3 ms·
> Poverty and housing insecurity are definite societal problems, but does that make it the fault or responsibility of each individual landlord? I've been livin
by kelnos 9y ago
> Poverty and housing insecurity are definite societal problems, but does that make it the fault or responsibility of each individual landlord?
I've been living in the SF bay area for nearly 15 years, and in SF itself for half of that. I've watched rent prices go up. The only reason those prices went up was because of higher demand. The higher prices didn't get anyone anything extra: the properties weren't maintained any better, or renovated or upgraded faster or better. On the landlord's side, there were no magical new costs coming into the equation to justify the higher rents.
If a landlord could rent out a place in 2005 for $1500/mo (and cover all costs and make some profit), there's no need for them to rent it out for $4000/mo in 2018. They're doing that because they want to and because they know someone will pay it. I'll absolutely agree that's capitalism in action right there, and in general that's not a bad thing. But we get gentrification and displacement as part of that bargain.
So yes, landlords should accept some of the burden of fault and responsibility. I'm not saying there isn't plenty to spread around, between existing homeowners, the city government, and incoming renters/homebuyers themselves, but... nope, sorry, landlords don't get to pretend they're innocent in all this.
(As an aside: I see you posting a lot on this article, and I want to say that I don't think you're "irredeemable" or greedy or whatever. I'm happy you've chosen to engage and have a productive discussion, at the very least. I just think you might be getting a little caught up in... something... and are missing the point that we're talking about housing and homelessness here, and that's a terrible thing for someone to have to fall into, regardless of reason or fault. Assuming you've been financially responsible on your end, missing rent payments from a tenant for a few months shouldn't put you out on the street, but... you as a landlord do have the power to put someone out on the street, and it'd be nice if you'd be cognizant of the extra power you have.)
- georgeecollins 9y agoHow is the price of rent going up the fault of landlords, when terrible urban planning (and NIMBYism) has limited housing in the Bay Area for decades. In the Bay Area, blaming landlords is shooting the messenger. The truth is that in a lot of these places existing homeowners are happy to see people priced out. At the same time, job growth is getting more concentrated in expensive urban environments. Local governments respond to local (property) tax payers, who don't mind gentrification. State and national governments do nothing, because the political pressure is zero. So, yeah blame the landlord.
- kelnos 9y agoYou might try actually reading my comment. I mentioned exactly those other things as well as being partly at fault. Landlords don't get a free pass, though.