4 ms·
All the arguments over the value of college always seem to ignore one obvious element—some of us go to college because we will learn things we could not or woul
by baddox 16y ago
All the arguments over the value of college always seem to ignore one obvious element—some of us go to college because we will learn things we could not or would not otherwise learn. I'm a Computer Science senior right now, and sure, I could have learned all the stuff I learned from buying my own books, but I never would have. Also, the awesome professors, though rare and littered among terrible ones, completely make it worth it.
- jcnnghm 16y agosome of us go to college because we will learn things we could not or would not otherwise learn. And some of us went to college because we had to prove to HR people that we know what we know with very expensive pieces of paper. I stopped going to college after I didn't attend classes or buy books for a semester, and got substantially the same grades. I didn't attend classes or buy books because I wasn't extracting value congruent to the time and money it cost to attend class. I ultimately made the decision to not go at all because the amount of money I was making running my business exceeded the amount I could make with a degree working for someone else. Computer science is probably one of the easiest fields to learn without formal instruction because deliberate practice is so easy and information is so accessible. The absolute most I learned in a college course was in a digital logic course. After the first class, the professor, whom I had before, took me to his office, told me I wouldn't learn anything in the class, gave me an FPGA development board (similar to http://www.altera.com/products/devkits/altera/kit-cyc2-2C20N.html#contents http://www.altera.com/products/devkits/altera/kit-cyc2-2C20N..., fpga, ethernet, usb, flash card reader), told me to read about Verilog, build something interesting, and to not attend class, he'd just give me a grade on whatever I built. I implemented a basic computer that would read and execute instructions off the memory card. Almost everything in computer science came together once I implemented jump instructions. I got almost nothing out of most classes, but an incredible amount out of that one. College is tedious if you already know a lot about a subject. If I could go back and was really interested in learning, I would have moved close to a college, and paid professors for short duration one-on-one instruction and guidance, probably just an hour or two a week, with independent study. It would have been substantially less expensive and more effective. You can't get a degree that way, but you can learn. I find the pacing of college courses to be too slow, if I am interested in learning about a new subject now, I'll get course videos and speed them up a bit, and skip ahead liberally. I can usually get through a semesters worth of lectures in a day.
- jacquesm 16y agoYou so lucked out with that professor. Amazing guy!
- jchonphoenix 16y agoYou're mixing up computer science and programming. Programming is easy to learn without formal instruction. Theory on the other hand, can and does become quite complex. Sure, its still possible to learn theory on your own, but the professor with the Turing award makes things much easier.
- jcnnghm 16y agoActually, I'm not mixing them up. There are incredible amounts of information readily available that will enable you to learn theory. If you are smart and motivated, you can learn theory without instruction.
- vecter 16y agoTo be honest, I don't think I (or a majority of people) could learn theory without help. Math and theoretical CS are pretty hard. I can't count the number of times that I've had questions that only a TA could answer for me. To be fair, there are resources now like mathoverflow, but I've found having a knowledgeable human you can have a lengthy discussion with is invaluable.
- jchonphoenix 16y agoThat can be said about any field. You stated that computer science was one of the EASIEST fields to learn without formal instruction. My claim is that learning theoretical ideas, discrete mathematics, automata theory, and formal languages without formal instruction is not any easier than any other scientific field, such as chem, physics, or mathematics.
- jcnnghm 16y agoI would argue that because of the computer savviness of computer scientists, documents and tutorials about computer science are more likely to be easily located and properly formatted for display on the internet.
- nanairo 16y agoYeah. Some of us like to go to university just for the joy of the experience, leaning new stuff, being surrounded by experts in the field. Sadly these type of abstract advantages cannot be quantified and hence are always forgotten. If I took a degree for the money and not the interest then I would have chosen Economics or Management, not Physics! And what about those who chose foreign languages? Or literature? Etc... Hopefully there's more than monetary advantages in going to uni.
- jimbokun 16y ago"I'm a Computer Science senior right now, and sure, I could have learned all the stuff I learned from buying my own books, but I never would have." One of the weird things about college or university is that it gives one social license to spend four years, or more, learning something as an adult. If you were not enrolled in a university, but instead diligently reading books, solving problems, writing essays etc. for four years without being otherwise employed, people would find you eccentric at the very least. But once officially enrolled at an educational institution, society thinks it is not only perfectly fine to do the same things, but to take on large amounts of debt for the privilege of doing so.
- alextp 16y agoThis is very true. I sometimes use the fact that I'm a phd student as a cover to study other, completely unrelated things (and get paid for it). It's weird to see institutional validation bias into play.
- wildjim 16y agoAs opposed to myself: I'm a Psychology Research graduate working as a Computer Engineer (for the last few decades) who taught myself an awful lot of what I know from reading books and manuals...
- ErrantX 16y agoSadly I think we are in the minority. I did Electronic Engineering and about 60% of my year group are now all pure management. Some of the rest are "consultants". I'd say around 15% went into engineering. I went to learn something & to have a damned good time doing it. A lot of people I met were there because they had nothing else to do and at least could get a job at the end.