6 ms·
Your company can increase voter turnout: make Election Day a company holiday
- masonic 9y ago... because filling out an absentee ballot is so arduous.
- morogop 9y agoIt is often illegal to vote via absentee ballot if you are physically present in the jurisdiction on the day of the vote. Many people who followed your advice would be "guilty" of voter fraud.
- sophistry 9y agoI've done an absentee ballot several times. It's a bit of a pain. If it wasn't so easy for me to vote in person, I might not vote as often.
- vonmoltke 9y agoNot only is this unnecessarily snarky, but it's wrong for many jurisdictions. In those, you cannot vote absentee unless you are actually going to be absent and unable to make a trip (within reason) to your designated polling place.
- jandrese 9y agoDepending on your state it can require an hour drive to a polling place for the 4 hours it is open on a random Thursday to get the ballot and provide a valid reason (doctor's note) why you need an absentee ballot.
- twobyfour 9y agoMany states will issue an absentee ballot only if you will be out of state on election day or have physical disabilities that will prevent visiting a polling place. Submitting an absentee ballot without meeting those conditions is voter fraud, which is a felony.
- xenadu02 9y ago20 states don't allow absentee ballots unless you have a valid excuse (medial or you'll be out of state). Some of those require you to appear in-person at the country registrar or before a board of elections to fill out a ballot.
- Aloha 9y ago.. or just make all balloting mail in. Though I think you'd see an increase in turnout if return postage was paid.
- tryptophan 9y ago... or lets realize its not 1950 and we could vote electronically.
- untog 9y agoPlease let's not. The security issues are terrifying.
- colemannugent 9y agoAs someone whose job is to solving problems with computers: this is not a problem that can be solved by computers. Mainly, it all comes down to trust. Computers introduce too many complex systems to properly audit and thus require too much trust to use for voting.
- Aloha 9y agowhy add complexity to a simple problem? Everyone can use a paper ballot - not everyone can use a computer - and I dont see this changing in the future. Not every problem is best solved by adding technology - some are much better served by removing some.
- alkonaut 9y agoEven if you can do it securely (I do all my taxes electronically, as is the case with all other contacts with public services and authorities), there are issues with elections. E.g: someone cold drive around “helping” elderly people to e-vote. This type of thing has to be done “visibly” if you have to bus people to polls. Basically, if you want to cheat you have to do it in public. Polling stations are a good invention. The ceremonial act of physically voting and seeing others vote also has value.
- gizmo686 9y ago
- twoquestions 9y agoTrouble is, a lot of companies disallow election day requests for time off specifically to disenfranchise their employees. Yes it's quite illegal, but that doesn't matter if you can't get a lawyer to assert your rights, or don't have the bargaining power to get another job after they fire you for making a stink.
- LyndsySimon 9y ago> Yes it's quite illegal Is it?
- lbotos 9y agoNot op, but I did a search and couldn't find the correct query to confirm or deny. It might not be illegal for businesses to refuse time off for voting in the US. (seems like a bad place to work, but I'm sure it happens.)
- asteli 9y agoReference for you: https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/taking-time-off-voting-jury-29708.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/taking-time-off-voti...
- twobyfour 9y agoIn some states, at least, employers are legally required to give employees a "reasonable" amount of time off to vote. A lot of this stuff varies state by state.
- asteli 9y agoIn the US, it depends on which state you're in. Many states (including mine) have a law entitling employees to time off to vote. Some states mandate that time off be paid up to a certain limit, commonly ~2 hours. IMO voting day should be a national holiday. Eight US states have already gone ahead and declared it a civic holiday.
- cujo 9y ago
- smileysteve 9y agoI question this validity a lot. Most people I know try to sync company holidays with their vacations.
- twobyfour 9y agoMake it a half day instead?
- monocasa 9y agoThe people using company holidays to coordinate vacations aren't the people the holiday is supposed to help. There's a difference between "I decided to go to Cabo that day, so I didn't get to vote in person", and "the last three people who asked for some time to go vote were quickly fired for bullshit that everyone here knows was just because they wanted to go vote. Guess I'll just stop voting."
- smileysteve 9y agoBased on the number of stores that are open on Thanksgiving, Black Friday, and states of emergency, I don't expect businesses that don't want people to vote to add a company holiday instead of 2 hours of flexibility. [I doubt it's banks, government services, and companies that love to add extra holidays that people don't travel on holidays]
- Bhilai 9y agoElection day is a holiday in India and there is still pretty low voter turn out.
- cletus 9y agoWe're tackling the most minor of symptoms. What US elections need is: 1. Mandatory voting. I'm talking a small fine if you don't show up to a polling place and get your name checked off; 2. Preferential voting. Vote for the candidates in the order you want. The one with the least primary votes gets eliminated and those votes get distributed to the second preferences. This continues until one candidate has 50.1% of the vote. This way you can vote for a third-party candidate without wasting your vote. 3. Voting over a two day period, probably Saturday and Sunday. This will allow you to use a whole host of government buildings as polling places such as schools that are almost by definition widely geographically distributed; 4. Zero electronic voting. None. Nada. Zilch. More, the standards need to be tightened to have high accuracy voting methods. Optically read ballots where you fill in a circle work wondrously well. Punch cards do not. See the Florida recount of 2000 if you want to see what happens with that; 5. An end to politicizing the election process. It's incredibly dangerous. No more elections for a supervisor of elections or the like. Other countries seem to manage with an electoral commission. The US can too; 6. An end to state governments controlling redistricting. The same electoral commission(s) should handle this. Of course, none of this will actually happen. EDIT: several commenters raised three points in particular. 1. Mandatory voting. I come from Australia where we have mandatory voting. By "mandatory" it means you just have to show up to a polling place and get your name ruled out of a large file. It's slightly more tedious if you vote out of your registered district but only slightly. There's nothing stopping you putting an empty ballot in the box or drawing a picture or just voting invalid. There is no free speech issue here. I used to be against it until I came to the US to see what havoc voluntary voting wreaks. The US has a long history of voter suppression because voting isn't mandatory. Getting out the vote is one thing. But the US in parts goes much further than this including: - Removing your vote if you're convicted of a felony. Why exactly? - Removing you from the electoral rolls if your name matches that of a felon on the other side of the country; - Sending mail to your registered address. If it's returned undeliverable, strike you off the rolls; - Making you wait hours to vote to discourage you from voting, particularly in areas heavily populated with those that might otherwise vote against you (in Australia it never took me more than about 5-10 minutes to vote). People argue about the evils of having the uninformed vote but if Trump has taught us nothing it's that choosing to vote isn't exactly a recipe for informed voting either. All of the above are a direct consequence of a politicized electioneering process made possible by non-mandatory voting. 2. Electronic voting. This is a recipe for a foreign power or just a hacker to steal your election by modifying the results in a database rather than interfering with paper ballots that can be audited and recounted. Sure you can ballot stuff with fake ballots but that's something that requires physical proximity and is far harder to do on the scale that large scale tampering with a database might mean. Electronic voting is a wholly terrible idea with literally no upside. 3. Mail in ballots. All in favour of it if it's like Oregon where you have the month before the election to send it in. It needs to be easy and flexible.
- sputknick 9y agoI've long thought we should eliminate Columbus day, and making election day a holiday.
- megaman22 9y agoWhy eliminate a holiday? We have few enough of them as it is.
- chrisdsaldivar 9y agoNice idea but could you remove the mining script from the site. It's a great way to piss people off and keep them from sharing the site.
- losteric 9y agowhat script?
- chrisdsaldivar 9y agoI had 100% cpu utilization a bit after I opened the link. I inspected it and found workers for coinhive.com. I closed the tab after that and cpu utilization dropped.
- untog 9y agoI see no such thing. I'd suggest checking your browser extensions or something to make sure nothing is injecting content.
- mikestew 9y agoNo repro on macOS and Safari. No evidence of anything from coinhive that I could see. CPU utilization normal.
- chrisdsaldivar 9y agoI reproduced it twice before I left the original comment. Now I'm not getting it anymore either. I reproduced it in Chrome and Firefox. My only extensions are adblock and privacy badger.
- jacek 9y agoMany countries have elections on Sundays to make it easier for most people to vote. Wouldn't advocating for moving the election day to Sunday be better alternative?
- smileysteve 9y agoor Early voting. In GA we have nearly a month of early voting.
- gms7777 9y agoOverall, I'm in favor of this, but there may be unintended consequences. For one, having it on Sunday seems like it disproportionately disadvantages those that work in retail and food service, which tend to be lower wage earners, as those are the individuals that are more likely to have to work on Sunday. Additionally, it might make it more difficult for individuals with children -- Tuesday is a school day so there's free childcare. Though overall, I'd say the benefits outweigh the costs.
- Blackthorn 9y agoPeople still work on Sundays. It doesn't address the root problem.
- alkonaut 9y ago“Country” is misspelled in the title.
- Zombieball 9y agoI didn’t know this was not already mandated by law. I wish I could say I’m surprised, but it seems to jive with the general theme of other US policies. To contrast, in Canada: “By law, eligible electors must have three consecutive hours to cast their vote on election day. If your hours of work do not allow for three consecutive hours to vote, your employer must give you time off. Employers cannot impose a penalty or deduct pay from an employee who is taking time off to vote if required by the Canada Elections Act. An employee must be paid what he or she would have earned during the time allowed off for voting.” [Source] http://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=vot&dir=faq&document=faqvoting&lang=e#a9 http://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=vot&dir=faq&doc... Edit: happy to see similar laws do exist for some states!
- _delirium 9y agoUnfortunately the UK is the same as the US in this regard. Elections are always held on a Thursday, and employers aren't required to give time off to vote.
- bigbluedots 9y agoIn Australia, voting is always on a weekend, and is compulsory. Also, there are sausages in bread for sale
- _delirium 9y agoWell, no hot dogs at UK polling stations, but there are regular dogs. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/gallery/2017/jun/08/dogs-at-polling-stations-in-pictures https://www.theguardian.com/politics/gallery/2017/jun/08/dog...
- inopinatus 9y agoI'm proud of my democracy sausage but remain unconvinced that criminalising nonparticipation advances the ideals and outcomes of a government by the people. There are downsides too, most obviously when some crude federal politician stretches the Overton window in an attempt to sway reluctant voters.
- taobility 9y agowhy not change the voting day to Saturday/Sunday?
- Blackthorn 9y agoPeople still work on Saturdays and Sundays.
- alkonaut 9y ago1. Election on a Sunday. It’s not controversial, it’s bloody obvious. No one should even be able to find an argument against moving it. 2. Automatic registration. Registration is just increasing the barrier to vote. 3. Remove all disenfranchisement. All adult citizens have a vote. Pretending you can somehow forfeit that right in a democracy is laughable. Now: there is one party that would rather not see either of these changes.
- smileysteve 9y ago> 1. Election on a Sunday No more weekend vacations?
- alkonaut 9y agoElections every Sunday might be a bit much.
- Spooks 9y agoAllow early voting. Isn't early voting a thing?
- alkonaut 9y agoMost democracies I hope have both: Election Day is sunday/holiday and early/absentee voting is free without any particular reason. Why not have all of it? What’s the “cost”?
- smileysteve 9y agoMany states already have weekend (and weekday) early voting. So, I ask, what is the change? Why will changing 1 of 3 weeks + 1 day of days significantly change voter turnout?
- alkonaut 9y agoAgain, most advanced democracies simply tick all boxes. Why? Because if a proposal is made that would increase turnout or make it easier to vote, you shouldn’t be able to come out against it without looking like you are protecting your own interests (and no one should survive that politically in this context). So: - auto registration - unrestricted early/absentee voting - official Election Day on weekend or made public holiday. It’s not that hard. As for your question “will it significantly change?” - I’m not sure. But it won’t make it worse and it will at least give an impression that someone is trying to make it easier to vote. Significant improvement shouldn’t even be necessary in this case. Just improvement or even percieved improvement (democracy is as much about a feeling of empowerment as it is actual empowerment).
- roschdal 9y agoIn Norway we can vote in advance before the election, at a convenient time. Problem solved!
- _delirium 9y agoThat's also common in the U.S., but it varies by state. 37 of the 50 states have early voting, while 13 have only election-day voting. Map here: http://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/absentee-and-early-voting.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/absente...
- jccooper 9y agoThat's also extremely common in the US. It's called early voting and in my jurisdiction runs for 17 days before the election. Ease of voting is not a factor in turnout.
- lcfcjs2 9y agoMost companies are owned by people who hate taxes. They most certainly wouldn't want all their employees coming in and voting Democrat.
- sixQuarks 9y agoSerious question: How does increasing voter turnout make anything better? Doesn't that just increase the likelihood of politicians using unscrupulous techniques to fool voters? A huge problem is actively ignorant voters in my opinion, this would make the problem worse.
- pdelbarba 9y agoThe current system appears to vastly under represent the young and poor and over represent the elderly. The politicians exist to represent everyone's interests so any statistical disconnect undermines the system.
- sixQuarks 9y agoDid Net neutrality not teach you anything? Open your eyes, politicians exist to represent special interests - if they're doing that with net neutrality, think of what they're doing in areas where people don't pay much attention.
- shmageggy 9y agoThe group of people that don't vote because of work obligations do not come from a homogenous social class. Hint: it's not the executives that have this problem. The motivation for increasing voter turnout is to make the vote more of a representative sample.
- neaden 9y agoIt's about making sure voters are picking the politicians, not politicians picking their voters. What you see in a lot of situations in the US right now is the use of tools like Gerrymandering, challenging voter rolls, voter ID etc, are used in areas where the political party in charge knows they would lose if everyone voted.
- fishcolorbrick 9y agoThe argument I've heard to counter this is the idea that economic markets are efficient even when many participants are irrational because the irrational participants cancel each other out, amounting to random noise. A market can find efficiency even when there are a significant number of irrational participants because the rational minority are in agreement, and the irrational minority step on each other's toes. Similarly, if 44% of a democracy has an irrational preference to always vote for Team Blue, and 44% of a democracy has an irrational preference to always votes for Team Red, then the remaining 12% actually decide which team wins.
- xenadu02 9y agoPSA: For those of us in CA, fill out the form online at http://registertovote.ca.gov http://registertovote.ca.gov. If you don't have a CA driver's license print and mail the form. If you do have a CA identification the entire registration is handled electronically. The only requirement to be a resident is that you live in California with the intent to make it your home. Once you're registered mail in the vote-by-mail form elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/vote-by-mail/pdf/vote-by-mail-application.pdf. From that point forward they will mail the ballot to your house anytime there is an election. Check the boxes and drop the pre-paid envelope in the mail. It really is very easy. Often municipal elections are decided by narrow margins. If everyone working at startups in the bay area registered and started voting it could easily swing the outcome of various propositions, housing policy, etc. We like to think our industry is non-political but as software eats the world we are only going to increasingly be involved in politics. Voting is the bare-minimum in civic duty. If we don't make our voices heard we'll keep getting restrictive zoning on the local level and DMCA/CFAA garbage on the national level.
- DrScump 9y agoThe only requirement to be a resident is that you live in California with the intent to make it your home. But to register to vote in a state/Federal election, you must be a citizen. If you drill down to the FAQ, its opening page says: "Who can register to vote? To register to vote in California, you must be: A United States citizen and a resident of California, 18 years old or older on Election Day"
- ProAm 9y agoWhy would our company do this when our company can vote with it's dollars thanks to Citizens United. They have a better way to shape policy than let its employees choose. I'm being a little sarcastic but also speak with a tinge of truthfulness.
- f4rker 9y agoThis is a myth. If people arent voting its because they are too lazy to vote. - the exact date of voting is known well in advance, years even - voting works almost the exact same way every time - voting info is readily available - early voting is wide spread
- kyleblarson 9y agoJust implement all vote by mail. Washington State did it a few years back and we haven't looked back.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sbassi 9y agoWhy is voter turnout considered important?
- mikestew 9y agoWhich election day? The Sunday that I sit down at my leisure with the voting guide and fill out my ballot? Or maybe I'm busy on Sunday and do it Saturday. Or maybe I'm actually on the ball this year and do it a week early. I've been trying to find downsides to mail-in voting since Washington implemented it. Haven't found any, but I'm open to ideas. Don't have a stamp? Fine drop it off at the drop-off box on the way to work. Can't even do that? I'm pretty sure the local $SENIOR_ORG will drive you if you call them. Oh, and mail-in gets rid of the "day off work" problem, too.
- craftyguy 9y agoCompletely agree. We also have this in Oregon, and it basically amounts to having nearly a month to 'find time' to vote. As if that were not enough time, the voting guides typically go out a few weeks before you receive the ballot, so you have something like 1.5-2 months to figure out how you want to vote and 1 month to fill in some damn bubbles and mail it in or drop it off. The process is ridiculously easy.
- jahabrewer 9y agoI think the only objection is that you don't have much of a secrecy guarantee. Votes could, in theory, be compelled. That said, I love voting by mail. Super easy.
- andrewla 9y agoThe only downside that I'm aware of is that it makes certain kinds of systematic voter fraud possible. Specifically, selling your ballot becomes a trivial thing. Currently, that practice is limited by in-person voting for a couple of reasons; first that you have to show up at the polling place and sign in the book, second is that there is no way for a third party to verifiably see that you have voted the correct way, much less fill out the ballot on your behalf. While both of these can be worked around, it is at much higher cost in terms of the possibility of being caught. How concerned we should be about this is a matter of opinion; there's not really a practical way to measure whether it makes a difference, since the fraud is so undetectable. The other thing is that this does not solve the voter turnout problem -- Washington, Oregon, and Colorado all do well for voter turnout, but don't lead the pack compared to other states with in-person voting.
- 40acres 9y agoI've voted twice in my life. The first time was in 2012, where I waited for over 2.5 HRS in pretty cold weather and saw dozens of folks leave the line because they had to go to work, school, or just couldn't wait that long because they had kids or were elderly. The second time I voted was last year, since 2012 I've moved to Oregon. I got a voters pamphlet in the mail weeks before the election, and while we all knew who the presidential candidates where this pamphlet provided a great way to catch up on state and local races. I spent 2-3 days reading the pamphlet and researching the issues. I filled out a form within ~10 minutes and dropped it in the mail. It was great. More states should move to vote by mail.
- Thlom 9y ago2.5 hours long lines to vote would have been a major crisis in Norway. The longest I've ever waited was 20 minutes when I voted in city hall just after 4 pm when everyone got off work and voted on their way home. Even then there was an election official walking up and down the line warning about the waiting times and guiding people to to other places to vote. Seriously, this is easily solvable with easy access to early voting, enough ballot places with enough election officials and enough voting booths.
- warent 9y agoWhat are you trying to do, give everybody in the USA a voice or something? Not in THIS lobby!
- steeef 9y agoCoincidently, 1998 was the first year I could vote, and the first year of vote by mail in Oregon. It's made it super-easy to vote, and I honestly have no idea why other states haven't adopted it across the board.
- JBlue42 9y agoI've always either early voted or done vote by mail. I have friends here and in other states that feel they have to vote in person because it means something to them symbolically. I would rather take a weekend afternoon to read up on candidates and/or propositions and vote. I would say to each their own...but vote by mail is better. ;-)
- peterwwillis 9y agoLargest employers in the USA: - United States Department of Defense : 3.2 million - Walmart : 2.3 million - United States Postal Service : 574 thousand - Amazon : 541 thousand - Kroger : 443 thousand - Yum! Brands : 420 thousand - International Business Machines : 414 thousand - The Home Depot : 406 thousand - McDonald's : 375 thousand - Berkshire Hathaway : 367 thousand - FedEx : 335 thousand - United Parcel Service : 335 thousand - Target Corporation : 323 thousand And so on with Walgreens, GE, Albertsons, Wells Fargo, AT&T, PepsiCo, Cognizant, Starbucks, Deloitte, J.P. Morgan Chase, Lowe's, TJX, Ernst & Young, and UnitedHealth Group. ......Does anyone else get the feeling that maybe this would have a biased impact?
- nawgszy 9y agoI'm not sure I understand the implication. Can you be a bit more explicit?
- peterwwillis 9y agoFor one thing, it allows large corporations to increase their influence, by helping people that are vested in protecting their interests vote for candidates who support those companies. If a large enough set of employees is in one area, that could swing a local election. Two, a lot of these employers would appear to employ people along a particular side of the political spectrum. Combine these aspects with the fact that it would probably be easier for these large companies to switch a current day off to election day, rather than small companies who may not be able to afford it, if they give days off at all. It could end up having decidedly biased impacts on what political party is in power, and what industries get more power.
- peeters 9y ago> More people would vote if Election Day were a holiday. That's the premise. Do we know it's true? If people are going to work, they're at least mobile that day. Give people a free day off and some percentage won't even put pants on that day. There should be enough companies that already give a holiday for election day that the numbers on how it affects voter turnout should be available. But I didn't see that anywhere on the page. My gut says that giving paid time to vote, rather than the whole day off, would be better for turnout. But that's just a guess. Show me the numbers.
- Zanni 9y agoMy exact thought. I think this is a recipe for getting people to call in sick on Monday before Election Day to get a four-day weekend, rather than increase voter turnout. A half-day off seems more likely to work.
- akkat 9y agoI don't know the answer but in Israel election day is a holiday. The common stigma is that you vote in the morning and then have a barbeque in the afternoon. I don't know whether it would work the same way in the US, but that's how it is in one country.
- mrsea 9y agoBe careful about going along with a secular government and giving your consent to it with a vote, for we are not to call anyone leader except the Messiah - see Matt 23:10 in the Aramaic. What you think is freedom from the creator's life-giving ways is a deceptive illusion from the Adversary. Reject it and vote for the Messiah by living righteously.
- Blackthorn 9y agoMaking election day a holiday is pointless. Poor people work on holidays. What would actually be helpful is what a lot of states like Washington have done. Early voting, voting by mail, voting by drop off places.
- thespace123 9y agoThere's a list of people who choose not to vote that is published every year. Shame! (bell) Shame! (bell) Shame! (bell)
- lucidguppy 9y agoStart a petition in your state to make it a holiday.
- Balgair 9y agoThough a nice sentiment, such a holiday would be unnecessary and too complicated to implement. As other commenters point out, mail balloting is much easier and already implemented in many precincts. The US is a very large country, and there are elections all the time. Would people need a day off for school board elections? What about the recent Alabama special senate election? Restricting it to only presidential elections, or once yearly elections, would be impractical for the day to day democracy of our nation. Perhaps compulsory voting would be a better idea? Though groups like the Amish and Jehovah's Witnesses would be dead set against such an idea, compulsory voting has good track records in places like Australia where there was much hand wringing over a low 91% turnout. However, many Australians point to the compulsory vote as a reason why their parliaments are bad, as it forces people with little to no interest to make a choice in an election. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_Australia
- ClayShentrup 9y agoTurnout is incredibly unimportant. http://scorevoting.net/RelImport.html http://scorevoting.net/RelImport.html