8 ms·
Clever ad spot, but I think this is confusing the debate more than clarifying: 1) >Video portrays a world where patrons pay more for fast service Paying more
by SilasX 9y ago
Clever ad spot, but I think this is confusing the debate more than clarifying:
1)
>Video portrays a world where patrons pay more for fast service
Paying more for faster service is orthogonal to Net Neutrality. Of course you can pay more for a fatter pipe. No one has a problem with this. The issue is preferentially charging for data based on who is dumping it to their side of that pipe.
2) In the food world, you can already, likewise, pay more for better quality food. No one has a problem with that.
3) You can also, more controversially, bribe or tip the staff to get preferential service. That's widely accepted. The food service world is already more like net non-neutrality.
- scaryclam 9y agoYou make some valid points, but considering that the anti-net neutrality folks are making some terrible comparisons and lies to lure the public into backing them, is it really so bad for burger king to do the same?
- bllguo 9y agoyes? What's the point of combatting misinformation with misinformation? not as bad of course, plus the intentions seem good, but still.
- nly 9y agoWhen your opponent will win at any cost, sometimes you just have to do the same. We saw bad (but winning) analogies in the UK media with the refendum on voting reform[0]. Ultimately the pro-reform side didnt have good analogies, and people failed to understand what they were voting for. FPTP is easy to explain and feels fair when explained in the laziest way. "One person, one vote" was the winning campaign slogan. Powerful stuff. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Alternative_Vote_referendum,_2011 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Alternative_Vot...
- ikeboy 9y agoWhat lies are being used?
- weaksauce 9y agothe main one I have seen them say is that "we didn't have net neutrality back in the day and everything was great" when there was throttling and disabling of services that actually triggered NN to be codified as law.
- ikeboy 9y agoWell the more careful claim it that none of the violations were that bad and definitely not enough to justify regulation across the board, Stratchery sketches out that argument reasonably well. I think it's broadly true that the internet was not, in fact, a dystopia during those times.
- ikeboy 9y ago>The issue is preferentially charging for data based on who is dumping it to their side of that pipe. This has nothing to do with the recent order, it was legal before.
- rabboRubble 9y agoThink the ad adequately replicated the consumer frustrations to be had without net neutrality. The consumer environment and drivers will be different, but the frustration will be the same.
- jrs95 9y agoRegarding #2...if only there was a Burger King that I could pay to give me food as good as what they had 15 years ago.
- braindongle 9y agoWe geeks do indeed need to be armed with apt analogies for Net Neutrality and its absence. My current favorite is: toll booths that charge you different amounts depending on your destination. Or, highways with different speed limits depending on your destination.
- na85 9y agoThose are both confusing analogies to me. Don't toll booths already charge you different amounts depending on your destination? We don't have "toll booths" here in Canada that I'm aware of, but on the express toll routes such as the 407 through Toronto, you're charged based on the distance you travel. Is it not the same in the US? I seem to recall that on the Ohio Turnpike you end up paying more if you're going from Toledo to Cleveland than you would if you got off at Sandusky, because you go through more booths. Seems to me a more apt analogy would be that they lower the speed limit across the board, and then charge drivers more to get the original speed limit back.
- braindongle 9y agoThanks for the thoughts. Room for improvement. I had in mind something more like a bridge toll. Two people leaving NYC, one going to New Jersey, the other to Pennsylvania. To get over the George Washington bridge, they are charged different amounts. The bridge authority (Comcast) is in bed with Jersey (Netflix), so they have an incentive to Charge the PA people (Hulu) more and keep the Jersey traffic flowing.
- null000 9y agonitpick: Comcast owns a 30% stake in hulu. If anything, the preferential treatment would be the other way around.
- gruturo 9y agoToll booths charging more if your car is red, or if it’s a certain brand, or if you have a Wyoming license plate. A highway intentionally halving its speed limit, and then asking you money if you wish to drive fast (at the original speed limit) An airline charging you extra if you have a certain brand of products in your checked bag, even though it’s within the weight allowances.
- subroutine 9y agoAgree. A better food analogy would be like some all-you-can-eat 'consignment-style' buffet where a venue provides booths for vendors and charges customers an entry fee. Then at some point the venue realizes that customers are really liking one or two vendors, consuming a lot of their food, so the venue decides to also start charging those vendors people consume the most food from.
- Nition 9y agoOr alternatively, customers can pay an extra $X per month to get unlimited food from the most popular vendors. But now other vendors are suffering because no-one wants to pay for them when they've already paid for their free pass to the popular ones. Net neutrality isn't always charging more for things. Often it's more like "all our mobile plans come with UNLIMITED data for Facebook and YouTube." Which actually seems nice for consumers but hurts any other site trying to inhabit the same space.
- millstone 9y agoThat's a key question - if dropping NN benefited just the titans, that would certainly be stifling the competition. But is it? The most infamous example in the US is TMobile's Binge On, which has a pretty big list of participating services [1] including even a few porn sites. I just don't see evidence that this is tilting things further towards entrenched powers (yet). 1: https://www.t-mobile.com/offer/binge-on-streaming-video-list.html https://www.t-mobile.com/offer/binge-on-streaming-video-list...
- Already__Taken 9y agoI have just the worst feeling looking at this page. How do you qualify your service to get into that offering? What happens when t-mobile gets bought be someone who wants to make a youtube competitor?
- subroutine 9y agoIf I had T-Mobile I would definitely take advantage of zero-rated streaming. Naturally this service is influencing people's choices about what sites to visit and 'binge on' when they have down time. Evidence of this can be gleaned from the reviews from content providers that have gotten themselves onto T-Mobile's Binge-On list... What Binge On providers are saying. Many of the smaller video providers rave about Binge On and what it means for their business: Since joining Binge On, we’ve seen twice the flow of new T-Mobile customers coming to the app and spending twice as long than customers of the carriers.” -- David Moffly, CEO, Baeble Media Sure, it's great for those who decide to opt-in to T-Mobile's terms. And of course it's free... for now. To me it seems suspiciously similar to a silicon valley-type tactic: offer something that clearly has value, but oddly charge nothing, act like of course it'll always be free, and wait patiently as they flock to your platform. Of course there is always a catch. I was interested in what that catch currently looks like, since it will never be more mild than now. I've facetiously paraphrased it for ya'll (if you'd rather read the policy first hand, without the snark, I've linked it below)... -------------------- Binge-On Content Provider Policy and Technical Criteria To be included, a content provider's video delivery will meet the following requirements: A. [Allow us to identify and monitor your content, and we will help you degrade its quality, otherwise we'll make our best effort to degrade it for you lol]. Use of technology protocols which make detection of video difficult such as https and UDP require additional collaboration with T‐Mobile to enable the video detection. B. [Any decisions to change the way you deliver video must flow through us.]. T-Mobile reserves the right to suspend the content provider’s participation in Binge On C. [Your video content is all we want. You're a video streaming service, just stay a video streaming service. If you try to deliver other content, we will count that against our customers data cap]. D.The network caps the bandwidth to detectable videos to 1.5 Mbps and as a result, many video services will deliver videos at lower resolutions that will look good on mobile devices, typically 480p F. T-Mobile reserves the right to [degrade] your content in the event of consistent failure to [degrade your own] content within our guidelines [Lastly, for those that want to opt-out, fine. Just... keep in mind our customers have Bing-On switched on basically always, so that all content delivered to them is under 1.5 Mbps ~480p. If your company can't deal with that for technical reasons, you must OPT-IN to OPT-OUT, per se. That is, we need to identify and monitor your content (ie. stop using https) so we know not to throttle the content when our customers are using Binge-On (aka all our customers, always). ------------------------- [1] https://www.t-mobile.com/content/dam/tmo/en-g/pdf/BingeOn-Video-Technical-Criteria-March-2016.pdf https://www.t-mobile.com/content/dam/tmo/en-g/pdf/BingeOn-Vi...
- Bodell 9y agoJust to play devils advocate for a moment :) 1) The video showed that you could receive a chicken sandwich now. That you were only paying more to receive only ,specifically, a whooper faster. This I thought shows preferential treatment over different types of food (data). 2) the quality of the food was not an issue in this video everyone was receiving the 'same' whooper, presumably. 3) The example burger king made was not quite the same as bribing a Maitre d' to get a table faster than other customers due to limited table resources. The video showed them withholding whoopers that were already made and ready to go, for a certain time-frame, in order to shake down the customer for more money. The idea that others who paid more for their whooper got it faster, due to limited supply of whoopers, was not the issue. The issue was that burger king would be falsely creating a pipeline delay, simply to get money out of the end user. Although, all metaphors will be mostly speculation, as far as how it will directly relate to future ISP behavior and it's relationship with the end users. How exactly US ISP's decide to use the repeal of net neutrality, debatably, remains to be seen. It would be quite hard to form a 100% accurate metaphor for something that hasn't been fully realized quite yet. I do not mean this to imply that the behavior would in anyway be good. simply that the specifics of it are still unknown. As a side note I like to think burger king is also inadvertently creating a self-deprecating metaphor. I hope that in the Internet world it is also only the shitty food that is being tiered. If you have to pay more to get Google, Facebook, Amazon (terrible junk food) then no worries for me. Unfortunately that bit of speculation is probably way to optimistic. ;)
- djsumdog 9y agoYea, the chicken sandwich example is .. interesting. I mean it works in this really basic example and I think it will help the lay-person get the general idea. A more accurate analogy would be in a food court: For free, you're allowed to access Taco Hell, Burger Thing, and Mc Doubles. For $5/month, you get a special pass that also sets you access Suppression Chicken[1], Pizza Slut and Baskin Toboggans For $8/month, you get an extended pass that lets you get into the line for a few more diabetes joins. You can get in any of those lines without a pass, but it will cost $1/visit. This is of course, limitation of service (which is already done in some countries, like Optus Australia which gives you unmetered Facebook and Twitter that doesn't count against your mobile data), or African ISPs that give people free Wikipedia (which is arguably, kinda a good thing -- which is what makes this tricky). The other aspect is quality of service. Say you could get to all those fast food joins for free, but you bought passes that put you in different positions in the queues (which is more like what we see with the Burger King example). It's like the airport pre-check. Pay government extortion prices and you get to jump to the front of the line, while everyone else gets molested by the TSA. [1] Chick-Fil-A .. if you didn't get that one Edit: formatting
- InclinedPlane 9y agoMaybe you weren't paying enough attention to the video. Customers could get chicken sandwiches quickly, but if they wanted a whopper quickly they had to pay extra. This is actually a pretty good analogy for net neutrality. Some things will be delivered at "full throttle" relative to whatever speed internet you've signed up for, other things (whoppers) will be throttled or even restricted in access, and you'll have to pay extra to unlock "full throttle" access.
- okreallywtf 9y agoI thought they handled 1) by acknowledging that paying for "faster" service was really just paying for the service they used to get by default. They weren't really creating a fast lane as much as artificially slowing down the normal lane, which is I think an apt analogy. As for 3, that seems kind of a stretch. I thought they did a half decent job, I don't think it does more harm than good for sure.
- letsgetphysITal 9y ago> 1) by acknowledging that paying for "faster" service was really just paying for the service they used to get by default. This is what everyone is missing. There is no "fast lane" and we need to stop acknowledging that phrase. There is only "your "the service you currently pay for" and "artificially slowed traffic".
- goialoq 9y agoThis is one of the worst things Obama did for Net Neutrality -- tying its fate to paid prioritization because the public is too ignorant to understand any of the real complexities of NN.
- cornholio 9y agoThe analogy works because the customers were portrayed to be 'trapped' in the slow lane, with no option but to pay the extra fee or wait. This is a compelling real life example that anyone can relate to. Of course, repeat customers would avoid such a burger joint - but it's a real debate if they would be able to avoid data selective ISPs given the low competition in most markets. From an advocacy and PR point of view, it's a very good piece that conveys the extreme case in which they are not able to switch ISP.
- rootlocus 9y ago> This is a compelling real life example that anyone can relate to. But that's not what net neutrality is about. Net neutrality is about netflix not being able to take more bandwidth than other streaming services. Net neutrality is fundamentally about producers and consumers sharing a path between them, with that path being neutral towards producers. The burger king analogy pushes the costs of having a faster path to the consumer. In the case of net neutrality, the producers would be able to pay more to take more of the bandwidth. This wouldn't negatively affect consumers financially, but would affect the quality of service of other consumers. It's important to get the distinction right because the consumers wouldn't be affected like the video portrays. They would simply get burgers at burger king faster, but much slower at mcdonalds. They wouldn't understand why mcdonalds isn't able to produce burgers faster, and they wouldn't be able to pay to get faster mcdonalds burgers. They would simply go to burger king.
- wastedhours 9y agoBurger King could pay for a larger store, with wider queues, but they're disincentivised from doing so without pushing the extra overhead onto the customer. Same with Netflix, they could pay all of the tolls with all the of the ISPs, but do you really think they wont push that cost onto the user?
- jsgo 9y agoNot sure I agree with your points. If this were a fatter pipe situation, it'd be like $26 gets a Triple Whopper or something (is that a thing there? Don't know). Instead, it is a matter of getting access to it quicker. With ISPs, you're not paying for the data (it is owned/provided by someone else), you're paying for the capacity to access it. What it is saying is that you'd be prioritized in queue to get to the data (Whopper) based on paying extra with no direct impact to quality of the data (paying extra for fatter pipe does impact quality of streaming, download speed, etc. though, but again, they don't say that the $26 Whopper is any better than the $5 one).