7 ms·
At least Boris is fixated on absurd bridges that will never be built, not walls. A brief response from a structural engineer: https://theconversation.com/bori
by twic 9y ago
At least Boris is fixated on absurd bridges that will never be built, not walls.
A brief response from a structural engineer:
https://theconversation.com/boris-johnsons-english-channel-bridge-an-engineering-experts-view-90409 https://theconversation.com/boris-johnsons-english-channel-b...
- gaius 9y agoArtificial islands, he likes those too. And why not, the UK used to do megascale engineering at the drop of a hat. Now we can't even do railways.
- igravious 9y agoA response from the Telegraph. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/lists/worlds-longest-bridges/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/lists/worlds-longest-bridg... For comparison they show the following list. Where | Length in kilometres Danyang–Kunshan Grand Bridge, China 165 Changhua-Kaohsiung Viaduct, Taiwan 157 Tianjin Grand Bridge, China 114 Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau Bridge, China 55 Bang Na Expressway, Thailand 54 Lake Pontchartrain Causeway, USA 38 > 'Boris Bridge', UK-France 35 In light of all these other megastructures the proposed Boris Bridge doesn't sound too unreasonable? Considering the two economies it would link… Linking Ireland and the UK, that'd be another matter entirely.
- pouetpouet 9y agoThe Danyang-Kunshan is mainly over land. It's an elevated railway line. It does cross the Yangcheng Lake, but that part is only 9km long. It's not a suspended bridge, there are piles every 80m. Not suitable for heavy maritime traffic. The lake has an average depth of 2m. https://www.lakepedia.com/lake/yangcheng.html https://www.lakepedia.com/lake/yangcheng.html It's not comparable as a channel crossing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danyang%E2%80%93Kunshan_Grand_Bridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danyang%E2%80%93Kunshan_Grand_... Likewise the depth of Jiaozhou bay is 10 to 15m. The channel is 45m deep between Calais and Dover (the shortest and shallowest crossing). Moreover the strait of Dover (or Pas de Calais in french) is the busiest shipping lane in the world http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/05/22/article-2636152-1E1A483000000578-594_964x516.jpg http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/05/22/article-2636152-1E...
- maxerickson 9y agoSome of those can't admit any ships, never mind the biggest ships on the ocean. For example, the Lake Pontchartrain Causeway impacts quite small boats: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Pontchartrain_Causeway#/media/File:Lake_Pontchartrain_Causeway.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Pontchartrain_Causeway#/m... That's a completely different project than something that won't impact traffic that needs 50 or 70 meters of clearance.
- make3 9y agothe problem they say is that this would be on one of the world's most active shipping lane and that boats would need to be able to pass under the bridge, requiring it to be much higher than the other bridges of that list
- kibwen 9y agoThe engineer's statements linked by the parent poster mentions Danyang-Kunshan: "the longest bridge in the world is the Danyang–Kunshan Grand Bridge in China. It is mostly a conventional bridge made from columns sunk into the seabed, although it has a cable-stayed section. The bridge is 165km long (just over 100 miles) but the short distance between the columns would not do for the busy Channel."
- tankenmate 9y agoThe size of ships and number of ships going through the English channel are much larger than any of the bridges listed above apart from possibly the HK <-> Macau bridge.
- mastax 9y agoThe only bridge on that list even remotely comparable is the Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau Bridge. The rest are essentially elevated highways which are almost entirely over land. I am not a civil engineer so this is just some uninformed speculation: - The channel goes to about 45m deep between Dover and Calais, while the path of the HK bridge only goes to about 20m depth. - The bay formed by the Pearl River is more enclosed and protected from weather than any part of the channel. - The bridge would need sections elevated high enough for future mega container ships. - The HK bridge cost $15.9b. I'd expect the channel bridge to cost much more. It might be cheaper to just build another tunnel. Edit: and, of course, by the time I finish this comment there are 10 more saying basically the same thing.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau includes a section of tunnel, so it doesn't need the height above the water that a pure bridge crossing would require.
- joelrunyon 9y agoCan someone explain to me why a wall can't be built? I know people say it shouldn't be built - but I don't understand why people say we "can't" build it when they've been built before, and we've done endlessly more complex things - rockets, going to the moon, et (all while China is building artificial islands and the like). In comparison to some of those feats, a wall seems trivial.
- thinkingemote 9y agoI heard that a big portion of the border is over a mountain range, both making actual wall construction hard and almost fulfils the same role of a wall?
- zachrose 9y agoNot the answer you’re looking for, but if you think about short-term and long-term political willpower, “shouldn’t” and “can’t” turn out to be the same thing.
- failwall 9y agoCross-post: http://johnsalvatier.org/blog/2017/reality-has-a-surprising-amount-of-detail http://johnsalvatier.org/blog/2017/reality-has-a-surprising-... Let’s consider some of these details. Something I think people don’t consider is that there are a non-trivial number of land animal species that migrate across the border. They have no concept of nation-states, and for some, our xenophobic electorate is basically passing a death sentence. The wall would devastate several important ecosystems, especially in the Rio Grande Valley. Walls also need to be maintained, like any other piece of infrastructure. Have you ever visited the great state of Michigan? We can’t even handle roads. How will the federal government, which doesn’t have the best track record with maintaining infrastructure, deal with a 2,000+ mile-long wall? Another issue is surveillance. Who will watch the entire thing? Who will make sure someone isn’t chipping away at the other side with a spoon or trying to dig under it? You can’t watch thousands of miles of wall very easily. There are all kinds of issues with this (oh, funding is a big one too), and this just scratches the surface. If you Google “Trump border wall problems”, plenty of articles have already been written that go into much more detail.
- oh_sigh 9y agoWhy do you think the wall isn't happening? They are building prototypes right now. Is the wall absurd because people will find another way around? Or because you think it literally can't be built? Or it's absurd to protect the borders of a country? Or is it absurd simply because it is proposed by Trump and you just don't like him? Also, I don't see why this bridge can't be similar to the Chesapeake Bay bridge. That has a 1km span for ships up to 60m to pass under.
- failwall 9y agoThe wall isn’t happening because it’s nothing more than a campaign lie and an extension of the electorate’s racism, which, like the wall, has no place in modern society and is unsustainable in the long-term.
- oh_sigh 9y agoSo the wall isn't happening because it is a lie? That isn't a very strong argument.
- failwall 9y agoThe wall isn’t happening because, among other reasons, 2,000-mile long structures aren’t trivial to build, especially when subject to the whims of the political machine. Have you considered too just how long the thing would take? We’d probably be well into the next administration by the time it even got close.
- oh_sigh 9y agoNo one ever argued for a 2000 mile long structure that completely disregards any natural wall that already exists
- failwall 9y agoImmigration is a tough issue, and so are xenophobia and racism. But spending tens or hundreds of billions of dollars to build a wall that has countless logistical problems (say goodbye to several migratory species that cross the border; hope none of them are important for the food chain), is just so mind-bogglingly shortsighted and cruel. How many immigrants could we help for that much money? Have Americans so quickly forgotten that, up until rather recently, there was no immigration policy? You could just come to the US to flee whatever terrible life you had before, and nobody asked any questions. I feel incredibly fortunate that my mom’s side came here from Germany well before WWII. I wouldn’t want to prevent anyone else from having a chance to be here.