3 ms·
"Why do you think that his main Thesis about events with large impact and low expectation and their effect on our ability to make predictions is incorrect?" I
by timr 16y ago
"Why do you think that his main Thesis about events with large impact and low expectation and their effect on our ability to make predictions is incorrect?"
I didn't say that. I said that he's a bad writer, that he argues in flimsy metaphors, and that he tends to make sweeping generalizations based on little more than his own previous metaphors and generalizations. Don't put words in my mouth.
It's axiomatic that low-probability events must occur, given a long enough outlook. What's not axiomatic are the broad, overwrought conclusions that Taleb reaches from this starting place. Reasonable people who grasp the basic tenets of probability theory as well as Taleb can (and do) arrive at drastically different conclusions about US fiscal policy than does Taleb.