14 ms·
BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging
- ddinh 9y agoI wonder how long it will take before somebody figures out how to jailbreak BMW infotainment systems to enable CarPlay. This kind of stuff is not exactly without precedent: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1099782_bmw-i3-rex-electric-car-coding-unlocks-features-owners-want-and-may-void-warranty https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1099782_bmw-i3-rex-elec...
- Klathmon 9y agoA bunch of us were hacking on Mazda infotainment systems a while back trying to get some more features. The biggest limitation was that it looked like it used an older version of presto (operas old engine) as the main UI engine, and it was pretty locked down. But even then we got some cool features worked into it and disabled some annoying ones (like the "hit okay to agree to be safe" on every start of the car). I actually wonder if they every got Android screen mirroring working, which was the "holy grail" of what most of us wanted.
- awinder 9y agohttps://mazdatweaks.com https://mazdatweaks.com Android Auto is working, but looks like mazda locked down the USB ports so there’s some disassembly required if you’re past a certain firmware version. Android Auto and CarPlay are supposed to be coming to recent mazda models but apparently it’s been promised a while. I’m gonna wait a year and then see what the state of that + the hack scene is but seems like interesting stuff!
- Klathmon 9y agoThat's genuinely amazing! I honestly didn't think it would be possible when I sold my Mazda a few years ago, and I'm so happy they were able to get it working. And I'm with you, I don't believe that AA or carplay is coming any time soon, since they were saying that it was "coming soon" when I sold the thing. And there is absolutely 0 chance they will allow an update to bring it to older cars.
- mdekkers 9y agoI followed this for some time, and eventually ripped out the Mazda system and replaced it with a Chinese Android system that just did what I wanted.
- vinceguidry 9y agoI didn't understand the net neutrality dig. Price gouging is price gouging, the practice is far older than the Internet.
- mmcconnell1618 9y agoBMW is switching from a one-time $300 to an $80 annual fee. The net neutrality comparison is your ISP charging you $5/month more just to access YouTube.
- plorkyeran 9y agoHow is switching from a one-time fee to an annual fee in any way similar to charging extra for a specific website other than that they both involving charging money?
- gervase 9y agoI think the intention is something like: A service which is free from the creator's perspective (YouTube / CarPlay) will now carry a new fee imposed by the company which delivers the service (ISP / BMW) despite the intention of the creator.
- muro 9y ago1. It carries a cost before, just the way it's charged had changed 2. It's not free
- hedora 9y agoI don’t see how this is any worse than the standard practice of charging an annual fee to automatically call emergency services if the airbags deploy. (Especially since it is illegal in the US for cell phone providers to deny access to 911 due to non-payment)
- lotsofpulp 9y agoPresumably the vehicle manufacturers are paying the mobile networks for the ability to call emergency services. I doubt it falls under the same rules that allow for mobile phones to always call 911.
- disillusioned 9y agoNot least of all because the vehicles _don't_ call emergency services. They call a service center that can dispatch emergency services if they determine it's necessary.
- hedora 9y agoI assume they do that so they can skirt the law about charging for 911 service. If the car decides to call 911, and the driver is not coherent enough to say “We’re OK, and there is no need to file an accident report; don’t send anyone.” (or press a “cancel” button within 10 seconds, before 911 is dialed), then the only responsible thing for the dispatch center to do is forward the call to 911. It would strictly be better to just call 911 directly. The current system just delays dispatch of the first responders. Since airbag deployments are rare and expensive, and imply significant risks of injuries or third party property damage, there’s no way the false positive rate on this will cause significant trouble for the police or 911 dispatchers. Adding a extra human to the loop can only delay the dispatch of emergency services, leading to loss of life, even for paying customers. I can’t think of any realistic scenarios that serve as a counter argument. Can you?
- lttlrck 9y agoThe service center may have access to GPS location which offset any delay by a large margin. 911 can’t get that from an unconscious or disoriented driver. Besides the service centers exist for other purposes such as breakdown recovery, not just for corralling 911 calls.
- analog31 9y ago>>>> If there's a positive to this system, and I'm admittedly stretching here, it's that you can get a car configured exactly to your needs, a car uniquely constructed to your exact specification. I imagine that's a very nice feeling indeed, though I confess I've never had the wherewithal to enjoy such a luxury myself. I've enjoyed that luxury on the two cars that my family owns. Both were purchased with zero options. Granted, they aren't BMW's. ;-)
- flibble 9y agoThis fee shouldn’t be compared with net neutrality. It’s a completely different and less scary thing.
- torstenvl 9y agoOne of the fears among Net Neutrality advocates is that, without the Internet being regulated as a utility, ISPs will start nickel and diming you for using services for which the ISP is only the conduit. Call it the Trojan model of rent-seeking. That may not be the most important aspect of the Net Neutrality fight for you, personally. But it is an aspect of it. And it is valid for others to be concerned about it. And for those people to whom Net Neutrality is principally about nickel-and-dime rent-seeking, comparisons to BMW's nickel-and-dime rent-seeking are appropriate.
- icantdrive55 9y agoI find these cute annual/monthly fees very troubling. Any MBA, "Hay, the idiots(customers) will not blink on the low monthly reaccuring fee! It's the price of a pizza. Once we hook them, they will probally forget about our monthly bill!" They are becoming so common, they must work? Hell--I just dusted off an old Neat Scanner I bought years ago when I had too much money, and they now think their product is so special people will pay a monthly fee for CL----oud Service. Nope. They don't work on my end. Rent, water, electricity, and begrudgingly the most hated company (My lovely internet monopoly) in America, and a burner phone. Yes--I've become as cheap as my father. Actually, not as thrifty as my dad, but don't like giving away money to dubious companies, and their dubious products. I will basically write off a product if they want a monthly fee. It's not so much about the money; it's the principal art this point. (Not in a good mood today--sorry.)
- apercu 9y agoSo don't buy BMW's if it matters to you. The issue will then self correct. I guess it's easy for me to say, because beyond a BMW 2002 (which ain't got no airplay) I wouldn't even consider it.
- timbo1642 9y agoSorry, but this is childish thinking.This won't make a damn difference because so many other people will continue to buy. Same shit with the iPhone X. There are enough suckers that will buy it that Apple will continue to charge an ultra premium. And on top of it, you buy a car for a variety of reasons. For example, BMW has better handling, style, etc... Some people just don't want a mercedes or audi. You can't convince enough people to jump ship and BMW will never think its because of the airplay thing anyways.
- madeofpalk 9y ago> Same shit with the iPhone X. There are enough suckers Are you calling me a sucker for exercising critical thinking when I purchased my iPhone X? Just because I like something that you don't like doesnt make me a 'sucker'.
- dietr1ch 9y ago"That's exactly what a sucker would say"
- timbo1642 9y agoYou're telling Apple that its okay to rip users off like yourself. No reason why that phone should cost that much.
- seanp2k2 9y agoThe Samsung Galaxy Note 8 is $960 if purchased outright through Verizon (64GB version): https://www.verizonwireless.com/smartphones/samsung-galaxy-note-8/ https://www.verizonwireless.com/smartphones/samsung-galaxy-n... 2017 flagship phones are expensive because of R&D, manufacturing, and profit margins. Samsung and Apple both roll some of their own silicon (Exynos + A-series). The iPhone X has a Samsung display, and I'm sure that they give them as bad of a deal as they can get away with, since they're their direct competitor. Though https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20171108005056/en/iPhone-Costs-Apple-370-Materials-IHS-Markit https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20171108005056/en/iPh... puts the cost of the CPU at $27.50 , consider the R&D that was required to get to that part and that part cost, and the operating system, which receives continual updates for years after the device is released, which has hundreds of people working on it at Apple. The LEGO 75192 Millennium Falcon is $800 retail and sold out everywhere. It's just plastic blocks to some people. The reason it costs so much is because that's how much it costs to design, develop , manufacture, distribute, market, sell (Apple owns a ton of retail locations + employs many salespeople + support people that you usually get free access to), and support the hardware and software while maintaining ~20% net profit margins ( https://www.stock-analysis-on.net/NASDAQ/Company/Apple-Inc/Ratios/Profitability https://www.stock-analysis-on.net/NASDAQ/Company/Apple-Inc/R... ). The fact that it exists at $1000 is impressive to me given how Samsung, LG, Sony, Motorola, HTC, etc bear much less of the cost of OS development + support. http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/11/02/android-versus-ios-software-updates-revisited-two-years-later/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/11/02/android-versus-ios-s... shows where some of the extra cost of an Apple device goes.
- exabrial 9y agoOk someone please explain how this is a net neutrality issue exactly?
- colejohnson66 9y agoProbably because without net neutrality, ISPs can nickel and dime people, and this is a case of BMW nickel and diming the customer. IMHO, it’s a bad comparison because cars are a competitive market unlike ISPs (in many areas).
- boardwaalk 9y agoThe comparison to net neutrality might be a bad one. But there's one thing that can be compared: competition. The auto industry is a paradise of competition in comparison to ISPs... So vote with your dollar. (Aside: screw CNET and their autoplay videos and notification requests.)
- andybak 9y agoCNET has been at the forefront of user-hostile web design for as long as I can remember.
- chillingeffect 9y ago>CNET [....] user-hostile web design Did that page quickly load about 8 deeper pages for everyone, making the back button appear not to work (until you realize it's just 8 deep)?
- prepend 9y agoI was surprised by the net neutrality reference. This seems more like the ancient “open statem” vs “closed system.” And not having to pay licenses for everything was a big plus for open.
- wyager 9y agoAlthough this article is kind of stupid (viz. the irrelevant net neutrality references), it does touch on two good pieces of advice. 1. Probably don’t buy BMW unless you really have your heart set on a particular model 2. Almost every car company attempt at building infotainment systems are abominations unto God. If at all possible, buy a car without any computer more powerful than the ECU and just use your phone or a tablet or an aftermarket “””smart””” interface.
- Klathmon 9y agoThat's what annoys me. There has never been a car infotainment system that I liked. They are all slow, expensive, ugly, never get updated, barely work in many cases, and are just a pain to use. I got an Audi with Android auto a year or 2 ago, and it's been such a treat I never want to go back. Like this is now a required feature to cars for me. And the biggest reason is because it doesn't look like trash and is actually quick and reactive.
- MBCook 9y agoIt was a big decision in me buying my last car. I really wanted something with CarPlay because I absolutely DID NOT want to be stuck with the OEM garbage for the next 10 years. Now that I’ve given up on even listening to NPR on my radio, I never leave CarPlay. Works fantastically. And it’s MILES better than the terrible OEM system (which reviews said was dramatically better than the previous version. Shudder.)
- rayiner 9y agoI don’t get the first point. If you can afford a BMW, $80 a year is nothing. Why do I care if it costs $80 a year instead of say $700 up front?
- 013a 9y agoPay $700 upfront and that value translates into the used market when you sell the car. Subscription fee, and that money goes straight to BMW Corporate.
- skywhopper 9y agoIt's so bizarre. There's no reasonable fiscal reason for BMW to require this. The only reason to implement something like this would be just to establish the precedent of paying a subscription to the carmaker so they can add on easy-to-pay-for additional features and one-time expenses later. Micropayments and loot boxes for your car.
- netsharc 9y agoPorsche already has an idea of temporarily more horsepower for money, not even permanently.
- celim307 9y agoLink? That's disgusting
- netsharc 9y agoI can only find one German article about it, maybe they were just throwing ideas to see how the public would react: http://winfuture.de/news,100802.html http://winfuture.de/news,100802.html Ah I found the interview: https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/company/porsche-digitalization-autonomous-driving-functions-on-demand-connectivity-innodrive-technology-interview-lutz-meschke-14586.html https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/company/porsche-digitalizati... > Which solutions are relevant for a brand like Porsche? > We will increasingly offer functions “on demand”. That means that the costumer can buy new functions at any time if needed – including long after buying the car and, where applicable, only temporarily. Be it as a one-off for a fee, as a flat rate or as a subscription. > Which functions do you offer on demand? > For example, it would be possible to combine modules from the area of autonomous driving individually. Imagine that you could use a software update to download a few more PS over-the-air at short notice if you want to head to the racetrack on the weekend – or dynamic headlights if you are headed for a long night drive.
- Jeremy1026 9y agoAnd Tesla lets you access the rest of your battery pack by paying more.
- jbuzbee 9y agoI'll tell you what I'd do if a car dealer pulled this on me. After all the normal haggling was done: "$80 a year? Fine. I plan to hang on to this car for 10 years. If you don't take an additional $800 off the price, no deal. Period"
- MBCook 9y agoThat’s probably smarter, I imagine I would just walk out in disgust. If that’s the way they want to treat me I don’t think I want to deal with them.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- harryh 9y agoYou'd go into a dealership to buy a $35,000+ plus vehicle and then get all huffy about 80 bucks a year? That's a pretty strange thing to do. Most BMW customers won't care.
- mikestew 9y agoI didn’t get to the point of owning two BMW motorcycles, and the means to buy a BMW car should I have the desire, by letting $80/year slide. Maybe if one has FU money, but I don’t, and I therefore care. Let’s flip it around: I’m buying a $42K car (the 428 I’ve had my eye on), and BMW is going to nickel-and-dime me on it?
- epa 9y agoYes. That is what they are known for. $42K is just the upfront fee. Consider the next $10K in maintenance to be 'subscription' as well.
- MBCook 9y agoBut the maintence fee actually DOES something. It replaces parts with physical wear. It’s understandable (if expensive). The $80/yr... turns a boolean from false to true. One that much cheaper cars give away. How would you feel if BMW decided to start charging $80/yr for heated seats? There is absolutely no reason that should have a yearly fee attached to it.
- sjwright 9y agoI agree it's stupid (and there's no question this move won't survive in the long term) but there's one thing to keep in mind: BMW's iDrive is better than CarPlay. As someone who very much likes Apple's current iOS and Mac UI, this feels absurd to say but iDrive is just that good. Of course choice always preferable, but unless CarPlay is extended to allow me to use Waze maps, I can't imagine why I'd ever use it. Unlike CarPlay, iDrive has a well-resolved, tactile and customisable physical interface. It's just better suited for someone who's driving. Tesla doesn't support CarPlay at all, but you don't hear about hoards of people boycotting Telsa: because their system is also better than CarPlay. (Though at least BMW gives you the option, even if they do so in a weirdly customer-hostile way.) The only clear advantage of CarPlay is that the software is being continually updated and improved. Perhaps when your 2018 model is seven years old, the features of CarPlay in iOS 16 running on your iPhone Xs Edition would be preferred. And by then BMW will have been shamed into aborting this annual fee joke.
- Klathmon 9y agoNow I don't know about carplay specifically, but Android auto works great even without a touchscreen, giving you the tactile feel that you want, and there is no reason why BMW can't extend the customizable physical buttons to work for functions in AA. And Tesla does get shit for not supporting either, quite frequently. Not to "boycott" levels, but it has absolutely affected my last car purchase, and the fact that they don't support it makes me want the brand a lot less.
- tacomonstrous 9y agoI installed Android Auto on my Mazda after someone on a previous HN thread convinced me to, and now I can't go back to using the native system. It makes such a huge difference, and works perfectly with the physical controls.
- Yhippa 9y agoHow were you able to do that? Was this made available through Mazda?
- zerostar07 9y agothe net neutrality comment seemed so far off from the next few statements that i stopped reading. i don't think i m missing anything interesting
- monochromatic 9y agoThis has literally nothing to do with net neutrality.
- to3m 9y agoI don't know what the problem is here. Instead of adding $300 to the cost of the car, you now add $0, and then after year 1 you pay $80/year. Maybe it's different in America or something, but in the UK approximately 100% of BMWs are leased, or bought with some kind of loan secured on the vehicle (I think based on estimated resale value when the period is up). So the "owner" will have the car for 2-3 years, maybe 4, then they'll chop it in for whatever's newer at the time. With that in mind: 1 year. Old way: $300. New way: $0. 2 years. Old way: $300. New way: $80. 3 years. Old way: $300. New way: $160. 4 years. Old way: $300. New way: $240. Cheaper! 5 years. Old way: $300. New way: $320. OK, but I wonder how many people keep their car for this long?
- thetinguy 9y agoNow they can all the other owners of the car instead of just the first.
- to3m 9y agoExactly. This is good for BMW, and that's why they do it. The initial keeper is happy, because it's cheaper for them. ~100% of them will lease it for <4 years, and you can consult my table to discover this. Subsequent buyers are less happy... but, wait, fuck those guys. When N>0, the Nth owner pays owner N-1, not BMW. So previously BMW would see nothing from these transactions. And now there's a >0% chance these subsequent owners will pay them $80/year. (Many software vendors have been trying to move to a subscription model. They want the recurring revenue. The iOS and Android video game markets have by now almost entirely switched to a free-to-play model - which is basically the same thing, just with a more compelling free sample, so they can sucker in the punters. This is basically the same!) This might make a dent in resale values, but I assume the >0% chance of getting $80/year from future owners makes up for this. I do admit, though, that I really don't have a good feel for how this would play out. Of course, people that buy a BMW with the intention of keeping it for >=5 years will get the shaft.... so I expect you can be sure that they've got good evidence that most keepers of a new BMW get rid of it before that point.
- ramenmeal 9y ago
- gnicholas 9y agoQuestion: was the old $300 fee available for all BMWs, or were there tiers/packages that you had to buy for it to be an option? If there were prerequisites to purchasing under the old price stricture, are there any under the new structure?
- dingo_bat 9y agoJust a warning: article has LOUD autoplaying video that will start up about a minute after you open the tab in the background, just to fuck with you.
- mdekkers 9y agoPretty much all software produced, ever, has been cracked. I suspect an "unlock" will appear soon.
- mark_sz 9y agoI'm guessing their next step will be to charge monthly for Bluetooth connectivity and probably Navigation.
- alkonaut 9y agoDoes anyone know when all APIs will be made available to CarPlay apps so they become actually usable? The only app I ever use in a car is Waze, and without support for CarPlay I much rather run waze in the phone, than apples maps in the dashboard. Surely they are working on this, I mean this can’t be a deliberate omission to try to keep me from using third party apps?
- MBCook 9y agoApple has been VERY careful about third-party apps. When you do use one, like overcast for podcasts, it could all use a template to Apple has already premade. This all appears to be for safety/legal reasons. Many areas seem to have laws that dictate how interfaces on infotainment system to work when someone is driving. I’m guessing apple doesn’t want to give anyone control because then they might cause the system to fall out of compliance. So even if they allowed Waze on the platform I’m not sure would look any different from Apple Maps or support any additional functionality. This is mostly speculation based on what I’ve heard.
- pimlottc 9y ago> Apple has been VERY careful about third-party apps. When you do use one, like overcast for podcasts, it could all use a template to Apple has already premade. I’m sorry, I don’t quite understand what you’re saying here?
- MBCook 9y agoWow, autocorrect really did a number on that. Sorry. Third parties can’t actually design a UI for CarPlay. It seems there are a few templates that they can make the tiniest changes to and that’s the extent of their customization. So every podcast player and music app looks basically the same. They use the standard car playlist for you for selecting things and the standard now playing type screen for controlling play back. Want to add extra buttons to be able to skip between chapters on a podcast? You can’t. Want to rearrange where the buttons are? You can’t. What people to be able to select a podcast by choosing from cover art instead of a list? You can’t. Basically even the kind of apps Apple does allow our EXTREMELY restricted.
- jessaustin 9y agoAs someone who primarily bicycled for transportation during the years I lived in Los Angeles, it is my considered judgement that no group of drivers deserves to have to pay ridiculous fees more than those who drive BMWs. They are hands-down the most dangerous to everyone else on the street. It's just too bad these fees are going to BMW.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoThis is so incredibly stupid and seems in the long run is going to hurt BMW a lot more then it would gain in the short term. This is such a short term move.
- thrillgore 9y agoI recently decided to buy a Kia Forte over a Honda Civic because Honda (and the dealer) had the nerve to charge me an expensive trim level (23.5k over 20k) just to get a dashboard with Android Auto. I have no regrets, its a great little sedan! The ability to integrate smartphone/tablet apps within the car is arguably more of a safety feature than just a "trim option" and it befuddles me why car manufacturers see it fit to charge a premium as egregious as BMW is. Knock that shit off, it adds dollars to the cost of the hardware and software development. I'd say it should be a regulatory matter but that just means, like with rear view cameras, manufacturers will build that into the price. If CarPlay matters to you, i'm sure there are other brands of automobile that agree with your line of thinking.