoIt is not true to say that we have "no idea" how the brain works.