4 ms·
I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the
by rootusrootus 9y ago
I wonder if it is imprudent to create too many vehicles that have partial self-driving capability before we have ones that can do 100% of it. Instead of to the point where you can take your attention away from the road, but not to the point where it can reliably avoid accidents on your behalf. Too many people aren't wise enough to use the partial autonomous technology without abusing it.
- aphextron 9y agoI have a feeling Tesla knew this and didn't care. The marketing value of "Autopilot" is too great.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sathackr 9y agoAirbags save lives. Airbags also kill babies if used incorrectly. There are warning placards in several places in your car saying such. Sometimes an airbag can cause more injury than the accident. A seatbelt may trap you in a sinking car. But overall, airbags and seatbelts have significantly reduced traffic injuries and fatalities. Autopilot saves lives. Autopilot used incorrectly can kill people. But overall, Autopilot has significantly reduced the number of accidents involving Teslas. So do we take airbags away because using them incorrectly might hurt a child? Are they a safety feature or marketing value?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>Autopilot saves lives. There is no evidence of this.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoNHTSA says it does (autopilot reduced crash rates by 40%). http://bgr.com/2017/01/19/tesla-autopilot-crash-safety-statistics-report-nhtsa/amp/ http://bgr.com/2017/01/19/tesla-autopilot-crash-safety-stati...
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoThis is a common misinterpretation. The data only shows that TACC + Autosteer reduced crashes by 40% vs TACC alone. There is no comparison to complete driver control.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 9y agoTesla’s data shows autopilot (TACC + Autosteer) to be 50% safer than human driver control. While I have yet to see an independent study verifying that, the evidence is compelling. Humans are terrible drivers. Time will tell as they ramp production.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWhere does Tesla's data show TACC + Autosteer to be 50% safer than human driver control?
- toomuchtodo 9y agohttp://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/04/25/elon-musk-teslas-autopilot-makes-accidents-50pc-less-likely/amp/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/04/25/elon-musk-t... > "The probability of having an accident is 50 per cent lower if you have Autopilot on," said Musk, speaking at an energy conference in Oslo, Norway. "Even with our first version, it's almost twice as good as a person." > The results are from Tesla's first generation of Autopilot, which owners have already used to drive over 47 million miles since it launched in October 2015.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoOkay, so the problem there is that it isn't an apples to apples comparison. The 'miles driven while using autopilot' basically only contain very nice driving conditions, either slow moving congestion, wide open roads, no miles with snow surely, no lane changing, etc. But the 'miles driven without autopilot' contain all those things, quick lane changes and snow and rain and city driving and parking lot driving, basically all the scenarios where accidents are very likely. It's pure selection bias, it says nothing about the state of Autopilot and Musk likes it that way.
- criddell 9y agoI think Tesla has enough telemetry and miles driven to come up with some idea of whether or not miles traveled with Autopilot on have more or fewer deaths than cars in general. I don't know what the answer is, but there's certainly evidence.
- steve_adams_86 9y ago> Autopilot used incorrectly can kill people. Sorry, I don't get it. How do you use something incorrectly when by definition you aren't really using it at all? It seems like an oxymoron.
- kelnos 9y agoUsing Autopilot while not being alert and engaged would be "using it incorrectly".
- c0nducktr 9y agoMaybe they could take some ideas from the rail industry, which have been dealing with this issue for quite some time now. Engineers are required to to make some kind of input to verify that they're still alert, or the train stops[1] if they haven't done anything in X seconds. Obviously you wouldn't want the car to just stop in the middle of the road, but there could be something like that designed. [1] https://www.quora.com/If-a-train-driver-falls-asleep-what-happens-to-the-train https://www.quora.com/If-a-train-driver-falls-asleep-what-ha...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kg5key 9y agoTesla does have a sensor in the wheel that "feels" for resistance on the wheel. In my experience, it's more than sensitive enough to be able to detect a hand being on the wheel, but is easily defeated by idiots. I'd imagine Tesla wasn't thinking about how the driver alertness feature could be countered unfortunately. Perhaps we'll see Tesla adapting the eye tracking tech that Cadillac Hypercruise is using. https://www.dailydot.com/debug/tesla-orange-hack/ https://www.dailydot.com/debug/tesla-orange-hack/
- Zombieball 9y agoNever knew about the Cadillac. Very cool, thanks for calling it out. I wonder how to truly tell if a driver is attentive? The Cadillac indicates it uses head tracking technology. I wonder if that is sufficient? Seems you probably need even eye-tracking: an attentive driver keeps looking around or something.
- jcranmer 9y agoAll smart-assist cars are required to sense if the drivers are actually maintaining their hands of the wheel. I don't know if they are to disengage or merely to annoy the user, but Tesla is notorious for skirting these regulations.
- deleted 9y ago
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoPeople have been safely and intelligently using cruise control for... decades? It is a partial automation solution that reduces half of what you have to manage when controlling the car (how fast you're going). I suspect the primary problem is not the partial autonomous technology, but the marketing which is convincing people they can trust it. Nobody ever told you your cruise control means you don't have to pay attention, so very few[1] incidents happen due to misuse of it. First and foremost, Tesla should never have been allowed to release "Autopilot" being called that. From the very name it provides a false impression of what it can do. [1]I know you can find one. Humans are remarkably stupid.
- WiseWeasel 9y agoIt seems like an apt name to me; it pilots your car automatically. The only detail omitted is how often it pilots you into plainly visible large objects at full speed. It's true that people may be in particular need of a refresher, since such features could be perceived as more than advanced cruise control. It should be strongly emphasized to all drivers that we need to take full control whenever we see any exceptional conditions, from hazards, obstructions, pedestrians or wildlife in or entering the road, to poor visibility, and even when passing or being passed by small vehicles.
- aardvark291 9y ago> "People have been safely and intelligently using cruise control for... decades?" More than half a century in mass-market automobiles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cruise_control#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cruise_control#History
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- greglindahl 9y agoSo, you're saying that Tesla is wrong, without even bothering to collect any data about whether or not Tesla owners are confused about the capabilities of the system?
- typicalbender 9y agoAs long as there is a human variable I severely doubt we will every get to a system that is 100%. The raw truth of it is to make a system that can do it close to 100% you need data. Tesla has chosen to put a semi-autonomous system into the hands of consumers in order to generate the massive amounts of data necessary to achieve full automation. Other companies have chosen to log a crazy amount of hours using technicians to generate the same set of data, both have and will continue to experienced crashes as they work toward making the system better. Tesla I think has done a fantastic job at striking a balance between getting something into the market the generate real-world data and mitigating the risks that come with it. If this car really did crash into the fire truck at around 65 MPH then it did a pretty good job at keeping everyone safe. I think I would be hard pressed to find any technological or mechanical innovation that did not initially involve risk or have an accident associated with it. I've seen more examples where a Autopilot has done the right thing and avoided an accident than I have read stories of it making a mistake and causing an accident.
- CPLX 9y ago> If this car really did crash into the fire truck at around 65 MPH then it did a pretty good job at keeping everyone safe. I believe your definition of keeping everyone safe differs from the common usage.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI believe parent is referring to the survivability of a 65 MPH head on crash into a heavy object.
- typicalbender 9y agoCorrect, "safe" was a poor choice of word. Alive and relatively unscathed according to the article is what I was going for. Thanks for the clarification.
- CPLX 9y agoIt's also the survivability of the things that are being hit by two ton "autonomous" objects at 65mph that are at issue here.
- wpietri 9y agoYeah, the quote about the NTSB on a similar accident is telling: "the National Transportation Safety Board ruled that Autopilot contributed to the crash by allowing lengthy disengagement from the driving process." In my view, driving is already boring enough that it's insufficiently attention-grabbing for safety's sake. That's why, e.g., the "naked streets" model is removing lane marking. Decreasing (false) certainty forces more cognitive engagement, making things safer: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/feb/04/removal-road-markings-safer-fewer-accidents-drivers https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/feb/04/remova... If anything, for the decades [1] while we're waiting for full automation, I'd like to see the equivalent of Threat Image Projection. It's the technology for luggage scanning where they put images of fake guns, bombs, etc in the images of real luggage. If the operator doesn't press the "threat" button they are alerted that they slipped up. It brings the frequency of important events up into the range where humans can pay attention. It'd be great to have the same thing for cars, so that AR images of deer, cyclists, children, and fire trucks appear; if you don't attempt to take evasive action, you lose points. [2] [1] E.g., iRobot founder Rodney Brooks says not before mid 2030s: http://rodneybrooks.com/my-dated-predictions/ http://rodneybrooks.com/my-dated-predictions/ [2] I am, of course, kidding.
- sp332 9y agoDidn't Tesla respond to the NTSB report by requiring much more frequent interaction?
- greglindahl 9y agoYes. This type of accident in Level 2 systems is never going to be zero.
- samstave 9y agoWould it not be better engineering to have the roads driving the cars, as opposed to having the cars drive the roads? If the roads had sensors in the "bots dotts" and would track and steer all the volume of traffic - isnt that better than all the infantile-AI-cars doing it?
- uniformlyrandom 9y agoDo you really think there will ever be a 100% driverless car? I find it highly unlikely. And the paradox is, the better self-driving cars get, the more trouble driver is in when they are forced to take over. Drivers will be lacking basic driving skill, and essentially will get stuck on snowy/gravel/flooded roads.