5 ms·
Plug wars: the battle for electric car supremacy
- greglindahl 9y agoTesla's Chademo adapter is $450, so it doesn't sound to me like it's a life-or-death issue for any car company with volume to back the right or wrong fast charging technology.
- boznz 9y agoShame all these players cant get their shit together before we all have electric cars :-(
- twblalock 9y agoI'd rather see them compete on features, especially charging speed and ease of use. Hopefully the best system will become a standard, but even the mediocre ones should improve in response to competitive pressure. If the manufacturers agree on a standard so early in the development of the electric car industry, we'll be stuck with it for a while because there won't be anything pressuring them to improve it. All of this ought to be moot for buyers anyway. When I travel to countries with different electrical plugs than my own, I just bring an adapter. Hopefully the car charging systems will develop in such a way that it's possible for electric car owners to just keep a few adapters in their trunks when they need to charge somewhere other than their homes.
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoThere are multiple failures. There is a standard for ac power, j1772, it works fine. Pretty much every electric car can use it, even the tesla (it comes with a free adapter). Early ev charging standards had a fatal flaw, they allowed too little power. The j1772 only allowed about 30 amps. This was fine because early electric car and charagable hyrbrids only had tiny batteries that could be filled up in a few hours, there was a giant failure of imagination to see larger in the future batteries, or deliberate sabotage, so there was no planning for what would be needed to support large battery cars with needs for traveling. Then tesla came along with a giant battery & it couldn't be recharged in a reasonable timeframe. What good is 250 miles range, 80 kwh if it takes 2 days to recharge it? So there was an extension of the j1772 standard to support 80 amps, 220 v and this let you charge the tesla at 60 miles of range per hour. The early leaf barely had 80 miles of effective range. So this extension of the j1772 was great, but only tesla needed it. afaik, no other evs support the higher power of the j1772. Then tesla forsaw if they built high power dc chargers, then you could have long range travel - there were the superchargers, 120 kw - this used dc. dc has an advantage bc it can directly charge the batteries. There was no good standard for that, so telsa made their own. They offer it free of charge if people agree to not sue them. Then the american automative engineers came up with a different plug standard that had sepaate ac and dc chargers, and it had the fatal flaw that there was one using it, it was less attractive than others. Next, in europe, the car makers noticed that tesla was impossibly building long range, good cars that people wanted and even reduced their sales a bit. They built their own standard. There were claims it could have larger power than tesla super chargers but I think it was limited in practice. and again, no cars using it (eventually a few came on the market), and few or no high powered chargers. There was a law mandating so teslas in europe use that plug format. Then porsche decided they'd build a new standard that was better than teslas, and it's like double the power. But tesla has already built thousands of super chargers in their worldwide network for years. The new porsche format would be faster than teslas but i believe there are none in existence outside of a test system, and it would also not work on normal commerical power systems, afaik. The tesla plug has another advantage, it is small and light and supports both ac and dc through the same plug. The other car companies would never accept that the tesla plug could be the defacto standard, so we have all these different things showing up. Chademo was a better plan, it was 50kw, it was in lots of place in Japan. It is the only widely used standard that approaches widespread use that is close to the supercharger. What's really needed is a world wide standard, free of patents and chargers, that spans ac and dc, and supports chargins and v2g, but also allowed for very high power rates. These plugs negotiate the amount of power that you send, the car controls it, so you can have a plug system that for some cars sends 120 kw, for others sends 120v 10 amps (1.2kw). We need a standard that can imagine charging 100kwh battery in 5 minutes in the distant future, but works for things today. Tesla could probably have been that. The likely thing is j1772 + one of the 3 major intl standards (higher power than 50kw chademo, or the euro standard or the us standard). Meanwhile, I'll keep driving my tesla, like I have since the end of 2012.
- tlb 9y agoAC is straightforward to standardize (it's just a plug, and signaling for the maximum current), but DC charging is complex because the charging electronics are in the charging station. A charge station would have to support all present and future pack voltages, and be able to deliver a requested current at that voltage (and the request can change second-by-second.)
- heisenbit 9y agoBased on the article AC is not so powerful as DC. Makes perfect sense as the former changes direction while the latter is more direct. The mirages of modern journalism... You got a good point - the architecture, weight trade-off, capabilities trade-off and cost trade-offs matter. Who is responsible for what. As long as the industry changes quickly and big players don't agree the vertical integrated solutions will stay. In the long run there is a need for a platform as it will be cheaper to do as much as possible in the shared infrastructure. When lower cost cars are getting on the market in larger numbers may mark the time when things are settled.
- jwatte 9y agoThe real problem is that there isn't enough "top off" outlets at shopping centers, work places, and parking lots. It's actually cheap to put in regular outlets or 220V J1772. In some northern states, they actually have these to heat the cars in winter; let's just promote that idea to everywhere.
- j1772 9y agoDon't forget China. They took the European charge Mennekes connector, swapped the polarity of the pins, and then declared it "promoting indigenous innovation". China also has a DC charging plug that is completely different from everything else. Now every Chinese car needs TWO plugs. The dream of a world wide standard is impossible to achieve, since setting differing standards is much easier than imposing duties. It is similar to why North American cars seldom have yellow turn signals at the rear ... FMVSS vs EU-Directive and the likes.
- aunty_helen 9y agounlike the one-size-fits-all nozzle that can refill all petrol cars Current petrol stations (in NZ) have 4 different 'one-size-fits-all' nozzles. 91/95/98RON + diesel, some places also have adBlue for diesel trucks. It's wasteful to have multiple plugs but not the end of the world.
- donatj 9y agoDumb question I've been wondering for a while: why not standardize the batteries themselves, make them easy to swap, robotically from underneath maybe? Then have stations that switch out your battery like a propane tank rather than having to wait and recharge?
- ohazi 9y agoThe difference in value between a "new" and "used" collection of cells is on the order of $10k. If you built a system that swapped your cells like this, you'd have to charge somewhere in the neighborhood of this amount -- the price of a powertrain overhaul, rather than the price of a charge -- in order to avoid instantly going bankrupt.
- Lramseyer 9y agoNot really. On a battery unit, the time and number of charge/discharge cycles [wear] can be measured and used to calculate the depreciation of the battery during the time it spent in any particular car. The user can then be billed on a swap. The benefits to this are that the cost of the battery is spread out over time for the customer. And since the customer is always effectively paying the difference in cost of the deposit on the battery, the battery in their car will never exceed the value of what they have paid already. This also makes it way easier to recycle batteries once they have reached end of life as well.
- totalZero 9y ago> “People don’t care about pack swap,” Musk said. “The superchargers are fast enough. Based on what we’re seeing here, it’s unlikely to be something that’s worth expanding in the future unless something changes.” http://fortune.com/2015/06/10/teslas-battery-swap-is-dead/ http://fortune.com/2015/06/10/teslas-battery-swap-is-dead/
- jwatte 9y agoMost electric car owners never charge other than at home, while they are sleeping. The "I need to take my car across the country on a whim" theory of car ownership isn't /actually/ a thing for most people, and "range anxiety" was engineered by the petroleum industry. Put an outlet at every parking spot for topping up while you work or shop in a more remote location, and you'll solve the problem for 95% of all urban cars. (If your commute is > 80 miles, you have a bigger problem!)
- jwatte 9y agoJ1772 was fine until they added IP networking. I do not want a physical network connection between some unaudited charging station code and my likewise unaudited car control code. I don't even want to turn on telematics, until the car industry subcontractors start hiring security engineers instead of EEs for their software.
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoi've never heard that j1772 has ip networking to the car, are you sure of that? it's at least optional, because you can have home j1772 chargers without needing an internet connection.
- microcolonel 9y agoThe article repeatedly states that DC chargers can deliver more power than AC chargers, but I don't see how that could be a thing. Is it some limitation with the onboard power supplies? It's my (limited, third-party) understanding that dual chargers on a Tesla will gladly saturate a 240V 80A J1772, while a single charger will take 48A off a NEMA 14-50 @ 240V.
- lazyjones 9y ago> Is it some limitation with the onboard power supplies? I'm pretty sure it's a limitation of the rectifier circuit in the charger.
- gwbas1c 9y agoIt's a limitation in the car. When you have an AC based charger, the conversion and step up to battery voltage happens inside the car itself. This process generates waste heat, which must be vented. At level 1, (wall outlet,) and level 2, (oven outlet,) it's not a big deal. When rapid charging, the heat dissipation is huge. The AC to DC converters that can handle rapid charging are physically huge and There's no practical way to put that inside the car itself. I suggest learning the basics about how charging a battery works. You need to apply a DC voltage directly to the battery. Electric vehicle batteries are in the hundreds of volts. What these systems do is the car and the charger communicate, and the car ends up telling the external charger how to charge its battery. That's why there's a lot of competition among standards.
- microcolonel 9y ago> The AC to DC converters that can handle rapid charging are physically huge and There's no practical way to put that inside the car itself. Ahh, that makes more sense now that I think about it. Because of the cross sectional area required to efficiently rectify and transform such high currents, the equipment is either very large (and thus expensive) and heavy (and thus inappropriate for a motor vehicle), or very inefficient (requiring considerable active cooling, and costing a lot more dosh).
- NotSammyHagar 9y ago
- _ph_ 9y agoHere in Europe, CCS is now the official standard for DC charging. Europe had already Type 2 as standard for AC charging. CCS is a Type 2 plug with 2 additional large pins for DC. Tesla is using Type 2 both for AC and DC. So the plugs of a Tesla supercharger actually fit into a CCS socket. But of course, it won't charge. Tesla seems to be at the limits of the Type 2 plug with their superchargers, CCS is supposed to scale to larger power levels. So, while there probably was a tactical component in the German manufacturers pushing for CCS, one can also make quite good technical arguments for CCS. In true German fashion, it is bulky and somewhat overengineered for current cars, but for a reason.