4 ms·
As an artist and musician, I often encourage my friends to draw something, paint something, or make some music. The reply I hear over and over again is, "oh, n
by pmoriarty 9y ago
As an artist and musician, I often encourage my friends to draw something, paint something, or make some music. The reply I hear over and over again is, "oh, no, I don't have the talent" or "oh, no, I'm awful at drawing". It's like they don't realize that what they attribute to "talent" is attainable through practice and hard work. When I point that out and encourage them to just try, that it might be fun, they make some other excuse. I've come to understand that what all their excuses amount to is that they're just not interested in creating. They'd rather remain consumers.
You have to create in order to be creative. You have to practice creativity in order to be good at it. You can't just read a book, go to a seminar, or wear funny clothes and expect to suddenly be a "creative genius". It can take years to master.[1]
On the other hand, most children don't have any problem being creative. Somehow by the time we become adults we lose that, and then think we're permanently incapable.
[1] - One of my favorite videos[2] shows the artistic progression of Jonathan Hardesty. In his early work few would detect any hint of "talent", and yet after nine years of hard work, his skill rises to a truly impressive level -- at which point, if one had only seen the end result, a lot of people would call him "talented". But as you can see in the video, he was clearly not born with this "talent". He earned it. That's what it takes.
[2] - https://vimeo.com/29510470 https://vimeo.com/29510470
- epicide 9y agoI think a lot of it is a fear of failure. A fear of looking dumb or silly. Kids don't have an issue with that. We learn to be afraid.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoI think you're close. My observation suggests that kids are used to it, everything they do is new, they're inexpert at everything. They don't expect to be good. Adults think that they should be capable simply because one tends to get better at things as an adult. The weight of expectation makes them often worse. My field is pottery, some adults think they can just throw a vase on their first go, kids just enjoy the experience (on the whole) and don't expect to be good at it. Kids, once they've learnt some fine motor control, don't make kid-pictures because they're kids, they do it because they haven't practiced. Adults try, and their observation can get them a little further, but they still make the same sort of pictures and are embarrassed because it's "childish". I recently started a sports class where I'm ranked along with 7 & 8 yo kids, an interesting and humbling experience.
- projektir 9y agoAnother thing that happens is you can get hit by someone next to you, that has just as little experience, doing it a lot better than you on their first try. It doesn't help if this person is way younger than you to boot. Kids generally get more slack for not being good at things, as well, whereas with adults, since there are many adults who've done X since they were young, being an adult who just started X makes you extra bad and sometimes a minority. I have gotten the "why are you so bad at this?" reaction from people before when doing new things. Especially with anything physical, I improve rather slowly.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"some adults think they can just throw a vase on their first go, kids just enjoy the experience (on the whole) and don't expect to be good at it." If they're young enough, they don't even have an opinion on what "good" is (or what art is, for that matter). They just do, and are happy doing it. Judgement, of their own and others' work comes later. That may be when their inhibition starts.
- johnfn 9y ago> I've come to understand that what all their excuses amount to is that they're just not interested in creating. I don't think this is true. If they were uninterested, they would simply say so, rather than making a series of excuses. What seems more likely to me is that they are (on a deep level) scared of creating. Creativity of any sort requires you to project your personality and be vulnerable in a way that people don't normally do. This can be pretty scary when most actions people do don't open themselves up to possibly being criticized on such a personal level. I think when people aren't creative it's not that they don't care, but rather that the fear of being judged (whether conscious or unconscious) is too strong to overcome. This is why people "don't have any creative ideas" - it's not that they don't have ANY, but instead that they reject the ideas that they do have because they think they are not good enough. This is also the basis of writers block.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"If they were uninterested, they would simply say so, rather than making a series of excuses." I think they make those excuses because they don't want to cause offense by saying they aren't interested in what I'm interested in (and even consider to be part of my identity). I do agree that fear could motivate their aversion, though. But if the fear is there, I don't think it's usually rises to their consciousness or at least is something they could readily admit -- as if it was, they could simply say they're afraid, couldn't they?
- randcraw 9y agoOr maybe people refuse to try what you suggest because they hate the results of their past efforts. Many people cannot sing, and no amount of practice will change that. Many others are grossly uncoordinated, and thus hate dance or playing sports. If every attempt I make to draw with pencil and paper looks sick to me, I'm going to stop drawing (which I have). But I'm happy to create in other media. Maybe the trick to being "creative" is finding a suitable medium for innovation, which may not be one that's typically considered to be "art" -- like software design, organizing your workshop, or building a better mousetrap.
- WalterBright 9y ago
- dkarl 9y agoIt's like they don't realize that what they attribute to "talent" is attainable through practice and hard work. When I point that out and encourage them to just try, that it might be fun, they make some other excuse. That's a bit of a bait and switch, to say, why not try this simple thing just for fun, and then say all it takes is a lot of practice and hard work. Not only do you have to make a long-term commitment that this is going to be one of the few things in your life that you invest a lot of time and energy in, you also have to either enjoy being bad at it (which is even harder as an adult than it is when you're a kid) or stick with it through a lot of thankless effort.
- chillwaves 9y ago> enjoy being bad at it You don't have to enjoy being bad, you just have to value the process of getting good more than the pain of being bad.
- gagege 9y agoYou just explained the reason I don't like writing fiction. I do not enjoy the process of writing more than the pain of being bad at it. I've been trying to write for years but just can not seem to enjoy it. It's a hobby that feels awfully like work, yet I keep coming back to it.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"That's a bit of a bait and switch, to say, why not try this simple thing just for fun, and then say all it takes is a lot of practice and hard work." These aren't mutually exclusive. You could have fun doing something and yet still take a lot of time and effort to master it. It's like playing the violin -- something that most people understand takes years and years of effort to master. Most people wouldn't expect to pick up a violin and instantly be able to come out with a virtuoso performance. But for other arts it seems that that's exactly the expectation that they have. If their objection to a suggestion to try drawing is to say, "Oh, no, I'm no good at drawing" my reply would be: "Well, yeah, that's because you haven't practiced drawing. Why would you even expect to be good at drawing when you just start?" On the other hand, just because you can't yet get the ultimate results you're after when you start doesn't mean you can't have fun trying. There's some visceral enjoyment that can come from handling art materials like charcoal, paints, or clay and using them to create and express yourself -- an enjoyment that non-artists rarely have any idea is there, and will continue to be oblivious to as long as they refuse to try. The same goes for musical instruments. You can have fun just playing around with them, even if you don't know what you're doing and have no training whatsoever. When I encourage non-artists and non-musicians to give making art or music a try, I'm not trying to get them to immediately invest 10,000 hours of grueling practice nor to paint the Mona Lisa for me. I'm encouraging them to just try for five minutes, ten minutes, half an hour... just to maybe experience some of the joy that could be there for them.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoDrawing/painting takes a lot of concerted effort. If you have really never sat down for several hours and worked on a drawing, you immediately have several things going against you: 1. You know you won't make something particularly good the first time. Why spend several hours of concerted effort on something that won't immediately pay off? 2. You aren't an "artist". We tend to categorize people by their current skillset, and constrain ourselves to the skillsets we are comfortable with. I don't know of any good ways to teach the brain around this without simply "pushing through" it. 3. Your goal is to do it "right", but you are going to do it wrong. Thousands of times. Every stroke of a pencil is a wrong stroke. The instinct is to immediately erase. The beauty of painting is that you can't erase. This is why I would recommend a person begin with painting rather than drawing, so that every action is additive. 4. You have to start with purpose. The purpose has to be good enough to enthrall you for several hours. If you start painting something that you don't find interesting, you know at some point, you will get bored, and you will never finish, so why not stop now? This goes for anything creative. How can you learn to write software without software to write? How can you perform music without music to perform? How can you build something without something to build? Creation needs purpose, if nothing else. > On the other hand, most children don't have any problem being creative. Somehow by the time we become adults we lose that, and then think we're permanently incapable. This is one of the most important barriers for us to overcome. We need to practice doing things wrong, and creating garbage. Unfortunately, we constantly reiterate the claim that garbage is bad, and that we should do everything perfect.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pdfernhout 9y agoYour advice echoes that of Carol Dweck: http://www.mindsetonline.com/ http://www.mindsetonline.com/ "Mindset is a simple idea discovered by world-renowned Stanford University psychologist Carol Dweck in decades of research on achievement and success—a simple idea that makes all the difference. Teaching a growth mindset creates motivation and productivity in the worlds of business, education, and sports."