4 ms·
Does anyone really believe it is a reliable store of value? Surely the violent price swings and numerous scandals related to dodgy exchanges are hard to not not
by cm2187 9y ago
Does anyone really believe it is a reliable store of value? Surely the violent price swings and numerous scandals related to dodgy exchanges are hard to not notice. I assume they either perceive the risk as the cost of taking money out of the country or ignore it out of pure greed. Madoff disguised himself as a wise asset manager. I don't think bitcoin is disguising itself into anything else than a speculative product.
- akrymski 9y agoInvesting with Madoff was also a speculative endeavour. He never guaranteed anything. People invested with Madoff hoping they'd make money. People invest in BTC hoping they'd make money. Some people may have even pulled their money from Madoff prior to collapse and made a killing. As some did with BTC. The difference is Madoff knew the people he stole from, and they knew Madoff. BTC sellers can't put a face to the wallets buying their coins.
- AVTizzle 9y agoThis is a ridiculously weak comparison.
- repomies691 9y ago> BTC sellers can't put a face to the wallets buying their coins. I have often bought and sold BTC to/from a friend I know. > People invested with Madoff hoping they'd make money. People invest in BTC hoping they'd make money. Madoff advertised a legal investing business, while he was actually running a ponzi scheme and didn't invest anything. Bitcoin is a transparent open-source system that anyone can inspect very thoroughly how it works. The two cases don't have much to do with each other.
- akrymski 9y agoTransparent? Does everyone know who the handful of individuals are that hold 90+% of all coins? Do they report their transactions to the SEC? Do they manipulate or distort the market? Do they advertise and promote securities without retail investors knowing about it? Wolf of Wall Street was also pedalling stocks that people bought at their own risk. This is now illegal, because it leads to the same price dynamics as a ponzi scheme or a speculative bubble. HFT firms manipulating the market with large sums - also illegal. To think that the crypto market has no insiders is very naive imo
- georgeecollins 9y agoMadoff told people he was holding money in people's accounts that was not there. He spent money he had no right to spend under any circumstance in order to perpetuate a fraud. He lied repeatedly and deliberately. It's completely different.
- comboy 9y agoAsk yourself a question. Do you believe that at any point in future, we will have a reliable store of value in form of digital information? Banks don't provide that, it's somebody else saying that he will take care of your money an give you when you need it. We want some kind of gold but in a digital form. Information as a value in its most direct form. I believe we are going to have it. It would be a sad future without having such thing, now that we know it's possible. Second question. Is it going to be Bitcoin? Obviously it's possible and inevitable that there will be (or there is already) a cryptocurrency that's technically superior to Bitcoin in every aspect. So let's assume we switch to that, you move your "savings" from Bitcoin to X. But of course, at some point there will be something Pareto better than X. Is it going to be Y or Z? And is it already time to switch? Run that scenario in your head. It just doesn't work. You can't have a reliable store of value like that. Ever. That's why I think that if we are ever to have a reliable store of value in form of a cryptocurrency, it's going to be Bitcoin. It is however possible to switch to a completely new tech if you want to while not ruining the reliable store of value aspect, thanks to sidechains. But the magic of it is that Bitcoin keeps working as a store of value.
- usrusr 9y ago> It would be a sad future without having such thing Would it? An economy dominated by a deflatory currency would be very different from what we know and enjoy. Driven to the extreme it could even be a mass starvation level threat (well, that's easy to say given the low margin for error we have left).
- comboy 9y agoIt's about a storage of value. To be able ta have a place to put what you have earned and not worry that the inflation is slowly eating it up. Apart from precious metals an example of asset of this type we already have would be real estate. And I don't think that in itself it's causing things like starvation. I'm not 100% certain though about the assumption I made at the beginning that you are questioning. I do believe it's better for society if we have it, but I don't think I've read enough history and economy books to be super confident about it. Money makes money and the gap between poorest and richest surely is getting wider. Even in inflationary economy. However I don't know any 10,11 figure VC who isn't worried about that and is not trying to do something to protect those at the bad end of the spectrum (yeah, I don't know many VCs this is just a quote from some Eric Weinstein interview).
- acdha 9y ago> I don't think bitcoin is disguising itself into anything else than a speculative product. I’d add “successfully” to that — there are plenty of hucksters trying to spin it as a cash replacement (old spin) or store of value (current spin) so that failure isn’t for lack of trying.