9 ms·
Analysts put GM and Waymo far ahead in driverless car race
- sschueller 9y agoWhat is also interesting here is GM's Cruise doesn't need Uber to do what Uber does. However Uber needs cars to do what they do.
- xbmcuser 9y agoI have always argued with my friends that ai cars are more likely to kill uber than help as car manufacturers would start their own taxi service if the ai they have is not good enough would partner with waymo to stay in the market. Uber brings no value.
- netsharc 9y agoUber's value nowadays is that they have the infrastructure as a "connected" taxi service, and they have the users. But I guess that's not unique, Lyft has this too, and installing another taxi app or two is easy enough (or in the case of Google, they'll probably just integrate it to Google Maps -- I just realized why they've integrated Uber into Google Maps, so when they do that with Waymotaxi, no one can scream "anti-competitive move!"). Finding and vetting drivers will be the slightly harder task...
- matthewmacleod 9y agoI just realized why they've integrated Uber into Google Maps Google Ventures invested a large amount in Uber as well – I think they owned something like 5% last time I looked.
- amelius 9y ago> I just realized why they've integrated Uber into Google Maps, so when they do that with Waymotaxi, no one can scream "anti-competitive move! No, they integrated it so that Maps becomes the go-to point for users when they need a ride. That way, Google can snatch those users away when Waymo becomes available. The internet nowadays is all about being the "gatekeeper", and Google just wants to stay in that role.
- nindalf 9y agoGoogle will do the smart thing too. When Waymotaxi becomes available, they won't remove Uber as an option because that might be anti-competitive. But more relevantly, they wouldn't need to. Back of the envelope calculations say that a self driving cab would be 1/3rd of the cost. Show both in Google maps and let the people decide.
- bildung 9y ago> Back of the envelope calculations say that a self driving cab would be 1/3rd of the cost. I can hardly imagine taking the human drivers out of the equation will be that profitable. Right now, those drivers also do the labor intensive part of maintaining the fleet (gas/power, cleaning, repairs etc.). That part will stay with uber, lyft, google etc.
- lukasm 9y agoWhen car companies will become taxis, repairs will stop being profit centres, so the incentive will be to make more durable cars. Also electric cars will become more convenient with AI Taxi. Uber drivers don't use their cars 24/7. AI Taxi can deliver good between companies in the night. There is so much room for improvement. Right now it won't be 1/3 of the cost, but in the future AI Taxi will cost as much as public transport.
- vonmoltke 9y ago> When car companies will become taxis, repairs will stop being profit centres, so the incentive will be to make more durable cars. I think manufacturing cost is a much stronger driver of shitty reliability than repairs being a profit center. After all, in the US dealer system the manufacturer isn't getting the profits, the dealer is. > Uber drivers don't use their cars 24/7. AI Taxi can deliver good between companies in the night. Keeping complex systems like that running constantly is difficult and expensive. It also wears said systems out faster and increases capital costs.
- j_s 9y ago> they have the users As you pointed out, this is a very fickle (price sensitive) group. Anecdata-ly, I can point to many who prioritize Lyft based entirely on personal price comparison history.
- gumby 9y agoI’ve long thought Uber’s plan was acquisition: google up cash to GBF (Get Big Fast) with unassailable network effect (brand, user data, city usage data etc) and then sell off. Just as GM got Cruise (for a song) then a GM would buy uber. That seemed, for the reasons you gave, to be a long shot. Sure the car mfrs don’t have services in their dna, but it won’t cost THAT much to get there. Certainly not the $40-odd billion valuation Uber bears. I also have long believed there will only be 4-5 global car brands once the vehicles drive themselves (fleet production in a monopsony environment destroys the value of branding). I hadn’t guessed that GM might even have been in the runnng.
- threeseed 9y ago> there will only be 4-5 global car brands We heard the same thing about mechanical watches when smartwatches came out. But actually what happened was the opposite. People flocked back to mechanical, vintage watches and the watch industry is booming right now. I suspect the same thing will happen with cars. There will be even more car brands than we have today with old classics coming back e.g. Saab but all built off cheaper, commodity electric drive trains and far more differentiated. So you will have AI cars taking over family movers, taxis, buses etc and old, classic cars being modernised and built for drivers.
- croon 9y agoCars right now are both a practical good and a luxury item (where branding comes in). Clocks were the same, until everyone got a phone in their pocket at which point they were reduced to just a luxury item. I'm sure there will always be car collectors, but buying a car as a luxury item when there's no longer a practical need to own one, is far from comparable to buying a watch.
- vonmoltke 9y agoI have said it before, and will say it again: I do not understand why the assumption is that fully self-driving cars will eliminate individual car ownership. What are the practical reasons to own one now, and why will they be rendered irrelevant by AI drivers?
- rcMgD2BwE72F 9y agoFor now. Imagine that many people give up their personally-owed cars and rely on subscriptions in the next few years. Sales of cars would drop fast for manufacturers who don't have a on-demand service network with a sufficient critical mass. Don't forget that giants went close to bankruptcy around 2008 with only a few % of global sales decrease. Their market cap could drop low enough for Uber/Google/Apple (and their investors) to acquire them on the cheap.
- Retric 9y agoUber has massively subsidized users for years, but they don't have the cash to keep doing this for very long or buy a fleet of self driving cars. When self driving cars do take off you can expect a spike of sales as people really want that feature. So, Uber would need to survive ~15 years before any major car companies feel the squeeze and I doubt they can make another 5.
- caresource_ta 9y agoSubsidizing users is one side of the coin. The other side is that Uber has been living beyond their means and they do not have the cash to keep doing this.
- encoderer 9y agoUber would only need to raise fares 10% and not increase driver payouts to be in the black. The dire predictions don’t seem connected to the balance sheet I’ve looked at. Everybody wags their tongue at uber quarterly “loss” but they pay no attention to the more important measure of free cash flow
- Retric 9y agoBreak even does not enable them to pay for massive investments. A 20% increase would cost them significant ridership, but is more or less required to have any significant profit.
- 9y ago
- Aoyagi 9y agoEh. Cadillac's Supercruise™ technology doesn't seem to be that advanced, really...
- thisisit 9y agoSo, combining two expertise - first in form of self driving software and second in form of hardware - is better than trying to build it alone like Tesla or Apple.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoAn aircraft carrier can't turn on a dime but once it turns you have a f-ing aircraft carrier. When GM or some other BigCo throws its weight behind something that something gets done.
- saas_co_de 9y agoThey can't innovate but once other people innovate they can copy and buy up their technology and commercialize it more successfully. With self-driving cars the tech is only phase one. The legal/regulatory/social issues come next and that is where a company like GM with all of its political connections can really press their advantage. Even a company like Google is small time compared to GM when it comes to lobbying and political power with all of the unions, dealers, suppliers, trade associations, etc they have built up over a 100 years.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoGM has been innovating just fine in the EV segment, with the Volt, Spark EV, and now the Bolt. All three were extremely well engineered and relatively affordable -- if not as 'hip' as a Tesla. And designed mostly in house (the Bolt owes a lot to LG) I'm fairly impressed. I'm sure like most BigCorps it's not a fun or terrible nimble place to work, but it seems like they've got at least some aspects of their engineering culture figured out.
- ams6110 9y agoI'm surprised and a little disappointed that Ford hasn't done more. They have the EV version of the Focus but AFAIK it's only sold in California. Edit: 2018MY Focus Electric is a limited production model sold in select states (CA/CT/MA/MD/ME/NJ/NY/OR/RI/VT) at Ford EV Certified Dealers https://www.ford.com/cars/focus/models/focus-electric/?intcmp=fueleff-featcta-focus-electric https://www.ford.com/cars/focus/models/focus-electric/?intcm...
- freehunter 9y agoEspecially considering how quick they hopped on the hybrid concept, making hybrid versions of quite a few of their cars and SUVs, quite early on.
- theptip 9y agoAny candidate acquisitions for Waymo to buy the manufacturing capacity that it needs? I don't know the car industry well, but looking at the market cap of companies[1] it looks like you're talking at least $40-50B for an established manufacturer (Nissan, Tesla are in that range). That is affordable for Alphabet (~$80B cash on hand), but I'd be surprised if they went all-in like that. [1]: http://markets.on.nytimes.com/research/markets/usmarkets/industry.asp?industry=53111 http://markets.on.nytimes.com/research/markets/usmarkets/ind...
- freehunter 9y agoI've been wondering for a while where Waymo is getting all of its money since I've never heard them mentioned except when they're suing Uber or an article saying "Waymo's tech is awesome!", and I didn't realize until right this moment that it's a Google spin-off. That makes a lot more sense.
- csours 9y agoFCA (Fiat, Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, Maserati, Alfa Romeo) wants to sell itself or part of itself, but I can't imagine that Google would want to buy them. Their share price/market cap has been going crazy lately, for no apparent reason, perhaps indicating a buyer. https://ycharts.com/companies/FCAU/market_cap https://ycharts.com/companies/FCAU/market_cap
- wcunning 9y agoWaymo is already partnered with Fiat-Chysler -- the current test platform is the Chrysler Pacifica. Waymo also opened an office in Livonia, MI to be near the University of Michigan MCity testing grounds and the Auburn Hills, MI headquarters of their partner manufacturer.
- theptip 9y agoThat's a good fit then, thanks. With the tax bill's forced repatriation, I imagine Google will be looking for something to spend tens of billions on, so that could actually be a possibility.
- chx 9y agoWell, golly. Google is rumored to spend over a billion yearly to maintain their maps which are absolutely vital to a self driving car. That's a moat. As for where the technology stands, it's no surprise they want to launch in Phoenix first -- it doesn't rain there...
- bob_theslob646 9y agoThis same exact article was posted 20 hours ago. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16171625 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16171625) I am starting to get the impression that these websites, try and time when to push articles to HN in order to bring in visitors to their site... Some even change the title to get a more engaging tile.
- dang 9y agoOverwhelmingly it's just regular users posting things they found interesting. Reposts are ok if a story is good and it hasn't gotten attention yet: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html. What you're talking about exists, but as far as we know it has little impact on the site.
- bckygldstn 9y agoLink to report: http://fordmediacenter.nl/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/LB-AV-17-Navigant-Research_FINAL.pdf http://fordmediacenter.nl/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/LB-AV-1...
- jacksmith21006 9y agoThis will get to consumers through ride sharing services well before buying a car with the capabilities. Transportation will just become more of a service. The last numbers I have seen have Google still well ahead of everyone. https://www.wired.com/2017/02/california-dmv-autonomous-car-disengagement/ https://www.wired.com/2017/02/california-dmv-autonomous-car-... Autonomous Vehicles Makers Report Disengagement Numbers in ...
- harlanji 9y agoGood! Competition is good. JVM was just-okay until .NET came along and forced it to become great. I have my own car still because I don't like getting in strange cars all the time. Most of time time it's okay, sometimes I am with company and want privacy. Also when I need reliability it's worth paying $20 for parking in FiDi/SoMa (sometimes cheaper than a round trip from the Sunset), and it's nice for group adventures to not have a stranger in the car... slightly more/less convenient than rental options like Zip, depending on personal factors. Driverless taxi would make me a lot less likely to own I think, covers a few more use cases. I still like cruising up Great Highway and through the park (and the whole BA is beautiful), it'd be nice if they had a leisure mode for the Sunday Drive, maybe even with parking to leave stuff while you venture away.
- _Fricken 9y agoGM/Cruise developer here. GM's self-driving tech is a joke compared to Waymo's. Don't be fooled by the advertising.