3 ms·
Ikea has optimized the price and durability of an item to maximize utility for both the end user and the corp. People like getting new stuff for cheap and dont
by sitkack 9y ago
Ikea has optimized the price and durability of an item to maximize utility for both the end user and the corp. People like getting new stuff for cheap and dont value resale or reuse. Ikea is an excellent machine for turning Borneo rain forest into landfill at the lowest price.
- kalleboo 9y ago> Borneo rain forest Most of IKEAs wood comes from Europe/Russia. They also probably do a lot more work tracing the source of their wood and making it sustainable than your average furniture maker, simply due to their visibility. You might be better off with something hand-crafted by an artisan from local wood, but who can afford that? Most people get their furniture from other big box stores, with unknown provenance
- dbrgn 9y agoIkea actually plans to become "forest positive": https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/ikea-sustainability-forest-positive-karelia https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/ikea-sustai... The article is from 2012, not sure how far they progressed (true sustainability is difficult). I doubt they use any tropical wood though. Most of their wood supplies are already FSC certified.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoAlso worth pointing out that in the UK, the company now sends nothing to landfill itself (http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/article/38636272/ikea-sustainability-report-reveals-the-firm-sent-zero-waste-to-landfill-in-2016 http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/article/38636272/ikea-sustaina...). And in France, they will accept old Ikea furniture and resell it at low cost (https://www.climatesolutionsplatform.org/solution/giving-furniture-a-second-life-with-ikea/ https://www.climatesolutionsplatform.org/solution/giving-fur...) There are a few things to attack the company on; I’m not sure sustainability is one of their weak points.
- nicoburns 9y agoArguably they are one of the leading large companies with regard to sustainability. Most of their wood is fast growing pine, and they switched their entire lighting range over to LEDs way back in 2011 http://www.ikea.com/us/en/about_ikea/newsitem/IKEA_pulls_the_plug_on_incandescent_light_bulbs_press_release http://www.ikea.com/us/en/about_ikea/newsitem/IKEA_pulls_the...
- kalleboo 9y agoCompared to the BBC article saying that in 2012 they failed to reach their goal of 35% "preferred sources" (undefined), they currently claim to source 50% of their wood from "sustainable sources" (defined as either recycled or FSC-certified)
- zxcmx 9y agoOh man I love this line of argument but ikea is probably not the best place to deploy it. The phrase "waste in transit" is so good. Once you have it, and viscerally understand the idea of things sitting on store shelves which you will briefly take into your house before their inevitable journey to landfill... yeah, you will never look at the world the same way. But overall ikea are not the problem. They have corporate responsibility officers and like hippies who sold out and all kinds of things going on to ensure that the kind of social media disaster you discussed is supposed to never happen. Plus a lot of those people actually care. Shoot back with interesting evidence of ikea corporate crimes if you have any though.
- yourapostasy 9y agoHow much a civilization throws away and what it throws away is a very rough gauge of its technological and scientific level. At the far-future side of the spectrum, you only detect very low levels of heat energy close to zero Kelvin, and some similarly low leakage of EM. They’ve mastered nanotechnology say, and what we throw out today is high-energy, rich feedstocks to them.
- GlennS 9y agoA counterpoint: Ikea is effectively performing carbon sequestration. They plan fast-growing pine trees. Those trees remove carbon dioxide from the air. They chop down the trees and make furniture. The carbon is now locked up in that furniture. If they furniture goes into a landfill, that carbon could stay there for decades (or more?). Then, they plant some more trees. I don't actually know whether building lots of cheap furniture is actually better for climate change compared to building small quantities of durable furniture. But it's an interesting thought experiment and a reminder to check your facts and do your sums before spouting off.
- ptaipale 9y agoI'd say that the emissions from logistics (transport) may be quite significant compared to the CO2 stored into the materials, at least post-sales. Take a desk that contains 30 kg of wood material. 50 % of that is carbon, so there is 15 kg of carbon in it, corresponding to 60 kg of CO2, which is emitted by driving 400 km with a medium-sized car (150 g/km). That much is first contained by the material (even in landfill), and eventually released back to atmosphere. At least you shouldn't do a lot of transporting this desk back and forth. IKEAs logistics from manufacture to store is remarkably efficient.