6 ms·
Objects larger than the wavelength of sound in an acoustic tractor beam
- vidanay 9y agoWouldn't it be more accurate to call this an acoustic suspension beam? Calling it a tractor beam implies that it can be mounted on the ceiling and pull an object off the floor. Hence the name (at)tractor beam.
- nannal 9y agoNot named after farm tractors then which I'd always assumed had gained their name from the term traction engine.
- navaati 9y agoWell yes and no, traction is the act of "tirer" in French, that is the act of pulling. So a farm tractor is named as such because it pulls some (usually plowing) equipment behind it, and a tractor beam because it pulls some stuff at a distance.
- cyberferret 9y agoAlso reminds me of an interesting lesson we had in flying school, where our CFI was explaining that the "propeller" on an airplane should really be called a "tractor" because it is technically pulling the aircraft along, whereas an actual "propeller" would push the aircraft along (much as a ship's propeller does at the stern).
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoSometimes talking about cars someone brings that up the other way around - rear wheels 'propel', the commonly used 'traction' is about the front wheels pulling the car ...
- janekm 9y agoA propeller propels air behind it. The traction is a side effect by Newton’s third law.
- ithkuil 9y agoFrom Latin: trahere, past participle tractus. Drag, haul.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoWhenever you see "tractor beam" in this context, it most likely refers to "tractor beams" from Star Trek, which are all about pulling stuff towards you.
- Gravityloss 9y agoBesides the farm, also in airplanes. If the propeller is at the front, it's a tractor. If it's at the back, it's a pusher.
- thriftwy 9y agoI think the idea here is that suspension is easy (fans are enough for that), and the tricky part is pulling from "backwards", which this system does as indicated by the last few seconds of video.
- emiliobumachar 9y agoI've only read the posted article, but it seems theoretically possible to move objects, perhaps needing more speakers. For that, shift to a different modulation that sets the trap slightly to the side, at each small step. Analogous to a stepper motor.
- jobigoud 9y agoCan this tractor beam approach be used to gently push a finger in mid-air? Or create the illusion of a solid object where there's none? I'm wondering about applications to virtual reality.
- yorwba 9y agoThere's this company using ultrasound for touchless haptic feedback: https://www.ultrahaptics.com/ https://www.ultrahaptics.com/
- j_s 9y agoThis is awesome! Any further info / alternatives / etc. that you have time to provide would be greatly appreciated. found: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11025820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11025820
- amelius 9y agoBut if somebody stands between the transmitter and the target, the "object" would disappear. I'm guessing this would make the UX pretty crappy. Also, what if the tractor beam inadvertently attaches to your eardrum? (Ok, headphones could solve that)
- mrfusion 9y agoThe game could place things that require touch in certain parts of the room (or orient you in that manner) (Hmm sounds like something that might get patented. Can this be prior art and I donate to you guys?)
- amelius 9y agoAnother option would be to prevent another person to stand in the beam. This could be achieved using very strong haptic feedback from another transmitter :) Or spread multiple transmitters around the room (or even attached to the person's suit) to (try to) prevent blockage. That could work but there are loopholes and thus it's both expensive and not theoretically satisfying.
- rubyfan 9y agoWould this work in space?
- lucozade 9y agoDon't see why not as long as you don't try to use it outside of an environment with an atmosphere.
- jstanley 9y agoSo, no, it wouldn't work in space.
- Robotbeat 9y agoMars is in space. Venus is in space. And, I suppose, the Earth is in space, too. :) But if we're referring to the near-vacuum of space, it's still possible although the forces involved are incredibly small. There is SOME gas/plasma in space, and certain kinds of sound waves with really long wavelengths (called ion acoustic waves) do, indeed, travel through this thin medium. Unlike sound waves traveling in a neutral gas, ion acoustic waves, because they're traveling through a plasma, can also interact electromagnetically. There's a whole bunch of different waves like this that can travel through the plasma in space a lot like sound waves through the air: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waves_in_plasmas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waves_in_plasmas ...so I imagine that something like this could work under certain conditions (i.e very large and very low-mass objects).
- cyberferret 9y agoI don't think it would without some sort of medium to suspend the end target in. I am presuming that the articles in the video 'hover' there because they are caught in an air pressure pocket where multiple opposing waves essentially phase cancel each other out. In space, it would mean no air, therefore no medium in which to suspend the target. I do wonder about suspending nano particles using light waves though... conceivably that might work in space?!?
- 9y ago
- javiramos 9y agoThis project reminded me of Pixie Dust, a 2014 Siggraph project that produced a screen out of suspended particles. https://youtu.be/NLgD3EtxwdY https://youtu.be/NLgD3EtxwdY
- lawlessone 9y agoDo lifted objects exert a force back on the hardware producing the sounds? What happens if we aim these downwards and put a board on top? :-) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1ZdMOMUgXE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1ZdMOMUgXE
- Cshelton 9y agoBetter yet, can we make a platform that will levitate and hold whatever size/shape object it wants. The platform would then reflect all the waves back in a direction, away from the source, in a safe manner. I wonder how much force RF waves can really give? How high above 40Khz can we go?
- catskul2 9y agoRF? I thought we were talking about sound here...
- anfractuosity 9y agoI wondered about that too. The professor at Bristol has the following tweet - https://twitter.com/sonic_bruce/status/669560944234774528 https://twitter.com/sonic_bruce/status/669560944234774528 It says you need ~7.6kW of sound power to levitate a human. That's sound power, so I'm not sure what electrical power you'd need too, I'm not sure how efficient the transducers are.
- mabbo 9y agoBe a very amusing way to trap a person. They can wave around all they want, but the tractor beam has them stuck, levitating. Maybe if they had a backpack and threw it sideways very hard?
- mschuster91 9y agoHmm. 7.6 kW for a human of something around 76 kg (makes calculating easier, reality should be 80-85). That means you'd need about 100W/kg... or, to lift a car of 1t, 100 kW. Should be do-able with a modern biturbo engine and by cutting some weight. Am I the only one thinking of a Star Wars repulsorlift?
- randomdrake 9y agoStudy: Acoustic Virtual Vortices with Tunable Orbital Angular Momentum for Trapping of Mie Particles Citation: Asier Marzo, Mihai Caleap, Bruce W. Drinkwater. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 044301 – Published 22 January 2018. Link: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.044301 https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.044301 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.044301 Abstract: Acoustic vortices can transfer angular momentum and trap particles. Here, we show that particles trapped in airborne acoustic vortices orbit at high speeds, leading to dynamic instability and ejection. We demonstrate stable trapping inside acoustic vortices by generating sequences of short-pulsed vortices of equal helicity but opposite chirality. This produces a “virtual vortex” with an orbital angular momentum that can be tuned independently of the trapping force. We use this method to adjust the rotational speed of particles inside a vortex beam and, for the first time, create three-dimensional acoustics traps for particles of wavelength order (i.e., Mie particles).
- saagarjha 9y agoWhat's the "loudness" of speakers like these? I see that they're ultrasound, so we wouldn't be able to hear them anyways, but are they something a human can safely be around without suffering hearing loss?