10 ms·
High-end art is one of the most manipulated markets (2013)
- tw1010 9y agoManipulation is the game they're playing, that is the whole market. Fuzz your eyes to abstract the details of the art pieces and only look at the social structure around it, and that's all the information you need to predict demand.
- e_b 9y agoExactly. Art is the product for which the value is most close to being completely made up of perception - the artist's brand.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoI found this contradictory. Galleries set prices, but "desirable collectors are well educated consumers and won’t blatantly overpay." What are collectors educated in, exactly? Is it reading the collective market and understanding the pricing signals it generates? Is it marking new art to this market? If the latter, how does that work if the art has no intrinsic value?
- fsloth 9y agoI suppose this means formal or accidental training in art and shared taste with the art market community. I presume the minimal level of skill is identifying famous artists' work from similar pieces of not-so-famous artists, recognizing influences and obvious pastiches, and so on. I.e. someone who had credibility among the art crowd and whos purchase of a work will function as social proof of the gallerists' brand.
- galfarragem 9y agoGood answer. I don't invest in art but I have a friend (an aspiring artist) who advises art investors. He knows the art scene, the trends and the local young artists so he has educated guesses on what to choose.
- jaclaz 9y agoThere is also another effect, which I call recursive over-valuation. The "high-end" art collectors tend to be extremely wealthy, and - with of course some exceptions - wealthy people are wealthy also because they care about money. So, imagine that you are a wealthy art collector and you have just paid - let's say - 100,000 US$ for a painting by an "emerging" artist. It is only human to show off your new painting, and the people you frequent are likely to be also wealthy and art collectors. So, if you have a name as an art collector, that painting soon becomes in your elite a "set point" for the value of the new artist work. The year later, a gallerist that is selling at 115,000 US$ another similar painting of the same artists can well say "Last year TheOtherHobbes bought a similar one for US$ 100,000, and you know him, he wouldn't pay that kind of money if it hadn't this value". And this sets a second precedent, and it goes on. BTW it is all in your interest to "defend" and "promote" the artist (because you defend your investment into it) even if the painting is awful. In a couple of years this way you will be able to re-sell the painting for - still say - US$ 200,000 while having - besides the profit - reinforced your fame as good investor and educated art expert, capable to see the potentiality of the artist ahead of all others...
- CPLX 9y agoSure but this dynamic is always true for all markets for things. You're just loosely describing a Keynesian beauty contest. At the core there's still someone or some group of people making some kind of fundamental aesthetic valuation. It's really more the severe lack of liquidity and impossibility of commoditizing of the market that creates the effect you're seeing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- golergka 9y ago> You’d think the value of art would depend on its aesthetic value; a picture you enjoy looking at on your wall. How could a dismembered corpse artist be remotely successful? Cannot the author imagine a person who would find a dismembered corpse to be aesthetically pleasing and relaxing? If so, I don't think that person with such low empathy should be a journalist.
- galfarragem 9y agoArt is not utilitarian. Art doesn't have the function of being hanged in a wall or maximise good feelings. That's just a low trick to make common people buy it. Art is (self) expression.
- golergka 9y agoYour comment is stated as if you're arguing with me about something, but it doesn't contradict anything I said and I agree with it.
- pveierland 9y ago> Art is not utilitarian. Art doesn't have the function of being hanged in a wall or maximise good feelings. The sentiment can be appreciated, but as a general statement I believe this is false. As an example: when new hotels are built, they are commonly outfitted with a collection of original art consisting of pictures and sculptures. This is certainly done to a large degree due to the utility of the art, which serves to make the hotel more interesting and aesthetically pleasing. Would you argue that decoration for such a purpose does not constitute art?
- galfarragem 9y agoNo, I'm just saying that art is not made to be hanged in the walls and maximise good feelings but is sold to be used like that. And only a subset of artworks are suitable to be sold as original decoration. I'm not a seller but I believe is way easier to sell something with a clear function than the opposite.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoThis is tangential, but if you're looking for an oldschool history channel style documentary of a reclusive artist, this video on Henry Darger was fantastic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjCS_u3Sgpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjCS_u3Sgpg
- ThomPete 9y agoMy wife works in the high-end art and auction world. I always joke that artists are the most extreme capitalist you will ever find. This is a world where a dinner table can easily be sold for 1$mio because it's owned by some famous person. Pretty fascinating world. On a slightly different note. This is also the reason why I think cryptocurrencies/tokens are going to be doing just fine. Humans very rarely exchange and value based on utilitarianism alone.
- vinceguidry 9y agoMy whole attitude towards cryptocurrencies changed when I realized that intrinsic value literally didn't matter to the global rich, they're not interested in growth or value at all, only in security, and they'd be willing to pay a premium to store their wealth if it only means that they can control the risk. Crypto can provide them with precisely that. The volatility of crypto is immaterial, what matters is that it's still around. The resilience of Bitcoin means that rich people can park wealth there. They can trust the protocol more than they can trust their nation's banks, their political institutions, and their social order. Techies can make a nice side income arbitraging the scrambling of the global elite for a safe haven. It's the new Cayman Islands bank account, only now it's math keeping the filthy government's hands off your money, not the flimsy sham of sovereignty.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> The volatility of crypto is immaterial, what matters is that it's still around. The resilience of Bitcoin means that rich people can park wealth there. They can trust the protocol more than they can trust their nation's banks, their political institutions, and their social order. You may eventually be able to make this claim, but to make it now is lunacy.
- ThomPete 9y agoIt is but so is believing in the government-backed securities IMO.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoArt is extensively used to, ahem, conveniently move around large sums of money [1]. It is difficult to differentiate unusual prices due to money laundering from unusual prices due to manipulation. [1] https://mobile.nytimes.com/2013/05/13/arts/design/art-proves-attractive-refuge-for-money-launderers.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2013/05/13/arts/design/art-proves...
- onion2k 9y agoYou’d think the value of art would depend on its aesthetic value; a picture you enjoy looking at on your wall. Considering a lot of the art collectors buy is immediately whisked away to temperature-controlled, pitch dark warehouses where it can be kept safely until it's put back on the market a decade later, I really wouldn't expect the value to be related to what the art looks like at all.
- ThomPete 9y agoExactly. It's not. It's the history of it that matters.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThe history of an artistic work relies on its aesthetics though, surely?
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoNot necessarily. I don’t have an aesthetic fondness for Klimt’s Lady In Gold [1]. Its history, however, is fascinating. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portrait_of_Adele_Bloch-Bauer_I https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portrait_of_Adele_Bloch-Baue...
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoBut, the original creation is centred on aesthetics for most (historic) works, no? FWIW I love Klimt, Lady in Gold isn't my favourite but she's grown on me.
- ThomPete 9y agoNot in the sense we normally mean aesthetic (as in this looks good). In the sense of an aesthetic style (like the renaissance) sure.
- crazygringo 9y agoThis article is bizarre. High-end art prices aren't "manipulated" in some kind of nefarious way, they're just highly illiquid and complicated. The article makes it sound like there's collusion or price-fixing between galleries, but there's no evidence of that. The author makes the argument that more transparency would lead to lower prices... yet simultaneously implies prices are lower than they ought to be: "One of the worst things a dealer can do is over-price a work because they can’t lower the price when it doesn’t sell." And anyways, I find myself sympathizing far more with artists than with the rich buyers here -- making a living as an artist is already hard enough! Why would we want to lower what they can make? And for buyers who want less expensive art, there's tons -- just don't shop at Gagosian! Finally, the article seems to imply that art is subjectively bad now ("rape of dismembered corpses"), but that lowering prices would help fix that. That doesn't follow at all, and modern art on the vanguard is always considered "bad" by the majority at its time -- whether Monet or Pollock. For anyone interested in details of how the art world really works and why, I highly recommend "Seven Days in the Art World" by Sarah Thornton.
- fwdpropaganda 9y ago> The article makes it sound like there's collusion or price-fixing between galleries, but there's no evidence of that. I would say that a gallery bidding on an auction because they have an interest in increasing the transaction price of pieces being sold by an art dealer connected to them is a textbook example of collusion (as opposed to bidding because they want to own the piece). As usual free market fundamentalists will disagree that this is wrong in any way.
- gjem97 9y agoFurthermore, restricting future sales to a buyer because you don't like that they sold the last one sounds pretty anti-competitive, especially when you consider that usually a gallery has a temporary monopoly on an artists works.
- DennisP 9y agoNot only that, but dealers themselves privately bid on pieces they're selling to run up the price, according to Art as an Investment? by Melanie Gerlis.
- jamesfe 9y agoIn short, there is no objective way to value art, so galleries charge as much money as possible for the art. The author of the article is somehow either confused or offended by this.
- blauditore 9y agoOff-topic, but: > If an owner sells a gallery's art, then the gallery will often cut her off from future purchases I don't understand why some authors default to female pronouns in such cases, given English has a gender-neutral one ("them"). Is this a political statement? It just appears childish to me and makes the article look less professional.
- DanBC 9y agoIt's a stylistic choice. It's a bit weird to get caught by this arbitrary choice and ignore all the others they make.
- Bitcoin_McPonzi 9y agoEnglish has no gender-neutral singular pronoun in modern usage.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> given English has a gender-neutral one ("them") I use "they" and "them" as gender-neutral singular pronouns. There is disagreement on this choice of style. Alternating between gendered pronouns seems to be the preferred alternative to the last decade's (s)he he/she garbage.
- StavrosK 9y agoEh, I still prefer "(s)he" to ze/hir.
- SamBam 9y agoYou wouldn't have even noticed it if it were the male pronoun.
- blauditore 9y agoHighly doubt that, but I probably wouldn't have commented. It's not about the gender itself, but whether a gender pronoun has been chosen conciously, which likely is the case here.
- replayzero 9y agoArt is just good provenance - If you attach provenance to anything it becomes art.
- vinceguidry 9y agoThe objective of any industry is to collect power and influence for itself. Collusion is the natural state of affairs once people with power and money start entering the arena. Once you've exhausted the income opportunity that a single firm can offer you, your priorities change. Mere cash grabbing won't move the needle anymore. What you want to be doing at that point in time is move up the value chain so you can capture a healthy percentage of the entire market. Artists that make a killing open galleries and provide for emerging artists to make their mark, of course while you take your cut. You see it in every creative arena. Musicians open record labels, actors open acting schools and talent agencies. Career trajectories differ, but the principle remains the same. You move up the value chain. Once you've mastered selling shovels to the prospectors, then you have to learn how to control value itself. There is no intrinsic value to products of human creation, so that value has to get created somehow. The making of the value sausage is often really, really dirty. But as long as humans want it, then there needs to be a price attached. And that price has to be arrived at somehow.
- theoh 9y ago"Artists that make a killing open galleries and provide for emerging artists to make their mark" This is not generally the case in art. While there exist informal "artist run spaces" set up by struggling young artists, it is unknown for an artist to become a prestigious commercial gallerist. It doesn't happen. Setting up a gallery primarily requires capital, and only secondarily involves artistic judgement. Damien Hirst is the only partial exception I can think of, and he was also involved in coordinating group shows in temporary industrial spaces early in his career, so he has always had an interest in staging exhibitions. His London gallery is definitely not about making sales or supporting emerging artists, though. It's a status symbol. There are a few ways of looking at the art world that explain why artists don't become gallerists. One thing is that gallerists/curators are "cultural intermediaries" rather than creators. It's a different talent. Artists are sometimes asked to curate but they don't get involved in setting up galleries or publishers. It would be like an actor setting up a chain of cinemas. I guess the phenomenon you perhaps have in mind of movie stars becoming producers differs because producing is still a creative activity. There's a book called "Art World Prestige" that does a sociological analysis of what goes on -- all the things that are specific to the art world.
- doh 9y agoThere is a fascinating book on the topic of pricing art [0]. It was an eye opening study for me. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Talking-Prices-Contemporary-Princeton-Sociology/dp/0691134030 https://www.amazon.com/Talking-Prices-Contemporary-Princeton...
- djsumdog 9y agoThis makes me think of an episode of the short lived Dilbert animated series, where Dilbert engineers the perfect piece of art (a Blue Duckie). It becomes highly popular and the rulers of the underground art world (I think it included a still living Michelangelo or DiVinci) kidnap him and tell him to cut it out.
- cousin_it 9y agoI can't make myself outraged about rich people throwing money at each other. If there was no art, they'd find another excuse. It's not like that money would go to saving lives. I'm also not outraged about few artists making a living from all this money flying around. Artists aren't entitled to rich people's money, it's a side effect of the game. The only thing I'm outraged about is when the elite starts foisting ugly art on the poor, by putting it in public squares and government museums and textbooks. No matter how advanced your taste is, it's a brute fact that the poor don't enjoy ugly art. So these actions amount to taxing the poor in favor of the elite, which is immoral.
- bfuller 9y agoThe high priced art market definitely has negative effects on culture. When something is sold for $100m it stops being about whatever the art represents and just becomes about how expensive it is.
- watwat1 9y agoHow do you know the poor don’t enjoy ugly art?
- saint_fiasco 9y agoThe art they make themselves doesn't look like high-end art.
- matt4077 9y agoAlmost all artists, even successful ones, spend decades in poverty and uncertainty. Yes, it is tautologically true that today's "great artists" will also be rich. But considering that the art market is far more difficult to predict than even professional sports or science, nobody would choose a career in art for financial reasons.
- simonsarris 9y ago> I can't make myself outraged about rich people throwing money at each other. If there was no art, they'd find another excuse. It's not like that money would go to saving lives. What if they're throwing money at each other so that down the line they have the plausible deniability when they, um, "donate" $10m pieces because they need a tax write-off? What if its manipulated to inflate costs for a very hilarious game of tax evasion? Is that worth any outrage?
- petecooper 9y agoPerhaps a (2013) in the title?
- campbellmorgan 9y agoMost people tend to dismiss the wide-range manipulation of high-end art as an irrelevant problem that only affects millionaires and a tiny subsection of "commercial artists". A point worth making is that more often than not, it is taxpayers who end up footing the bill when public museums purchase wildly expensive work whose price has been driven up by the processes described in the article. While museums may get a discount for being important "taste-makers", I can't believe that that makes up for the crazy overvaluation. This alone should make the case for better regulation as difficult as it must be across international borders.
- hutzlibu 9y agoSo lets stop making museums buy overpriced art then. So while it is nice for the public to be able to see a certain original, I can think of millions of better ways to spend that money and then just see a replica.
- campbellmorgan 9y agoI'm with you and ready to sign any petition that stops museums buying Jeff Koons!
- gt_ 9y agoI spent 4 days in a row at the Met last week and I still want to agree with you. Museums are mostly a delicacy. The Louvre was built for artists to study other artist's work. That's tremendously not how we use museums. Medium is valuable for study, yes, but I didn't learn anything last week. I just saw evidence of it in bare vision. But I am torn, because the more privately funded museums seem to be more prone to skewing history. I could be wrong.
- candiodari 9y agoA story I heard is that it's very useful for tax cheating. You want to pay someone a lot of money ? "Sell" them high end art cheap. Nobody questions if art suddenly sells for 40% less or more, and then resells after a few years for 4x or 5x it's original amount. Of course, not entirely risk-free. Same goes for things like some watch brands and a few other things.
- Geekette 9y agoThe biggest issue in the art market is transparency and it continuously amazes me that governments allow it to go on because at minimum, a lot of tax money is lost. The fact that this sector is so under-regulated enables the opacity, making it a great avenue for money laundering and fraudulent behaviour including forgeries (enabled not just by forgers but some dealers), inaccurate reporting (flawed stats), price manipulation, collusion (at all levels and between individuals and organizations), etc. Buyers often never know whether they just overpaid or underpaid or what the current value for a piece is. Change is most possible (and has been occurring in fragments) in the primary art market vs secondary (resales, mostly of dead artists). BTW, for those implying artists benefit the most: galleries often make the bigger share of any sale they're involved in, with commissions ranging anyhere from 50-70% or more. Plus, auction house premiums are often at least 20%, leaving less of profit for seller (after subtracting original purchase price).
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> a lot of tax money is lost Art sales are taxable.
- Geekette 9y agoOf course, art sales are taxable but how much tax can be collected when many transactions are undeclared, item prices of declared sales are not reported correctly for various reasons, thus incorrect amount of tax is assessed? A lot of the activity in this sector is simply undetectable, even to many insiders.
- wastedhours 9y agoYou don't have to on-shore art. You can keep it as a store of wealth in "Freeports" (logistics hubs within airports around the globe) and not have to pay tax on the purchase or asset in your homeland if you have the required funds sitting outside of your tax base, which in these cases, is quite likely.
- simonsarris 9y agoYeah and you buy a piece for $1m and sell it for $1.1m to the guy who wants to "donate" it to a non-profit for a tax write off of $10m, offsetting his tax bill on something much larger. It's a vehicle for tax write offs and laundering.
- damontal 9y agoF For Fake is a great movie/video essay by Orson Wells investigating the work of one of the most notorious art forgers of the 20th Century. Fascinating story worth seeking out. The full film is on youtube at the moment, as well as Filmstruck.
- samfriedman 9y agoIt's a brilliant film not just because of its subject, but because Wells uses the structure of the movie itself to say something about the world of forgery.
- currymj 9y agoshocked that this doesn't mention taxes at all. if you donate a piece of art to a museum, in the US you can deduct its "fair market value" from your taxes. so if there's a way to drive "fair market value" up higher than what was paid, say if a few comparable artworks sell for an inflated price, everyone can donate to museums and effectively realize some profits without crashing the market by actually selling their art.
- kingkawn 9y agoThe opening paragraph’s assumptions imply that the history of art is meaningless. This is ignorant of the entire evolution of the discipline.
- d--b 9y ago> You’d think the value of art would depend on its aesthetic value. This is just plain wrong. Not only does the author not understand art at all, but he also doesn't understand basic collecting. Following that judgment, people collecting post stamps are just morons, cause a stamp that's been used can't be used again and so has 0 value - except perhaps its aesthetic one, which is not huge...
- hansmalone 9y agoWhile I feel I've seen enough evidence to suggest that galleries are used to launder/manipulate the market, this writer's reasoning seems problematic. Her whole argument starts from a place of misunderstanding art entirely: "You’d think the value of art would depend on its aesthetic value; a picture you enjoy looking at on your wall. How could a dismembered corpse artist be remotely successful? Yet these paintings were classified as desirable by the art market." aesthetic value != "a picture you enjoy looking at on your wall" and further, a corpse can't be enjoyable to look at?? (Picasso's Guernica, Caravaggio's Death of a Virgin...) That'd be like saying the movie market is clearly manipulated because Blair Witch Project is the most successful indie of all time.