5 ms·
Which election day? The Sunday that I sit down at my leisure with the voting guide and fill out my ballot? Or maybe I'm busy on Sunday and do it Saturday. Or ma
by mikestew 9y ago
Which election day? The Sunday that I sit down at my leisure with the voting guide and fill out my ballot? Or maybe I'm busy on Sunday and do it Saturday. Or maybe I'm actually on the ball this year and do it a week early.
I've been trying to find downsides to mail-in voting since Washington implemented it. Haven't found any, but I'm open to ideas. Don't have a stamp? Fine drop it off at the drop-off box on the way to work. Can't even do that? I'm pretty sure the local $SENIOR_ORG will drive you if you call them.
Oh, and mail-in gets rid of the "day off work" problem, too.
- craftyguy 9y agoCompletely agree. We also have this in Oregon, and it basically amounts to having nearly a month to 'find time' to vote. As if that were not enough time, the voting guides typically go out a few weeks before you receive the ballot, so you have something like 1.5-2 months to figure out how you want to vote and 1 month to fill in some damn bubbles and mail it in or drop it off. The process is ridiculously easy.
- jahabrewer 9y agoI think the only objection is that you don't have much of a secrecy guarantee. Votes could, in theory, be compelled. That said, I love voting by mail. Super easy.
- andrewla 9y agoThe only downside that I'm aware of is that it makes certain kinds of systematic voter fraud possible. Specifically, selling your ballot becomes a trivial thing. Currently, that practice is limited by in-person voting for a couple of reasons; first that you have to show up at the polling place and sign in the book, second is that there is no way for a third party to verifiably see that you have voted the correct way, much less fill out the ballot on your behalf. While both of these can be worked around, it is at much higher cost in terms of the possibility of being caught. How concerned we should be about this is a matter of opinion; there's not really a practical way to measure whether it makes a difference, since the fraud is so undetectable. The other thing is that this does not solve the voter turnout problem -- Washington, Oregon, and Colorado all do well for voter turnout, but don't lead the pack compared to other states with in-person voting.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>The only downside that I'm aware of is that it makes certain kinds of systematic voter fraud possible. Specifically, selling your ballot becomes a trivial thing. Buying votes is pretty much impossible to do on any meaningful scale undetected. You eliminate it by making it illegal, setting up stings and imposing jail sentences on offenders. It's a terrible reason to avoid any voting system. It's not credit card fraud ffs. The offender advertises their presence by the very nature of what they do.
- andrewla 9y agoYou _reduce_ it by making it illegal. Criminals will adapt their patterns based on the incentives. If it becomes a valuable market, all you need to do is set up blinds where people send a copy of their ballot to some email address, and then the votes are printed and submitted. Maybe you can use a sting to trick people into selling their votes to an election official, but that's small potatoes if you can't catch the buyers doing it in bulk. Or you engage in large-scale attempts to invalidate votes by submitting fake ballots to cancel out ones you don't like. You say it's a terrible reason, but preventing voter fraud is the only reason that voting is complicated. This sort of voter fraud (vote buying and vote bullying) hasn't been an issue for a long time because we've evolved the system of voting to make it more structurally difficult, rather than just legally difficult.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>You _reduce_ it by making it illegal. Eliminate. Think about it for a second. How exactly is a public figure supposed to advertise to a large number of people in complete secrecy that they are willing to purchase your vote? Both conditions need to be met for voters to sell their vote and the candidate to get away with it. No seriously, what's your threat model here? Just a quick example of one plausible threat of more than a thousand votes sold that you can't eliminate even with a semi-motivated police force. >You say it's a terrible reason, but preventing voter fraud is the only reason that voting is complicated. This sort of voter fraud (vote buying and vote bullying) hasn't been an issue for a long time because we've evolved the system of voting to make it more structurally difficult, rather than just legally difficult. In the UK it ended with the British Anti-Corrupt Practices Act of 1883. The US essentially copied that. The hard part wasn't making it structurally difficult, the hard part was getting that law passed and enforcing it and getting the courts to prosecute people for it. Other forms of voter fraud are a risk even after you make them illegal and crack down on it (e.g. ballot stuffing). This one is not.
- zeeZ 9y agoAs a German, when I get the vote notification via mail I just fill out a form online, receive the ballot via mail after about two days along with a form to sign, a bunch of color coded envelopes and instructions on how to assemble this voting Matrjoschka, and then just drop it all into any regular old mail box free of charge (well, kinda, taxpayer money and all). Or I just go to the place designated in the first letter on that Sunday between 8 AM and 6 PM and vote in person. I guess mail has the disadvantage that anyone could get a hold of your mail and fill it out in your place. Having at least a few options is good.
- koolba 9y agoI’m opposed to mail in voting. For any reason, not just voluntary. I think a voter should have to make the effort to go to the polls on Election Day. If you can’t or don’t want to do that then you can’t vote. It’s not that I don’t want old or disabled people to vote, it’s that I want people voting to be making a direct effort to do so. Not just checking off every D or R box on a form weeks before they even know anything about the candidates. I also think you should have to show ID and all voter registration should be abolished. Show up, scan your State ID and fill out a ballot. No ID? No vote. Also, getting a State ID should be free. Finally Election Day should really be on the weekend. Ideally a Saturday. Regardless of the day there are going to be people that have other obligations but as the majority of people work M-F it should be based on that schedule.
- mikestew 9y agoI think a voter should have to make the effort to go to the polls on Election Day. Should I self-flaggelate as I walk to the polls, to make sure I'm really serious about it? Look, I see what you're saying, and agree to a point. But isn't it enough that I research the candidates, and make the most informed selection? I don't see a reason to add additional burdens just to prove my worth. The only reason we "went to the effort" in the past was practicality, and now tradition. I also think you should have to show ID There's a sound argument to be made to call this "voter suppression". I'm still not 100% sure I agree with that, but many will make the argument. Finally Election Day should really be on the weekend. Man, we can't even agree on that. :-) See, if we're going to have to show up on a certain day, make it a work day. You, my fine employer, are obligated by law to give me X unpaid hours to go perform my service. Make it a big day, make everyone pitch in by letting employees off work, but by golly if we're going to "make the effort", then let's not soften it by doing it on a Saturday.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I think a voter should have to make the effort to go to the polls on Election Day. If you can’t or don’t want to do that then you can’t vote. Government of, by, and for the people—excluding those with serious physical health problems, thise with necessary short-term or long-term (business trip, witness in court, deployed on a diplomatic or military tour overseas) travel away from their home around election day. That sounds, well, completely arbitrary.