7 ms·
When we celebrate entrepreneurs like Bezos we should also keep in mind that this success comes on the backs of a lot of people who work in bad conditions. These
by maxxxxx 9y ago
When we celebrate entrepreneurs like Bezos we should also keep in mind that this success comes on the backs of a lot of people who work in bad conditions. These people are invisible to us. Amazon could easily afford to hire more people for the workload but instead they choose to squeeze everything out of existing employees.
- baxtr 9y agoTrue point. But then again, we as consumers demand everything to become cheaper and cheaper so that we can buy more stuff we probably don’t need. You could argue that he’s just fulfilling our desire within current labor laws.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIt's not a true point because Amazon could not easily choose to hire more people for the workload, given the assumption that people will choose to shop wherever they get the lowest prices. The assumption seems valid considering the domination of Walmart and Asda in the past few decades. The margins on retail are tiny as it is, so I highly doubt Amazon could easily hire more people.
- d4rti 9y agoSilicon Valley is more like the Gilded Age capitalists than they tell themselves.
- bdcravens 9y agoExcept that Amazon is a Seattle company.
- smnrchrds 9y agoSilicon Valley is commonly used as a figure of speech to refer to the entire tech industry. Similar to how Wall Street is used to refer to the financial industry, or Hollywood to the movie industry, or Washington to the entire federal government.
- bdcravens 9y agoGuess I'll put "Silicon Valley Programmer" on my resume now :-)
- bb88 9y agoAmazon employs people in SF too, so it's not entirely possible they didn't drink the kool-aid.
- linkmotif 9y ago> Amazon could easily afford to hire more people for the workload but instead they choose to squeeze everything out of existing employees. That’s just not the Titan of Industry mentality. And the Titan of Industry mentality is required to build a company like Amazon. And everyone buys from Amazon because they offer the lowest price and the greatest convenience. It’s got nothing to do with whether he could hire more people. It’s that whether it’s the Pyramids or Versailles or Amazon, humans are largely drawn to these things that represent or require the toil and suffering of invisible anonymous masses. It’s weird, but it seems fundamental to humanity. It’s always made me question the compatibility of humans with “human rights.” We fundamentally don’t value these things. At least we prioritize symbols of collective greatness to individual human experience.
- gonyea 9y agoAmazon is wildly expensive compared with Target and Costco. Its success is convenience and extensive product reviews.
- erikig 9y agoI find this claim hard to believe - what products are you using to make the comparison?
- CapacitorSet 9y ago>humans are largely drawn to these things that represent or require the toil and suffering of invisible anonymous masses. It’s weird, but it seems fundamental to humanity. Consumers are largely drawn to low-cost products, which require the exploitation of masses. It is fundamental to capitalism, but not to humanity.
- vixen99 9y agoWell, poor people tend to be drawn to low-cost products or do without. I wonder what you'd prefer the masses to be doing as against producing those goods? Capitalism enables global wealth re-distribution. Thus were 500 million Chinese lifted out of poverty from 1981 to 2012 (World Bank figures) thanks to consumers who've bought the products of their industry. Most of us have helped in that respect. Almost all of humanity lived for thousand of years in miserable and degrading poverty; the life of even the very rich two hundred years ago and later would be considered a low grade existence by a great majority of ordinary people today and not just in the West.
- HenryBemis 9y agoPlus when we buy a book from Amazon for £10 when in (e.g. Waterstones is £20, there is a reason (and it's not only the rent for the brick & mortar store). Every penny counts dear Maxxxxxx!
- maxxxxx 9y agoI shop at Amazon too because it's so convenient. But I am becoming more and more aware that companies who rely on underpaid workers create huge externalities for society. A polluter can also potentially produce cheaper goods but these come at a price for society. Same for companies like Walmart and Amazon.
- bluedino 9y agoFirst world governments created rules in the 1800's and 1900's. People used to work in unsafe conditions doing jobs in the coal mines and steel mills. This isn't an abusive job. It's just a working job. You can't leave your station at an automotive factory or in a line cook position either. You have to keep moving for 8 hours or more at a time. It's work. That's just how it goes. It's not for everyone.
- sorokod 9y agoWould you wish this kind of work on members of your family or friends? If not who do you think should be doing these jobs?
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoI'm not the person you were addressing, but I'll bite anyway. The members of my family have dreams, but any free time they have they spend it on Facebook. I don't WISH these jobs on them, but this is exactly the skills they have.
- adventured 9y agoWho exactly doesn't have family & friends that have done exactly these types of jobs at some point? Are we talking about the gold lined streets of Norway, as the 0.1% example that is supposed to represent the real condition of humanity among the other 7.6 billion people? I've never known someone that hasn't done these types of basic work jobs at some point their lives. That's not an exaggeration. It can be working a marina boating dock during the summer, pumping gas for minimum wage at 20 years old. It can be cutting yards & doing basic property maintenance work for $15 / hour at 25 years old. It can be a cashier at Walmart for $11 or $12 / hour. It can be working at a liquor store, doing cashier work, filling shelves, running product into the cooler, and vacuuming before going home at night. There are millions of basic jobs like that need to be done.
- dogma1138 9y agoWould this job be better if they were paid £22,000? £30,000? £45,000? Regardless of the pay it would always be a shitty job because it’s hard manual labor. There are worse jobs for sure but there is virtually no plausible amount of money that would make this job a good job other than the premise that any job is better than no job. And we are at fault here we want cheap stuff delivered ASAP even in the middle of the night.
- fao_ 9y ago> When we celebrate entrepreneurs like Bezos we should also keep in mind that this success comes on the backs of a lot of people who work in bad conditions. Is there a case where this is not true? Capitalists are all the same: Ignoring other's suffering to make a profit.
- andrepd 9y agoIndeed. And it's useless to pretend that's not the case.
- aitrean 9y ago"useless to pretend that's not the case" is a dumb, paint brush response. Yes, many, if not most, capitalists do so. That said, consumers don't tend to reward good behaviour either. Even when I put a minimal amount of effort into making purchases from "ethical" companies, I get people questioning what the hell I'm doing. Why don't I go for the cheapest, brand-namest, most-marketed, child labor made, etc equivalent from <Big Corporation Co>. If anyone is going to start rambling off about the evils of capitalism, I suggest they stick their foot in their mouth until they've already stopped buying from companies that benefit from exploitative behaviour. But since I've met almost nobody who falls into that category, then it's time to admit that capitalists aren't inherently unethical, it's just that consumers, including you (and even me) have decided to reward the ones who aren't.
- fao_ 9y ago> But since I've met almost nobody who falls into that category, then it's time to admit that capitalists aren't inherently unethical, it's just that consumers, including you (and even me) have decided to reward the ones who aren't. Of course society is (in theory) set up to ensure that it's the consumer's fault. Or that the consumer has some kind of mass control over this. Unfortunately the consumer is at a mass disadvantage. Not only do stress and monetary factors constrain the amount of control they can exercise, but also big companies expend hundreds of thousands of pounds in advertising and propaganda. Putting the blame on the sheep for the faults of the farmer is ludicrous.
- cm2187 9y agoOne can say that of pretty much any company that manufactures anything outside of the US.
- someonewhocar3s 9y agoLabour >market<
- indubitable 9y agoAnd these are jobs people 100 years ago in this country would have given anything to have, and ones millions today, perhaps even billions, would still give anything to have. And Amazon's margins are far smaller than you're implying. Their latest quarterly had a profit margin of 0.59%. They have more than half a million employees and a net income of just ~$2.4 billion. Imagine they give a modest $1000 raise to all their employees. That'd be more than $500 million or about 23% of their entire net income. Mass increases in labor to the point that the hourly requirements of each employee substantially decreased is simply out of the question. In looking at wealth inequality, I think we lose track of how many of us there are. If you received just $1 from each person on Earth you'd be the 175th richest person in the world. $15 per person and you'd be, by far, the richest person alive. And that also goes the other way - even the richest are diluted to very little on the scale of the populations of this place we live in. If every single dollar or produced value, at least according to GDP, was perfectly evently distributed in the US we'd each get about $52k a year. Getting about half the average for moving boxes doesn't seem like something that screams catastrophe to me.
- selectodude 9y agoAmazon is famous for spending every penny they make on investing in Amazon. Their net profit is not really a good place to look for the amount of money they’re actually making.
- indubitable 9y agoDefinitely a fair point. On the other hand without that investing jobs like these would not exist. Is Amazon destroying more lucrative jobs he could have otherwise had? Very possibly, but I think that's somewhat speculative. And it also ignores secondary effects of economic expansion. Amazon in turn helps countless other businesses grow and thrive which in turn provide more opportunity and jobs for people. So we can't only consider the jobs it may destroy but also the jobs which it creates. In the end, what is the net effect? That's an extremely complex question to answer, but I suspect living in a world where you can get $25k a year for moving boxes is more likely a positive than negative indicator of overall effect.
- 9y ago
- BurningFrog 9y agoThen again the employees are free to quit at any time, but the fact that they don't means these jobs are the very best alternatives they have. It's perhaps a shitty alternative, but it's undeniable that without Amazon they'd do something even shittier.
- suby 9y agoDepends how high the turnover rate is.
- Symbiote 9y agoYou could say the same about the children working in the cotton mills, but we banned that. Without Amazon, there might be more local tax revenue, more local shops providing employment, less focus on extracting 100% from every employee.
- bb88 9y agoAnd more businesses serving those local shops, including restaurants, dentists, drug stores, etc. I've never seen a great diversity of businesses that surround a warehouse, say.
- camus2 9y agoAnd this guy has the audacity to boast on Twitter about how he has too much money he doesn't know what to do with it. Well how about he gives his workers better work conditions? there are simple techniques that wouldn't even cost him much money like alternating tasks in warehouses, some tasks are less physical than others. Clearly some here are happy the 19th century style exploitation is a reality for their fellow workers, with the same arguments as 200 years ago like "well if you're not happy go work somewhere else", like everybody has the choice.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]