5 ms·
Which is worse: torture or killing? It seems that with all the attention that torture got, the Obama administration basically stopped trying to capture people a
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Which is worse: torture or killing? It seems that with all the attention that torture got, the Obama administration basically stopped trying to capture people alive to interrogate them and instead just sent drone based missiles to just kill anyone suspected of terrorism.
- function_seven 9y agoIf we limit ourselves to those two options, I believe torture is worse. Or can be. There is no end to the horrors when you intentionally keep someone alive to make them suffer at your whim, vs. killing them in one fell swoop. Torture exposes the blackest parts of our humanity in a way that droning someone never could.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIf you have the chance to save the life of a terrorist who is about to detonate a bomb, you should? If that terrorist tells you "my people have set other bombs just like this, your people will die horribly" do you choose to kill them, or torture then to potentially save the many others from death and mutilation? Or do you just say "oh, how naughty" and clean up the blood of the innocent people afterwards. If we refuse to play at the terrorists game of death then their cause wins at the cost of billions of lives. Then they can continue to kill and maim over ever more nuanced positions. In part the problem is that a (the, I suspect) major source of terrorists is adherents of Islam who follow Mohammed's example of murder, and his injunctions in the Koran, and hadith, to violently oppress. As long as that book exists to inspire the actions, and that man is treated as a model for others then we'll continue to have such problems.
- Retric 9y agoTorture. Army's are trained to kill not Torture for very good reasons.
- mulmen 9y agoAre they though? Sure we say we don't torture people but given a realistic choice between taking someone alive and killing them don't we generally favor capture?
- hulahoof 9y agoFrom a resourcing, cost and safety (for the captors) perspective - no.
- Retric 9y agoFrom a practical perspective, if surending means you get tortured then people are more likely to keep fighting which costs both sides significantly. On the other hand taking someone as a prisoner of war and treating them reasonably means denying the enemy soldiers at minimal cost. This is especially true at the end of a war.
- rdtsc 9y ago> Obama administration basically stopped trying to capture people alive to interrogate them and instead just sent drone based missiles to just kill anyone suspected of terrorism. Not only that but after receiving a Nobel Peace Prize he proceeded to engage in drone warfare. Just in 2016 he dropped more then 20k bombs, in countries which we were not even at war with. Many in Africa. It was surprising how little flak he got for it. Indeed when he was elected in 2008 he got the best marketer of year award http://adage.com/article/moy-2008/obama-wins-ad-age-s-marketer-year/131810/ http://adage.com/article/moy-2008/obama-wins-ad-age-s-market... and he presented a great image. > Which is worse: torture or killing? It is kind of a false choice. But let's go with it, Obama effectively picked both. Anyone remember how he promised to close Guantanamo? Well it is still open. He picked both killing and continued torture. Yet people still idolize him and think he was so great. Again, that's the power of propaganda and marketing at work, AdAge's award was very much on point, better then Coke, Nike and Apple.
- afjl 9y agoI think both of your statements can apply to any President. For instance, Trump has called for "fire and fury" against NK and "bombing the hell" out of our enemies. He's embraced torture as a mechanism for obtaining information and a cursory Google search shows that Gitmo conditions have gotten significantly worse over the past year. Frankly, this seems like a misdirected personal crusade of yours against Obama when virtually every administration has blood on its hands.
- mieseratte 9y ago> this seems like a misdirected personal crusade of yours against Obama I took it more as him pointing out that while Trump, right or wrong, is crucified in the press on a daily basis Obama was able to successfully spin a benevolent image to the point that he was absolutely held to a different standard. All presidents have blood on their hands, but there is a certain irony in Obama being the first Nobel peace price winner to bomb another peace prize winner.
- afjl 9y ago
- mulmen 9y agoI'm not sure how to begin answering the moral question of what bad thing is worse. I do know that the answer is uninteresting to me. We just shouldn't be doing either of those things. I do not believe the Obama administration used more drones because of public backlash against torture. Correlation does not imply causation and all that. It could easily be explained that because torture doesn't work there's no reason to risk more lives to capture someone alive. It may be that drone technology just advanced and became an option or an easier option. I can think of a lot of possibilities but I have no reason to believe any of them. Is there a name for this kind of fallacy?
- nachexnachex 9y agoFalse dilemma is related.
- ionised 9y agoSuspected by algorithm from what I understand as well. There was lacklustre human involvement in the decision-making process. He created a world in which the children of certain countries are afraid of clear, blue skies, because it means the drones will be operating. That's sick and totally devoid of humanity.
- stordoff 9y agoI don't think it's a dichotomy - even if torture were heavily used, I don't that would prevent the drone strikes (and then there's the weird arguments of how many would you kill vs. how many would you torture). Realistically, the answer should be _neither_. However, if you had to choose, I'd probably say torture is worse. Even a slow death is likely to be quick, and has an end, compared with a torturer who is actively trying to keep you alive so you can endure more.