3 ms·
In which cases are native still better than PWA?
by walterbell 9y ago
In which cases are native still better than PWA?
- atcole 9y agoIn cases similar to desktops with electron vs. native (although with different requirements) where either you need access to significant native features that are not supported in the browser, or if your app is process intensive, i.e. graphics heavy games.
- majewsky 9y agoThe analogy to Electron makes me wonder if a possible mass migration to PWAs will make the experience on already-slow low-end phones even more atrocious.
- nfRfqX5n 9y agoit would be the opposite actually, since you don't have to wrap the app in a heavy bundle. avg iOS app size is like 30mb. a web app shouldn't even come close.
- kaycebasques 9y agoExtreme example has been Twitter. Twitter PWA: 600KB Native Android Twitter: 23.5MB https://developers.google.com/web/showcase/2017/twitter#lowering_data_consumption https://developers.google.com/web/showcase/2017/twitter#lowe... This has been a huge differentiator in countries where users are sensitive to data consumption, which is why you see many case studies about countries in India, Africa, etc. getting great traction with PWAs. Disclaimer: I'm on Google Web DevRel team
- LocutusOfBorges 9y agoStorage space isn't generally the bottleneck on older devices- it's the CPU/RAM. On that count, native apps are usually overwhelmingly preferable. If these catch on a big way, it'll be catastrophic for more underpowered devices. Modern web pages are already starting to get acutely uncomfortable to use on older iPhones, let alone older Android devices- we aren't yet at the point where performance levels are high enough that we can slap the equivalent of an electron wrapper on everything, smirk at users' devices' vanishing battery life and call it a day.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoApples to oranges. The download size of a native app, while important to keep low, will have minimal effect of the actual user experience post-download. Web applications will in almost all cases be a strictly worse user experience.
- Joeri 9y agoIf you need to store non-trivial amounts of offline data then native is your only option.
- Klathmon 9y agoThat's not necessarily true, depending on what your definition of "non-trivial" is. I currently use IndexedDB to store over 500mb of data on phones successfully in a B2B application. The biggest issue in my experience is access to native "well optimized" APIs. (If I want a video feed, it causes significantly more battery draw to do it in a webview vs a native camera feed).
- walterbell 9y agoIs that local data safe from 3rd-party javascript?
- Klathmon 9y agoI'm not entirely sure what you are asking here. IndexedDB is subject to the same origin policy, so only javascript executed on my domain can access the data for my domain. Combined with a good Content-security-policy means I'm in control of exactly what code gets to access those resources.
- walterbell 9y agoSome discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16250519 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16250519
- Klathmon 9y agoAh, so in that case yes, it's safe from the extreme majority of XSS, because I use Content-Security-Policy headers. Any cookies would also be subject to XSS, unless they have the HTTP-Only flag set, in which case the whole point is not worth discussing because JavaScript cannot access it or even know it exists, so it would obviously be useless to any javascript. Localstorage (and friends like WebSQL and IndexedDB) and Cookies serve different purposes, and having data in IndexedDB is no less "secure" than having it displayed on the page. In both cases an XSS attack means game over.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoAll of them, in my opinion. I have not encountered a single case where a web app offered a better experience than a native app. There is a reasonable argument that it's cheaper to develop, allowing support for more platforms to be rolled out with less development time. That's the single reason that might be valid.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoI strongly prefer the Twitter PWA to the Twitter app. It uses only 279 KB storage on my phone. When Firefox 58 finishes rolling out, I'll play around with using web extensions to customize the app, which is something that will likely never be possible with a native app.
- ergothus 9y agoAlso the case where you have lots if transient users. Far better to have a first-rmtime visitor experience s mobile-friendly webpage that can act as an app than to throw a "download our app" message at them. For companies with more reliable visitors, Native definitely has an edge in options, but if a company is trying to build feature and experience parity across platforms, much if that edge is dulled.