3 ms·
Any specific features you believe makes it better than TB? First impressions aren't great -- is Claws an "email should be text only" advocate? -- brief look an
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
Any specific features you believe makes it better than TB?
First impressions aren't great -- is Claws an "email should be text only" advocate? -- brief look and the default mail format being non-standard; and all the screenshots on the website showing text only emails; tools including a special script to order threads by date (how else would you order them?); and the latest amendments to those scripts being over a year old; most recent theme links to a website that's offline.
...um, the downloads are from a server without a cert (cert is self-signed for a different domain; and their bugzilla is http only too), think that's a nope from me. Not because of the cert exactly but because not getting that write for a group that are supposed to be dealing in internet security seems like an indication of neglect.
- slrz 9y agoWhat do you mean with non-standard default mail format? Most mail I receive from Claws users seems perfectly fine, which is something you can't say for most other popular MUAs. Outlook and certain web mailers probably being the most egregious examples, only topped by some (thankfully rare) Android vendor mobile apps. The TLS setup certainly sucks but OTOH, the actual distribution archives are all cryptographically signed. Most users don't get Claws Mail from the website anyway, but use their distro packages, whose maintainers have hopefully verified the signatures before importing a new release.
- aidenn0 9y agoYou need to enable a plugin for html mail, but the plugin ships with claws. Up until 2013 the best option was a janky GtkHtml based plugin (about as good as average html e-mail renderings from early 00s, so not good), the current one is webkit based and works great[1] What do you mean by "default mail https://www.colino.net/wordpress/archives/2013/03/14/claws-mails-fancy-html-rendering-plugin-on-windows/format https://www.colino.net/wordpress/archives/2013/03/14/claws-m... being non-standard"? you don't need a script to order threads by date, it's an option in the main menu. It doesn't offer downloading over HTTPS, but a GPG signature is provided. Old-school, but not at all insecure. Things it does better than TB: TB has corrupted it's mail store on 3 separate occasions, in 3 different releases spread out over a decade. Claws has never done that. That's the reason I switched. It's builtin filtering, sorting, &c. tools are really great. Full-text search is slower than I'd like, but header based searching is plenty fast (the mode I use most searches all of from/to/subject, which is mostly what I want to do). When I need to do full-text searching I fall back on notmuch. My requirements for an e-mail client are fairly simple (in order of importance): 1) Let me read my mail 2) Don't lose my mail 3) Give me some reasonable way to automate the parts of my workflow that it makes sense to. TB has failed so bad at #2, that I've not spent the time to explore how it is at #3. It's about equal at #1. 1: https://www.colino.net/wordpress/archives/2013/03/14/claws-mails-fancy-html-rendering-plugin-on-windows/ https://www.colino.net/wordpress/archives/2013/03/14/claws-m...
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoExcellent, thanks for such a detailed response.
- aidenn0 9y agoActually every e-mail client I've used has had its issues, including commercial ones. TB isn't great for composing fancy formatted e-mails; I haven't figured out how to bottom-post such e-mails at all. Outlook seems to change lots of little things I don't care about every release, making it harder to use, since I can't gain familiarity well. Furthermore I hate corresponding with people who use it, since it puts a lot of effort into breaking threading. Thunderbird is just not a reliable store of data; perhaps it's fine for people who IMAP and store data on the server, but it's not for me. Which leads me into trojita; this is actually a fairly nice imap client, but I tend to keep my e-mail local, so I haven't used it much as my daily driver. mutt is terminal-only which rules it out for a lot of people (note that terminal only doesn't rule out reading html e-mail, it just rules out reading html e-mail in a manner that looks any better than lynx/links2). All of the notmuch frontends I've tried are kind of "the 10% of gmail that's easy to implement" and then abandoned. Bower has been both the most performant and the most stable, but it, like mutt, is terminal only, and is relatively feature-poor. I'd hack on it, but it's written in a statically-typed dialect of prolog that will probably take me weeks to learn. Note that I actually use a modified form of notmuch-web for handling mailing-lists; threads come in tagged as unanswered, so people can easily see what needs to be responded to.