9 ms·
The CLARA Method of De-Escalation
- hollander 9y agoThis is basically Non Violent Communication (Marshall Rosenberg). First you need to address their feelings (empathy), to make contact, then proceed to reason and find a solution (strategy). Solution doesn't mean that the problem is gone, but could mean that the situation is accepted.
- ideonexus 9y agoThis technique is extremely powerful in parenting. These are exactly the steps you take to reason with a toddler. Before anything else you have to get them out of their temper ta tantrum and articulating why they are angry. Then you segwey from listening to dialog.
- harshreality 9y agoBut... If you have to still do this with adults, it means the adults haven't learned to regulate their emotions well enough to listen to a rational argument even while they're upset. It's gotten so bad that some adults never listen to things they don't emotionally agree with, even when they're not initially upset (hearing contrary facts makes them upset). That is a catastrophe for rational thought and discourse. If an adult or an adolescent routinely requires being engaged on an emotional level before they'll listen to your rational argument, then once you do engage them emotionally they will listen to anything you say, whether it's logic or pseudologic or rhetorical, semantically-null bullshit. To elaborate a little bit... Of course humans have all sorts of rational deficits. I never meant to imply they could be turned into Vulcans. Putting too much emphasis on emotionally positive engagement over rational engagement leads to even worse emotional fragility and dependence than humans normally have. That leads to a constant preoccupation with the emotional side of interactions. And that indirectly atrophies their ability to evaluate incoming communication rationally, because they're constantly thinking about their own emotional state, or even worse the group emotional consensus of whatever groups they primarily identify as. That emotional evaluation interrupts rational evaluation. I'm not advising people to eschew emotional engagement if they're in the business of persuasion, or in the business of keeping peace, or if keeping peace is a priority in a specific situation. I agree that that is sometimes needed, but I think it needs to be more limited in its application, and not the default approach for handling all disagreements. I don't think it works to create lasting rationally-based changes to concepts in someone's mind; when emotional evaluation (mostly) replaces rational evaluation, anyone who makes the listener feel good can get them to believe anything. All the valid rational arguments you use today can be undone tomorrow by someone else who has no rational arguments but can keep the listener engaged.
- Faaak 9y agoSadly, humans are not rational thinkers. "Never Split the Difference" is a good book about that. I recommend anyone to read it !
- koonsolo 9y agoHaha, I was thinking about the same book when reading the comment! Highly recommended indeed, but you beat me to it.
- rtpg 9y agoI get what you're saying, though I've found that handling the emotional part of a discussion first makes the "rational" stuff way easier. One thing to keep in mind is that many people out there have mental disorders (treated and untreated) that make it difficult on a chemical level to control these things. For example, ADHD destroys inhibition (causing the classic "speak before you think" behavior) on a deep level that's hard to work out even after a lot of training. The way I see it is that emotional appeals serve first to level the playing field for this kind of state of mind, so that the rational discussion can happen. The Jobsian Reality Distortion Field is a thing, but for the most part I think it's about complementing the rational discussion.
- phasetransition 9y agoYour note about ADHD completely resonates with a close friend who has adhd is often open in ways that are to his detriment. Any chance you have a resource I could read more on this as it relates to ADHD
- gerbilly 9y ago>If an adult or an adolescent routinely requires being engaged on an emotional level before they'll listen to your rational argument, then once you do engage them emotionally they will listen to anything you say, whether it's logic or pseudologic or rhetorical, semantically-null bullshit. So that's fine. They will listen, then later mull it over and integrate it. Just because anger arose for them in that moment they were interacting with you does not mean they can't be rational. But more importantly, by creating a positive interaction you may have started to reduce their tendency to outgroup you and 'your tribe'. This can lead to more productive dialogue in the future. Also, as to why that person is angry. No one can know what life experiences that person may have had. Happy well adjusted people from happy families usually, don't fly into a blind rage that easily.
- codingdave 9y agoI'd say that is more valuable in the post-toddler stage. Toddlers test boundaries to see what works - and using this against a 3 year old throwing a tantrum is showing them that tantrums work to initiate a dialogue, which is not the parenting goal you are trying to reach at that stage. Once they are past the tantrum stage, absolutely this becomes a great way to interact.
- ObeyTheGuts 9y agoOmg the pathetic nerds.... Get a life lol
- wallflower 9y agoWhen I did phone technical support for a computer company, I received my share of angry customer calls. In addition to keeping calm at all times in response to angry statements, I would try to subliminally impart better customer behavior on all calls. Since this was in the days of Windows 95, I would often have to spell out DOS and Windows commands. If the command included an "I" like "regedit" or "sysedit", I would specifically say "I as in intelligent" for that letter. These were almost all fairly complicated issues like getting a modem to work in the days of Config.sys and IRQ conflicts and "Plug and Pray". Having a customer primed for intelligence couldn't hurt, as I was leading the customer through regedit and sysedit editing over the phone (no fancy remote control software existed).
- HenryBemis 9y agoOh those were the good old days!! IRQ conflicts, jumpers all around and thinking which device I need less :)
- drsim 9y agoI'd be interested to see how this works in dealing with bad reviews. They often feel disenfranchised/slighted/wronged and not a few, angry. I've been pretty effective in dealing with bad reviews for our app and lots of this method resonates with me. As I'm systematizing the company a key area is putting in a process and tools for the team to handle bad reviews rather than me. So far however, it seems each situation and personality makes it difficult to pin down an effective process.
- vanderZwan 9y ago> So far however, it seems each situation and personality makes it difficult to pin down an effective process. Well, obviously: using one-process-fits-all without appreciating local context is a recipe for disaster, isn't it?
- drsim 9y agoEverything can have a process. A process doesn't eliminate skill and judgement but establishes standards and guidance leading to improvement.
- vanderZwan 9y agoYes, but your description suggests this isn't a thing but is many things interacting, and hence, there isn't necessarily a process to apply, but many different processes (that would also interact, likely with unexpected results).
- b6 9y agoRegarding bad reviews, I feel for you. I am close to someone who is a good person, but seems unable to stop himself from leaving scathing reviews. If it's any consolation, I really believe that 1) trauma he experienced at a young age contributes to this behavior and 2) if he knew the person who produced the product and understood the difficulties they faced during its production, he would not do it.
- 9y ago
- stabbles 9y agoCoincidentally on the frontpage together with the rant of Linus Torvalds
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoI feel that most conflict resolution comes down to finding a compromise - like, you get reimbursed or something. For code and the Linux kernel though, there's little room for compromise - half of a shit patch is still shit. So to speak. It's an effective means of leadership if you're in a position where you don't need to make compromises.
- arkades 9y agoI never got the impression that DE-escalation was Linus’ goal.
- Joeboy 9y agoIsn't it? If you're the unchallenged dictator of a project, it seems to me that saying "I will brook no more of this nonsense" is a better de-escalation strategy than inviting further discussion. Edit: I hope my downvoter understands the irony in their actions.
- qznc 9y agoI rather believe Linus' goal is to change Intel. Some curse words got it escalated to the Hacker News frontpage and that publicity helps. Why de-escalate?
- Joeboy 9y agoYou're right, but I think he's actually accomplished two things - one is to create useful publicity outside the mailing list, and one is to minimize drama on the mailing list. I guess I assumed the latter of those two meanings. Also I interpreted it as a more general claim, not specifically about this fairly unusual instance where nerd talk interacts with stuff that's in the public consciousness.
- crypt1d 9y agoI can totally relate to this from both perspectives (being pissed off at someone, and trying to calm somebody pissed off) and seeing how both approaches work/dont work. Not too long ago I opened a dispute with Ryanair about what I thought was quite obvious their own issue for which I should be refunded (I provided screenshots and everything). I've reached out to their customer support expecting to raise a simple issue that should result in a quick solution on their end. I was shocked to see their support behaving in a very defensive and completely dismissive way that resulted in a 2 hour long support case that didn't really fix anything (they still have the same bug on their website, and I was not refunded). These guys basically upgraded me from 'slightly annoyed' to 'never again will I fly ryanair' kind of customer. In another case, I've reached out to an online chocolate vendor to point out an issue I had with their shipping carrier. I knew it was not directly the vendor's fault, but this being their only shipping method I figured they should be aware as it is a constant problem. These guys acknowledged my frustrations immediately and even offered a symbolic gift card as a way of apologizing for an issue that they can't really fix any time soon. I was generally happy to see them even acknowledging my problem, and in turn completely understood that this was out of their hands. I continue to be their customer even though the shipping is still a pain. I also have a local ad to help my father sell some stuff he makes by hand. As its a hand made thing that he makes in large quantities, mistakes happen every now and then and I get complaints. I try to be understanding of every issue they raise and offer urgent refunds/replacements to anyone affected. Even though people get pissed off they didnt get what they expected, everyone responded much better if I used similar methods of de-escalation. People are often (and understandably) very impulsive and rude when they feel they are being wronged. We should try to be more understanding of these emotions and work towards solving the issue instead of taking it so personally.
- z3t4 9y agoFirst of all, take a deep breath to take yourself out of "fight-mode". Then when you got your brain back you can take these steps.
- vletrmx 9y agoEasier said than done though, right?
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoDirect link [PDF] https://www.nasco.coop/sites/default/files/srl/Bystander%20Training.pdf https://www.nasco.coop/sites/default/files/srl/Bystander%20T...
- elorant 9y agoSomeone should send this to Intel management.
- viach 9y agoWon't someone, who applies this technique often enough, need some psychological help? So that we help customers here and ruin brains of these who do listen and try to calm down all these angry people? I think there is an analogy of conservation of energy law that could be applied to psychology...
- amelius 9y agoWhat also gets me angry is if they leave no way for me to get back in contact with the same support-person after chatting with them.
- dannyw 9y ago"Can I have your name [again]?" "Could you please transfer me to [name] as they were helping me out previously with this issue?"
- amelius 9y agoThat's difficult to ask when you are kicked out of the session with a "have a nice day, please rate this conversation". Come on, just give me a link to click on or an email address.
- the-dude 9y agoWhen I get connected I always take a note of the persons name, and ask for it if it not given upfront.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 9y agoAt this point you discover that everyone in the call centre is called "Dave" for professional purposes.
- baldfat 9y agoI have friends in politics and I have even run for office (School Board 17 people ran for 5 positions and 4 were re-elections I got 6th :( but my friend I was running with she got 5th :). My job every election is to go to where the screamers and yellers are. For some reason the election official leaves these people outside that will yell and throw a tantrum if anyone even mentions a different opinion, which lowers voter turnout. So I stand there for either 20 minutes or 2 hours until I can get people to start dialoguing with me. It can be painful but I actually go through these exact steps and until someone is felt heard and emotionally calmed down and they will never care about a single word you say. I hear how my friend has tens of thousands of dollars spent on his Man Cave in his basement and made all these crooked deals that they have proof of. I stand there and say have you been in his basement? He has a 20" TV a drum kit for 20 years ago and an ugly green carpet. I also want to say that he actually has personal debt and why would he be in the hole if he was raking in the money but ... People just love to feel like they have superior knowledge to anyone they disagree with. This is why debates never change eachother's mind, because we hold on to certain "facts" when in all honesty they are opinion or speculation at best.
- ideonexus 9y agoI volunteered for my town Planning Commission last year and have to deal with this all the time now. Residents are constantly ranting on social media accusing us of moving town borders, down-zoning our enemies, holding secret votes, and cutting deals. In reality, the only thing we did last year was approve a swimming pool and do some research on parking. It's extremely stressful for me as an introvert, but I quietly and patiently explain concepts like due process and open-hearings when I have the opportunity. I stress that everything we do is open to public scrutiny and public comment. I explain that we can't engage on Facebook because it's not an official public forum. I invite people to attend our meetings or read our meeting minutes, but they never do. Real government is incredibly boring and complicated. Its much more fun to rant and rave about conspiracies on social media.
- slfnflctd 9y agoEvery time I've had to deal with the general public in any kind of scheduled gathering for policy discussion, with or without specialists present, someone inevitably says something (loudly and at length) which displays such an utter lack of understanding of what the meeting is for and what it can accomplish that it makes me scream inside. It makes me feel terrible for those who are facilitating. I got so furious the last time it happened that I walked out and left my favorite water bottle behind. We should have great respect for anyone with even remotely good intentions who is willing to plow through this mess of misguided humanity to get something useful done. I'm pretty sure I can't do it, so if I want to see change happen I have to support those who can.
- mnw21cam 9y agoSo is this why when you phone up your broadband provider to complain that the service is down yet again, you get the incredibly infuriating nonsense about how sorry they are and how much it means to them that your service isn't working, before completely failing to do anything about it?
- petercooper 9y agoFor the record, the original, descriptive and not next-to-useless title: "How to talk to angry people: the CLARA method of de-escalation". HN guidelines say: "please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait." Maybe it's time to add "or if it's vague and non-descriptive"?
- HenryBemis 9y agoI liked soooo much more the previous title. The new one removes value of the article.
- hammock 9y ago@dang please change it back, and many would prefer that you don't change helpful, submitter-submitted titles to original article titles just because the guidelines say so.
- vinceguidry 9y agoOccasionally when dealing with irrational people I have found it useful to match their energy level. So if they're yelling, you start raising your voice too. And you take whatever it is they're saying seriously. And if you have an objection, you state that objection. Then you continue the argument until the raised voices seem pointless and you both just calm down. I had to learn this technique when I was living with friends that had undiagnosed and untreated personality disorders. Remaining calm while they're blowing up simply didn't work, and led them to think I was patronizing them. So I'd start making the same points I was trying to make to them, only with a raised voice. I would get completely invested in the argument, while remaining in full control of myself. Soon they would calm down. It usually wound up being a cathartic experience for them. They'd break down after the whole thing was over, sometimes even cried. At first I thought I was doing God's work, but eventually I realized that that sort of thing just wasn't ever going to 'fix' them, and they needed treatment. For most of us, major cathartic events happen once a month to once a year and provide opportunities for permanent personality growth. But when you have a personality disorder, no amount of catharsis will change your behavior, because your brain isn't wired the same way.
- pc86 9y agoOne of my sales mentors shared this story with me, but I'm not sure where he heard it originally. Basically what you said, if someone comes to you angry about something, be angrier but not at them. In all but the most extreme cases they end up trying to calm you down. His example was a tailor of very high-end clothes, think tuxedos that cost as much as most folks' cars, custom women's jackets for formal events, etc. A customer comes in, angry that a button is sewed on with an incorrect thread pattern. Something to fix if you're paying $10,000 for a jacket but not exactly something reasonable to get angry about. The customer comes in, throws the jacket on the counter and demands that it be fixed. Rather than trying to de-escalate their anger, be absolutely outraged that one of your employees would do this. Assure the customer that you will find out who did something so inconceivably stupid, and that you will most certainly fire them on the spot. The expected response will generally be something like "well, it's not that big of a deal I mean if we just fix the threading..." I'm sure there have been exceptions for other folks but every time I've used this tactic (generally reserved for the most egregiously ridiculous displays of anger) it's worked almost immediately.
- yorby 9y agoI would not get mad if Comcast didn't feel the need to transfer me 3-4 times before addressing my issue...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]